Impact of centralized evaluation of bone marrow histology in systemic mastocytosis
Impact of centralized evaluation of bone marrow histology in systemic mastocytosis
BACKGROUND:Bone marrow (BM) histology/immunohistochemistry, KIT D816V mutation analysis and serum tryptase measurements are mandatory tools for diagnosis of systemic mastocytosis (SM).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Within the 'German Registry of Disorders on Eosinophils and Mast Cells', we identified 65 SM patients who had two consecutive BM biopsies. The first biopsy was evaluated by a local pathologist (LP), the second biopsy by a reference pathologist (RP) of the 'European Competence Network on Mastocytosis (ECNM)'.
RESULTS: Final diagnoses by RP were SM (n = 27), SM or aggressive SM (ASM) with associated non-mast cell lineage hematologic disease [(A)SM-AHNMD, n = 34)] or mast cell leukemia ± AHNMD (n = 4). In 15/65 patients (23%), initial diagnoses by LP were incorrect (by overlooking SM), e.g. primary myelofibrosis (n = 3), myelodysplastic/myeloproliferative neoplasm unclassified (n = 3), B-cell lymphoma (n = 2). Fourteen of 15 patients (93%) with incorrect diagnosis had an advanced SM, mostly (A)SM-AHNMD. In the 50 concordantly diagnosed patients, immunohistochemical markers for quantitative assessment of mast cell infiltration, e.g. CD117 (KIT) or CD25, were applied by LP in only 34/50 patients (68%), and mutational analysis for KIT D816V was performed or recommended in only 13/50 patients (26%). Finally, the subclassification of SM was discordant because LP did not diagnose AHNMD in 9/50 (18%) patients.
CONCLUSIONS: In summary, adequate diagnosis and subclassification of SM requires an in-depth evaluation of the BM by experienced hematopathologists (preferably in a reference center) in combination with molecular genetics, serum tryptase and clinical parameters.
bone marrow histology, misdiagnosis, ecnm, kitd816v
392-397
Jawhar, Mohamad
a608a215-173b-47bd-89eb-a8de2fe595aa
Schwaab, Juliana
d63ed545-a6fc-4815-ab86-f901e55c2a2f
Horny, Hans-Peter
95077a3b-b869-49ba-a227-f88b2c0bad80
Sotlar, Karl
e3e96797-3fab-4c37-8728-7c77bb3ba389
Naumann, Nicole
43566136-d964-415e-be36-45aeb4f88965
Fabarius, Alice
5c31b1e0-c6da-49b8-843a-5b0ca736e5a2
Valent, Peter
1f551798-afce-4de4-abed-9efd78bc2e8a
Cross, Nicholas C.P.
f87650da-b908-4a34-b31b-d62c5f186fe4
Hofmann, Wolf-Karsten
ab66838b-bf8c-4352-a0f0-3c8aafed2570
Metzgeroth, Georgia
611ec46d-9a11-4e24-ae0f-5ac19dfd0237
Reiter, Andreas
ffa23e84-4a13-4cb5-aaf0-3fafe25dbede
May 2016
Jawhar, Mohamad
a608a215-173b-47bd-89eb-a8de2fe595aa
Schwaab, Juliana
d63ed545-a6fc-4815-ab86-f901e55c2a2f
Horny, Hans-Peter
95077a3b-b869-49ba-a227-f88b2c0bad80
Sotlar, Karl
e3e96797-3fab-4c37-8728-7c77bb3ba389
Naumann, Nicole
43566136-d964-415e-be36-45aeb4f88965
Fabarius, Alice
5c31b1e0-c6da-49b8-843a-5b0ca736e5a2
Valent, Peter
1f551798-afce-4de4-abed-9efd78bc2e8a
Cross, Nicholas C.P.
f87650da-b908-4a34-b31b-d62c5f186fe4
Hofmann, Wolf-Karsten
ab66838b-bf8c-4352-a0f0-3c8aafed2570
Metzgeroth, Georgia
611ec46d-9a11-4e24-ae0f-5ac19dfd0237
Reiter, Andreas
ffa23e84-4a13-4cb5-aaf0-3fafe25dbede
Jawhar, Mohamad, Schwaab, Juliana, Horny, Hans-Peter, Sotlar, Karl, Naumann, Nicole, Fabarius, Alice, Valent, Peter, Cross, Nicholas C.P., Hofmann, Wolf-Karsten, Metzgeroth, Georgia and Reiter, Andreas
(2016)
Impact of centralized evaluation of bone marrow histology in systemic mastocytosis.
European Journal of Clinical Investigation, 46 (5), .
(doi:10.1111/eci.12607).
(PMID:26914980)
Abstract
BACKGROUND:Bone marrow (BM) histology/immunohistochemistry, KIT D816V mutation analysis and serum tryptase measurements are mandatory tools for diagnosis of systemic mastocytosis (SM).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Within the 'German Registry of Disorders on Eosinophils and Mast Cells', we identified 65 SM patients who had two consecutive BM biopsies. The first biopsy was evaluated by a local pathologist (LP), the second biopsy by a reference pathologist (RP) of the 'European Competence Network on Mastocytosis (ECNM)'.
RESULTS: Final diagnoses by RP were SM (n = 27), SM or aggressive SM (ASM) with associated non-mast cell lineage hematologic disease [(A)SM-AHNMD, n = 34)] or mast cell leukemia ± AHNMD (n = 4). In 15/65 patients (23%), initial diagnoses by LP were incorrect (by overlooking SM), e.g. primary myelofibrosis (n = 3), myelodysplastic/myeloproliferative neoplasm unclassified (n = 3), B-cell lymphoma (n = 2). Fourteen of 15 patients (93%) with incorrect diagnosis had an advanced SM, mostly (A)SM-AHNMD. In the 50 concordantly diagnosed patients, immunohistochemical markers for quantitative assessment of mast cell infiltration, e.g. CD117 (KIT) or CD25, were applied by LP in only 34/50 patients (68%), and mutational analysis for KIT D816V was performed or recommended in only 13/50 patients (26%). Finally, the subclassification of SM was discordant because LP did not diagnose AHNMD in 9/50 (18%) patients.
CONCLUSIONS: In summary, adequate diagnosis and subclassification of SM requires an in-depth evaluation of the BM by experienced hematopathologists (preferably in a reference center) in combination with molecular genetics, serum tryptase and clinical parameters.
Text
eci12607.pdf
- Accepted Manuscript
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 18 February 2016
e-pub ahead of print date: 23 February 2016
Published date: May 2016
Keywords:
bone marrow histology, misdiagnosis, ecnm, kitd816v
Organisations:
Human Development & Health
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 388660
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/388660
ISSN: 0014-2972
PURE UUID: 86e8e057-436e-4dac-b6b4-778f58a3a3c7
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 01 Mar 2016 14:09
Last modified: 15 Mar 2024 05:25
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Mohamad Jawhar
Author:
Juliana Schwaab
Author:
Hans-Peter Horny
Author:
Karl Sotlar
Author:
Nicole Naumann
Author:
Alice Fabarius
Author:
Peter Valent
Author:
Wolf-Karsten Hofmann
Author:
Georgia Metzgeroth
Author:
Andreas Reiter
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics