An integrated methodology to study site formation processes on submerged shipwrecks in the 21st c.
An integrated methodology to study site formation processes on submerged shipwrecks in the 21st c.
Submerged
shipwreck sites are dynamic open systems that require a multiple-approach
method to capture their complexity adequately. Conventional methods of
recording and monitoring these sites have resulted in mono-dimensional models
by focusing primarily on macro- or micro-scale studies. Fortunately, the
application of new technologies to record underwater cultural heritage (UCH)
has pushed the boundaries of maritime archaeology. Recent advances in remote
sensing techniques provide valuable tools for collecting data rapidly with a
high degree of accuracy and detail. However, while compelling digital outputs
can be generated (Demesticha, Skarlatos, and Neophytou 2014; Drap, Merad, et
al. 2015; Nayling and Jones 2014; PAS 2017; Pieraccini, Guidi, and Atzeni 2001;
Plets et al. 2009; Yamafune 2016), we have to consider their analytical
potential/ability to contribute by exploring their capabilities and limitations.
With the above in mind, this thesis addresses the lacuna in
the analysis of site formation processes (SFP) on shipwrecks, by presenting an
analytical understanding of data collection and presenting an integrated
methodology. Demonstrating a flexible approach adapting to a variety of
environments on Hazardous 1706, Rooswijk 1740, and Invincible 1758. Bracklesham
Bay (Hazardous), the Goodwin Sands (Rooswijk), and The Eastern Solent
(Invincible), offers a broad spectrum of highly dynamic environments in shallow
water. Rarely do archaeologists get the opportunity to carry out extensive
pre-disturbance surveys and excavations, and collect first-hand data
periodically, on the same wrecks. Over the years 2016-2018 a number of
international projects on Invincible (2013-2018) Rooswijk (2017-2018) and
Hazardous (2016-2018) made it possible to develop and carry out this research.
This opportunity was highly significant in bridging the gap between management
policies, and targeted research of site formation processes enhancing our
shipwreck interpretation of these historically significant vessels.
Shipwrecks are complex systems composed of material culture
regulated by anthropogenic and taphonomic processes. Geo-acoustic methods offer
accurate tools (<.2m) for macro-scale taphonomy (e.g. Stirling Castle 1703
(Astley 2016; Bates et al. 2011), or Fougeoux 1805 (Fernández-Montblanc et al.
2016)). However, they overlook the pressing need to attend to the intra-site
level analysis concerning the shipwrecks’ integral coherence, combined with
diver based in situ observations. The high-resolution time-series, acquired by
computational optical imaging and acoustic positioning, presented in this
thesis, provides that intra-site or micro-level analysis.
It is critical to use a multi-scalar approach of time and
space, as understanding changes on a shipwreck require moving between synchronic
and diachronic analysis. This is possible by integrating previous work on site,
as well as presenting the extant shipwrecks’ structure and artefact
distribution. The use of new technologies allows capturing three-dimensional
(3D) structures throughout time (4D), instead of traditional insufficient
two-dimensional (2D) recording methods. This opens a new realm of possibilities
for capturing quantitative and qualitative data, offering innovative display
methods with analytical tools. Efficiency is paramount to record and analyse
UCH, considering that in situ preservation is impossible, due its entropic
nature: it is a finite resource bound to disintegrate.
University of Southampton
Ortiz Vázquez, Rodrigo
a4cf83b8-780a-44cb-8229-267497276184
September 2018
Ortiz Vázquez, Rodrigo
a4cf83b8-780a-44cb-8229-267497276184
Adams, Jonathan
184a058c-d4b1-44fc-9bff-cadee3882bc8
Sturt, Fraser
442e14e1-136f-4159-bd8e-b002bf6b95f6
Ortiz Vázquez, Rodrigo
(2018)
An integrated methodology to study site formation processes on submerged shipwrecks in the 21st c.
University of Southampton, Doctoral Thesis, 702pp.
Record type:
Thesis
(Doctoral)
Abstract
Submerged
shipwreck sites are dynamic open systems that require a multiple-approach
method to capture their complexity adequately. Conventional methods of
recording and monitoring these sites have resulted in mono-dimensional models
by focusing primarily on macro- or micro-scale studies. Fortunately, the
application of new technologies to record underwater cultural heritage (UCH)
has pushed the boundaries of maritime archaeology. Recent advances in remote
sensing techniques provide valuable tools for collecting data rapidly with a
high degree of accuracy and detail. However, while compelling digital outputs
can be generated (Demesticha, Skarlatos, and Neophytou 2014; Drap, Merad, et
al. 2015; Nayling and Jones 2014; PAS 2017; Pieraccini, Guidi, and Atzeni 2001;
Plets et al. 2009; Yamafune 2016), we have to consider their analytical
potential/ability to contribute by exploring their capabilities and limitations.
With the above in mind, this thesis addresses the lacuna in
the analysis of site formation processes (SFP) on shipwrecks, by presenting an
analytical understanding of data collection and presenting an integrated
methodology. Demonstrating a flexible approach adapting to a variety of
environments on Hazardous 1706, Rooswijk 1740, and Invincible 1758. Bracklesham
Bay (Hazardous), the Goodwin Sands (Rooswijk), and The Eastern Solent
(Invincible), offers a broad spectrum of highly dynamic environments in shallow
water. Rarely do archaeologists get the opportunity to carry out extensive
pre-disturbance surveys and excavations, and collect first-hand data
periodically, on the same wrecks. Over the years 2016-2018 a number of
international projects on Invincible (2013-2018) Rooswijk (2017-2018) and
Hazardous (2016-2018) made it possible to develop and carry out this research.
This opportunity was highly significant in bridging the gap between management
policies, and targeted research of site formation processes enhancing our
shipwreck interpretation of these historically significant vessels.
Shipwrecks are complex systems composed of material culture
regulated by anthropogenic and taphonomic processes. Geo-acoustic methods offer
accurate tools (<.2m) for macro-scale taphonomy (e.g. Stirling Castle 1703
(Astley 2016; Bates et al. 2011), or Fougeoux 1805 (Fernández-Montblanc et al.
2016)). However, they overlook the pressing need to attend to the intra-site
level analysis concerning the shipwrecks’ integral coherence, combined with
diver based in situ observations. The high-resolution time-series, acquired by
computational optical imaging and acoustic positioning, presented in this
thesis, provides that intra-site or micro-level analysis.
It is critical to use a multi-scalar approach of time and
space, as understanding changes on a shipwreck require moving between synchronic
and diachronic analysis. This is possible by integrating previous work on site,
as well as presenting the extant shipwrecks’ structure and artefact
distribution. The use of new technologies allows capturing three-dimensional
(3D) structures throughout time (4D), instead of traditional insufficient
two-dimensional (2D) recording methods. This opens a new realm of possibilities
for capturing quantitative and qualitative data, offering innovative display
methods with analytical tools. Efficiency is paramount to record and analyse
UCH, considering that in situ preservation is impossible, due its entropic
nature: it is a finite resource bound to disintegrate.
Text
Rodrigo Ortiz Vazquez PhD 2019
- Version of Record
More information
Published date: September 2018
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 435554
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/435554
PURE UUID: 1556df14-cb0f-495e-9a53-dab9eefec070
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 11 Nov 2019 17:30
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 05:02
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Rodrigo Ortiz Vázquez
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics