new technology in the human services

peer review form

Dear NTHS advisory network member,

The enclosed article has been submitted for publication in our journal. We would ask you to review this article and indicate on the attached evaluation form whether it is suitable for publication or needs revision.

We ask you to complete this task within two weeks of receipt, as we wish to minimise the time between submission and possible publication.

While reading this article, please make notes in the margins wherever appropriate. Also fill in the evaluation form. It would be helpful if you could fax us the enclosed form back, as well as mailing a copy with the article back to our address. As soon as we have all the reviewers comments we can contact the author and provide feedback. The author will not know the idenity of the reviewer(s). We will only forward the 'comments' section on the evaluation form directly to the author. The other information is support for the editor.

Evaluation form

  • Identification data
    • Title of this contribution :
    • Reviewer :
    • Date :
  • Your conclusion
    • Accept as is
    • Accept as is with minor editorial changes
    • Send back to author(s) for changes, no second blind review needed
    • Send back to author(s) for substantial changes, resubmit for blind review afterwards
    • Good article but not suitable for New Technology in the Human Services
      • reason :
      • please forward to this journal :
  • Your evaluation
    • Regarding contents :

    • Regarding relevance :

    • Regarding style :

    • Regarding language :

  • Your comments
    Please write us your comments, as briefly or lengthy as appropriate. These comments will be forwarded directly to the author(s), without identifying you as reviewer. Please give the author constructive advice on possible changes.


The journal has now ceased publication (2003)