Accommodating change? An investigation of the impacts of government contracting processes on third sector providers of homelessness services in South East England
Accommodating change? An investigation of the impacts of government contracting processes on third sector providers of homelessness services in South East England
This study investigates the impacts of government contracting on third sector providers of services for single homeless people in Southampton and Hampshire, in South East England. It focuses particularly on tendering and quality measurement. 24 interviews were conducted with representatives of 21 third sector organisations (TSOs) and a further two with local government representatives. Quantitative data were used to describe the characteristics of the TSOs. Different TSOs experienced and responded to government contracting in different ways, and a typology was therefore developed which categorised the organisations into one of four types: Comfortable Contractors; Compliant Contractors; Cautious Contractors; and Community-based Non-contractors.
Tendering and quality measurement consumed significant amounts of time and required TSOs to access legal and tender-writing expertise. This was more problematic for the smaller Cautious Contractors, whereas larger TSOs with multiple contracts could meet the requirements more cost-efficiently. The quality measurement processes introduced as part of the Supporting People programme were deemed to have considerably improved standards. However, there were concerns that the emphasis on achieving measurable outcomes and moving clients on within a specified time could lead to the neglect of less tangible aspects such as improved self-esteem, and did not take sufficient account of longer term outcomes for clients.
The impacts of contracting were ambiguous and varied amongst the different types of providers. However, the commissioning processes seemed to favour larger, more professionalised TSOs, which exhibited fewer of the distinctive characteristics upon which New Labour’s support for third sector involvement in service provision was premised. This points to the need for a more carefully differentiated policy discourse which acknowledges the third sector’s diversity and is more transparent about which types of TSO the government is seeking to engage with for which purposes.
Buckingham, Heather
79c73525-0a93-4af1-a38e-336f7f9057ae
February 2010
Buckingham, Heather
79c73525-0a93-4af1-a38e-336f7f9057ae
Mohan, John
01d0f96b-aee7-4f4d-ad3f-e177231005f6
Roth, Silke
cd4e63d8-bd84-45c1-b317-5850d2a362b6
Buckingham, Heather
(2010)
Accommodating change? An investigation of the impacts of government contracting processes on third sector providers of homelessness services in South East England.
University of Southampton, School of Social Sciences: Sociology and Social Policy, Doctoral Thesis, 294pp.
Record type:
Thesis
(Doctoral)
Abstract
This study investigates the impacts of government contracting on third sector providers of services for single homeless people in Southampton and Hampshire, in South East England. It focuses particularly on tendering and quality measurement. 24 interviews were conducted with representatives of 21 third sector organisations (TSOs) and a further two with local government representatives. Quantitative data were used to describe the characteristics of the TSOs. Different TSOs experienced and responded to government contracting in different ways, and a typology was therefore developed which categorised the organisations into one of four types: Comfortable Contractors; Compliant Contractors; Cautious Contractors; and Community-based Non-contractors.
Tendering and quality measurement consumed significant amounts of time and required TSOs to access legal and tender-writing expertise. This was more problematic for the smaller Cautious Contractors, whereas larger TSOs with multiple contracts could meet the requirements more cost-efficiently. The quality measurement processes introduced as part of the Supporting People programme were deemed to have considerably improved standards. However, there were concerns that the emphasis on achieving measurable outcomes and moving clients on within a specified time could lead to the neglect of less tangible aspects such as improved self-esteem, and did not take sufficient account of longer term outcomes for clients.
The impacts of contracting were ambiguous and varied amongst the different types of providers. However, the commissioning processes seemed to favour larger, more professionalised TSOs, which exhibited fewer of the distinctive characteristics upon which New Labour’s support for third sector involvement in service provision was premised. This points to the need for a more carefully differentiated policy discourse which acknowledges the third sector’s diversity and is more transparent about which types of TSO the government is seeking to engage with for which purposes.
Text
Buckingham_Thesis_2010.pdf
- Other
More information
Published date: February 2010
Organisations:
University of Southampton
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 174795
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/174795
PURE UUID: 67d6a206-aed0-4d36-ad3e-3ef5f72c9066
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 19 May 2011 14:28
Last modified: 14 Mar 2024 02:51
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Heather Buckingham
Thesis advisor:
John Mohan
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics
