Report on the sixth blind test of organic crystal-structure prediction methods
Report on the sixth blind test of organic crystal-structure prediction methods
The sixth blind test of organic crystal-structure prediction (CSP) methods has been held, with five target systems: a small nearly rigid molecule, a polymorphic former drug candidate, a chloride salt hydrate, a co-crystal, and a bulky flexible molecule. This blind test has seen substantial growth in the number of submissions, with the broad range of prediction methods giving a unique insight into the state of the art in the field. Significant progress has been seen in treating flexible molecules, usage of hierarchical approaches to ranking structures, the application of density-functional approximations, and the establishment of new workflows and "best practices" for performing CSP calculations. All of the targets, apart from a single potentially disordered Z` = 2 polymorph of the drug candidate, were predicted by at least one submission. Despite many remaining challenges, it is clear that CSP methods are becoming more applicable to a wider range of real systems, including salts, hydrates and larger flexible molecules. The results also highlight the potential for CSP calculations to complement and augment experimental studies of organic solid forms.
1-59
Reilly, Anthony M.
a8a858aa-810c-4ee6-a691-49ae82907295
Cooper, Richard I.
1843983e-e602-440c-9fe1-834fda5cfd91
Adjiman, Claire S.
f29d1eb0-66e7-4019-9b22-763e10e39e45
Bhattacharya, Saswate
70a4c061-4828-401d-97ff-dd05fbaaae4b
Boese, A. Daniel
78b85fcc-3986-40df-9ef3-11cfe077bb88
Brandenburg, Jan Gerit
f118497a-b37a-4463-b080-428e1c964557
Bygrave, Peter J.
5b60f2a0-1477-43f6-a6a4-aa5a2804a549
Bylsma, Rita
89531172-aa26-4cbe-8048-82161757471b
Campbell, Josh E.
09d87084-e709-457b-8a97-1b12acdd1b56
Car, Roberto
af12b912-8c7c-40e1-8a6d-92ffe0830071
Case, David H.
5697af1e-06b6-4e46-83eb-185cec9699ec
Chadha, Renu
7f8dd0b7-19b2-452f-a8bc-200ec022c76a
Cole, Jason C.
e743b9da-cd36-4cd6-a19a-0e503ce69650
Cosburn, Katherine
bad8b911-4939-4e99-abce-f28483adb776
Cuppen, Herma M.
f94d78b1-db42-4e67-b4cd-2731674aade2
Curtis, Farren
9525b6be-3183-4221-b8ff-804a7da0067f
Day, Graeme M.
e3be79ba-ad12-4461-b735-74d5c4355636
DiStasio Jr, Robert A.
b75f60db-6154-41e5-8f4c-d8b5c4785156
Dzyabchenko, Alexander
a1a39a34-831c-4ed6-9096-866742027634
van Eijck, Bouke P.
c65113ad-9769-47b9-9bbb-c392f19b6c2c
Elking, Dennis M.
e25767e1-de04-4fd6-9937-f4ce194cfa5a
can den Ende, Joost A.
caaa28d1-0f35-4886-80e5-55a81655a10c
Facelli, Julio C.
190b1ad1-44d6-4bb8-8a84-b002af5ad604
Ferraro, Marta B.
58fee1d7-6131-47ec-9bc5-bf021005fff3
Fusti-Molnar, Laszlo
3d010fee-0c3a-4254-9e51-5329802e9087
Gatsiou, Chritina-Anna
b50f45b6-d766-420f-bb75-535f3b4a19ed
Gee, Thomas S.
e5c34f80-388e-4cb4-a705-5452c514291e
de Gelder, Rene
330da1e1-eafc-4466-b581-76f3945e19de
Ghiringhelli, Luca M.
263bd8f7-76f9-442e-aaf7-4d168dec9da2
Goto, Hitoshi
c6bcaae0-8da2-4d88-be78-9e7bca4a43fc
Grimme, Stefan
ebf7fbd0-cb55-4dd6-91b4-0b51070734ae
Guo, Rui
e55f8f56-17fd-40b2-9e3a-69b5f70b451e
Hofmann, Detlef W.M.
2b1a23f0-cd75-4f78-b476-1357e78c89e0
Hoja, Johannes
0ad6655e-0dbd-495d-9b68-6d4a5a5da4fb
Hylton, Rebecca K.
6b4b5781-1812-4235-8678-6634df51e712
Iuzzolino, Luca
83141671-c590-41ac-9710-d53f88e57eab
Jankiewicz, Wojciech
759a9b27-6a8d-4873-a27e-503fbdd42c29
de Jong, Daniel T.
7b306f6d-3884-4c96-bd32-ac2e6c8ac09c
Kendrick, John
94d1a2a2-6c7e-41f8-8ef2-036d5bdfa930
de Klerk, Niek J.J.
0259ce8c-7df9-4f51-acc8-0e2b41a55f35
Ko, Hsin-Yu
3a07ba93-6e1b-4d21-9876-b3cc0799866c
Kuleshova, Liudmila N.
e3b21233-95ac-4e94-9b23-4023e21dc4cd
Li, Xiayue
69394d37-9b10-48d4-9b35-6001f0f19546
Lohani, Sanjaya
e7574ea1-77e7-4168-87eb-1ec598296d8b
Leusen, Frank J.J.
d41462dd-3804-4380-ad6f-c45e9faeec45
Lund, Albert M.
dcac9baa-e2f6-4767-9dfc-4171bc7af4e6
Lv, Jian
ea49412d-9963-463e-84bd-583a461ff490
Ma, Yanming
ace712f1-b03c-4888-abf6-2278fc95f853
Marom, Noa
f491daf5-ee13-42da-9e47-7f3660ff2794
Masunov, Artem E.
038c2b1a-8871-4d2a-a44c-cbbbfb35d29e
McCabe, Patrick
b70e4c1f-de09-4bb5-88ff-4651ec7d9f3f
McMahon, David P.
026a4184-d048-4a12-964e-5c6d9da81c68
Meekes, Hugo
2efde48e-73b4-4762-9a8c-329fb85cb4ac
Metz, Michael P.
607a9b34-6c09-435b-8af0-93c6ed14eafe
Misquitta, Alston J.
a4cd3001-29ab-402b-8e6a-8546d46dd2f9
Mohamed, Sharmarke
cfc0916d-fbc1-44a0-9cc0-b798c1019889
Monserrat, Bartomeu
3015b6fd-2848-48b8-aa3f-376dcfe99d24
Needs, Richard J.
819db509-25be-418b-a97e-55ba3711392e
Neumann, Marcus A.
f004825f-59bd-489d-8337-55148a4da3ca
Nyman, Jonas
0feff679-4e4f-4205-9ef9-6a4458ff2fc9
Obata, Shigeaki
ada5967d-634c-4374-924c-33e04646c4d8
Oberhofer, Harald
e6b73c0c-95e7-4d43-ad7c-1ca9ada10d93
Oganov, Artem R.
d1f7d0c9-aba5-4ab1-8fca-9ab794784684
Orendt, Anita M.
74ca0cdf-e8a5-439e-9d93-2fb320897eec
Pagola, Gabriel I.
e88145c4-8ca8-47a0-b09e-b7e35e216390
Pantelides, Constantinos C.
e492bb17-7b93-4493-9b13-1de3cc042137
Pickard, Chris J.
b221ee8f-4093-4601-91a0-82d010ed07e2
Podeszwa, Rafal
0c634d3b-76a1-4035-9be2-c6c8f8a8726c
Price, Louise S.
d1aac7e3-f6fb-4394-afc1-c0936350a1ac
Price, Sarah L.
ab33d469-c548-4a15-918f-b0614ce6129a
Pulido, Angeles
cdc804ed-2c64-4f41-85f9-b8fadc2940b6
Read, Murray G.
6abab9d9-dd68-45ff-9b9c-1c107a2293a1
Reuter, Karsten
7a3376ac-e36d-4b05-8d5d-b4272053fbe5
Schneider, Elia
2e7745f0-bc92-47e6-8b6e-b7bd3082cf56
Schober, Christoph
d4b0cf24-54bc-452b-a85f-3d68f3fcf2b1
Shields, Gregory P.
54dbc381-1d14-406d-88fe-9c9e5001a951
Singh, Pawanpreet
49a63703-8a7b-40c3-a70a-4d2c93818ad4
Sugden, Isaac J.
eb3490f5-b212-405f-9f5a-f91007c27810
Szaleqicz, Krzysztof
cc590b7b-d8cc-4886-b64f-8216c2e7d46d
Taylor, Christopher R.
95bebf3a-a98a-453c-acb6-aebc451bd5a8
Tkatchenko, Alexandre
5388f42d-5dc0-4421-a96b-ad40e451c814
Tuckerman, Mark E.
e46bf4bc-faaf-4860-893b-59119ee7ed06
Vacarro, Francesca
35ef917f-bc06-455e-90a8-93aad40e026d
Vasileiadis, Manolis
460e8967-485c-4c08-bf32-430554891561
Vazquez-Mayagoitia, Alvaro
5fc6fb3d-72bd-4599-b291-d7be3c51ac2f
Vogt, Leslie
1f3e4f13-22d6-4ee3-ad5d-549f5c1db343
Wang, Yanchao
c249e68b-1651-4fd1-b9e0-926986d89c42
Watson, Rona E.
05334bbc-cdd0-4aec-b1b2-f9c5907dcc55
de Wijs, Gilles A.
3fbfd053-cd16-425b-acc7-9e788d381a04
Yang, Jack
4f29196a-5127-4511-8dba-4aea32a4e25e
Zhu, Qiang
d1e9b689-8ce1-4adb-816a-7af76695d7e5
Groom, Colin R.
fecbe1d3-b8c3-4c45-8ba2-8b6848d748f8
Reilly, Anthony M.
a8a858aa-810c-4ee6-a691-49ae82907295
Cooper, Richard I.
1843983e-e602-440c-9fe1-834fda5cfd91
Adjiman, Claire S.
f29d1eb0-66e7-4019-9b22-763e10e39e45
Bhattacharya, Saswate
70a4c061-4828-401d-97ff-dd05fbaaae4b
Boese, A. Daniel
78b85fcc-3986-40df-9ef3-11cfe077bb88
Brandenburg, Jan Gerit
f118497a-b37a-4463-b080-428e1c964557
Bygrave, Peter J.
5b60f2a0-1477-43f6-a6a4-aa5a2804a549
Bylsma, Rita
89531172-aa26-4cbe-8048-82161757471b
Campbell, Josh E.
09d87084-e709-457b-8a97-1b12acdd1b56
Car, Roberto
af12b912-8c7c-40e1-8a6d-92ffe0830071
Case, David H.
5697af1e-06b6-4e46-83eb-185cec9699ec
Chadha, Renu
7f8dd0b7-19b2-452f-a8bc-200ec022c76a
Cole, Jason C.
e743b9da-cd36-4cd6-a19a-0e503ce69650
Cosburn, Katherine
bad8b911-4939-4e99-abce-f28483adb776
Cuppen, Herma M.
f94d78b1-db42-4e67-b4cd-2731674aade2
Curtis, Farren
9525b6be-3183-4221-b8ff-804a7da0067f
Day, Graeme M.
e3be79ba-ad12-4461-b735-74d5c4355636
DiStasio Jr, Robert A.
b75f60db-6154-41e5-8f4c-d8b5c4785156
Dzyabchenko, Alexander
a1a39a34-831c-4ed6-9096-866742027634
van Eijck, Bouke P.
c65113ad-9769-47b9-9bbb-c392f19b6c2c
Elking, Dennis M.
e25767e1-de04-4fd6-9937-f4ce194cfa5a
can den Ende, Joost A.
caaa28d1-0f35-4886-80e5-55a81655a10c
Facelli, Julio C.
190b1ad1-44d6-4bb8-8a84-b002af5ad604
Ferraro, Marta B.
58fee1d7-6131-47ec-9bc5-bf021005fff3
Fusti-Molnar, Laszlo
3d010fee-0c3a-4254-9e51-5329802e9087
Gatsiou, Chritina-Anna
b50f45b6-d766-420f-bb75-535f3b4a19ed
Gee, Thomas S.
e5c34f80-388e-4cb4-a705-5452c514291e
de Gelder, Rene
330da1e1-eafc-4466-b581-76f3945e19de
Ghiringhelli, Luca M.
263bd8f7-76f9-442e-aaf7-4d168dec9da2
Goto, Hitoshi
c6bcaae0-8da2-4d88-be78-9e7bca4a43fc
Grimme, Stefan
ebf7fbd0-cb55-4dd6-91b4-0b51070734ae
Guo, Rui
e55f8f56-17fd-40b2-9e3a-69b5f70b451e
Hofmann, Detlef W.M.
2b1a23f0-cd75-4f78-b476-1357e78c89e0
Hoja, Johannes
0ad6655e-0dbd-495d-9b68-6d4a5a5da4fb
Hylton, Rebecca K.
6b4b5781-1812-4235-8678-6634df51e712
Iuzzolino, Luca
83141671-c590-41ac-9710-d53f88e57eab
Jankiewicz, Wojciech
759a9b27-6a8d-4873-a27e-503fbdd42c29
de Jong, Daniel T.
7b306f6d-3884-4c96-bd32-ac2e6c8ac09c
Kendrick, John
94d1a2a2-6c7e-41f8-8ef2-036d5bdfa930
de Klerk, Niek J.J.
0259ce8c-7df9-4f51-acc8-0e2b41a55f35
Ko, Hsin-Yu
3a07ba93-6e1b-4d21-9876-b3cc0799866c
Kuleshova, Liudmila N.
e3b21233-95ac-4e94-9b23-4023e21dc4cd
Li, Xiayue
69394d37-9b10-48d4-9b35-6001f0f19546
Lohani, Sanjaya
e7574ea1-77e7-4168-87eb-1ec598296d8b
Leusen, Frank J.J.
d41462dd-3804-4380-ad6f-c45e9faeec45
Lund, Albert M.
dcac9baa-e2f6-4767-9dfc-4171bc7af4e6
Lv, Jian
ea49412d-9963-463e-84bd-583a461ff490
Ma, Yanming
ace712f1-b03c-4888-abf6-2278fc95f853
Marom, Noa
f491daf5-ee13-42da-9e47-7f3660ff2794
Masunov, Artem E.
038c2b1a-8871-4d2a-a44c-cbbbfb35d29e
McCabe, Patrick
b70e4c1f-de09-4bb5-88ff-4651ec7d9f3f
McMahon, David P.
026a4184-d048-4a12-964e-5c6d9da81c68
Meekes, Hugo
2efde48e-73b4-4762-9a8c-329fb85cb4ac
Metz, Michael P.
607a9b34-6c09-435b-8af0-93c6ed14eafe
Misquitta, Alston J.
a4cd3001-29ab-402b-8e6a-8546d46dd2f9
Mohamed, Sharmarke
cfc0916d-fbc1-44a0-9cc0-b798c1019889
Monserrat, Bartomeu
3015b6fd-2848-48b8-aa3f-376dcfe99d24
Needs, Richard J.
819db509-25be-418b-a97e-55ba3711392e
Neumann, Marcus A.
f004825f-59bd-489d-8337-55148a4da3ca
Nyman, Jonas
0feff679-4e4f-4205-9ef9-6a4458ff2fc9
Obata, Shigeaki
ada5967d-634c-4374-924c-33e04646c4d8
Oberhofer, Harald
e6b73c0c-95e7-4d43-ad7c-1ca9ada10d93
Oganov, Artem R.
d1f7d0c9-aba5-4ab1-8fca-9ab794784684
Orendt, Anita M.
74ca0cdf-e8a5-439e-9d93-2fb320897eec
Pagola, Gabriel I.
e88145c4-8ca8-47a0-b09e-b7e35e216390
Pantelides, Constantinos C.
e492bb17-7b93-4493-9b13-1de3cc042137
Pickard, Chris J.
b221ee8f-4093-4601-91a0-82d010ed07e2
Podeszwa, Rafal
0c634d3b-76a1-4035-9be2-c6c8f8a8726c
Price, Louise S.
d1aac7e3-f6fb-4394-afc1-c0936350a1ac
Price, Sarah L.
ab33d469-c548-4a15-918f-b0614ce6129a
Pulido, Angeles
cdc804ed-2c64-4f41-85f9-b8fadc2940b6
Read, Murray G.
6abab9d9-dd68-45ff-9b9c-1c107a2293a1
Reuter, Karsten
7a3376ac-e36d-4b05-8d5d-b4272053fbe5
Schneider, Elia
2e7745f0-bc92-47e6-8b6e-b7bd3082cf56
Schober, Christoph
d4b0cf24-54bc-452b-a85f-3d68f3fcf2b1
Shields, Gregory P.
54dbc381-1d14-406d-88fe-9c9e5001a951
Singh, Pawanpreet
49a63703-8a7b-40c3-a70a-4d2c93818ad4
Sugden, Isaac J.
eb3490f5-b212-405f-9f5a-f91007c27810
Szaleqicz, Krzysztof
cc590b7b-d8cc-4886-b64f-8216c2e7d46d
Taylor, Christopher R.
95bebf3a-a98a-453c-acb6-aebc451bd5a8
Tkatchenko, Alexandre
5388f42d-5dc0-4421-a96b-ad40e451c814
Tuckerman, Mark E.
e46bf4bc-faaf-4860-893b-59119ee7ed06
Vacarro, Francesca
35ef917f-bc06-455e-90a8-93aad40e026d
Vasileiadis, Manolis
460e8967-485c-4c08-bf32-430554891561
Vazquez-Mayagoitia, Alvaro
5fc6fb3d-72bd-4599-b291-d7be3c51ac2f
Vogt, Leslie
1f3e4f13-22d6-4ee3-ad5d-549f5c1db343
Wang, Yanchao
c249e68b-1651-4fd1-b9e0-926986d89c42
Watson, Rona E.
05334bbc-cdd0-4aec-b1b2-f9c5907dcc55
de Wijs, Gilles A.
3fbfd053-cd16-425b-acc7-9e788d381a04
Yang, Jack
4f29196a-5127-4511-8dba-4aea32a4e25e
Zhu, Qiang
d1e9b689-8ce1-4adb-816a-7af76695d7e5
Groom, Colin R.
fecbe1d3-b8c3-4c45-8ba2-8b6848d748f8