The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Opening the woods: towards a quantification of Neolithic clearance around the Somerset levels and moors

Opening the woods: towards a quantification of Neolithic clearance around the Somerset levels and moors
Opening the woods: towards a quantification of Neolithic clearance around the Somerset levels and moors
Environmental reconstructions from pollen records collected within archaeological landscapes have traditionally taken a broadly narrative approach, with few attempts made at hypothesis testing or formal assessment of uncertainty. This disjuncture between the traditional interpretive approach to palynological data and the requirement for detailed, locally specific reconstructions of the landscapes in which people lived has arguably hindered closer integration of palaeoecological and archaeological datasets in recent decades. Here we implement a fundamentally different method for reconstructing past land cover from pollen records to the landscapes of and around the Somerset Levels and Moors—the Multiple Scenario Approach (MSA)—to reconstruct land cover for a series of 200-year timeslices covering the period 4200–2000 cal BC. Modelling of both archaeological and sediment chronologies enables the integration of reconstructed changes in land cover with archaeological evidence of contemporary Neolithic human activity. The MSA reconstructions are presented as a series of land cover maps and as graphs of quantitative measures of woodland clearance tracked over time. Our reconstructions provide a more nuanced understanding of the scale and timing of Neolithic clearance than has previously been available from narrative-based interpretations of pollen data. While the archaeological record tends to promote a view of long-term continuity in terms of the persistent building of wooden structures in the wetlands, our new interpretation of the palynological data contributes a more dynamic and varying narrative. Our case study demonstrates the potential for further integration of archaeological and palynological datasets, enabling us to get closer to the landscapes in which people lived.
Somerset Levels and Moors, Multiple ScenarioApproach, Chronological modelling, Palynology, Neolithic, Land cover, Clearance
1072-5369
1-31
Farrell, Michelle
fcca1e17-e75c-4c83-8233-eb9c7c84dc71
Bunting, M. Jane
23938df2-823f-4ce2-8429-c479e15ec268
Sturt, Fraser
442e14e1-136f-4159-bd8e-b002bf6b95f6
Grant, Michael
56dae074-d54a-4da8-858a-2bf364a5a550
Aalbersberg, Gerard
2aea080e-42df-4e8a-a50d-d37fd3c1bad0
Batchelor, Rob
cb97d84a-3111-4c4d-ab17-64bac5917594
Brown, Alex
4cfe8b16-d1c9-467c-9a31-c3adb2ec77cd
Druce, Denise
29285a1e-bd89-41d9-ace0-7cce8c2c92e1
Hill, Tom
4db0c57e-732d-4135-9c20-4b448a056d6e
Hollinrake, Arthur
ba81ef03-8e7e-409e-a86b-0484f88d7ae9
Jones, Julie
4df04d8e-9f50-4d64-9372-3810ef1aa560
Tinsley, Heather
6a5a0e94-8103-4165-aafc-4281d2bc94ab
Bayliss, Alex
a1e1fde7-2fdf-4b6a-b19c-bdb437a2c46f
Marshall, Peter
f4269a18-4d19-44f2-902e-bdc198572f3c
Richer, Suzi
75f5dc72-75d0-4a2c-92de-12062e8bb1f9
Whittle, Alasdair
9d619dad-c86c-4e40-b894-4d327ca378f5
Farrell, Michelle
fcca1e17-e75c-4c83-8233-eb9c7c84dc71
Bunting, M. Jane
23938df2-823f-4ce2-8429-c479e15ec268
Sturt, Fraser
442e14e1-136f-4159-bd8e-b002bf6b95f6
Grant, Michael
56dae074-d54a-4da8-858a-2bf364a5a550
Aalbersberg, Gerard
2aea080e-42df-4e8a-a50d-d37fd3c1bad0
Batchelor, Rob
cb97d84a-3111-4c4d-ab17-64bac5917594
Brown, Alex
4cfe8b16-d1c9-467c-9a31-c3adb2ec77cd
Druce, Denise
29285a1e-bd89-41d9-ace0-7cce8c2c92e1
Hill, Tom
4db0c57e-732d-4135-9c20-4b448a056d6e
Hollinrake, Arthur
ba81ef03-8e7e-409e-a86b-0484f88d7ae9
Jones, Julie
4df04d8e-9f50-4d64-9372-3810ef1aa560
Tinsley, Heather
6a5a0e94-8103-4165-aafc-4281d2bc94ab
Bayliss, Alex
a1e1fde7-2fdf-4b6a-b19c-bdb437a2c46f
Marshall, Peter
f4269a18-4d19-44f2-902e-bdc198572f3c
Richer, Suzi
75f5dc72-75d0-4a2c-92de-12062e8bb1f9
Whittle, Alasdair
9d619dad-c86c-4e40-b894-4d327ca378f5

Farrell, Michelle, Bunting, M. Jane, Sturt, Fraser, Grant, Michael, Aalbersberg, Gerard, Batchelor, Rob, Brown, Alex, Druce, Denise, Hill, Tom, Hollinrake, Arthur, Jones, Julie, Tinsley, Heather, Bayliss, Alex, Marshall, Peter, Richer, Suzi and Whittle, Alasdair (2019) Opening the woods: towards a quantification of Neolithic clearance around the Somerset levels and moors. Journal of Archaeological Method and Theory, 1-31. (doi:10.1007/s10816-019-09427-9).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Environmental reconstructions from pollen records collected within archaeological landscapes have traditionally taken a broadly narrative approach, with few attempts made at hypothesis testing or formal assessment of uncertainty. This disjuncture between the traditional interpretive approach to palynological data and the requirement for detailed, locally specific reconstructions of the landscapes in which people lived has arguably hindered closer integration of palaeoecological and archaeological datasets in recent decades. Here we implement a fundamentally different method for reconstructing past land cover from pollen records to the landscapes of and around the Somerset Levels and Moors—the Multiple Scenario Approach (MSA)—to reconstruct land cover for a series of 200-year timeslices covering the period 4200–2000 cal BC. Modelling of both archaeological and sediment chronologies enables the integration of reconstructed changes in land cover with archaeological evidence of contemporary Neolithic human activity. The MSA reconstructions are presented as a series of land cover maps and as graphs of quantitative measures of woodland clearance tracked over time. Our reconstructions provide a more nuanced understanding of the scale and timing of Neolithic clearance than has previously been available from narrative-based interpretations of pollen data. While the archaeological record tends to promote a view of long-term continuity in terms of the persistent building of wooden structures in the wetlands, our new interpretation of the palynological data contributes a more dynamic and varying narrative. Our case study demonstrates the potential for further integration of archaeological and palynological datasets, enabling us to get closer to the landscapes in which people lived.

Text
Farrell_et-al_2019 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (5MB)

More information

e-pub ahead of print date: 21 September 2019
Keywords: Somerset Levels and Moors, Multiple ScenarioApproach, Chronological modelling, Palynology, Neolithic, Land cover, Clearance

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 434450
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/434450
ISSN: 1072-5369
PURE UUID: 6e6d2c82-c59b-4edc-a59f-1c155262fcdb
ORCID for Michael Grant: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-4766-6913

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 24 Sep 2019 16:30
Last modified: 05 Nov 2019 01:36

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Michelle Farrell
Author: M. Jane Bunting
Author: Fraser Sturt
Author: Michael Grant ORCID iD
Author: Gerard Aalbersberg
Author: Rob Batchelor
Author: Alex Brown
Author: Denise Druce
Author: Tom Hill
Author: Arthur Hollinrake
Author: Julie Jones
Author: Heather Tinsley
Author: Alex Bayliss
Author: Peter Marshall
Author: Suzi Richer
Author: Alasdair Whittle

University divisions

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×