The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Trial outcomes in child death cases: influenced by mothering myths?

Trial outcomes in child death cases: influenced by mothering myths?
Trial outcomes in child death cases: influenced by mothering myths?
This thesis draws on the insights of rape myth scholarship and also critical responses to battered women who kill to argue that trial outcomes in child death cases may have been influenced by mothering myths. It argues that in order to understand the reasons for wrongful convictions in such cases, we must look beyond the issue of flawed expert evidence, namely to possibly stereotypical interpretations of maternal behaviours around the time the children died. Notwithstanding the difficulties in reading across from rape trials to child death cases, and that both rape myth acceptance research and the carceral approach have been challenged, Gerger et al’s definition of a rape myth is adapted here to theorise a mothering myth.
Child death cases are interrogated to identify evidence admitted of maternal behaviours, and using the theorisation of a mothering myth, this thesis suggests that if fixed beliefs were used to interpret maternal behaviours, biased inferences may have been made. Little evidence of the probative value of such material has been identified. This thesis therefore examines why evidence of maternal behaviour was admitted and whether mothering myths may have informed aspects of child death cases including admissibility, the absence of judicial directions and jury deliberations.
Options to limit the extent to which juries in future child death cases can rely on mothering myths are considered, and proposals for new judicial directions are made. A roadmap of empirical research is proposed to test the suggested analogies between rape myths and mothering myths, drawing on the methodological insights of rape myth work.
University of Southampton
Orr, N.G.F.
07fb8d11-6449-4d50-9505-ac9fd9c4694b
Orr, N.G.F.
07fb8d11-6449-4d50-9505-ac9fd9c4694b
Gurnham, David
f63e1a54-5924-4fd0-a3f5-521311cee101

Orr, N.G.F. (2016) Trial outcomes in child death cases: influenced by mothering myths? University of Southampton, Doctoral Thesis, 412pp.

Record type: Thesis (Doctoral)

Abstract

This thesis draws on the insights of rape myth scholarship and also critical responses to battered women who kill to argue that trial outcomes in child death cases may have been influenced by mothering myths. It argues that in order to understand the reasons for wrongful convictions in such cases, we must look beyond the issue of flawed expert evidence, namely to possibly stereotypical interpretations of maternal behaviours around the time the children died. Notwithstanding the difficulties in reading across from rape trials to child death cases, and that both rape myth acceptance research and the carceral approach have been challenged, Gerger et al’s definition of a rape myth is adapted here to theorise a mothering myth.
Child death cases are interrogated to identify evidence admitted of maternal behaviours, and using the theorisation of a mothering myth, this thesis suggests that if fixed beliefs were used to interpret maternal behaviours, biased inferences may have been made. Little evidence of the probative value of such material has been identified. This thesis therefore examines why evidence of maternal behaviour was admitted and whether mothering myths may have informed aspects of child death cases including admissibility, the absence of judicial directions and jury deliberations.
Options to limit the extent to which juries in future child death cases can rely on mothering myths are considered, and proposals for new judicial directions are made. A roadmap of empirical research is proposed to test the suggested analogies between rape myths and mothering myths, drawing on the methodological insights of rape myth work.

Text
Final thesis - Version of Record
Available under License University of Southampton Thesis Licence.
Download (6MB)

More information

Published date: 6 November 2016

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 413557
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/413557
PURE UUID: f777ecb6-039a-4d88-a38e-a302a7794aff
ORCID for David Gurnham: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-6807-7587

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 25 Aug 2017 16:31
Last modified: 25 Jul 2019 00:31

Export record

Contributors

Author: N.G.F. Orr
Thesis advisor: David Gurnham ORCID iD

University divisions

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×