A primary care web-based intervention modelling experiment replicated behaviour changes seen in earlier paper-based experiment
A primary care web-based intervention modelling experiment replicated behaviour changes seen in earlier paper-based experiment
Objectives: Intervention Modelling Experiment (IMEs) are a way of developing and testing behaviour change interventions prior to a trial. We aimed to test this methodology in a web-based IME that replicated the trial component of an earlier, paper-based IME.
Study design and setting: Three-arm, web-based randomised evaluation of two interventions (persuasive communication and action plan) and a ‘no intervention’ comparator. The interventions were designed to reduce the number of antibiotic prescriptions in the management of uncomplicated upper respiratory tract infection. General practitioners (GPs) were invited to complete an online questionnaire and eight clinical scenarios where an antibiotic might be considered.
Results: 129 GPs completed the questionnaire. GPs receiving the persuasive communication did not prescribe an antibiotic in 0.70 more scenarios (95% confidence interval = 0.17 to 1.24) than those in the control arm. For the action plan, GPs did not prescribe an antibiotic in 0.63 (95% CI = 0.11 to 1.15) more scenarios than those in the control arm. Unlike the earlier IME, behavioural intention was unaffected by the interventions; this may be due to a smaller sample size than intended.
Conclusions: A web-based IME largely replicated the findings of an earlier paper-based study, providing some grounds for confidence in the IME methodology.
1-26
Treweek, Shaun
2e309a54-c618-4a59-b0fd-2b878034cb98
Francis, Jill J.
d99967a1-f8f2-4785-8cb1-3570135cd8bf
Bonetti, Debbie
eede767b-0ba3-4e90-87ae-2180c7362422
Eccles, Martin P.
13c517f1-c4d5-4f21-bab7-61497732d306
Hudson, Jemma
3ca41223-889e-4d90-a89b-691bc2b296e0
Jones, Claire
92b1382f-9e0e-40b9-b56c-e7efeac9139a
Pitts, Nigel B.
f33b73ae-b7ff-4639-ad67-bd4f6179b15e
Ricketts, Ian W.
d23b08b5-8996-4119-a895-21dda4121e37
Sullivan, Frank
54fec8ce-02e9-4aab-b2e6-c32e668458cd
Weal, Mark
e8fd30a6-c060-41c5-b388-ca52c81032a4
MacLennan, Graeme
209593f8-0b7c-44fd-9abc-c1ea575b6c61
Treweek, Shaun
2e309a54-c618-4a59-b0fd-2b878034cb98
Francis, Jill J.
d99967a1-f8f2-4785-8cb1-3570135cd8bf
Bonetti, Debbie
eede767b-0ba3-4e90-87ae-2180c7362422
Eccles, Martin P.
13c517f1-c4d5-4f21-bab7-61497732d306
Hudson, Jemma
3ca41223-889e-4d90-a89b-691bc2b296e0
Jones, Claire
92b1382f-9e0e-40b9-b56c-e7efeac9139a
Pitts, Nigel B.
f33b73ae-b7ff-4639-ad67-bd4f6179b15e
Ricketts, Ian W.
d23b08b5-8996-4119-a895-21dda4121e37
Sullivan, Frank
54fec8ce-02e9-4aab-b2e6-c32e668458cd
Weal, Mark
e8fd30a6-c060-41c5-b388-ca52c81032a4
MacLennan, Graeme
209593f8-0b7c-44fd-9abc-c1ea575b6c61
Treweek, Shaun, Francis, Jill J., Bonetti, Debbie, Eccles, Martin P., Hudson, Jemma, Jones, Claire, Pitts, Nigel B., Ricketts, Ian W., Sullivan, Frank, Weal, Mark and MacLennan, Graeme
(2016)
A primary care web-based intervention modelling experiment replicated behaviour changes seen in earlier paper-based experiment.
Journal of Clinical Epidemiology, .
(doi:10.1016/j.jclinepi.2016.07.008).
Abstract
Objectives: Intervention Modelling Experiment (IMEs) are a way of developing and testing behaviour change interventions prior to a trial. We aimed to test this methodology in a web-based IME that replicated the trial component of an earlier, paper-based IME.
Study design and setting: Three-arm, web-based randomised evaluation of two interventions (persuasive communication and action plan) and a ‘no intervention’ comparator. The interventions were designed to reduce the number of antibiotic prescriptions in the management of uncomplicated upper respiratory tract infection. General practitioners (GPs) were invited to complete an online questionnaire and eight clinical scenarios where an antibiotic might be considered.
Results: 129 GPs completed the questionnaire. GPs receiving the persuasive communication did not prescribe an antibiotic in 0.70 more scenarios (95% confidence interval = 0.17 to 1.24) than those in the control arm. For the action plan, GPs did not prescribe an antibiotic in 0.63 (95% CI = 0.11 to 1.15) more scenarios than those in the control arm. Unlike the earlier IME, behavioural intention was unaffected by the interventions; this may be due to a smaller sample size than intended.
Conclusions: A web-based IME largely replicated the findings of an earlier paper-based study, providing some grounds for confidence in the IME methodology.
Text
1-s2.0-S0895435616302335-main.pdf
- Accepted Manuscript
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 18 July 2016
e-pub ahead of print date: 26 July 2016
Organisations:
Web & Internet Science
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 398803
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/398803
PURE UUID: dc6aae06-fa7a-4330-88c2-e7f156773cd8
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 03 Aug 2016 09:29
Last modified: 15 Mar 2024 05:46
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Shaun Treweek
Author:
Jill J. Francis
Author:
Debbie Bonetti
Author:
Martin P. Eccles
Author:
Jemma Hudson
Author:
Claire Jones
Author:
Nigel B. Pitts
Author:
Ian W. Ricketts
Author:
Frank Sullivan
Author:
Mark Weal
Author:
Graeme MacLennan
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics