Early intervention and evidence-based policy and practice: framing and taming

Edwards, Rosalind, Gillies, Val and Horsley, Nicola (2015) Early intervention and evidence-based policy and practice: framing and taming. Social Policy and Society, 15, 1-14. (doi:10.1017/S1474746415000081).

Record type: Article

Abstract

In this article we highlight some critical issues in the way that an issue is framed as a problem in policy-making and the consequent means of taming that problem, to focus on the use and implications of neuroscientific discourse of brain claims in early intervention policy and practice. We draw on three sets of analyses: of the contradictory set of motifs framing the state of ‘evidence’ of what works in intervention in the early years; of the (mis)use of neuroscientific discourse to frame deficient parenting as causing inequalities and support particular policy directions; and of the way that early years practitioners adopt brain claims to tame the problem of deficient parenting. We argue that using expedient brain claims as a framing and taming justification is entrenching gendered and classed understandings and inequalities.

Text

SP&S accepted EI evidence article.doc - Accepted Manuscript

Download (91kB)