The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

On Fodor on Darwin on Evolution

Harnad, Stevan (2009) On Fodor on Darwin on Evolution s.n.

Record type: Monograph (Project Report)


Jerry Fodor argues that Darwin was wrong about "natural selection" because (1) it is only a tautology rather than a scientific law that can support counterfactuals ("If X had happened, Y would have happened") and because (2) only minds can select. Hence Darwin's analogy with "artificial selection" by animal breeders was misleading and evolutionary explanation is nothing but post-hoc historical narrative. I argue that Darwin was right on all counts. Until Darwin's "tautology," it had been believed that either (a) God had created all organisms as they are, or (b) organisms had always been as they are. Darwin revealed instead that (c) organisms have heritable traits that evolved across time through random variation, with survival and reproduction in (changing) environments determining (mindlessly) which variants were successfully transmitted to the next generation. This not only provided the (true) alternative (c), but also the methodology for investigating which traits had been adaptive, how and why; it also led to the discovery of the genetic mechanism of the encoding, variation and evolution of heritable traits. Fodor also draws erroneous conclusions from the analogy between Darwinian evolution and Skinnerian reinforcement learning. Fodor's skepticism about both evolution and learning may be motivated by an overgeneralization of Chomsky's "poverty of the stimulus argument" -- from the origin of Universal Grammar (UG) to the origin of the "concepts" underlying word meaning, which, Fodor thinks, must be "endogenous," rather than evolved or learned.

PDF fodorcomm.pdf - Other
Available under License Other.
Download (203kB)
HTML fodorcomm.htm - Other
Available under License Other.
Download (125kB)
HTML fodor-harnad1.html - Other
Available under License Other.
Download (11kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 14 April 2009
Additional Information: Commentary On: Fodor, Jerry A. (forthcoming) Against Darwinism.
Keywords: adaptation, Chomsky, consciousness, counterfactuals, Darwin, evolution, fitness, Fodor, learning, lexicon, mind, natural selection, poverty of the stimulus, Skinner, Turing, underdetermination, universal grammar
Organisations: Web & Internet Science


Local EPrints ID: 267274
PURE UUID: b94f4c58-a48c-4519-b4b3-00c592f450b8

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 14 Apr 2009 18:35
Last modified: 18 Jul 2017 07:06

Export record


Author: Stevan Harnad

University divisions

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton:

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.