Critical research gaps and translational priorities for the successful prevention and treatment of breast cancer
Critical research gaps and translational priorities for the successful prevention and treatment of breast cancer
Introduction
Breast cancer remains a significant scientific, clinical and societal challenge. This gap analysis has reviewed and critically assessed enduring issues and new challenges emerging from recent research, and proposes strategies for translating solutions into practice.
Methods
More than 100 internationally recognised specialist breast cancer scientists, clinicians and healthcare professionals collaborated to address nine thematic areas: genetics, epigenetics and epidemiology; molecular pathology and cell biology; hormonal influences and endocrine therapy; imaging, detection and screening; current/novel therapies and biomarkers; drug resistance; metastasis, angiogenesis, circulating tumour cells, cancer ‘stem’ cells; risk and prevention; living with and managing breast cancer and its treatment. The groups developed summary papers through an iterative process which, following further appraisal from experts and patients, were melded into this summary account.
Results
The 10 major gaps identified were: (1) understanding the functions and contextual interactions of genetic and epigenetic changes in normal breast development and during malignant transformation; (2) how to implement sustainable lifestyle changes (diet, exercise and weight) and chemopreventive strategies; (3) the need for tailored screening approaches including clinically actionable tests; (4) enhancing knowledge of molecular drivers behind breast cancer subtypes, progression and metastasis; (5) understanding the molecular mechanisms of tumour heterogeneity, dormancy, de novo or acquired resistance and how to target key nodes in these dynamic processes; (6) developing validated markers for chemosensitivity and radiosensitivity; (7) understanding the optimal duration, sequencing and rational combinations of treatment for improved personalised therapy; (8) validating multimodality imaging biomarkers for minimally invasive diagnosis and monitoring of responses in primary and metastatic disease; (9) developing interventions and support to improve the survivorship experience; (10) a continuing need for clinical material for translational research derived from normal breast, blood, primary, relapsed, metastatic and drug-resistant cancers with expert bioinformatics support to maximise its utility. The proposed infrastructural enablers include enhanced resources to support clinically relevant in vitro and in vivo tumour models; improved access to appropriate, fully annotated clinical samples; extended biomarker discovery, validation and standardisation; and facilitated cross-discipline working.
Conclusions
With resources to conduct further high-quality targeted research focusing on the gaps identified, increased knowledge translating into improved clinical care should be achievable within five years.
1-37
Eccles, Suzanne A.
d75ea311-8425-435a-83c6-5928152e092f
Aboagye, Eric O.
bb2bcdf6-e5e9-493d-98c6-0f6afa1f51b3
Ali, Simak
7d471c65-fb89-4edb-be44-965f39215a85
Anderson, Annie S.
15b45529-dbd3-46b9-9c5f-14037ed5f20c
Armes, Jo
d72d1004-457a-4f30-bec7-329e696fe34f
Berditchevski, Fedor
f1a2b25b-e73c-440b-8a78-7a22e647b33d
Blaydes, Jeremy P.
e957f999-fd91-4f77-ad62-5b4ef069b15b
Brennan, Keith
1aaaabe5-f475-44fd-a49d-65842b93eba1
Brown, Nicola J.
cbc4d705-c4e7-430f-ab33-ae21254795f7
Bryant, Helen E.
80a41ad8-cdc1-49ab-8885-d23ae81cc6b3
Bundred, Nigel J.
4ceba3cc-eae4-45ed-ba6f-7c07c7bfcb75
Burchell, Joy M.
a775f580-bad2-43ef-bd00-315709b02372
Campbell, Anna M.
cdf3f55a-65cd-43d7-803f-9654e25b072e
Carroll, Jason S.
a94b37bd-6a58-45f6-84fd-90d369e520a1
Clarke, Robert B.
4132a740-2769-4fdf-878f-2d4318699d86
Coles, Charlotte E.
a57ae239-eac4-496f-96f4-367ad6f35350
Cook, Gary J.R.
c33461e4-ea73-4b67-bdf8-9940f9c90f75
Cox, Angela
41fd94c3-79a2-49d4-bda0-616488b147da
Curtin, Nicola J.
4a6971d6-adac-480b-922c-597839068639
Dekker, Lodewijk V.
0c3344dd-7f5e-4034-a995-8ae048361221
dos Santos Silva, Isabel
f8366712-2545-4c3d-921d-ae7dc202bb29
Duffy, Stephen W.
5b52362d-cad8-47a7-8549-5adcd7359a0e
Easton, Douglas F.
2661cf5e-8fc6-4f1d-b27a-e60cac8c8819
Eccles, Diana M.
5b59bc73-11c9-4cf0-a9d5-7a8e523eee23
Edwards, Dylan R.
b487d128-6527-42fc-aa7f-e07225990a6b
Edwards, Joanne
11961a36-d1ab-4bed-a861-707721a517f1
Evans, D. Gareth
314acefb-89fb-4eb7-a0e7-0a6949c9af6c
Fenlon, Deborah F.
52f9a9f1-1643-449c-9856-258ef563342c
Flanagan, James M.
ac6487d1-96c1-4262-91aa-721afc62a357
Foster, Claire
00786ac1-bd47-4aeb-a0e2-40e058695b73
Gallagher, William M.
2c70fc9b-c4fa-4363-a9d9-a763f1ad0666
Garcia-Closas, Montserrat
bd1054d7-f127-4fa8-b52e-67a352d29009
Gee, Julia M.W.
7fff1742-2d4a-4d48-bcd1-48ebb03999e2
Gescher, Andy J.
912127a9-cefd-4979-a1f3-ab0362bd7b74
Goh, Vicky
c5a1049a-8dd6-442c-8df0-649f9dec7f3b
Groves, Ashley M.
40b2d7cc-5bc7-4210-90e0-e07070879de1
Harvey, Amanda J.
02a86d1e-6e90-4454-b386-5933cd4ce484
Harvie, Michelle
5a044f8f-a21c-45ef-9d37-bbc5d70de6d0
Hennessy, Bryan T.
c7cfc114-7162-4ef1-ac30-c005730cb515
Hiscox, Stephen
22714246-dd31-4870-9ccc-8030f94c2b97
Holen, Ingunn
8e90d073-3c91-49b5-a6be-54d02279d534
Howell, Sacha J.
6dd4d7ac-a8dd-4d1a-8723-37f015467c55
Howell, Anthony
1a0a7e78-3d51-4e76-8cd5-bd46cb90d588
Hubbard, Gill
0f482bac-8d01-4a89-a10e-bcc272cb8316
Hulbert-Williams, Nick
c2d2d7f8-67ac-482f-8fe4-f41e8c1e1974
Hunter, Myra S.
fce15222-f73f-478a-87fd-d480cac6fd2a
Jasani, Bharat
bb0b21a9-8542-42bf-9bbb-9c9f5fe88adf
Jones, Louise J.
246f319c-2650-4ddf-a067-2d2489c6fbd8
Key, Timothy J.
cd5d4108-d0b3-4661-b4c2-5b12ac43fe37
Kirwan, Cliona C.
4a465729-935f-422b-99c6-8d5302271ab8
Kong, Anthony
86d4dce7-24f7-42ea-b913-f09259888788
Kunkler, Ian H.
d04475d8-fe29-4abb-bc65-edc2ff1d32b3
Langdon, Simon P.
a78ab8c9-d28d-49bc-a2a7-cc7a0ec36ad2
Leach, Martin O.
bbf92f83-c0eb-4549-85bd-1e5e788f0d79
Mann, David J.
6e44ce79-ca8a-481a-b369-4d6cd3ff9b69
Marshall, John F.
1134b21f-7f23-4ee6-aaf5-c7580b73c10b
Martin, Lesley Ann
eebfd860-c253-40e3-a3ad-0d499e832005
Martin, Stewart G.
f41c5fb2-4a0d-4dfa-a23b-5c0d4f4e435a
Macdougall, Jennifer E.
4e36d7eb-f121-47f8-9f67-5ffc3277ea92
Miles, David W.
4c5053ba-f407-4f2a-8639-8c0ddaee1410
Miller, William R.
e99e0226-1811-4cae-b032-b2ccbde0cac4
Morris, Joanna R.
81c2907d-a2de-45d1-b526-47594f08cd92
Moss, Sue M.
78d38b21-9d19-4da0-a53a-a8039045ab3a
Mullan, Paul
0e916302-10f6-4dfc-99a2-7d822b41c390
Natrajan, Rachel
40444b21-ede4-4634-a787-e528ce47c5c4
O’Connor, James P.B.
4247c7ce-3dcc-488a-b06d-48edfa9a0367
O’Connor, Rosemary
99842d95-5b13-4ab6-af19-dc78b335ed10
Palmieri, Carlo
e6321c8b-c189-4173-ac81-05af5b20c611
Pharoah, Paul D.P.
75503648-dfdc-4da1-93c9-26fa44dec680
Rakha, Emad A.
26d9b09b-90c9-4e04-87ae-d95135d76a2b
Reed, Elizabeth
72718a86-3a38-4f30-9808-cd6a17b0beb0
Robinson, Simon P.
bd695429-3311-4c5b-b1a5-b9ddcf9e8528
Sahai, Erik
c50ade2b-9291-44ff-bc5a-7dd97c05bc7e
Saxton, John M.
ff94a7d0-fd41-46ee-a8c5-6c4ebcd16999
Schmid, Peter
3c11e6da-8376-484a-a2de-f4f98c1b0c58
Smalley, Matthew J.
384caa9d-6df3-4ec7-ac62-d03b4b681fef
Speirs, Valerie
aa8448ce-da72-4b1a-a5e8-b0ae5de96394
Stein, Robert
d2d4cadc-9ab4-4357-b1bf-14242c296090
Stingl, John
3845024e-ce89-4739-99b2-fb089516b423
Streuli, Charles H.
467c69ac-555b-407c-a35e-c6210cf3ccd5
Tutt, Andrew N. J.
45cfcb42-c74f-4ef7-a932-180f47ce8f0e
Velikova, Galina
60a74ab1-7fba-4d7a-8b40-598ed8398393
Walker, Rosemary A.
1054c80c-e92e-4f52-9b78-c86741d17d5e
Watson, Christine J.
6fd9bc09-6e96-47ce-b4f7-be6d67c4820e
Williams, Kaye J.
a9e29844-19d8-44d6-b2d8-c0c4c66583a9
Young, Leonie S.
254912a9-fd8b-40b1-ac77-15257621e16b
Thompson, Alastair M.
80960cef-85b6-4224-835b-e86ad7c2c55e
1 October 2013
Eccles, Suzanne A.
d75ea311-8425-435a-83c6-5928152e092f
Aboagye, Eric O.
bb2bcdf6-e5e9-493d-98c6-0f6afa1f51b3
Ali, Simak
7d471c65-fb89-4edb-be44-965f39215a85
Anderson, Annie S.
15b45529-dbd3-46b9-9c5f-14037ed5f20c
Armes, Jo
d72d1004-457a-4f30-bec7-329e696fe34f
Berditchevski, Fedor
f1a2b25b-e73c-440b-8a78-7a22e647b33d
Blaydes, Jeremy P.
e957f999-fd91-4f77-ad62-5b4ef069b15b
Brennan, Keith
1aaaabe5-f475-44fd-a49d-65842b93eba1
Brown, Nicola J.
cbc4d705-c4e7-430f-ab33-ae21254795f7
Bryant, Helen E.
80a41ad8-cdc1-49ab-8885-d23ae81cc6b3
Bundred, Nigel J.
4ceba3cc-eae4-45ed-ba6f-7c07c7bfcb75
Burchell, Joy M.
a775f580-bad2-43ef-bd00-315709b02372
Campbell, Anna M.
cdf3f55a-65cd-43d7-803f-9654e25b072e
Carroll, Jason S.
a94b37bd-6a58-45f6-84fd-90d369e520a1
Clarke, Robert B.
4132a740-2769-4fdf-878f-2d4318699d86
Coles, Charlotte E.
a57ae239-eac4-496f-96f4-367ad6f35350
Cook, Gary J.R.
c33461e4-ea73-4b67-bdf8-9940f9c90f75
Cox, Angela
41fd94c3-79a2-49d4-bda0-616488b147da
Curtin, Nicola J.
4a6971d6-adac-480b-922c-597839068639
Dekker, Lodewijk V.
0c3344dd-7f5e-4034-a995-8ae048361221
dos Santos Silva, Isabel
f8366712-2545-4c3d-921d-ae7dc202bb29
Duffy, Stephen W.
5b52362d-cad8-47a7-8549-5adcd7359a0e
Easton, Douglas F.
2661cf5e-8fc6-4f1d-b27a-e60cac8c8819
Eccles, Diana M.
5b59bc73-11c9-4cf0-a9d5-7a8e523eee23
Edwards, Dylan R.
b487d128-6527-42fc-aa7f-e07225990a6b
Edwards, Joanne
11961a36-d1ab-4bed-a861-707721a517f1
Evans, D. Gareth
314acefb-89fb-4eb7-a0e7-0a6949c9af6c
Fenlon, Deborah F.
52f9a9f1-1643-449c-9856-258ef563342c
Flanagan, James M.
ac6487d1-96c1-4262-91aa-721afc62a357
Foster, Claire
00786ac1-bd47-4aeb-a0e2-40e058695b73
Gallagher, William M.
2c70fc9b-c4fa-4363-a9d9-a763f1ad0666
Garcia-Closas, Montserrat
bd1054d7-f127-4fa8-b52e-67a352d29009
Gee, Julia M.W.
7fff1742-2d4a-4d48-bcd1-48ebb03999e2
Gescher, Andy J.
912127a9-cefd-4979-a1f3-ab0362bd7b74
Goh, Vicky
c5a1049a-8dd6-442c-8df0-649f9dec7f3b
Groves, Ashley M.
40b2d7cc-5bc7-4210-90e0-e07070879de1
Harvey, Amanda J.
02a86d1e-6e90-4454-b386-5933cd4ce484
Harvie, Michelle
5a044f8f-a21c-45ef-9d37-bbc5d70de6d0
Hennessy, Bryan T.
c7cfc114-7162-4ef1-ac30-c005730cb515
Hiscox, Stephen
22714246-dd31-4870-9ccc-8030f94c2b97
Holen, Ingunn
8e90d073-3c91-49b5-a6be-54d02279d534
Howell, Sacha J.
6dd4d7ac-a8dd-4d1a-8723-37f015467c55
Howell, Anthony
1a0a7e78-3d51-4e76-8cd5-bd46cb90d588
Hubbard, Gill
0f482bac-8d01-4a89-a10e-bcc272cb8316
Hulbert-Williams, Nick
c2d2d7f8-67ac-482f-8fe4-f41e8c1e1974
Hunter, Myra S.
fce15222-f73f-478a-87fd-d480cac6fd2a
Jasani, Bharat
bb0b21a9-8542-42bf-9bbb-9c9f5fe88adf
Jones, Louise J.
246f319c-2650-4ddf-a067-2d2489c6fbd8
Key, Timothy J.
cd5d4108-d0b3-4661-b4c2-5b12ac43fe37
Kirwan, Cliona C.
4a465729-935f-422b-99c6-8d5302271ab8
Kong, Anthony
86d4dce7-24f7-42ea-b913-f09259888788
Kunkler, Ian H.
d04475d8-fe29-4abb-bc65-edc2ff1d32b3
Langdon, Simon P.
a78ab8c9-d28d-49bc-a2a7-cc7a0ec36ad2
Leach, Martin O.
bbf92f83-c0eb-4549-85bd-1e5e788f0d79
Mann, David J.
6e44ce79-ca8a-481a-b369-4d6cd3ff9b69
Marshall, John F.
1134b21f-7f23-4ee6-aaf5-c7580b73c10b
Martin, Lesley Ann
eebfd860-c253-40e3-a3ad-0d499e832005
Martin, Stewart G.
f41c5fb2-4a0d-4dfa-a23b-5c0d4f4e435a
Macdougall, Jennifer E.
4e36d7eb-f121-47f8-9f67-5ffc3277ea92
Miles, David W.
4c5053ba-f407-4f2a-8639-8c0ddaee1410
Miller, William R.
e99e0226-1811-4cae-b032-b2ccbde0cac4
Morris, Joanna R.
81c2907d-a2de-45d1-b526-47594f08cd92
Moss, Sue M.
78d38b21-9d19-4da0-a53a-a8039045ab3a
Mullan, Paul
0e916302-10f6-4dfc-99a2-7d822b41c390
Natrajan, Rachel
40444b21-ede4-4634-a787-e528ce47c5c4
O’Connor, James P.B.
4247c7ce-3dcc-488a-b06d-48edfa9a0367
O’Connor, Rosemary
99842d95-5b13-4ab6-af19-dc78b335ed10
Palmieri, Carlo
e6321c8b-c189-4173-ac81-05af5b20c611
Pharoah, Paul D.P.
75503648-dfdc-4da1-93c9-26fa44dec680
Rakha, Emad A.
26d9b09b-90c9-4e04-87ae-d95135d76a2b
Reed, Elizabeth
72718a86-3a38-4f30-9808-cd6a17b0beb0
Robinson, Simon P.
bd695429-3311-4c5b-b1a5-b9ddcf9e8528
Sahai, Erik
c50ade2b-9291-44ff-bc5a-7dd97c05bc7e
Saxton, John M.
ff94a7d0-fd41-46ee-a8c5-6c4ebcd16999
Schmid, Peter
3c11e6da-8376-484a-a2de-f4f98c1b0c58
Smalley, Matthew J.
384caa9d-6df3-4ec7-ac62-d03b4b681fef
Speirs, Valerie
aa8448ce-da72-4b1a-a5e8-b0ae5de96394
Stein, Robert
d2d4cadc-9ab4-4357-b1bf-14242c296090
Stingl, John
3845024e-ce89-4739-99b2-fb089516b423
Streuli, Charles H.
467c69ac-555b-407c-a35e-c6210cf3ccd5
Tutt, Andrew N. J.
45cfcb42-c74f-4ef7-a932-180f47ce8f0e
Velikova, Galina
60a74ab1-7fba-4d7a-8b40-598ed8398393
Walker, Rosemary A.
1054c80c-e92e-4f52-9b78-c86741d17d5e
Watson, Christine J.
6fd9bc09-6e96-47ce-b4f7-be6d67c4820e
Williams, Kaye J.
a9e29844-19d8-44d6-b2d8-c0c4c66583a9
Young, Leonie S.
254912a9-fd8b-40b1-ac77-15257621e16b
Thompson, Alastair M.
80960cef-85b6-4224-835b-e86ad7c2c55e