Species-specific responses of Late Quaternary megafauna to climate and humans
Species-specific responses of Late Quaternary megafauna to climate and humans
Despite decades of research, the roles of climate and humans in driving the dramatic extinctions of large-bodied mammals during the Late Quaternary period remain contentious. Here we use ancient DNA, species distribution models and the human fossil record to elucidate how climate and humans shaped the demographic history of woolly rhinoceros, woolly mammoth, wild horse, reindeer, bison and musk ox. We show that climate has been a major driver of population change over the past 50,000 years. However, each species responds differently to the effects of climatic shifts, habitat redistribution and human encroachment. Although climate change alone can explain the extinction of some species, such as Eurasian musk ox and woolly rhinoceros, a combination of climatic and anthropogenic effects appears to be responsible for the extinction of others, including Eurasian steppe bison and wild horse. We find no genetic signature or any distinctive range dynamics distinguishing extinct from surviving species, emphasizing the challenges associated with predicting future responses of extant mammals to climate and human-mediated habitat change
359-364
Lorenzen, Eline D.
3f2d68f9-c620-4d80-8a21-69bab4b937a9
Nogués-Bravo, David
04e317cb-9aee-4d99-88f0-32b2d9d38f78
Orlando, Ludovic
e04542c6-d310-4c3e-aaf0-b1679b723fe0
Weinstock, Jaco
edcdb255-f6d0-4a66-8c47-28b70d79896e
Binladen, Jonas
5cba0905-87f5-4475-8727-bb2c3c69c69e
Marske, Katharine A.
f9552dac-7351-4701-97d9-35eb9ab9117d
Ugan, Andrew
909e2152-48db-4df0-97c7-0202a493b845
Borregaard, Michael K.
47bf8580-532c-411c-be16-f09d3c3f13df
Gilbert, M. Thomas P.
1614a657-2ff7-44ce-9117-144d2a0f95c0
Nielsen, Rasmus
37969021-af81-40e0-8c1c-54099e5aee8b
Ho, Simon Y W
e10ca7d6-bd3e-4b38-9462-7ecc291d1b56
Goebel, Ted
5e144e4a-e7ac-452a-82a2-b2446fd917cb
Graf, Kelly E.
67b19418-8857-417a-b6b9-be08d1fd855b
Byers, David
bb95ef85-2fd5-4491-a193-e51b04ebf451
Stenderup, Jesper T.
f0e52d21-5a83-4bd1-9c25-7cf6f3b40851
Rasmussen, Morten
add6a98b-839b-458e-8abf-99e85cc95637
Campos, Paula F
35ddeac1-5c63-4a5e-851e-0a2f356725f1
Leonard, Jennifer A
c5c2303b-a49c-4aaa-bdd4-2ba663e58c4c
Koepfli, Klaus-Peter
c992f163-e1eb-4774-97b9-b595e0c5ae3d
Froese, Duane
99d8a8be-b0fb-47b2-b91e-ec5e9b3a19e3
Zazula, Grant
b25a4a7d-4efc-4d0f-af3a-3164f705bc34
Stafford, Thomas W
eac1b96a-7386-4441-9e4f-7f277f8044f3
Aaris-Sørensen, Kim
b01c902f-e84d-4179-93a5-b0c25fc73938
Batra, Persaram
e6088863-f4dc-4872-9fcb-0bea6e12aa51
Haywood, Alan M.
579a1e53-4e73-45fe-b8be-10724dcf65f0
Singarayer, Joy S.
063cf8a9-c3a8-464f-becd-cfae50aef593
Valdes, Paul J.
d4cdc123-544c-4df7-8c61-1781cf50f104
Boeskorov, Gennady
c1a93cbc-27e2-4253-8219-eb29fb8ddbe5
Burns, James A.
9b6a9094-7fed-49cb-b104-35ee1f1433ee
Davydov, Sergey P.
d6a1c6a0-085a-4252-b804-701f4e2e65a8
Haile, James
831f077c-daae-4aa1-b4b7-c4c76a2f6c00
Jenkins, Dennis L
6811bcae-fdde-48b5-baf7-cc71da66605c
Kosintsev, Pavel
b4ad92e3-56df-473b-98ec-24ea207e3d32
Kuznetsova, Tatyana
7a569c37-006a-436a-8201-4a40a3b4aaf4
Lai, Xulong
d031430a-966e-4d9b-a69c-603a2debfe90
Martin, Larry D.
8bb66655-b0c3-4fe6-978d-e4b252bec1b6
McDonald, H Gregory
347e9563-9a7c-476b-a009-614fc039b81e
Mol, Dick
e57245a7-f66d-4c69-8ad6-431eebd4ea29
Meldgaard, Morten
49fdd48b-07c6-4a5d-9547-dc46fdff4909
Munch, Kasper
d466214d-76b5-4ddc-bf25-1736848d677b
Stephan, Elisabeth
66b49bf8-1e73-4b68-a95f-e7b7938068a5
Sablin, Mikhail
0180587d-281b-4ab7-a390-150c965d7fb5
Sommer, Robert S.
1fe987d4-7f71-49ae-a73d-fb04a828c4a0
Sipko, Taras
6ba6bafc-7f4a-4395-857b-f600b75618d5
Scott, Eric
fcdf9f61-a191-4ac7-b77b-e4b334fcc51d
Suchard, Marc A..
36149f12-b16f-4b90-b854-e0accbbffdd0
Tikhonov, Alexei
6957f4d9-1709-4000-8dd0-a522524fd3e6
Willerslev, Rane
e0819183-4a2b-4dec-8dd5-7d96e6f5a8e0
Wayne, Robert K.
61ff3065-addb-4ca5-b4be-33986c4a15a1
Cooper, Alan
9971af32-4b24-4794-b5b1-e4c78965e191
Hofreiter, Michael
d11d1afd-a5b9-4925-a5f9-fa9776ff66a5
Sher, Andrei
50deedd6-0f3b-486f-8578-9e184c2b3a44
Shapiro, Beth
6c1d02da-0c76-4740-bf73-109060706282
Rahbek, Carsten
a701b752-ccb8-4520-9377-1772c79434ad
Willerslev, Eske
3815b419-7ba2-4827-a7a7-e97dd7118ee6
17 November 2011
Lorenzen, Eline D.
3f2d68f9-c620-4d80-8a21-69bab4b937a9
Nogués-Bravo, David
04e317cb-9aee-4d99-88f0-32b2d9d38f78
Orlando, Ludovic
e04542c6-d310-4c3e-aaf0-b1679b723fe0
Weinstock, Jaco
edcdb255-f6d0-4a66-8c47-28b70d79896e
Binladen, Jonas
5cba0905-87f5-4475-8727-bb2c3c69c69e
Marske, Katharine A.
f9552dac-7351-4701-97d9-35eb9ab9117d
Ugan, Andrew
909e2152-48db-4df0-97c7-0202a493b845
Borregaard, Michael K.
47bf8580-532c-411c-be16-f09d3c3f13df
Gilbert, M. Thomas P.
1614a657-2ff7-44ce-9117-144d2a0f95c0
Nielsen, Rasmus
37969021-af81-40e0-8c1c-54099e5aee8b
Ho, Simon Y W
e10ca7d6-bd3e-4b38-9462-7ecc291d1b56
Goebel, Ted
5e144e4a-e7ac-452a-82a2-b2446fd917cb
Graf, Kelly E.
67b19418-8857-417a-b6b9-be08d1fd855b
Byers, David
bb95ef85-2fd5-4491-a193-e51b04ebf451
Stenderup, Jesper T.
f0e52d21-5a83-4bd1-9c25-7cf6f3b40851
Rasmussen, Morten
add6a98b-839b-458e-8abf-99e85cc95637
Campos, Paula F
35ddeac1-5c63-4a5e-851e-0a2f356725f1
Leonard, Jennifer A
c5c2303b-a49c-4aaa-bdd4-2ba663e58c4c
Koepfli, Klaus-Peter
c992f163-e1eb-4774-97b9-b595e0c5ae3d
Froese, Duane
99d8a8be-b0fb-47b2-b91e-ec5e9b3a19e3
Zazula, Grant
b25a4a7d-4efc-4d0f-af3a-3164f705bc34
Stafford, Thomas W
eac1b96a-7386-4441-9e4f-7f277f8044f3
Aaris-Sørensen, Kim
b01c902f-e84d-4179-93a5-b0c25fc73938
Batra, Persaram
e6088863-f4dc-4872-9fcb-0bea6e12aa51
Haywood, Alan M.
579a1e53-4e73-45fe-b8be-10724dcf65f0
Singarayer, Joy S.
063cf8a9-c3a8-464f-becd-cfae50aef593
Valdes, Paul J.
d4cdc123-544c-4df7-8c61-1781cf50f104
Boeskorov, Gennady
c1a93cbc-27e2-4253-8219-eb29fb8ddbe5
Burns, James A.
9b6a9094-7fed-49cb-b104-35ee1f1433ee
Davydov, Sergey P.
d6a1c6a0-085a-4252-b804-701f4e2e65a8
Haile, James
831f077c-daae-4aa1-b4b7-c4c76a2f6c00
Jenkins, Dennis L
6811bcae-fdde-48b5-baf7-cc71da66605c
Kosintsev, Pavel
b4ad92e3-56df-473b-98ec-24ea207e3d32
Kuznetsova, Tatyana
7a569c37-006a-436a-8201-4a40a3b4aaf4
Lai, Xulong
d031430a-966e-4d9b-a69c-603a2debfe90
Martin, Larry D.
8bb66655-b0c3-4fe6-978d-e4b252bec1b6
McDonald, H Gregory
347e9563-9a7c-476b-a009-614fc039b81e
Mol, Dick
e57245a7-f66d-4c69-8ad6-431eebd4ea29
Meldgaard, Morten
49fdd48b-07c6-4a5d-9547-dc46fdff4909
Munch, Kasper
d466214d-76b5-4ddc-bf25-1736848d677b
Stephan, Elisabeth
66b49bf8-1e73-4b68-a95f-e7b7938068a5
Sablin, Mikhail
0180587d-281b-4ab7-a390-150c965d7fb5
Sommer, Robert S.
1fe987d4-7f71-49ae-a73d-fb04a828c4a0
Sipko, Taras
6ba6bafc-7f4a-4395-857b-f600b75618d5
Scott, Eric
fcdf9f61-a191-4ac7-b77b-e4b334fcc51d
Suchard, Marc A..
36149f12-b16f-4b90-b854-e0accbbffdd0
Tikhonov, Alexei
6957f4d9-1709-4000-8dd0-a522524fd3e6
Willerslev, Rane
e0819183-4a2b-4dec-8dd5-7d96e6f5a8e0
Wayne, Robert K.
61ff3065-addb-4ca5-b4be-33986c4a15a1
Cooper, Alan
9971af32-4b24-4794-b5b1-e4c78965e191
Hofreiter, Michael
d11d1afd-a5b9-4925-a5f9-fa9776ff66a5
Sher, Andrei
50deedd6-0f3b-486f-8578-9e184c2b3a44
Shapiro, Beth
6c1d02da-0c76-4740-bf73-109060706282
Rahbek, Carsten
a701b752-ccb8-4520-9377-1772c79434ad
Willerslev, Eske
3815b419-7ba2-4827-a7a7-e97dd7118ee6