Toroidal Optical Activity

T.A. Raybould, V. A. Fedotov, N. Papasimakis, I. Kuprov, I.J. Youngs, W. T. Chen, D. P. Tsai and N. I. Zheludev


Figure 2b
Column 1 - Frequency, Units GHz
Column 2 - FEM t_{--} transmission coefficient
Column 3 - FEM t_{++} transmission coefficient
Column 2 - Multipole t_{--} transmission coefficient
Column 3 - Multipole t_{++} transmission coefficient









   1.2500000e+01   9.6776556e-01   9.7060079e-01   9.6194954e-01   9.7007620e-01
   1.2540000e+01   9.6752225e-01   9.7032167e-01   9.6146256e-01   9.6976658e-01
   1.2581000e+01   9.6725912e-01   9.7001716e-01   9.6094590e-01   9.6943382e-01
   1.2621000e+01   9.6697500e-01   9.6968529e-01   9.6039828e-01   9.6907692e-01
   1.2662000e+01   9.6666856e-01   9.6932394e-01   9.5981947e-01   9.6869439e-01
   1.2702000e+01   9.6633863e-01   9.6893087e-01   9.5919796e-01   9.6828306e-01
   1.2742000e+01   9.6598390e-01   9.6850364e-01   9.5853364e-01   9.6783839e-01
   1.2783000e+01   9.6560299e-01   9.6803962e-01   9.5784200e-01   9.6736810e-01
   1.2823000e+01   9.6519459e-01   9.6753589e-01   9.5709569e-01   9.6685779e-01
   1.2864000e+01   9.6475707e-01   9.6698914e-01   9.5631524e-01   9.6631806e-01
   1.2904000e+01   9.6428886e-01   9.6639573e-01   9.5546855e-01   9.6572874e-01
   1.2944000e+01   9.6378810e-01   9.6575142e-01   9.5456436e-01   9.6509305e-01
   1.2985000e+01   9.6325259e-01   9.6505135e-01   9.5361325e-01   9.6441521e-01
   1.3025000e+01   9.6267980e-01   9.6428992e-01   9.5258155e-01   9.6367490e-01
   1.3066000e+01   9.6206670e-01   9.6346045e-01   9.5147803e-01   9.6287338e-01
   1.3106000e+01   9.6140951e-01   9.6255506e-01   9.5028939e-01   9.6200249e-01
   1.3146000e+01   9.6070354e-01   9.6156425e-01   9.4900845e-01   9.6105697e-01
   1.3187000e+01   9.5994284e-01   9.6047655e-01   9.4762499e-01   9.6002076e-01
   1.3227000e+01   9.5911970e-01   9.5927796e-01   9.4611313e-01   9.5888038e-01
   1.3268000e+01   9.5822403e-01   9.5795115e-01   9.4446776e-01   9.5762278e-01
   1.3308000e+01   9.5724236e-01   9.5647457e-01   9.4264522e-01   9.5622283e-01
   1.3348000e+01   9.5615652e-01   9.5482093e-01   9.4061976e-01   9.5465682e-01
   1.3389000e+01   9.5494152e-01   9.5295551e-01   9.3836961e-01   9.5289485e-01
   1.3429000e+01   9.5356253e-01   9.5083330e-01   9.3580298e-01   9.5088763e-01
   1.3470000e+01   9.5197006e-01   9.4839538e-01   9.3287809e-01   9.4858536e-01
   1.3510000e+01   9.5009263e-01   9.4556329e-01   9.2945480e-01   9.4590892e-01
   1.3551000e+01   9.4782456e-01   9.4223070e-01   9.2541750e-01   9.4276475e-01
   1.3591000e+01   9.4500672e-01   9.3825125e-01   9.2052195e-01   9.3900909e-01
   1.3631000e+01   9.4139322e-01   9.3341914e-01   9.1446923e-01   9.3446049e-01
   1.3672000e+01   9.3659424e-01   9.2743959e-01   9.0678515e-01   9.2884387e-01
   1.3712000e+01   9.2997449e-01   9.1988151e-01   8.9668029e-01   9.2175839e-01
   1.3753000e+01   9.2046668e-01   9.1010411e-01   8.8296127e-01   9.1263600e-01
   1.3793000e+01   9.0622307e-01   8.9714653e-01   8.6353659e-01   9.0061374e-01
   1.3833000e+01   8.8395681e-01   8.7958740e-01   8.3489632e-01   8.8444372e-01
   1.3874000e+01   8.4773124e-01   8.5547610e-01   7.9095847e-01   8.6247843e-01
   1.3914000e+01   7.8701078e-01   8.2282110e-01   7.2124154e-01   8.3320222e-01
   1.3955000e+01   6.8493281e-01   7.8223716e-01   6.1017114e-01   7.9770943e-01
   1.3995000e+01   5.2252060e-01   7.4416705e-01   4.4299365e-01   7.6610928e-01
   1.4035000e+01   3.0010945e-01   7.3303001e-01   2.3467979e-01   7.5988380e-01
   1.4076000e+01   7.4576488e-02   7.6184805e-01   1.4111214e-01   7.8873426e-01
   1.4116000e+01   1.7100700e-01   8.0912453e-01   2.8278545e-01   8.3256358e-01
   1.4157000e+01   3.1914990e-01   8.5068455e-01   4.1320736e-01   8.7022907e-01
   1.4197000e+01   4.1874009e-01   8.7975207e-01   5.0010135e-01   8.9626397e-01
   1.4237000e+01   4.8140575e-01   8.9835258e-01   5.5333002e-01   9.1276641e-01
   1.4278000e+01   5.1826564e-01   9.0975304e-01   5.8312307e-01   9.2280724e-01
   1.4318000e+01   5.3668562e-01   9.1641341e-01   5.9635806e-01   9.2865771e-01
   1.4359000e+01   5.4104143e-01   9.1992203e-01   5.9698892e-01   9.3177020e-01
   1.4399000e+01   5.3369945e-01   9.2127504e-01   5.8720643e-01   9.3305896e-01
   1.4439000e+01   5.1568976e-01   9.2111582e-01   5.6790739e-01   9.3308128e-01
   1.4480000e+01   4.8711533e-01   9.1989887e-01   5.3924508e-01   9.3229269e-01
   1.4520000e+01   4.4741227e-01   9.1800338e-01   5.0090869e-01   9.3101727e-01
   1.4561000e+01   3.9556707e-01   9.1582002e-01   4.5238834e-01   9.2962412e-01
   1.4601000e+01   3.3040077e-01   9.1382130e-01   3.9368945e-01   9.2852198e-01
   1.4641000e+01   2.5108268e-01   9.1260804e-01   3.2647877e-01   9.2822445e-01
   1.4682000e+01   1.5838393e-01   9.1289903e-01   2.5764597e-01   9.2931146e-01
   1.4722000e+01   6.3494803e-02   9.1541652e-01   2.0749511e-01   9.3231461e-01
   1.4763000e+01   9.2280973e-02   9.2064604e-01   2.1260324e-01   9.3757619e-01
   1.4803000e+01   2.0950458e-01   9.2855375e-01   2.7967563e-01   9.4492638e-01
   1.4843000e+01   3.3064582e-01   9.3846275e-01   3.7596439e-01   9.5369399e-01
   1.4884000e+01   4.4433971e-01   9.4924544e-01   4.7674816e-01   9.6293009e-01
   1.4924000e+01   5.4506816e-01   9.5973007e-01   5.7004562e-01   9.7160721e-01
   1.4965000e+01   6.3046465e-01   9.6906811e-01   6.5087068e-01   9.7913390e-01
   1.5005000e+01   7.0058768e-01   9.7684771e-01   7.1799779e-01   9.8522104e-01
   1.5045000e+01   7.5696328e-01   9.8301531e-01   7.7231166e-01   9.8987250e-01
   1.5086000e+01   8.0173830e-01   9.8772879e-01   8.1558768e-01   9.9327375e-01
   1.5126000e+01   8.3710854e-01   9.9123009e-01   8.4985884e-01   9.9567029e-01
   1.5167000e+01   8.6503196e-01   9.9376788e-01   8.7692668e-01   9.9727923e-01
   1.5207000e+01   8.8713246e-01   9.9556150e-01   8.9834829e-01   9.9829606e-01
   1.5247000e+01   9.0470307e-01   9.9679020e-01   9.1536121e-01   9.9886262e-01
   1.5288000e+01   9.1875071e-01   9.9759416e-01   9.2893545e-01   9.9912717e-01
   1.5328000e+01   9.3005070e-01   9.9808044e-01   9.3983572e-01   9.9914073e-01
   1.5369000e+01   9.3919748e-01   9.9832981e-01   9.4863005e-01   9.9898832e-01
   1.5409000e+01   9.4664692e-01   9.9840272e-01   9.5576500e-01   9.9871579e-01
   1.5449000e+01   9.5275044e-01   9.9834438e-01   9.6158522e-01   9.9835694e-01
   1.5490000e+01   9.5778902e-01   9.9818936e-01   9.6635605e-01   9.9793525e-01
   1.5530000e+01   9.6193402e-01   9.9796072e-01   9.7025491e-01   9.9748402e-01
   1.5571000e+01   9.6538575e-01   9.9767851e-01   9.7349160e-01   9.9699621e-01
   1.5611000e+01   9.6826959e-01   9.9735766e-01   9.7616716e-01   9.9647771e-01
   1.5652000e+01   9.7068337e-01   9.9700835e-01   9.7838362e-01   9.9596344e-01
   1.5692000e+01   9.7270849e-01   9.9663858e-01   9.8022009e-01   9.9543211e-01
   1.5732000e+01   9.7441041e-01   9.9625439e-01   9.8174381e-01   9.9490209e-01
   1.5773000e+01   9.7584194e-01   9.9586026e-01   9.8300222e-01   9.9437550e-01
   1.5813000e+01   9.7704608e-01   9.9545959e-01   9.8404169e-01   9.9384715e-01
   1.5854000e+01   9.7805778e-01   9.9505489e-01   9.8489634e-01   9.9332924e-01
   1.5894000e+01   9.7890582e-01   9.9464793e-01   9.8558893e-01   9.9280243e-01
   1.5934000e+01   9.7961388e-01   9.9424009e-01   9.8615348e-01   9.9229287e-01
   1.5975000e+01   9.8020166e-01   9.9383218e-01   9.8659809e-01   9.9178444e-01
   1.6015000e+01   9.8068558e-01   9.9342491e-01   9.8694492e-01   9.9128310e-01
   1.6056000e+01   9.8107930e-01   9.9301861e-01   9.8720318e-01   9.9078446e-01
   1.6096000e+01   9.8139445e-01   9.9261347e-01   9.8739077e-01   9.9029370e-01
   1.6136000e+01   9.8164077e-01   9.9220960e-01   9.8751420e-01   9.8980558e-01
   1.6177000e+01   9.8182648e-01   9.9180699e-01   9.8757918e-01   9.8932383e-01
   1.6217000e+01   9.8195873e-01   9.9140545e-01   9.8759308e-01   9.8884182e-01
   1.6258000e+01   9.8204348e-01   9.9100487e-01   9.8756850e-01   9.8837824e-01
   1.6298000e+01   9.8208599e-01   9.9060509e-01   9.8750161e-01   9.8790469e-01
   1.6338000e+01   9.8209071e-01   9.9020584e-01   9.8739720e-01   9.8743592e-01
   1.6379000e+01   9.8206148e-01   9.8980695e-01   9.8726903e-01   9.8698020e-01
   1.6419000e+01   9.8200170e-01   9.8940804e-01   9.8711142e-01   9.8651950e-01
   1.6460000e+01   9.8191430e-01   9.8900895e-01   9.8692677e-01   9.8606386e-01
   1.6500000e+01   9.8180176e-01   9.8860933e-01   9.8672227e-01   9.8560978e-01
