The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Laparoscopically assisted versus open oesophagectomy for patients with oesophageal cancer--the Randomised Oesophagectomy: Minimally Invasive or Open (ROMIO) study: protocol for a randomised controlled trial (RCT)

Laparoscopically assisted versus open oesophagectomy for patients with oesophageal cancer--the Randomised Oesophagectomy: Minimally Invasive or Open (ROMIO) study: protocol for a randomised controlled trial (RCT)
Laparoscopically assisted versus open oesophagectomy for patients with oesophageal cancer--the Randomised Oesophagectomy: Minimally Invasive or Open (ROMIO) study: protocol for a randomised controlled trial (RCT)
Introduction: Surgery (oesophagectomy), with neoadjuvant chemo(radio)therapy, is the main curative treatment for patients with oesophageal cancer. Several surgical approaches can be used to remove an oesophageal tumour. The Ivor Lewis (two-phase procedure) is usually used in the UK. This can be performed as an open oesophagectomy (OO), a laparoscopically assisted oesophagectomy (LAO) or a totally minimally invasive oesophagectomy (TMIO). All three are performed in the National Health Service, with LAO and OO the most common. However, there is limited evidence about which surgical approach is best for patients in terms of survival and postoperative health-related quality of life.
Methods and analysis: We will undertake a UK multicentre randomised controlled trial to compare LAO with OO in adult patients with oesophageal cancer. The primary outcome is patient-reported physical function at 3 and 6 weeks postoperatively and 3 months after randomisation. Secondary outcomes include: postoperative complications, survival, disease recurrence, other measures of quality of life, spirometry, success of patient blinding and quality assurance measures. A cost-effectiveness analysis will be performed comparing LAO with OO. We will embed a randomised substudy to evaluate the safety and evolution of the TMIO procedure and a qualitative recruitment intervention to optimise patient recruitment. We will analyse the primary outcome using a multi-level regression model. Patients will be monitored for up to 3 years after their surgery.
Ethics and dissemination: This study received ethical approval from the South-West Franchay Research Ethics Committee. We will submit the results for publication in a peer-reviewed journal.
Trial registration number: ISRCTN10386621.
2044-6055
Brierley, Rachel C.
fea91a57-dd3c-47db-873d-3fb319f14c2b
Gaunt, Daisy
a92ea42c-2439-4ccc-b169-b5c821f3b644
Metcalf, Chris
ca0b4b2f-b633-4209-ac9d-f0485f6f4658
Blazeby, Jane M.
689d490e-fca3-4430-88de-f19ec6cebf58
Blencowe, Natalie M.
7e5cc777-c525-46e1-b6ad-db3cc85c5463
Jepson, Marcus
1fa4bfcb-1f4e-4195-8d3d-db06d44ad24b
Berrisford, Richard G.
9d854586-fd7d-43f5-8ace-148b7f9afa77
Avery, Kerry N.L.
24516239-1a12-4fee-a8e5-295dd3e6662f
Hollingworth, William
404d4c1e-3911-4e9f-8be1-1436b4b98713
Rice, Caoimhe T.
557c646e-4013-4b2f-86bb-30d59e39f744
Moure-Fernandez, Aide
cf852315-c6de-44a4-b6b1-c4137760458d
Wong, Newton
2558f304-0e13-4a62-adab-e8cc265c54c1
Nicklin, Joanna
8c876962-314e-4fe2-91b3-e2f1930ebd27
Skilton, Anni
7f95823b-5071-47fd-b91c-05fa450f47af
Boddy, Alex
06d2ca4e-5aa2-4a82-810b-9b202293ba7e
Byrne, James P.
e3d5b8fe-1b69-441c-a173-e084fe5372a6
Underwood, Timothy
8e81bf60-edd2-4b0e-8324-3068c95ea1c6
Vohra, Ravi
36460fd9-6d4c-4b6c-97d3-81ec2ddc8b00
Cotton, James A.
2a80a7b9-b59f-49ba-8101-c2746999c20c
Pursani, Kish
2c8c631c-ef36-4d12-9bf8-b283fc2df808
Melhado, Rachel
7c8d3e42-a462-43c4-ba78-d7d7f1feb32c
Alkhaffaf, Bilal
5616e7a6-bf39-4e4d-a729-31827c497cbd
Krysztopik, Richard
ae317341-b91e-4298-b3c2-dc710a95cba4
Lamb, Peter
31854dab-bcd7-40fd-a2ad-21e8a7068e26
Culliford, Lucy
6886cb46-ebe2-41de-8c56-76fba4337389
Rogers, Chris
f14f59d6-d9f1-4e6e-a238-b3b36dca1816
Howes, Benjamin
4ce089d7-2375-4e88-b223-b2e13cfef434
Chalmers, Katy
15ddfd19-a659-4ee4-91b7-d04137e2c40f
Cousins, Sian
241c9f44-998b-4486-a764-637c3b907928
Ellitt, Jackie
582483fd-f41a-4a65-8cdd-c76359fca240
Donovan, Jenny
9189eca7-3335-474c-b31f-b9ca6a872f4a
Hayes, Rachael
080f058a-777d-447c-97e2-46fb4f00eb12
Wickens, Robin A.
3fae8758-ef16-4dfa-aabb-bf7b145458f8
Wilkerson, Paul
5e992151-011c-4d1e-b209-f3c8df88ee1a
Hollowood, Andrew
49908560-83d7-4659-ad03-80701788e9ed
Streets, Christopher
028cc23b-3321-4044-b0c0-c4645cb01425
Titcomb, Dan
f651a3c8-af1f-45a2-b02b-6ee455916a91
Lee Humphreys, Martyn
846b8219-69ea-4786-99c5-090efcb24516
Wheatley, Tim
db3646cd-71d6-4f3f-9293-1b5bdddfd16c
Sanders, Grant
4aa74740-0ef4-4a2d-868a-a0e6340609cc
Ariyarathenam, Arun
bad3215c-b439-4f6c-a3b1-829168eabc84
Kelly, Jamie
cc93c77d-2902-4cc9-8e79-82f59396552c
Noble, Fergus
4f14574c-28f2-4e04-bd95-f53c7649e1fa
Couper, Graeme
e4c1c9f1-ff63-448a-a3c5-8c39b11bb6d6
Skipworth, Richard J.E.
a1826e3b-f9c3-4c0b-94b1-f981a3a83116
Deans, Chris
554435e3-5a76-4e04-ba81-ba1706d179d5
Ubhi, Sukhibir
16793f09-519a-4ccf-b9aa-3837457e39c0
Williams, Robert
13de0ba5-9a22-45f9-b04a-f16e5961378d
Bowrey, David
d0302ffb-1909-4898-9b7b-27f50dba7090
Exon, David
efbea3ac-f559-445a-87df-d3f93fee2979
Turner, Paul
7c0fbc62-458f-4122-9039-02cf06aa51e5
Daya Shetty, Vinutha
7d660492-9b07-447e-9c70-c522c2fa807d
Chaparala, Ram
bb28c78a-f161-4256-b506-5deda576d0fa
Akhtar, Khurshid
7250eabe-9a66-4326-86d0-d9b07251836c
Farooq, Naheed
f11c36ca-106c-46b7-992e-a04aa4d73d7b
Parsons, Simon L.
5e02c969-b698-4947-9c40-0557e35fbcfc
Welch, Neil T.
2651128c-ac44-4c56-a153-e892690a06b7
Houlihan, Rebecca J.
21d322e5-94c7-4483-8364-e311b167a2a3
Smith, Joanne
1067ae12-5a09-4506-9a0f-059f4182e52c
Schranz, Rachel
59587776-67b7-42b7-8a7e-f9f96ce34180
Rea, Nicola
e0549381-7b2c-48e6-adac-955635fd5f22
Cooke, Jill
ab9e0f48-1081-4341-a0d5-8a84aa2e4c26
Williams, Alexandra
922a0421-8ce1-4f86-92b7-b166f1322681
Hindmarsh, Carolyn
dfa852d3-f610-4292-9ad4-f6d08a68aa4d
Maitland, Sally
3d998177-2de3-4279-b5a0-32d684b166da
Howie, Lucy
d2f878ba-9504-4e36-a839-0e4b36a9fec5
Barham, Christopher Paul
4a82c99b-f4a1-4832-b559-1ad9985ba37b
Brierley, Rachel C.
fea91a57-dd3c-47db-873d-3fb319f14c2b
Gaunt, Daisy
a92ea42c-2439-4ccc-b169-b5c821f3b644
Metcalf, Chris
ca0b4b2f-b633-4209-ac9d-f0485f6f4658
Blazeby, Jane M.
689d490e-fca3-4430-88de-f19ec6cebf58
Blencowe, Natalie M.
7e5cc777-c525-46e1-b6ad-db3cc85c5463
Jepson, Marcus
1fa4bfcb-1f4e-4195-8d3d-db06d44ad24b
Berrisford, Richard G.
9d854586-fd7d-43f5-8ace-148b7f9afa77
Avery, Kerry N.L.
24516239-1a12-4fee-a8e5-295dd3e6662f
Hollingworth, William
404d4c1e-3911-4e9f-8be1-1436b4b98713
Rice, Caoimhe T.
557c646e-4013-4b2f-86bb-30d59e39f744
Moure-Fernandez, Aide
cf852315-c6de-44a4-b6b1-c4137760458d
Wong, Newton
2558f304-0e13-4a62-adab-e8cc265c54c1
Nicklin, Joanna
8c876962-314e-4fe2-91b3-e2f1930ebd27
Skilton, Anni
7f95823b-5071-47fd-b91c-05fa450f47af
Boddy, Alex
06d2ca4e-5aa2-4a82-810b-9b202293ba7e
Byrne, James P.
e3d5b8fe-1b69-441c-a173-e084fe5372a6
Underwood, Timothy
8e81bf60-edd2-4b0e-8324-3068c95ea1c6
Vohra, Ravi
36460fd9-6d4c-4b6c-97d3-81ec2ddc8b00
Cotton, James A.
2a80a7b9-b59f-49ba-8101-c2746999c20c
Pursani, Kish
2c8c631c-ef36-4d12-9bf8-b283fc2df808
Melhado, Rachel
7c8d3e42-a462-43c4-ba78-d7d7f1feb32c
Alkhaffaf, Bilal
5616e7a6-bf39-4e4d-a729-31827c497cbd
Krysztopik, Richard
ae317341-b91e-4298-b3c2-dc710a95cba4
Lamb, Peter
31854dab-bcd7-40fd-a2ad-21e8a7068e26
Culliford, Lucy
6886cb46-ebe2-41de-8c56-76fba4337389
Rogers, Chris
f14f59d6-d9f1-4e6e-a238-b3b36dca1816
Howes, Benjamin
4ce089d7-2375-4e88-b223-b2e13cfef434
Chalmers, Katy
15ddfd19-a659-4ee4-91b7-d04137e2c40f
Cousins, Sian
241c9f44-998b-4486-a764-637c3b907928
Ellitt, Jackie
582483fd-f41a-4a65-8cdd-c76359fca240
Donovan, Jenny
9189eca7-3335-474c-b31f-b9ca6a872f4a
Hayes, Rachael
080f058a-777d-447c-97e2-46fb4f00eb12
Wickens, Robin A.
3fae8758-ef16-4dfa-aabb-bf7b145458f8
Wilkerson, Paul
5e992151-011c-4d1e-b209-f3c8df88ee1a
Hollowood, Andrew
49908560-83d7-4659-ad03-80701788e9ed
Streets, Christopher
028cc23b-3321-4044-b0c0-c4645cb01425
Titcomb, Dan
f651a3c8-af1f-45a2-b02b-6ee455916a91
Lee Humphreys, Martyn
846b8219-69ea-4786-99c5-090efcb24516
Wheatley, Tim
db3646cd-71d6-4f3f-9293-1b5bdddfd16c
Sanders, Grant
4aa74740-0ef4-4a2d-868a-a0e6340609cc
Ariyarathenam, Arun
bad3215c-b439-4f6c-a3b1-829168eabc84
Kelly, Jamie
cc93c77d-2902-4cc9-8e79-82f59396552c
Noble, Fergus
4f14574c-28f2-4e04-bd95-f53c7649e1fa
Couper, Graeme
e4c1c9f1-ff63-448a-a3c5-8c39b11bb6d6
Skipworth, Richard J.E.
a1826e3b-f9c3-4c0b-94b1-f981a3a83116
Deans, Chris
554435e3-5a76-4e04-ba81-ba1706d179d5
Ubhi, Sukhibir
16793f09-519a-4ccf-b9aa-3837457e39c0
Williams, Robert
13de0ba5-9a22-45f9-b04a-f16e5961378d
Bowrey, David
d0302ffb-1909-4898-9b7b-27f50dba7090
Exon, David
efbea3ac-f559-445a-87df-d3f93fee2979
Turner, Paul
7c0fbc62-458f-4122-9039-02cf06aa51e5
Daya Shetty, Vinutha
7d660492-9b07-447e-9c70-c522c2fa807d
Chaparala, Ram
bb28c78a-f161-4256-b506-5deda576d0fa
Akhtar, Khurshid
7250eabe-9a66-4326-86d0-d9b07251836c
Farooq, Naheed
f11c36ca-106c-46b7-992e-a04aa4d73d7b
Parsons, Simon L.
5e02c969-b698-4947-9c40-0557e35fbcfc
Welch, Neil T.
2651128c-ac44-4c56-a153-e892690a06b7
Houlihan, Rebecca J.
21d322e5-94c7-4483-8364-e311b167a2a3
Smith, Joanne
1067ae12-5a09-4506-9a0f-059f4182e52c
Schranz, Rachel
59587776-67b7-42b7-8a7e-f9f96ce34180
Rea, Nicola
e0549381-7b2c-48e6-adac-955635fd5f22
Cooke, Jill
ab9e0f48-1081-4341-a0d5-8a84aa2e4c26
Williams, Alexandra
922a0421-8ce1-4f86-92b7-b166f1322681
Hindmarsh, Carolyn
dfa852d3-f610-4292-9ad4-f6d08a68aa4d
Maitland, Sally
3d998177-2de3-4279-b5a0-32d684b166da
Howie, Lucy
d2f878ba-9504-4e36-a839-0e4b36a9fec5
Barham, Christopher Paul
4a82c99b-f4a1-4832-b559-1ad9985ba37b

Brierley, Rachel C., Gaunt, Daisy, Metcalf, Chris, Blazeby, Jane M., Blencowe, Natalie M., Jepson, Marcus, Berrisford, Richard G., Avery, Kerry N.L., Hollingworth, William, Rice, Caoimhe T., Moure-Fernandez, Aide, Wong, Newton, Nicklin, Joanna, Skilton, Anni, Boddy, Alex, Byrne, James P., Underwood, Timothy, Vohra, Ravi, Cotton, James A., Pursani, Kish, Melhado, Rachel, Alkhaffaf, Bilal, Krysztopik, Richard, Lamb, Peter, Culliford, Lucy, Rogers, Chris, Howes, Benjamin, Chalmers, Katy, Cousins, Sian, Ellitt, Jackie, Donovan, Jenny, Hayes, Rachael, Wickens, Robin A., Wilkerson, Paul, Hollowood, Andrew, Streets, Christopher, Titcomb, Dan, Lee Humphreys, Martyn, Wheatley, Tim, Sanders, Grant, Ariyarathenam, Arun, Kelly, Jamie, Noble, Fergus, Couper, Graeme, Skipworth, Richard J.E., Deans, Chris, Ubhi, Sukhibir, Williams, Robert, Bowrey, David, Exon, David, Turner, Paul, Daya Shetty, Vinutha, Chaparala, Ram, Akhtar, Khurshid, Farooq, Naheed, Parsons, Simon L., Welch, Neil T., Houlihan, Rebecca J., Smith, Joanne, Schranz, Rachel, Rea, Nicola, Cooke, Jill, Williams, Alexandra, Hindmarsh, Carolyn, Maitland, Sally, Howie, Lucy and Barham, Christopher Paul (2019) Laparoscopically assisted versus open oesophagectomy for patients with oesophageal cancer--the Randomised Oesophagectomy: Minimally Invasive or Open (ROMIO) study: protocol for a randomised controlled trial (RCT). BMJ Open, 9 (11), [e030907]. (doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2019-030907).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Introduction: Surgery (oesophagectomy), with neoadjuvant chemo(radio)therapy, is the main curative treatment for patients with oesophageal cancer. Several surgical approaches can be used to remove an oesophageal tumour. The Ivor Lewis (two-phase procedure) is usually used in the UK. This can be performed as an open oesophagectomy (OO), a laparoscopically assisted oesophagectomy (LAO) or a totally minimally invasive oesophagectomy (TMIO). All three are performed in the National Health Service, with LAO and OO the most common. However, there is limited evidence about which surgical approach is best for patients in terms of survival and postoperative health-related quality of life.
Methods and analysis: We will undertake a UK multicentre randomised controlled trial to compare LAO with OO in adult patients with oesophageal cancer. The primary outcome is patient-reported physical function at 3 and 6 weeks postoperatively and 3 months after randomisation. Secondary outcomes include: postoperative complications, survival, disease recurrence, other measures of quality of life, spirometry, success of patient blinding and quality assurance measures. A cost-effectiveness analysis will be performed comparing LAO with OO. We will embed a randomised substudy to evaluate the safety and evolution of the TMIO procedure and a qualitative recruitment intervention to optimise patient recruitment. We will analyse the primary outcome using a multi-level regression model. Patients will be monitored for up to 3 years after their surgery.
Ethics and dissemination: This study received ethical approval from the South-West Franchay Research Ethics Committee. We will submit the results for publication in a peer-reviewed journal.
Trial registration number: ISRCTN10386621.

Text
e030907.full - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (751kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 19 August 2019
e-pub ahead of print date: 19 November 2019
Published date: 2019
Additional Information: DOI doesn't work without adding the DX.doi.org 18/01/23

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 436237
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/436237
ISSN: 2044-6055
PURE UUID: 17c52747-aa34-4ff5-a255-a08bf84e688c
ORCID for Timothy Underwood: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0001-9455-2188

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 04 Dec 2019 17:30
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 02:58

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Rachel C. Brierley
Author: Daisy Gaunt
Author: Chris Metcalf
Author: Jane M. Blazeby
Author: Natalie M. Blencowe
Author: Marcus Jepson
Author: Richard G. Berrisford
Author: Kerry N.L. Avery
Author: William Hollingworth
Author: Caoimhe T. Rice
Author: Aide Moure-Fernandez
Author: Newton Wong
Author: Joanna Nicklin
Author: Anni Skilton
Author: Alex Boddy
Author: James P. Byrne
Author: Ravi Vohra
Author: James A. Cotton
Author: Kish Pursani
Author: Rachel Melhado
Author: Bilal Alkhaffaf
Author: Richard Krysztopik
Author: Peter Lamb
Author: Lucy Culliford
Author: Chris Rogers
Author: Benjamin Howes
Author: Katy Chalmers
Author: Sian Cousins
Author: Jackie Ellitt
Author: Jenny Donovan
Author: Rachael Hayes
Author: Robin A. Wickens
Author: Paul Wilkerson
Author: Andrew Hollowood
Author: Christopher Streets
Author: Dan Titcomb
Author: Martyn Lee Humphreys
Author: Tim Wheatley
Author: Grant Sanders
Author: Arun Ariyarathenam
Author: Jamie Kelly
Author: Fergus Noble
Author: Graeme Couper
Author: Richard J.E. Skipworth
Author: Chris Deans
Author: Sukhibir Ubhi
Author: Robert Williams
Author: David Bowrey
Author: David Exon
Author: Paul Turner
Author: Vinutha Daya Shetty
Author: Ram Chaparala
Author: Khurshid Akhtar
Author: Naheed Farooq
Author: Simon L. Parsons
Author: Neil T. Welch
Author: Rebecca J. Houlihan
Author: Joanne Smith
Author: Rachel Schranz
Author: Nicola Rea
Author: Jill Cooke
Author: Alexandra Williams
Author: Carolyn Hindmarsh
Author: Sally Maitland
Author: Lucy Howie
Author: Christopher Paul Barham

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×