Identifying gaps in HIV service delivery across the diagnosis-to-treatment cascade: findings from health facility surveys in six sub-Saharan countries
Identifying gaps in HIV service delivery across the diagnosis-to-treatment cascade: findings from health facility surveys in six sub-Saharan countries
Abstract
Introduction: Despite the rollout of antiretroviral therapy (ART), challenges remain in ensuring timely access to care and
treatment for people living with HIV. As part of a multi-country study to investigate HIV mortality, we conducted health
facility surveys within 10 health and demographic surveillance system sites across six countries in Eastern and Southern
Africa to investigate clinic-level factors influencing (i) use of HIV testing services, (ii) use of HIV care and treatment and (iii)
patient retention on ART.
Methods: Health facilities (n = 156) were sampled within 10 surveillance sites: Nairobi and Kisumu (Kenya), Karonga
(Malawi), Agincourt and uMkhanyakude (South Africa), Ifakara and Kisesa (Tanzania), Kyamulibwa and Rakai (Uganda)
and Manicaland (Zimbabwe). Structured questionnaires were administered to in-charge staff members of HIV testing,
prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) and ART units within the facilities. Forty-one indicators influencing uptake and patient retention along the continuum of HIV care were compared across sites using descriptive
statistics.
Results: The number of facilities surveyed ranged from six in Malawi to 36 in Zimbabwe. Eighty percent were governmentrun; 73% were lower-level facilities and 17% were district/referral hospitals. Client load varied widely, from less than one up
to 65 HIV testing clients per provider per week. Most facilities (>80%) delivered services or interventions that would support
patient retention in care such as delivering free services, offering PMTCT within antenatal care, pre-ART monitoring and
adherence counselling. Many facilities under-delivered in several areas, however, such as targeted testing for high-risk groups
(21%) and mobile testing (36%). There were also intra-site and inter-site differences, including in the delivery of Option B+
(ranging from 6% in Kisumu to 93% in Kyamulibwa), and nurse-led ART initiation (ranging from 50% in Kisesa to 100% in
Karonga and Agincourt). Only facilities in Malawi did not require additional lab tests for ART initiation. Stock-outs of HIV test
kits and antiretroviral drugs were particularly common in Tanzania.
Conclusions: We identified a high standard of health facility performance in delivering strategies that may support
progression through the continuum of HIV care. HIV testing policy and practice was particularly weak. Inter- and intracountry differences in quality and coverage represent opportunities to improve the delivery of comprehensive services to
people living with HIV
HIV and AIDS, PMTCT
Church, Kathryn
3a60dc6b-c6ca-4c46-95b5-bea9c8a617c0
Machiyama, Kazuyo
3c895bc2-7e39-462c-b669-22253ba64f07
Todd, Jim
94c1eee9-4700-4c22-957c-118622f2cdcd
Njamwea, Brian
56ca21c4-0d9c-4d85-b6ac-95ddbcceafed
Mwangome, Mary
caaa57ea-25e7-4d23-934c-29d32c12a678
Hosegood, Victoria
c59a89d5-5edc-42dd-b282-f44458fd2993
Michel, Janet
ff275124-37f3-4d66-82df-9d4066f6e3bf
Oti, Samuel
52b48d5c-8ffd-4085-aa72-5ef4d3aa1262
Nyamukapa, Constance
3222cb49-f056-436c-b817-4db0f3932714
Crampin, Amelia
f94a8026-dc3e-4fd4-a363-e7ecc7c41bef
Nyaguara, Amek
c35d290b-2e1f-468c-86c0-5570e73299ed
Nakigozi, Gertrude
2884ef2a-e936-476e-b082-1553c6b7e84b
Michael, Denna
549d5e34-bf84-4365-8b2b-e2caacafceb6
Gómez-Olivé, Xavier
4257ffb0-e815-412f-9ffe-f4dac46316e2
Nakiyingi-Miiro, Jessica
5ef7e0ee-120d-411e-a350-4ed960508fd1
Zaba, Basia
e5d3b7e2-e51a-4b2d-a6cd-c90d152623f0
Wringe, Alison
616301a6-4d77-4067-acd9-4eecfc6e47ac
12 January 2017
Church, Kathryn
3a60dc6b-c6ca-4c46-95b5-bea9c8a617c0
Machiyama, Kazuyo
3c895bc2-7e39-462c-b669-22253ba64f07
Todd, Jim
94c1eee9-4700-4c22-957c-118622f2cdcd
Njamwea, Brian
56ca21c4-0d9c-4d85-b6ac-95ddbcceafed
Mwangome, Mary
caaa57ea-25e7-4d23-934c-29d32c12a678
Hosegood, Victoria
c59a89d5-5edc-42dd-b282-f44458fd2993
Michel, Janet
ff275124-37f3-4d66-82df-9d4066f6e3bf
Oti, Samuel
52b48d5c-8ffd-4085-aa72-5ef4d3aa1262
Nyamukapa, Constance
3222cb49-f056-436c-b817-4db0f3932714
Crampin, Amelia
f94a8026-dc3e-4fd4-a363-e7ecc7c41bef
Nyaguara, Amek
c35d290b-2e1f-468c-86c0-5570e73299ed
Nakigozi, Gertrude
2884ef2a-e936-476e-b082-1553c6b7e84b
Michael, Denna
549d5e34-bf84-4365-8b2b-e2caacafceb6
Gómez-Olivé, Xavier
4257ffb0-e815-412f-9ffe-f4dac46316e2
Nakiyingi-Miiro, Jessica
5ef7e0ee-120d-411e-a350-4ed960508fd1
Zaba, Basia
e5d3b7e2-e51a-4b2d-a6cd-c90d152623f0
Wringe, Alison
616301a6-4d77-4067-acd9-4eecfc6e47ac
Church, Kathryn, Machiyama, Kazuyo, Todd, Jim, Njamwea, Brian, Mwangome, Mary, Hosegood, Victoria, Michel, Janet, Oti, Samuel, Nyamukapa, Constance, Crampin, Amelia, Nyaguara, Amek, Nakigozi, Gertrude, Michael, Denna, Gómez-Olivé, Xavier, Nakiyingi-Miiro, Jessica, Zaba, Basia and Wringe, Alison
(2017)
Identifying gaps in HIV service delivery across the diagnosis-to-treatment cascade: findings from health facility surveys in six sub-Saharan countries.
Journal of the International AIDS Society, 20 (21188).
(doi:10.7448/IAS.20.1.21188).
Abstract
Abstract
Introduction: Despite the rollout of antiretroviral therapy (ART), challenges remain in ensuring timely access to care and
treatment for people living with HIV. As part of a multi-country study to investigate HIV mortality, we conducted health
facility surveys within 10 health and demographic surveillance system sites across six countries in Eastern and Southern
Africa to investigate clinic-level factors influencing (i) use of HIV testing services, (ii) use of HIV care and treatment and (iii)
patient retention on ART.
Methods: Health facilities (n = 156) were sampled within 10 surveillance sites: Nairobi and Kisumu (Kenya), Karonga
(Malawi), Agincourt and uMkhanyakude (South Africa), Ifakara and Kisesa (Tanzania), Kyamulibwa and Rakai (Uganda)
and Manicaland (Zimbabwe). Structured questionnaires were administered to in-charge staff members of HIV testing,
prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) and ART units within the facilities. Forty-one indicators influencing uptake and patient retention along the continuum of HIV care were compared across sites using descriptive
statistics.
Results: The number of facilities surveyed ranged from six in Malawi to 36 in Zimbabwe. Eighty percent were governmentrun; 73% were lower-level facilities and 17% were district/referral hospitals. Client load varied widely, from less than one up
to 65 HIV testing clients per provider per week. Most facilities (>80%) delivered services or interventions that would support
patient retention in care such as delivering free services, offering PMTCT within antenatal care, pre-ART monitoring and
adherence counselling. Many facilities under-delivered in several areas, however, such as targeted testing for high-risk groups
(21%) and mobile testing (36%). There were also intra-site and inter-site differences, including in the delivery of Option B+
(ranging from 6% in Kisumu to 93% in Kyamulibwa), and nurse-led ART initiation (ranging from 50% in Kisesa to 100% in
Karonga and Agincourt). Only facilities in Malawi did not require additional lab tests for ART initiation. Stock-outs of HIV test
kits and antiretroviral drugs were particularly common in Tanzania.
Conclusions: We identified a high standard of health facility performance in delivering strategies that may support
progression through the continuum of HIV care. HIV testing policy and practice was particularly weak. Inter- and intracountry differences in quality and coverage represent opportunities to improve the delivery of comprehensive services to
people living with HIV
Text
21188-27678-2-PB
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 15 December 2016
e-pub ahead of print date: 1 January 2017
Published date: 12 January 2017
Additional Information:
This study was made possible with support from the Wellcome Trust [085477/
Z/08/Z], and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation [BMGF-OPP1082114].
Salaries of some individual authors are sponsored by institutional and project
grants from: the Wellcome Trust, the Medical Research Council (MRC, UK), the
Economic and Social Research Council (UK) and the National Institutes of
Health (USA). AW is funded by a Population Health Scientist award, jointly
funded by the MRC (UK) and the Department for International Development
(DFID, UK) under the MRC/DFID Concordat agreement and is also part of the
EDCTP2 program supported by the European Council.
Keywords:
HIV and AIDS, PMTCT
Organisations:
Social Statistics & Demography
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 407365
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/407365
ISSN: 1758-2652
PURE UUID: 91f77735-e191-4ad1-b295-5e7a8abc1540
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 04 Apr 2017 01:07
Last modified: 16 Mar 2024 04:06
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Kathryn Church
Author:
Kazuyo Machiyama
Author:
Jim Todd
Author:
Brian Njamwea
Author:
Mary Mwangome
Author:
Janet Michel
Author:
Samuel Oti
Author:
Constance Nyamukapa
Author:
Amelia Crampin
Author:
Amek Nyaguara
Author:
Gertrude Nakigozi
Author:
Denna Michael
Author:
Xavier Gómez-Olivé
Author:
Jessica Nakiyingi-Miiro
Author:
Basia Zaba
Author:
Alison Wringe
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics