Global patient outcomes after elective surgery: Prospective cohort study in 27 low-, middle- and high-income countries
Global patient outcomes after elective surgery: Prospective cohort study in 27 low-, middle- and high-income countries
Background: As global initiatives increase patient access to surgical treatments, there remains a need to understand the adverse effects of surgery and define appropriate levels of perioperative care. Methods: We designed a prospective international 7-day cohort study of outcomes following elective adult inpatient surgery in 27 countries. The primary outcome was in-hospital complications. Secondary outcomes were death following a complication (failure to rescue) and death in hospital. Process measures were admission to critical care immediately after surgery or to treat a complication and duration of hospital stay. A single definition of critical care was used for all countries. Results: A total of 474 hospitals in 19 high-, 7 middle- and 1 low-income country were included in the primary analysis. Data included 44 814 patients with a median hospital stay of 4 (range 2-7) days. A total of 7508 patients (16.8%) developed one or more postoperative complication and 207 died (0.5%). The overall mortality among patients who developed complications was 2.8%. Mortality following complications ranged from 2.4% for pulmonary embolism to 43.9% for cardiac arrest. A total of 4360 (9.7%) patients were admitted to a critical care unit as routine immediately after surgery, of whom 2198 (50.4%) developed a complication, with 105 (2.4%) deaths. A total of 1233 patients (16.4%) were admitted to a critical care unit to treat complications, with 119 (9.7%) deaths. Despite lower baseline risk, outcomes were similar in low- and middle-income compared with high-income countries. Conclusions: Poor patient outcomes are common after inpatient surgery. Global initiatives to increase access to surgical treatments should also address the need for safe perioperative care.
cohort studies, critical care/utilisation, operative/mortality, postoperative care/methods, postoperative care/statistics and numerical data, surgery, surgical procedures
601-609
Grocott, Mike
1e87b741-513e-4a22-be13-0f7bb344e8c2
Bennett, Michael
6df5585a-3d93-4870-8797-389759fc82c7
Jones, Philip
8a1b8758-5424-467f-8e13-aaa45d2853c6
Hall, Richard
ee5acd7c-129a-40b1-bb44-0f36029be306
Yang, Jian
a95e75db-6340-4085-af35-54e655b46b6f
Yang, Yang
d1e03c97-703a-4139-bb00-6db4be624188
He, Miao
48da7088-e533-48d1-86a1-430972a21b31
Zhang, Yan
8552a39d-0c4d-4712-8ad8-d0d5cc9d1779
Wang, Jun
dac45864-634f-41ec-ba2a-1e59ad23ae97
Lin, Hong
1c7e2576-2249-4c3c-98ab-b0a3436780cf
Liu, Yang
2ae56585-1501-463d-b2a1-7d7745ccd1b7
Zhang, Min
b05c2fb3-97e7-49a1-9a42-ca8a7c0cc4f0
Zhang, Yuan
216a85be-a3a9-461b-a5c8-6b919a675eba
Zhang, Weiwei
9b25a74b-3fb0-4237-9e08-b92dd8dc4411
Li, Xiaoqin
9fcafa44-5c41-4f40-99ae-6c832dd947bd
Wang, Dong
e32fb954-4df7-42eb-b72f-7285c77d069b
Chen, Hong
408a190d-f7b1-4668-a856-9a2afbcd95c3
Li, Hui
f2946764-1b60-4abf-b466-0f5225978a4b
Liu, Mei
e0020db0-fb1b-43f8-986e-3c8a95fc6435
Xu, Lin
59225595-a82e-4fcf-96fb-3f17226cbe14
Zhang, Hongyan
c4c6ac3a-194a-4c01-88b1-a3edeee78535
Zhang, Jie
21de2303-4727-4097-9b0f-ae43d95d052a
Chen, Chen
9486d28c-9591-4606-a751-b8fc8e258dcd
Li, Bo
30acbe59-a3fe-47a8-9e6a-2dd279f38a7a
Xiao, Wei
a0094364-e728-4b1e-acca-f9b92b9e7de0
Wang, Jin
2be33751-49bb-4355-aa52-221c1bcd4e54
Liu, Yi
4dd4cf66-7dfd-470e-8f31-fa6ed3b020ca
Bell, Rachel
c4a7e11e-cbb0-4859-82a3-b472c038e004
Armstrong, John
ba42eda3-6147-4486-bab4-026d9dc68d83
Roberts, Stephen John
bef54d77-70ea-4332-bb73-dffc4e9ecdea
Johnson, Robert
0356783d-2fea-4be0-945f-0c032428a411
Anderson, Frank
a0b4d3f7-f9e6-4f1f-8cbb-a3a60f152f72
Skinner, David L.
4cdf8bfb-616f-444f-80e8-97498c8df3b0
Thomas, Megan
a7730210-b14e-474f-98b0-a470925a7723
Williams, Sarah
f98f47db-b1d6-42c2-b0eb-7c0cb9a981d0
Kaura, Vikas
6a0bc58e-50d0-4a29-8a2c-3823c603bcd2
Smith, Neil
f0691f2b-a454-4345-8f37-157b4dc1df11
Adams, David
32594754-135b-4af5-bb6b-90e419fff9aa
Jones, Stephanie
32640e91-b78a-4429-976f-a9c7137dcb50
Martin, Matthew
85d62a4b-8bab-44ab-9d7a-810acaa60f89
Self, James
8484e242-4243-4119-9ae1-d880384e2480
Smith, Christopher
969cad82-7677-470b-8997-c9a8c3cb0e13
Bennett, Victoria
24a1b7b7-3221-439e-b1fa-39cfb2026cd8
Brown, Richard
906b3b6e-a64a-4fab-8dae-6f5459bc3770
Kumar, Pawan
63c79684-5e70-4733-926f-4bb516dfad1e
Gill, James
50622028-9fb3-417b-947b-278cf31d7635
Smith, Emma Jane
06458659-8b7b-4f40-bfc2-24112f4fd49d
Brown, Andrew
d41c2ba9-6a1e-44f6-a892-d69895cc4fb8
Hall, Kathryn
34f6e4b1-ae84-4594-95fc-31f984eacd7c
Foster, Rebecca
928914f2-32cc-495d-82d3-304dc3ee4fb9
Milne, David
f5a008bb-e067-42ec-ab84-c3db41d5962e
Tbaily, Lee
91a8d748-42c2-4917-916e-1487000d3b7b
Phillips, Stephen
88c3a2a7-6152-43c5-a1c0-36824a610aef
Richardson, James
1a60ee7a-a4b1-4eda-bdcf-7612bca4d4a8
White, Steve
d16c2425-49aa-4503-ab56-e804d84df09f
Pearson, Sally Anne
4d7d7449-51af-43a5-b5d1-d8f32950fdcc
Hall, Andrew Macalister
047e5808-849f-45f4-b0b8-a7a85ce74968
Walker, Robert
b96ea24c-8845-4b1d-ae80-72996dbef974
Anderson, Charlotte
1e752f42-31b8-4bcd-b255-fea3c8b49859
Smith, Andrew
28d2a985-1801-4e42-9a43-8061526d8e48
Owen, Thomas
5163420c-6106-4552-b1b0-9b5b9f9f3534
Jones, Eleanor
f3cfee5f-545c-4e78-bc89-8a8b0339fcd4
Lewis, Megan
12a7fe28-6956-4281-a23d-85522f894558
Collins, Hannah
40622714-ec7e-47cb-86fc-dc1aefcc6f88
Edwards, Mark
818201d5-7636-4292-9af8-7dd8bcd1fcb5
Levett, Denny
1743763a-2853-4baf-affe-6152fde8d05f
Payne, Hannah
8f45a90f-4bc2-4dd2-a6bc-4f7a6a5b4953
Smith, Thomas
a1500cc7-f4dd-4c82-8d57-95d0889cf7b3
Stevens, Alice
c94bc67f-aaa9-45bd-a0b5-8e91fb2a881c
The International Surgical Outcomes Study group
1 November 2016
Grocott, Mike
1e87b741-513e-4a22-be13-0f7bb344e8c2
Bennett, Michael
6df5585a-3d93-4870-8797-389759fc82c7
Jones, Philip
8a1b8758-5424-467f-8e13-aaa45d2853c6
Hall, Richard
ee5acd7c-129a-40b1-bb44-0f36029be306
Yang, Jian
a95e75db-6340-4085-af35-54e655b46b6f
Yang, Yang
d1e03c97-703a-4139-bb00-6db4be624188
He, Miao
48da7088-e533-48d1-86a1-430972a21b31
Zhang, Yan
8552a39d-0c4d-4712-8ad8-d0d5cc9d1779
Wang, Jun
dac45864-634f-41ec-ba2a-1e59ad23ae97
Lin, Hong
1c7e2576-2249-4c3c-98ab-b0a3436780cf
Liu, Yang
2ae56585-1501-463d-b2a1-7d7745ccd1b7
Zhang, Min
b05c2fb3-97e7-49a1-9a42-ca8a7c0cc4f0
Zhang, Yuan
216a85be-a3a9-461b-a5c8-6b919a675eba
Zhang, Weiwei
9b25a74b-3fb0-4237-9e08-b92dd8dc4411
Li, Xiaoqin
9fcafa44-5c41-4f40-99ae-6c832dd947bd
Wang, Dong
e32fb954-4df7-42eb-b72f-7285c77d069b
Chen, Hong
408a190d-f7b1-4668-a856-9a2afbcd95c3
Li, Hui
f2946764-1b60-4abf-b466-0f5225978a4b
Liu, Mei
e0020db0-fb1b-43f8-986e-3c8a95fc6435
Xu, Lin
59225595-a82e-4fcf-96fb-3f17226cbe14
Zhang, Hongyan
c4c6ac3a-194a-4c01-88b1-a3edeee78535
Zhang, Jie
21de2303-4727-4097-9b0f-ae43d95d052a
Chen, Chen
9486d28c-9591-4606-a751-b8fc8e258dcd
Li, Bo
30acbe59-a3fe-47a8-9e6a-2dd279f38a7a
Xiao, Wei
a0094364-e728-4b1e-acca-f9b92b9e7de0
Wang, Jin
2be33751-49bb-4355-aa52-221c1bcd4e54
Liu, Yi
4dd4cf66-7dfd-470e-8f31-fa6ed3b020ca
Bell, Rachel
c4a7e11e-cbb0-4859-82a3-b472c038e004
Armstrong, John
ba42eda3-6147-4486-bab4-026d9dc68d83
Roberts, Stephen John
bef54d77-70ea-4332-bb73-dffc4e9ecdea
Johnson, Robert
0356783d-2fea-4be0-945f-0c032428a411
Anderson, Frank
a0b4d3f7-f9e6-4f1f-8cbb-a3a60f152f72
Skinner, David L.
4cdf8bfb-616f-444f-80e8-97498c8df3b0
Thomas, Megan
a7730210-b14e-474f-98b0-a470925a7723
Williams, Sarah
f98f47db-b1d6-42c2-b0eb-7c0cb9a981d0
Kaura, Vikas
6a0bc58e-50d0-4a29-8a2c-3823c603bcd2
Smith, Neil
f0691f2b-a454-4345-8f37-157b4dc1df11
Adams, David
32594754-135b-4af5-bb6b-90e419fff9aa
Jones, Stephanie
32640e91-b78a-4429-976f-a9c7137dcb50
Martin, Matthew
85d62a4b-8bab-44ab-9d7a-810acaa60f89
Self, James
8484e242-4243-4119-9ae1-d880384e2480
Smith, Christopher
969cad82-7677-470b-8997-c9a8c3cb0e13
Bennett, Victoria
24a1b7b7-3221-439e-b1fa-39cfb2026cd8
Brown, Richard
906b3b6e-a64a-4fab-8dae-6f5459bc3770
Kumar, Pawan
63c79684-5e70-4733-926f-4bb516dfad1e
Gill, James
50622028-9fb3-417b-947b-278cf31d7635
Smith, Emma Jane
06458659-8b7b-4f40-bfc2-24112f4fd49d
Brown, Andrew
d41c2ba9-6a1e-44f6-a892-d69895cc4fb8
Hall, Kathryn
34f6e4b1-ae84-4594-95fc-31f984eacd7c
Foster, Rebecca
928914f2-32cc-495d-82d3-304dc3ee4fb9
Milne, David
f5a008bb-e067-42ec-ab84-c3db41d5962e
Tbaily, Lee
91a8d748-42c2-4917-916e-1487000d3b7b
Phillips, Stephen
88c3a2a7-6152-43c5-a1c0-36824a610aef
Richardson, James
1a60ee7a-a4b1-4eda-bdcf-7612bca4d4a8
White, Steve
d16c2425-49aa-4503-ab56-e804d84df09f
Pearson, Sally Anne
4d7d7449-51af-43a5-b5d1-d8f32950fdcc
Hall, Andrew Macalister
047e5808-849f-45f4-b0b8-a7a85ce74968
Walker, Robert
b96ea24c-8845-4b1d-ae80-72996dbef974
Anderson, Charlotte
1e752f42-31b8-4bcd-b255-fea3c8b49859
Smith, Andrew
28d2a985-1801-4e42-9a43-8061526d8e48
Owen, Thomas
5163420c-6106-4552-b1b0-9b5b9f9f3534
Jones, Eleanor
f3cfee5f-545c-4e78-bc89-8a8b0339fcd4
Lewis, Megan
12a7fe28-6956-4281-a23d-85522f894558
Collins, Hannah
40622714-ec7e-47cb-86fc-dc1aefcc6f88
Edwards, Mark
818201d5-7636-4292-9af8-7dd8bcd1fcb5
Levett, Denny
1743763a-2853-4baf-affe-6152fde8d05f
Payne, Hannah
8f45a90f-4bc2-4dd2-a6bc-4f7a6a5b4953
Smith, Thomas
a1500cc7-f4dd-4c82-8d57-95d0889cf7b3
Stevens, Alice
c94bc67f-aaa9-45bd-a0b5-8e91fb2a881c