Delayed antibiotic prescription for children with respiratory infections: A randomized trial
Delayed antibiotic prescription for children with respiratory infections: A randomized trial
OBJECTIVES: To assess the effectiveness and safety of delayed antibiotic prescription (DAP) compared to immediate antibiotic prescription (IAP) and no antibiotic prescription (NAP) in children with uncomplicated respiratory infections. METHODS: Randomized clinical trial comparing 3 antibiotic prescription strategies. The participants were children with acute uncomplicated respiratory infections attended to in 39 primary care centers. Children were randomly assigned into prescription arms as follows: (1) DAP, (2) IAP, or (3) NAP. Primary outcomes were symptom duration and severity. Secondary outcomes were antibiotic use, parental satisfaction, parental beliefs, additional primary care visits, and complications at 30 days. RESULTS: In total, 436 children were included in the analysis. The mean (SD) duration of severe symptoms was 10.1 (6.3) for IAP, 10.9 (8.5) for NAP, and 12.4 (8.4) for DAP (P =.539), although the differences were not statistically significant. The median (interquartile range) of the greatest severity for any symptom was similar for the 3 arms (median [interquartile range] score of 3 [2-4]; P =.619). Antibiotic use was significantly higher for IAP (n = 142 [96%]) compared to DAP (n = 37 [25.3%]) and NAP (n = 17 [12.0%]) (P,.001). Complications, additional visits to primary care, and satisfaction were similar for all strategies. Gastrointestinal adverse effects were higher for IAP. CONCLUSIONS: There was no statistically significant difference in symptom duration or severity in children with uncomplicated respiratory infections who received DAP compared to NAP or IAP strategies; however, DAP reduced antibiotic use and gastrointestinal adverse effects.
Mas-Dalmau, Gemma
86902702-1211-4313-bf1f-1273659ee89b
Villanueva López, Carmen
a6888b5e-5652-49a0-87bd-7f4614ac39c3
Gorrotxategi Gorrotxategi, Pedro
f97f32f5-3251-4531-92d5-b8c8ad69850f
Argüelles Prendes, Emma
c14e473f-e873-4116-9842-43738725ef1e
Espinazo Ramos, Oscar
8fd8e74c-f6b0-40af-b8bd-64db808d2ce3
Valls Duran, Teresa
637bc389-8ec6-4fd2-96ab-78b7f799cd52
Gonzalo Alonso, María Encarnación
7e886fb1-0c66-44be-bea9-ed46632895e8
Cortés Viana, María Pilar
5da914ad-9135-47e7-aec9-a6d29e1cba88
Menéndez Bada, Tatiana
4be91831-ea20-4f9f-9b3c-b7c6895f7251
Vázquez Fernández, Marta Esther
bee7de77-8c75-4530-8a02-a1300564f39b
Pérez Hernández, Ana Isabel
05d2f613-6d4f-4d5f-ab66-15dc7de4c362
Muñoz Ortiz, Laura
57f0b6c9-823b-4e9d-baf0-0b0c768aa30b
Little, Paul
1bf2d1f7-200c-47a5-ab16-fe5a8756a777
De La Poza Abad, Mariam
bdf25a4e-90b1-4442-bbf3-0e943ca783a7
Alonso-Coello, Pablo
2d29e862-ea00-4134-acd9-6e2269c054e8
1 March 2021
Mas-Dalmau, Gemma
86902702-1211-4313-bf1f-1273659ee89b
Villanueva López, Carmen
a6888b5e-5652-49a0-87bd-7f4614ac39c3
Gorrotxategi Gorrotxategi, Pedro
f97f32f5-3251-4531-92d5-b8c8ad69850f
Argüelles Prendes, Emma
c14e473f-e873-4116-9842-43738725ef1e
Espinazo Ramos, Oscar
8fd8e74c-f6b0-40af-b8bd-64db808d2ce3
Valls Duran, Teresa
637bc389-8ec6-4fd2-96ab-78b7f799cd52
Gonzalo Alonso, María Encarnación
7e886fb1-0c66-44be-bea9-ed46632895e8
Cortés Viana, María Pilar
5da914ad-9135-47e7-aec9-a6d29e1cba88
Menéndez Bada, Tatiana
4be91831-ea20-4f9f-9b3c-b7c6895f7251
Vázquez Fernández, Marta Esther
bee7de77-8c75-4530-8a02-a1300564f39b
Pérez Hernández, Ana Isabel
05d2f613-6d4f-4d5f-ab66-15dc7de4c362
Muñoz Ortiz, Laura
57f0b6c9-823b-4e9d-baf0-0b0c768aa30b
Little, Paul
1bf2d1f7-200c-47a5-ab16-fe5a8756a777
De La Poza Abad, Mariam
bdf25a4e-90b1-4442-bbf3-0e943ca783a7
Alonso-Coello, Pablo
2d29e862-ea00-4134-acd9-6e2269c054e8
Mas-Dalmau, Gemma, Villanueva López, Carmen, Gorrotxategi Gorrotxategi, Pedro, Argüelles Prendes, Emma, Espinazo Ramos, Oscar, Valls Duran, Teresa, Gonzalo Alonso, María Encarnación, Cortés Viana, María Pilar, Menéndez Bada, Tatiana, Vázquez Fernández, Marta Esther, Pérez Hernández, Ana Isabel, Muñoz Ortiz, Laura, Little, Paul, De La Poza Abad, Mariam and Alonso-Coello, Pablo
(2021)
Delayed antibiotic prescription for children with respiratory infections: A randomized trial.
Pediatrics, 147 (3), [e20201323].
(doi:10.1542/peds.2020-1323).
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: To assess the effectiveness and safety of delayed antibiotic prescription (DAP) compared to immediate antibiotic prescription (IAP) and no antibiotic prescription (NAP) in children with uncomplicated respiratory infections. METHODS: Randomized clinical trial comparing 3 antibiotic prescription strategies. The participants were children with acute uncomplicated respiratory infections attended to in 39 primary care centers. Children were randomly assigned into prescription arms as follows: (1) DAP, (2) IAP, or (3) NAP. Primary outcomes were symptom duration and severity. Secondary outcomes were antibiotic use, parental satisfaction, parental beliefs, additional primary care visits, and complications at 30 days. RESULTS: In total, 436 children were included in the analysis. The mean (SD) duration of severe symptoms was 10.1 (6.3) for IAP, 10.9 (8.5) for NAP, and 12.4 (8.4) for DAP (P =.539), although the differences were not statistically significant. The median (interquartile range) of the greatest severity for any symptom was similar for the 3 arms (median [interquartile range] score of 3 [2-4]; P =.619). Antibiotic use was significantly higher for IAP (n = 142 [96%]) compared to DAP (n = 37 [25.3%]) and NAP (n = 17 [12.0%]) (P,.001). Complications, additional visits to primary care, and satisfaction were similar for all strategies. Gastrointestinal adverse effects were higher for IAP. CONCLUSIONS: There was no statistically significant difference in symptom duration or severity in children with uncomplicated respiratory infections who received DAP compared to NAP or IAP strategies; however, DAP reduced antibiotic use and gastrointestinal adverse effects.
Text
ed_DAP Pediatrics_Publication__18.11.20
- Accepted Manuscript
Restricted to Repository staff only
Request a copy
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 18 November 2020
e-pub ahead of print date: 11 February 2021
Published date: 1 March 2021
Additional Information:
Funding Information:
FUNDING: Funded by Instituto de Salud Carlos III under a 2016 grant call (Acción Estratégica en Salud 2013–2016: Programa de Investigación Orientada a los Retos de la Sociedad) within the framework of the Spanish National Plan for Scientific and Technical Research and Innovation 2013–2016 (dossier PI11/02192) cofunded by the European Union through the European Regional Development Fund and with the support of the Spanish Ministry of Health, Social Services, and Equality (reference EC11-339).
Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2021 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 447144
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/447144
ISSN: 0031-4005
PURE UUID: 8d0dde5e-771b-4550-b798-db92681b064b
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 04 Mar 2021 17:38
Last modified: 16 Mar 2024 11:03
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Gemma Mas-Dalmau
Author:
Carmen Villanueva López
Author:
Pedro Gorrotxategi Gorrotxategi
Author:
Emma Argüelles Prendes
Author:
Oscar Espinazo Ramos
Author:
Teresa Valls Duran
Author:
María Encarnación Gonzalo Alonso
Author:
María Pilar Cortés Viana
Author:
Tatiana Menéndez Bada
Author:
Marta Esther Vázquez Fernández
Author:
Ana Isabel Pérez Hernández
Author:
Laura Muñoz Ortiz
Author:
Mariam De La Poza Abad
Author:
Pablo Alonso-Coello
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics