Hybrid qualifications, institutional expectations and youth transitions: a case of swimming with or against the tide
Hybrid qualifications, institutional expectations and youth transitions: a case of swimming with or against the tide
This paper uses the concept of hybrid qualifications to expose some of the ways in which the English system, with its longstanding academic and vocational divide, fails to support the transitions of young people with 'average' educational attainment. The concept of hybrid qualifications was developed during EU funded research undertaken in 2010 - 11 with project partners from Germany, Austria and Denmark. It was conceived to mean those qualifications generally achieved by young people aged 16-18 which would facilitate entry to the labour market or access to university. In the English system we defined Level 3 qualifications such as the BTEC National suite of Diplomas, Applied A-Levels, the Advanced Diploma and some qualifications contained within the Advanced Apprenticeship programme as contenders for hybridity. Compared with the clear pathways for entry to bachelor degrees that are articulated for those who have attained traditional academic qualifications (namely A-levels), the routes for those leaving school with vocational qualifications are poorly and narrowly-defined, and fragile. Using the rich, narrative data gathered from interviews and focus groups with students, tutors and key stakeholders, we illustrate how for this group transition often involves 'swimming against rather than with the tide'. To make sense of their uncertain and at times fragmented journeys we draw on Bourdieu's conceptual toolbox, and argue that his notion of 'doxa' is especially helpful in making sense of the way in which educational institutions play their own very distinctive roles in shaping those transitions
Davey, Gayna
688b1d43-7c50-4edb-a893-7f7f0a05e249
Fuller, Alison
c6b47796-05b5-4548-b67e-2ca2f2010fef
Davey, Gayna
688b1d43-7c50-4edb-a893-7f7f0a05e249
Fuller, Alison
c6b47796-05b5-4548-b67e-2ca2f2010fef
Davey, Gayna and Fuller, Alison
(2013)
Hybrid qualifications, institutional expectations and youth transitions: a case of swimming with or against the tide.
Sociological Research Online, 18 (1).
(doi:10.5153/sro.2876).
Abstract
This paper uses the concept of hybrid qualifications to expose some of the ways in which the English system, with its longstanding academic and vocational divide, fails to support the transitions of young people with 'average' educational attainment. The concept of hybrid qualifications was developed during EU funded research undertaken in 2010 - 11 with project partners from Germany, Austria and Denmark. It was conceived to mean those qualifications generally achieved by young people aged 16-18 which would facilitate entry to the labour market or access to university. In the English system we defined Level 3 qualifications such as the BTEC National suite of Diplomas, Applied A-Levels, the Advanced Diploma and some qualifications contained within the Advanced Apprenticeship programme as contenders for hybridity. Compared with the clear pathways for entry to bachelor degrees that are articulated for those who have attained traditional academic qualifications (namely A-levels), the routes for those leaving school with vocational qualifications are poorly and narrowly-defined, and fragile. Using the rich, narrative data gathered from interviews and focus groups with students, tutors and key stakeholders, we illustrate how for this group transition often involves 'swimming against rather than with the tide'. To make sense of their uncertain and at times fragmented journeys we draw on Bourdieu's conceptual toolbox, and argue that his notion of 'doxa' is especially helpful in making sense of the way in which educational institutions play their own very distinctive roles in shaping those transitions
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
e-pub ahead of print date: 28 February 2013
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 348360
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/348360
ISSN: 1360-7804
PURE UUID: ccd861c8-db99-47b4-a6e3-cf2386fa758d
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 12 Feb 2013 13:28
Last modified: 14 Mar 2024 12:58
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Gayna Davey
Author:
Alison Fuller
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics