DNA methylation and body mass index from birth to adolescence: meta-analyses of epigenome-wide association studies
DNA methylation and body mass index from birth to adolescence: meta-analyses of epigenome-wide association studies
Background: DNA methylation has been shown to be associated with adiposity in adulthood. However, whether similar DNA methylation patterns are associated with childhood and adolescent body mass index (BMI) is largely unknown. More insight into this relationship at younger ages may have implications for future prevention of obesity and its related traits.
Methods: we examined whether DNA methylation in cord blood and whole blood in childhood and adolescence was associated with BMI in the age range from 2 to 18 years using both cross-sectional and longitudinal models. We performed meta-analyses of epigenome-wide association studies including up to 4133 children from 23 studies. We examined the overlap of findings reported in previous studies in children and adults with those in our analyses and calculated enrichment.
Results: DNA methylation at three CpGs (cg05937453, cg25212453, and cg10040131), each in a different age range, was associated with BMI at Bonferroni significance, P < 1.06 × 10 −7, with a 0.96 standard deviation score (SDS) (standard error (SE) 0.17), 0.32 SDS (SE 0.06), and 0.32 BMI SDS (SE 0.06) higher BMI per 10% increase in methylation, respectively. DNA methylation at nine additional CpGs in the cross-sectional childhood model was associated with BMI at false discovery rate significance. The strength of the associations of DNA methylation at the 187 CpGs previously identified to be associated with adult BMI, increased with advancing age across childhood and adolescence in our analyses. In addition, correlation coefficients between effect estimates for those CpGs in adults and in children and adolescents also increased. Among the top findings for each age range, we observed increasing enrichment for the CpGs that were previously identified in adults (birth P enrichment = 1; childhood P enrichment = 2.00 × 10 −4; adolescence P enrichment = 2.10 × 10 −7).
Conclusions: there were only minimal associations of DNA methylation with childhood and adolescent BMI. With the advancing age of the participants across childhood and adolescence, we observed increasing overlap with altered DNA methylation loci reported in association with adult BMI. These findings may be compatible with the hypothesis that DNA methylation differences are mostly a consequence rather than a cause of obesity.
Body mass index, Childhood obesity, DNA methylation, Epigenetics
Vehmeijer, Florianne O. L.
6e9a72a7-e51e-4df7-b620-e36204b8b64c
Küpers, Leanne K.
733e94ec-9e37-450c-a8ca-e1adf2eec323
Sharp, Gemma C.
1ca7cdb0-ff2c-4679-b625-d00e347fd140
Salas, Lucas A.
27547fe3-d10e-4720-8079-d8cc48040326
Lent, Samantha
b7cf2ae0-4e7d-4f88-9e00-5705bb4492a1
Jima, Dereje D.
1a56553e-03d9-46d3-be53-6fd60ec12e40
Tindula, Gwen
19da777a-3166-46ae-bedd-3306fec7ee59
Reese, Sarah
fed1b1a6-6d68-4069-b086-017f0f94a002
Qi, Cancan
1d9e574a-a966-4570-af31-d9d20b86ace5
Gruzieva, Olena
0865d16b-2fdc-4e58-b834-a9fd22283ca5
Page, Christian
e257bad2-6515-4014-83ff-540c571b9c47
Rezwan, Faisal I.
203f8f38-1f5d-485b-ab11-c546b4276338
Melton, Philip E.
e054a449-8aa6-4a02-a182-19b763984434
Nohr, Ellen
0912c010-2117-4b67-931e-359651c0f234
Escaramís, Geòrgia
c8c54a35-ac65-4272-ae7e-f27b504b13e2
Rzehak, Peter
2f4a6676-3440-4e5f-b40f-1480dafac4dc
Heiskala, Anni
af1564e8-9b1e-4909-b364-0e10dcf35a02
Gong, Tong
9ca67389-07ed-489a-b493-74669a64cea9
Tuominen, Samuli T.
b8bae766-f501-4259-907b-28550ff40ca3
Gao, Lu
80a9b183-04cb-42a6-9f2a-8ee86f5c25d6
Ross, Jason P.
5aad56b3-0d1e-4d1d-9a11-64c6980c0275
Starling, Anne P.
6266da08-8b60-4fdd-a1ea-f8509dece8b6
Holloway, John W.
4bbd77e6-c095-445d-a36b-a50a72f6fe1a
Yousefi, Paul
fabf4c33-d6dc-46e9-8e66-6af27b5e0bdd
Aasvang, Gunn Marit
71fe03fc-4b0e-4a15-897c-8c97a923f627
Beilin, Lawrence J.
a6eec1bf-0677-4f42-a5b3-3d8f2b53f090
Bergström, Anna
b7b8b4f8-15a5-4a0a-82db-28bfe3e6abc2
Binder, Elisabeth
96047fdc-dbd4-4864-b424-ab3d9da8012a
Chatzi, Leda
d120a7e6-1fe3-4ce9-8b2b-55ad9aa1c254
Corpeleijn, Eva
05909036-7f7f-4296-89f2-7a005feb5460
Czamara, Darina
f28d6b74-2e82-45d7-aab1-78f6b26355cb
Eskenazi, Brenda
fcd9d0e5-f06e-43b1-8481-f021799150ec
Ewart, Susan
28667421-3cf7-43d7-b1c3-ca27564938f7
Ferre, Natalia
05f7064b-2d56-4654-83ad-e29c51b2adb1
Grote, Veit
9962d399-4c9f-4bf6-afa2-460f0d6dcd60
Gruszfeld, Dariusz
769efa21-ea0e-48c6-85d8-e3716b18e02d
Håberg, Siri E.
63fa0e56-75ee-4fd3-9e3c-a5baa9d9e1ce
Hoyo, Cathrine
2b25673d-5f67-47f8-9961-222a4f0bb516
Huen, Karen
b8da207b-6b9d-4ca1-9909-859081965eba
Karlsson, Robert
496ca473-fc2a-4a2c-8b39-c749be1f0317
Kull, Inger
a5927f4c-709a-4f6f-a576-a6c1200f4840
Langhendries, Jean-paul
626eef38-e4aa-42dc-a39b-67593c9ccce8
Lepeule, Johanna
1f2c7812-564d-4531-9c79-9a867dd03b95
Magnus, Maria C.
88cf8d2b-fe9d-49ad-b5c9-105f6bb36cec
Maguire, Rachel L.
7646cd55-7e04-4e70-af77-9601c9113c31
Molloy, Peter L.
20514790-58bd-4188-926d-e0e6dae9dd19
Monnereau, Claire
2cdfd719-8197-475e-adcb-2f00a13da387
Mori, Trevor A.
182e02e5-0b4a-44c2-81c6-f910c7a4d0e6
Oken, Emily
b1938408-745f-4bf8-82a1-96b4a892b4f6
Räikkönen, Katri
32cd0aa3-6dc2-40a3-b1a0-245ccedd41c3
Rifas-shiman, Sheryl
3b275623-dc9d-411c-adbe-c780400f14fe
Ruiz-arenas, Carlos
e3ce90a5-40b4-48ab-be96-e4823f2798fc
Sebert, Sylvain
d3f6c0f7-92b9-4959-a86c-9f7ad3346ee3
Ullemar, Vilhelmina
c98d98d3-3348-4ccf-aff2-343ae9988222
Verduci, Elvira
aeb62036-658e-4f37-a3d0-ad9cfba84d24
Vonk, Judith M.
505c8bc4-909f-40b7-b3ae-1e94aeccc25d
Xu, Cheng-jian
1c4d76ae-4c68-4688-8ef6-88ef2529a436
Yang, Ivana V.
ffb15dcd-ac2e-43bf-a2cc-443ff692f526
Zhang, Hongmei
9f774048-54d6-4321-a252-3887b2c76db0
Zhang, Weiming
200bdfa1-0f58-474e-908f-c03af0df1348
Karmaus, Wilfried
281d0e53-6b5d-4d38-9732-3981b07cd853
Dabelea, Dana
ac81e62b-06c8-48cd-801f-03f17eeaf559
Muhlhausler, Beverly S.
ecea767b-3f11-4b5b-a325-ed8db61a6c67
Breton, Carrie V.
4a6d3cb3-49c2-44f6-b57f-c802bbd0917c
Lahti, Jari
230457a3-300b-4faf-810e-e2a07f57fcee
Almqvist, Catarina
2b040b02-78fe-461e-adba-ed60d9f77ea0
Jarvelin, Marjo-riitta
54bf0cc8-8f32-47db-b22d-6e694f1c1b26
Koletzko, Berthold
22ab3df4-675f-4a6b-972b-03711bfdb8e4
Vrijheid, Martine
74022e9a-2b23-418f-b66d-8165926feef0
Sørensen, Thorkild I. A.
c2e37ca6-5a48-4728-b64c-fc998cc60906
Huang, Rae-chi
d39aca4d-8017-48c3-8f40-0aa2e52dbf66
Arshad, Syed Hasan
917e246d-2e60-472f-8d30-94b01ef28958
Nystad, Wenche
d23bedd0-f153-45a4-8160-9420c0129d52
Melén, Erik
c7ee5423-aed5-4905-80b3-65bc07192e0c
Koppelman, Gerard H.
8d04aab8-5795-4e62-b64a-de7e368c0d1d
London, Stephanie J.
320afdd8-d870-49a0-9f68-b409fb522e85
Holland, Nina
1e673ec1-58b4-4ae5-ad01-ed03907b3015
Bustamante, Mariona
fd901679-fcff-437d-acff-3bebcfc87be6
Murphy, Susan K.
5e25a27a-da84-4e47-b720-b51847971715
Hivert, Marie-france
fe7b2f3e-ae38-4a77-aa0d-3d0599d58306
Baccarelli, Andrea
3f52b53f-a38b-458a-9d1b-242cf6644a3d
Relton, Caroline L.
7a9fe7f7-d14b-4bb7-be71-a3afa6ff8538
Snieder, Harold
3ffb9ec7-cf11-4fff-8b45-02ba4d83a32e
Jaddoe, Vincent W. V.
9a192cd2-9c0c-4d34-ad24-c6c4162e7b05
Felix, Janine F.
fcd2dff7-ebdf-40b3-8714-eeba5fa4818a
25 December 2020
Vehmeijer, Florianne O. L.
6e9a72a7-e51e-4df7-b620-e36204b8b64c
Küpers, Leanne K.
733e94ec-9e37-450c-a8ca-e1adf2eec323
Sharp, Gemma C.
1ca7cdb0-ff2c-4679-b625-d00e347fd140
Salas, Lucas A.
27547fe3-d10e-4720-8079-d8cc48040326
Lent, Samantha
b7cf2ae0-4e7d-4f88-9e00-5705bb4492a1
Jima, Dereje D.
1a56553e-03d9-46d3-be53-6fd60ec12e40
Tindula, Gwen
19da777a-3166-46ae-bedd-3306fec7ee59
Reese, Sarah
fed1b1a6-6d68-4069-b086-017f0f94a002
Qi, Cancan
1d9e574a-a966-4570-af31-d9d20b86ace5
Gruzieva, Olena
0865d16b-2fdc-4e58-b834-a9fd22283ca5
Page, Christian
e257bad2-6515-4014-83ff-540c571b9c47
Rezwan, Faisal I.
203f8f38-1f5d-485b-ab11-c546b4276338
Melton, Philip E.
e054a449-8aa6-4a02-a182-19b763984434
Nohr, Ellen
0912c010-2117-4b67-931e-359651c0f234
Escaramís, Geòrgia
c8c54a35-ac65-4272-ae7e-f27b504b13e2
Rzehak, Peter
2f4a6676-3440-4e5f-b40f-1480dafac4dc
Heiskala, Anni
af1564e8-9b1e-4909-b364-0e10dcf35a02
Gong, Tong
9ca67389-07ed-489a-b493-74669a64cea9
Tuominen, Samuli T.
b8bae766-f501-4259-907b-28550ff40ca3
Gao, Lu
80a9b183-04cb-42a6-9f2a-8ee86f5c25d6
Ross, Jason P.
5aad56b3-0d1e-4d1d-9a11-64c6980c0275
Starling, Anne P.
6266da08-8b60-4fdd-a1ea-f8509dece8b6
Holloway, John W.
4bbd77e6-c095-445d-a36b-a50a72f6fe1a
Yousefi, Paul
fabf4c33-d6dc-46e9-8e66-6af27b5e0bdd
Aasvang, Gunn Marit
71fe03fc-4b0e-4a15-897c-8c97a923f627
Beilin, Lawrence J.
a6eec1bf-0677-4f42-a5b3-3d8f2b53f090
Bergström, Anna
b7b8b4f8-15a5-4a0a-82db-28bfe3e6abc2
Binder, Elisabeth
96047fdc-dbd4-4864-b424-ab3d9da8012a
Chatzi, Leda
d120a7e6-1fe3-4ce9-8b2b-55ad9aa1c254
Corpeleijn, Eva
05909036-7f7f-4296-89f2-7a005feb5460
Czamara, Darina
f28d6b74-2e82-45d7-aab1-78f6b26355cb
Eskenazi, Brenda
fcd9d0e5-f06e-43b1-8481-f021799150ec
Ewart, Susan
28667421-3cf7-43d7-b1c3-ca27564938f7
Ferre, Natalia
05f7064b-2d56-4654-83ad-e29c51b2adb1
Grote, Veit
9962d399-4c9f-4bf6-afa2-460f0d6dcd60
Gruszfeld, Dariusz
769efa21-ea0e-48c6-85d8-e3716b18e02d
Håberg, Siri E.
63fa0e56-75ee-4fd3-9e3c-a5baa9d9e1ce
Hoyo, Cathrine
2b25673d-5f67-47f8-9961-222a4f0bb516
Huen, Karen
b8da207b-6b9d-4ca1-9909-859081965eba
Karlsson, Robert
496ca473-fc2a-4a2c-8b39-c749be1f0317
Kull, Inger
a5927f4c-709a-4f6f-a576-a6c1200f4840
Langhendries, Jean-paul
626eef38-e4aa-42dc-a39b-67593c9ccce8
Lepeule, Johanna
1f2c7812-564d-4531-9c79-9a867dd03b95
Magnus, Maria C.
88cf8d2b-fe9d-49ad-b5c9-105f6bb36cec
Maguire, Rachel L.
7646cd55-7e04-4e70-af77-9601c9113c31
Molloy, Peter L.
20514790-58bd-4188-926d-e0e6dae9dd19
Monnereau, Claire
2cdfd719-8197-475e-adcb-2f00a13da387
Mori, Trevor A.
182e02e5-0b4a-44c2-81c6-f910c7a4d0e6
Oken, Emily
b1938408-745f-4bf8-82a1-96b4a892b4f6
Räikkönen, Katri
32cd0aa3-6dc2-40a3-b1a0-245ccedd41c3
Rifas-shiman, Sheryl
3b275623-dc9d-411c-adbe-c780400f14fe
Ruiz-arenas, Carlos
e3ce90a5-40b4-48ab-be96-e4823f2798fc
Sebert, Sylvain
d3f6c0f7-92b9-4959-a86c-9f7ad3346ee3
Ullemar, Vilhelmina
c98d98d3-3348-4ccf-aff2-343ae9988222
Verduci, Elvira
aeb62036-658e-4f37-a3d0-ad9cfba84d24
Vonk, Judith M.
505c8bc4-909f-40b7-b3ae-1e94aeccc25d
Xu, Cheng-jian
1c4d76ae-4c68-4688-8ef6-88ef2529a436
Yang, Ivana V.
ffb15dcd-ac2e-43bf-a2cc-443ff692f526
Zhang, Hongmei
9f774048-54d6-4321-a252-3887b2c76db0
Zhang, Weiming
200bdfa1-0f58-474e-908f-c03af0df1348
Karmaus, Wilfried
281d0e53-6b5d-4d38-9732-3981b07cd853
Dabelea, Dana
ac81e62b-06c8-48cd-801f-03f17eeaf559
Muhlhausler, Beverly S.
ecea767b-3f11-4b5b-a325-ed8db61a6c67
Breton, Carrie V.
4a6d3cb3-49c2-44f6-b57f-c802bbd0917c
Lahti, Jari
230457a3-300b-4faf-810e-e2a07f57fcee
Almqvist, Catarina
2b040b02-78fe-461e-adba-ed60d9f77ea0
Jarvelin, Marjo-riitta
54bf0cc8-8f32-47db-b22d-6e694f1c1b26
Koletzko, Berthold
22ab3df4-675f-4a6b-972b-03711bfdb8e4
Vrijheid, Martine
74022e9a-2b23-418f-b66d-8165926feef0
Sørensen, Thorkild I. A.
c2e37ca6-5a48-4728-b64c-fc998cc60906
Huang, Rae-chi
d39aca4d-8017-48c3-8f40-0aa2e52dbf66
Arshad, Syed Hasan
917e246d-2e60-472f-8d30-94b01ef28958
Nystad, Wenche
d23bedd0-f153-45a4-8160-9420c0129d52
Melén, Erik
c7ee5423-aed5-4905-80b3-65bc07192e0c
Koppelman, Gerard H.
8d04aab8-5795-4e62-b64a-de7e368c0d1d
London, Stephanie J.
320afdd8-d870-49a0-9f68-b409fb522e85
Holland, Nina
1e673ec1-58b4-4ae5-ad01-ed03907b3015
Bustamante, Mariona
fd901679-fcff-437d-acff-3bebcfc87be6
Murphy, Susan K.
5e25a27a-da84-4e47-b720-b51847971715
Hivert, Marie-france
fe7b2f3e-ae38-4a77-aa0d-3d0599d58306
Baccarelli, Andrea
3f52b53f-a38b-458a-9d1b-242cf6644a3d
Relton, Caroline L.
7a9fe7f7-d14b-4bb7-be71-a3afa6ff8538
Snieder, Harold
3ffb9ec7-cf11-4fff-8b45-02ba4d83a32e
Jaddoe, Vincent W. V.
9a192cd2-9c0c-4d34-ad24-c6c4162e7b05
Felix, Janine F.
fcd2dff7-ebdf-40b3-8714-eeba5fa4818a