The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The causal topography of cognition

Harnad, Stevan (2012) The causal topography of cognition [in special issue: A Computational Foundation for the Study of Cognition] Journal of Cognitive Science, 13, (2), pp. 181-196.

Record type: Article


The causal structure of cognition can be simulated but not implemented computationally, just as the causal structure of a furnace can be simulated but not implemented computationally. Heating is a dynamical property, not a computational one. A computational simulation of a furnace cannot heat a real house (only a simulated house). It lacks the essential causal property of a furnace. This is obvious with computational furnaces. The only thing that allows us even to imagine that it is otherwise in the case of computational cognition is the fact that cognizing, unlike heating, is invisible (to eveyrone except the cognizer). Chalmers’s “Dancing Qualia” Argument is hence invalid: Even if there could be a computational model of cognition that was behaviorally indistinguishable from a real, feeling cognizer, it would still be true that if, like heat, feeling is a dynamical property of the brain, a flip-flop from the presence to the absence of feeling would be undetectable anywhere along Chalmers’s hypothetical component-swapping continuum from a human cognizer to a computational cognizer -- undetectable to everyone except the cognizer. But that would only be because the cognizer was locked into being incapable of doing anything to settle the matter simply because of Chalmers’s premise of input/output indistinguishability. That is not a demonstration that cognition is computation; it is just the demonstation that you get out of a premise what you put into it. But even if the causal topography of feeling, hence of cognizing, is dynamic rather than just computational, the problem of explaining the causal role played by feeling itself – how and why we feel – in the generation of our behavioral capacity – how and why we can do what we can do – will remain a “hard” (and perhaps insoluble) problem.

Other ChalmcomREV1.docx - Accepted Manuscript
Download (158kB)
PDF ChalmcomREV1.pdf - Accepted Manuscript
Download (162kB)
PDF - Version of Record
Restricted to Repository staff only
Download (372kB)

More information

Published date: April 2012
Additional Information: Commentary on: Chalmers, David (2012) A Computational Foundation for the Study of Cognition. Journal of Cognitive Science
Keywords: chalmers, causation, cognition, computation, computationalism, consciousness, dynamics, dancing qualia, feeling, functionalism, hard problem, mind/body problem, symbol grounding, turing
Organisations: Web & Internet Science


Local EPrints ID: 273232
ISSN: 2158-9216
PURE UUID: 179ed89e-8f19-4a99-8c9c-43a8d774a618

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 24 Feb 2012 20:27
Last modified: 18 Jul 2017 06:15

Export record


Author: Stevan Harnad

University divisions

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton:

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.