Integrating social power and political influence into models of social–ecological systems
Integrating social power and political influence into models of social–ecological systems
Shaping policy for environmental sustainability depends upon decision-makers conceptualizing problems in ways that are either shared or similar enough to communicate about, diagnose, and act. The quality of this shared mental model of a social–ecological system (SES) is paramount to its effectiveness. Fundamentally, the mental model must integrate multiple kinds of knowledge about the system. If the decision-making body's assumptions about, description of, and solution for a problem do not to reflect the many ways stakeholders know a system, then the products of that decision-making process are viewed as illegitimate. Sustainability policy must fit the often subtle social order of the communities expected to implement it. In this essay, we discuss how a systems-based perspective can be a versatile tool for tackling these challenges of knowledge integration and decision-making in the context of a complex SES. Using social theory of Pierre Bourdieu, we construct a conceptual model that illustrates a route for integrating locally known social complexities (power, influence) gleaned from stakeholder interviews (N = 57). Stakeholders and end-user groups may dismiss any model that they perceive fails to satisfactorily account for specific, locally salient social nuances. Our approach leverages the overlapping notion of “capital” in social and ecological theory to demonstrate how reciprocal interactions between human and ecological systems can be adopted into tools for reaching viable solutions to SES problems
61-76
Hall, Damon M.
a3ad7394-37d7-4930-8d77-df8676631443
Swannack, Todd M.
d6f1a257-bfd7-40be-a147-a1a6ac64bda7
Lazarus, Eli
642a3cdb-0d25-48b1-8ab8-8d1d72daca6e
Peterson, Markus J.
3afcb5c3-9c5b-448f-b4af-4625d5c0a259
Gilbertz, Susan J.
e4f7bbcf-ae48-49d6-bce9-6bc572199c81
Horton, Cristi C.
61ab6310-fc89-453a-bc74-2a9ace800d58
Peterson, Tarla R.
78df1f55-9bec-4c94-88df-084cd99d52e9
2015
Hall, Damon M.
a3ad7394-37d7-4930-8d77-df8676631443
Swannack, Todd M.
d6f1a257-bfd7-40be-a147-a1a6ac64bda7
Lazarus, Eli
642a3cdb-0d25-48b1-8ab8-8d1d72daca6e
Peterson, Markus J.
3afcb5c3-9c5b-448f-b4af-4625d5c0a259
Gilbertz, Susan J.
e4f7bbcf-ae48-49d6-bce9-6bc572199c81
Horton, Cristi C.
61ab6310-fc89-453a-bc74-2a9ace800d58
Peterson, Tarla R.
78df1f55-9bec-4c94-88df-084cd99d52e9
Hall, Damon M., Swannack, Todd M., Lazarus, Eli, Peterson, Markus J., Gilbertz, Susan J., Horton, Cristi C. and Peterson, Tarla R.
(2015)
Integrating social power and political influence into models of social–ecological systems.
European Journal of Sustainable Development, 4 (2), .
(doi:10.14207/ejsd.2015.v4n2p61).
Abstract
Shaping policy for environmental sustainability depends upon decision-makers conceptualizing problems in ways that are either shared or similar enough to communicate about, diagnose, and act. The quality of this shared mental model of a social–ecological system (SES) is paramount to its effectiveness. Fundamentally, the mental model must integrate multiple kinds of knowledge about the system. If the decision-making body's assumptions about, description of, and solution for a problem do not to reflect the many ways stakeholders know a system, then the products of that decision-making process are viewed as illegitimate. Sustainability policy must fit the often subtle social order of the communities expected to implement it. In this essay, we discuss how a systems-based perspective can be a versatile tool for tackling these challenges of knowledge integration and decision-making in the context of a complex SES. Using social theory of Pierre Bourdieu, we construct a conceptual model that illustrates a route for integrating locally known social complexities (power, influence) gleaned from stakeholder interviews (N = 57). Stakeholders and end-user groups may dismiss any model that they perceive fails to satisfactorily account for specific, locally salient social nuances. Our approach leverages the overlapping notion of “capital” in social and ecological theory to demonstrate how reciprocal interactions between human and ecological systems can be adopted into tools for reaching viable solutions to SES problems
Text
88b124dcd6ca5a6632bae179ae2ae9e7(1).pdf
- Version of Record
Available under License Other.
More information
Published date: 2015
Organisations:
Earth Surface Dynamics
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 400715
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/400715
ISSN: 2239-5938
PURE UUID: 0ae8afb0-42e5-48f9-b1e2-583d669e36b0
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 23 Sep 2016 14:08
Last modified: 15 Mar 2024 03:57
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Damon M. Hall
Author:
Todd M. Swannack
Author:
Markus J. Peterson
Author:
Susan J. Gilbertz
Author:
Cristi C. Horton
Author:
Tarla R. Peterson
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics