Investigating the material modelling of a polymeric bioresorbable scaffold via in-silico and in-vitro testing
Investigating the material modelling of a polymeric bioresorbable scaffold via in-silico and in-vitro testing
The accurate material modelling of poly-l-lactic acid (PLLA) is vital in conducting finite element analysis of polymeric bioresorbable scaffolds (BRS) to investigate their mechanical performance and seek improved scaffold designs. To date, a large variety of material models have been utilised, ranging from simple elasto-plastic models to high fidelity parallel network models. However, no clear consensus has been reached on the appropriateness of these different models and whether simple, less computationally expensive models can serve as acceptable approximations. Therefore, we present a study which explored the use of different isotropic and anisotropic elasto-plastic models in simulating the balloon expansion and radial crushing of the thin-strut (sub-100 μm) ArterioSorb
TM BRS using the Abaqus/Explicit (DS SIMULIA) solution method. Stress–strain data was obtained via tensile tests at two different displacement rates. The use of isotropic and transversely isotropic elastic theories was explored, as well as the implementation of stress relaxation in the plastic regime of the material. The scaffold performance was quantified via its post-expansion diameter, percentage recoil and radial strength. The in-silico results were validated via comparison with in-vitro data of an analogous bench test. Accurately predicting both the post-expansion scaffold shape and radial strength was found to be challenging using the in-built Abaqus models. Therefore, a novel user-defined material model was developed via the VUMAT subroutine which improved functionality by facilitating a variable yield ratio, dependent upon the plastic strain as well as stress relaxation in overly strained elements. This achieved prediction of the radial strength within 1.1% of the in-vitro results and the scaffold's post-expansion diameter within 6.7%. A realistic multi-balloon simulation strategy was also used which confirmed that a mechanism exists in the PLLA which facilitates the extremely low percentage recoil behaviour observed in the ArterioSorb
TM BRS. This could not be captured by the aforementioned material property models.
Absorbable Implants, Computer Simulation, Finite Element Analysis, Polymers, Prosthesis Design, Stress, Mechanical
104557
Hoddy, Ben
b1e75d8a-f1aa-489a-8cb7-38cb51ab8fd0
Ahmed, Naveed
222cd8bf-d6e9-4f86-a8ac-4eb20eecfd6e
Al-Lamee, Kadem
e9b757db-f829-4c5f-81cf-08047caef616
Bullett, Nial
0db21e40-0fff-4078-9c65-538d93256068
Curzen, Nick
c590bddc-f851-4b94-b3b8-00120e8a87ef
Bressloff, Neil W
4f531e64-dbb3-41e3-a5d3-e6a5a7a77c92
1 August 2021
Hoddy, Ben
b1e75d8a-f1aa-489a-8cb7-38cb51ab8fd0
Ahmed, Naveed
222cd8bf-d6e9-4f86-a8ac-4eb20eecfd6e
Al-Lamee, Kadem
e9b757db-f829-4c5f-81cf-08047caef616
Bullett, Nial
0db21e40-0fff-4078-9c65-538d93256068
Curzen, Nick
c590bddc-f851-4b94-b3b8-00120e8a87ef
Bressloff, Neil W
4f531e64-dbb3-41e3-a5d3-e6a5a7a77c92
Hoddy, Ben, Ahmed, Naveed, Al-Lamee, Kadem, Bullett, Nial, Curzen, Nick and Bressloff, Neil W
(2021)
Investigating the material modelling of a polymeric bioresorbable scaffold via in-silico and in-vitro testing.
Journal of the Mechanical Behavior of Biomedical Materials, 120, , [104557].
(doi:10.1016/j.jmbbm.2021.104557).
Abstract
The accurate material modelling of poly-l-lactic acid (PLLA) is vital in conducting finite element analysis of polymeric bioresorbable scaffolds (BRS) to investigate their mechanical performance and seek improved scaffold designs. To date, a large variety of material models have been utilised, ranging from simple elasto-plastic models to high fidelity parallel network models. However, no clear consensus has been reached on the appropriateness of these different models and whether simple, less computationally expensive models can serve as acceptable approximations. Therefore, we present a study which explored the use of different isotropic and anisotropic elasto-plastic models in simulating the balloon expansion and radial crushing of the thin-strut (sub-100 μm) ArterioSorb
TM BRS using the Abaqus/Explicit (DS SIMULIA) solution method. Stress–strain data was obtained via tensile tests at two different displacement rates. The use of isotropic and transversely isotropic elastic theories was explored, as well as the implementation of stress relaxation in the plastic regime of the material. The scaffold performance was quantified via its post-expansion diameter, percentage recoil and radial strength. The in-silico results were validated via comparison with in-vitro data of an analogous bench test. Accurately predicting both the post-expansion scaffold shape and radial strength was found to be challenging using the in-built Abaqus models. Therefore, a novel user-defined material model was developed via the VUMAT subroutine which improved functionality by facilitating a variable yield ratio, dependent upon the plastic strain as well as stress relaxation in overly strained elements. This achieved prediction of the radial strength within 1.1% of the in-vitro results and the scaffold's post-expansion diameter within 6.7%. A realistic multi-balloon simulation strategy was also used which confirmed that a mechanism exists in the PLLA which facilitates the extremely low percentage recoil behaviour observed in the ArterioSorb
TM BRS. This could not be captured by the aforementioned material property models.
Text
Investigating the material modelling of a polymeric bioresorbable scaffold via in-silico and in-vitro testing
- Accepted Manuscript
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 19 April 2021
e-pub ahead of print date: 23 April 2021
Published date: 1 August 2021
Additional Information:
Funding Information:
Curzen is involved in unrestricted research grants from Boston Scientific, HeartFlow and Beck-mann Coulter and receives speaker/consultancy fees from Boston Scientific, HeartFlow and Abbott. Ahmed, Al-Lamee and Bullet are all employees of Arterius Ltd.
Funding Information:
This work was funded by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council, United Kingdom .
Publisher Copyright:
© 2021 Elsevier Ltd
Copyright:
Copyright 2021 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
Keywords:
Absorbable Implants, Computer Simulation, Finite Element Analysis, Polymers, Prosthesis Design, Stress, Mechanical
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 450146
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/450146
ISSN: 1751-6161
PURE UUID: 2f65e80a-69ed-4bfb-81e4-2c72f4124cc0
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 13 Jul 2021 16:32
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 06:43
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Naveed Ahmed
Author:
Kadem Al-Lamee
Author:
Nial Bullett
Author:
Nick Curzen
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics