The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Identifying key priorities for research to protect the consumer with food hypersensitivity: A UK Food Standards Agency Priority Setting Exercise

Identifying key priorities for research to protect the consumer with food hypersensitivity: A UK Food Standards Agency Priority Setting Exercise
Identifying key priorities for research to protect the consumer with food hypersensitivity: A UK Food Standards Agency Priority Setting Exercise

INTRODUCTION: Food hypersensitivity (FHS), including food allergy, coeliac disease and food intolerance, is a major public health issue. The Food Standards Agency (FSA), an independent UK Government department working to protect public health and consumers' wider interests in food, sought to identify research priorities in the area of FHS.

METHODS: A priority setting exercise was undertaken, using a methodology adapted from the James Lind Alliance-the first such exercise with respect to food hypersensitivity. A UK-wide public consultation was held to identify unanswered research questions. After excluding diagnostics, desensitization treatment and other questions which were out of scope for FSA or where FSA was already commissioning research, 15 indicative questions were identified and prioritized by a range of stakeholders, representing food businesses, patient groups, health care and academia, local authorities and the FSA.

RESULTS: 295 responses were received during the public consultation, which were categorized into 70 sub-questions and used to define 15 key evidence uncertainties ('indicative questions') for prioritization. Using the JLA prioritization framework, this resulted in 10 priority uncertainties in evidence, from which 16 research questions were developed. These could be summarized under the following 5 themes: communication of allergens both within the food supply chain and then to the end consumer (ensuring trust in allergen communication); the impact of socio-economic factors on consumers with FHS; drivers of severe reactions; mechanism(s) underlying loss of tolerance in FHS; and the risks posed by novel allergens/processing.

DISCUSSION: In this first research prioritization exercise for food allergy and FHS, key priorities identified to protect the food-allergic public were strategies to help allergic consumers to make confident food choices, prevention of FHS and increasing understanding of socio-economic impacts. Diagnosis and treatment of FHS was not considered in this prioritization.

James Lind Alliance, allergen labelling, coeliac disease, food allergy, research prioritization
0954-7894
1322-1330
Turner, Paul J
22cee218-a226-4300-aad1-b9a77ca65915
Andoh-Kesson, Elizabeth
dc1afbbc-0ac6-4343-984c-ee3410ac7450
Baker, Sarah
a6867058-51d7-4059-90bb-e98ff86d97e6
Baracaia, Alexa
f9d7e89b-7d28-4576-ac02-2e65feeb53b0
Barfield, Alisha
0e9ba96f-ffa4-4995-a4ef-efb1d1181b7a
Barnett, Julie
e075f8d9-cf31-4bfc-a6be-41988b5ce764
Brunas, Karen
49e30035-5220-4734-b3e5-8d8e5cccaa81
Chan, Chun-Han
d65a70e6-e7a5-4b19-8757-fa0751a6c01e
Cochrane, Stella
153d09bb-11c2-4ce7-ae0d-e2bbc026cb88
Cowan, Katherine
fcc235c9-3a39-484b-9e5e-f310bf724071
Feeney, Mary
29a6a117-af58-431f-90ad-d29495c665c8
Flanagan, Simon
3f6dbae1-8b16-4c45-a858-8ddace1dc55e
Fox, Adam T
f8964501-ad42-4b81-a987-b1e74b5ee182
George, Leigh
96985632-dd28-44fb-ac97-3fc40d6cf8c3
Gowland, M Hazel
72a62d3c-fe49-4b92-9776-ff235a7c5db3
Heeley, Christina
484b4bf2-e788-4f79-8c7e-929e7ec2e565
Kimber, Ian
3825fa14-6231-4f2f-ba27-6c093d618e9c
Knibb, Rebecca
ecf7d254-dfd6-4048-b274-6719b71ef410
Langford, Kirsty
96f3c882-6045-40b8-84cf-b49f48493f13
Mackie, Alan
435a29e1-595d-4c22-8f93-ce91ccdc8050
McLachlan, Tim
513e34fb-995e-4b6d-b8b3-cd1eb4344023
Regent, Lynne
57fc8920-f3d4-4c96-bc79-5f3bf8f40af8
Ridd, Matthew
2f15120c-d5fa-4f5d-bb86-21356e034df7
Roberts, Graham
ea00db4e-84e7-4b39-8273-9b71dbd7e2f3
Rogers, Adrian
37efcbfa-850c-4039-b8a1-0b85d90e453f
Scadding, Guy
2bea9516-10e8-41ef-adf8-a2c866b31118
Stoneham, Sarah
58738186-fbf1-423f-854f-73d673f04f73
Thomson, Darryl
99f46819-88c2-45c6-85c3-4a360236850b
Urwin, Heidi
3efd37e0-fa35-43c1-acc0-141379d74e85
Venter, Carina
a9b7dd5e-b0cb-4068-be82-e15b587cc20b
Walker, Michael
0b9c3ccc-caad-4944-a2da-31f7f42bc9f8
Ward, Rachel
9fa2b8a5-26d2-41d2-9abb-bb591a067eef
Yarham, Ross A R
4bb87b07-167d-4a55-85df-4da0f908e698
Young, Maggie
f09b2ed7-b265-414d-b3e7-b4daf6511fa9
O'Brien, John
0906821d-4431-47e6-8155-27de5d7f9612
Turner, Paul J
22cee218-a226-4300-aad1-b9a77ca65915
Andoh-Kesson, Elizabeth
dc1afbbc-0ac6-4343-984c-ee3410ac7450
Baker, Sarah
a6867058-51d7-4059-90bb-e98ff86d97e6
Baracaia, Alexa
f9d7e89b-7d28-4576-ac02-2e65feeb53b0
Barfield, Alisha
0e9ba96f-ffa4-4995-a4ef-efb1d1181b7a
Barnett, Julie
e075f8d9-cf31-4bfc-a6be-41988b5ce764
Brunas, Karen
49e30035-5220-4734-b3e5-8d8e5cccaa81
Chan, Chun-Han
d65a70e6-e7a5-4b19-8757-fa0751a6c01e
Cochrane, Stella
153d09bb-11c2-4ce7-ae0d-e2bbc026cb88
Cowan, Katherine
fcc235c9-3a39-484b-9e5e-f310bf724071
Feeney, Mary
29a6a117-af58-431f-90ad-d29495c665c8
Flanagan, Simon
3f6dbae1-8b16-4c45-a858-8ddace1dc55e
Fox, Adam T
f8964501-ad42-4b81-a987-b1e74b5ee182
George, Leigh
96985632-dd28-44fb-ac97-3fc40d6cf8c3
Gowland, M Hazel
72a62d3c-fe49-4b92-9776-ff235a7c5db3
Heeley, Christina
484b4bf2-e788-4f79-8c7e-929e7ec2e565
Kimber, Ian
3825fa14-6231-4f2f-ba27-6c093d618e9c
Knibb, Rebecca
ecf7d254-dfd6-4048-b274-6719b71ef410
Langford, Kirsty
96f3c882-6045-40b8-84cf-b49f48493f13
Mackie, Alan
435a29e1-595d-4c22-8f93-ce91ccdc8050
McLachlan, Tim
513e34fb-995e-4b6d-b8b3-cd1eb4344023
Regent, Lynne
57fc8920-f3d4-4c96-bc79-5f3bf8f40af8
Ridd, Matthew
2f15120c-d5fa-4f5d-bb86-21356e034df7
Roberts, Graham
ea00db4e-84e7-4b39-8273-9b71dbd7e2f3
Rogers, Adrian
37efcbfa-850c-4039-b8a1-0b85d90e453f
Scadding, Guy
2bea9516-10e8-41ef-adf8-a2c866b31118
Stoneham, Sarah
58738186-fbf1-423f-854f-73d673f04f73
Thomson, Darryl
99f46819-88c2-45c6-85c3-4a360236850b
Urwin, Heidi
3efd37e0-fa35-43c1-acc0-141379d74e85
Venter, Carina
a9b7dd5e-b0cb-4068-be82-e15b587cc20b
Walker, Michael
0b9c3ccc-caad-4944-a2da-31f7f42bc9f8
Ward, Rachel
9fa2b8a5-26d2-41d2-9abb-bb591a067eef
Yarham, Ross A R
4bb87b07-167d-4a55-85df-4da0f908e698
Young, Maggie
f09b2ed7-b265-414d-b3e7-b4daf6511fa9
O'Brien, John
0906821d-4431-47e6-8155-27de5d7f9612

Turner, Paul J, Andoh-Kesson, Elizabeth, Baker, Sarah, Baracaia, Alexa, Barfield, Alisha, Barnett, Julie, Brunas, Karen, Chan, Chun-Han, Cochrane, Stella, Cowan, Katherine, Feeney, Mary, Flanagan, Simon, Fox, Adam T, George, Leigh, Gowland, M Hazel, Heeley, Christina, Kimber, Ian, Knibb, Rebecca, Langford, Kirsty, Mackie, Alan, McLachlan, Tim, Regent, Lynne, Ridd, Matthew, Roberts, Graham, Rogers, Adrian, Scadding, Guy, Stoneham, Sarah, Thomson, Darryl, Urwin, Heidi, Venter, Carina, Walker, Michael, Ward, Rachel, Yarham, Ross A R, Young, Maggie and O'Brien, John (2021) Identifying key priorities for research to protect the consumer with food hypersensitivity: A UK Food Standards Agency Priority Setting Exercise. Clinical and experimental allergy : journal of the British Society for Allergy and Clinical Immunology, 51 (10), 1322-1330. (doi:10.1111/cea.13983).

Record type: Article

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Food hypersensitivity (FHS), including food allergy, coeliac disease and food intolerance, is a major public health issue. The Food Standards Agency (FSA), an independent UK Government department working to protect public health and consumers' wider interests in food, sought to identify research priorities in the area of FHS.

METHODS: A priority setting exercise was undertaken, using a methodology adapted from the James Lind Alliance-the first such exercise with respect to food hypersensitivity. A UK-wide public consultation was held to identify unanswered research questions. After excluding diagnostics, desensitization treatment and other questions which were out of scope for FSA or where FSA was already commissioning research, 15 indicative questions were identified and prioritized by a range of stakeholders, representing food businesses, patient groups, health care and academia, local authorities and the FSA.

RESULTS: 295 responses were received during the public consultation, which were categorized into 70 sub-questions and used to define 15 key evidence uncertainties ('indicative questions') for prioritization. Using the JLA prioritization framework, this resulted in 10 priority uncertainties in evidence, from which 16 research questions were developed. These could be summarized under the following 5 themes: communication of allergens both within the food supply chain and then to the end consumer (ensuring trust in allergen communication); the impact of socio-economic factors on consumers with FHS; drivers of severe reactions; mechanism(s) underlying loss of tolerance in FHS; and the risks posed by novel allergens/processing.

DISCUSSION: In this first research prioritization exercise for food allergy and FHS, key priorities identified to protect the food-allergic public were strategies to help allergic consumers to make confident food choices, prevention of FHS and increasing understanding of socio-economic impacts. Diagnosis and treatment of FHS was not considered in this prioritization.

This record has no associated files available for download.

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 22 June 2021
e-pub ahead of print date: 7 July 2021
Published date: October 2021
Additional Information: Funding Information: All authors have completed the ICMJE uniform disclosure form at www.icmje.org/coi_disclosure.pdf and declare competing interests as follows: PJT reports grants from the Food Standards Agency, JM Charitable Foundation, Medical Research Council, NIHR/Imperial Biomedical Research Centre and End Allergies Together, outside the submitted work; personal fees from UK Food Standards Agency, Aimmune Therapeutics, AllerGenis and ILSI Europe outside the submitted work. JB reports personal fees and grants from Food Standards Agency, outside the submitted work. SC reports financial activities with Unilever, outside the submitted work. KC is an independent facilitator and senior adviser to the James Lind Alliance. She is co‐author/editor of the JLA Guidebook and supports the JLA Secretariat and team of JLA advisers. She was an independently contracted adviser for this work. MF reports personal fees from Aimmune Therapeutics and Danone outside the submitted work. ATF is current President of the British Society for Allergy & Clinical Immunology (BSACI) and Chair of the Health Advisory Board of Allergy UK, both of which receive corporate sponsorship from companies involved in food allergy. He also reports consultancy work with Aimmune, without receiving a personal fee. MHG reports personal fees from Food Standards Agency (as a subcontractor), outside the submitted work. IK reports personal fees from Food Standards Agency, outside the submitted work. J’OB John O'Brien is a trustee of the Institute of Food Science & Technology, a member of the non‐executive board of Campden BRI, and Director of the Food Observatory; personal fees from Food Standards Agency, outside the submitted work. GR reports grants from European Union and Food Standards Agency outside the submitted work; he is also President Elect of the BSACI. CV reports grants from National Peanut Board; grants and personal fees from Reckitt Benckiser; personal fees from Nestle Nutrition Institute, Danone, Abbott Nutrition, INTENT Study, and Else Nutrition, outside the submitted work. The other authors do not report any conflicts of interest. Funding Information: This work was funded by the UK Food Standards Agency. The funders had no role in data collection, data analysis, data interpretation or writing of the report. We thank Paul Nunn and Rachel Whiteside at the UK Food Standards Agency (FSA) for administrative support, Hannah Lambie-Mumford (member of the FSA?s Advisory Committee for Social Science) and the following individuals who acted as independent facilitators: Jonathan Gower, Toto Gronlund, Sally Crowe and Maryrose Tarpey. Publisher Copyright: © 2021 The Authors. Clinical & Experimental Allergy published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
Keywords: James Lind Alliance, allergen labelling, coeliac disease, food allergy, research prioritization

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 450573
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/450573
ISSN: 0954-7894
PURE UUID: a55b71ba-8958-4dc3-af49-e6ba131de0a8
ORCID for Graham Roberts: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-2252-1248

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 04 Aug 2021 16:33
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 03:01

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Paul J Turner
Author: Elizabeth Andoh-Kesson
Author: Sarah Baker
Author: Alexa Baracaia
Author: Alisha Barfield
Author: Julie Barnett
Author: Karen Brunas
Author: Chun-Han Chan
Author: Stella Cochrane
Author: Katherine Cowan
Author: Mary Feeney
Author: Simon Flanagan
Author: Adam T Fox
Author: Leigh George
Author: M Hazel Gowland
Author: Christina Heeley
Author: Ian Kimber
Author: Rebecca Knibb
Author: Kirsty Langford
Author: Alan Mackie
Author: Tim McLachlan
Author: Lynne Regent
Author: Matthew Ridd
Author: Graham Roberts ORCID iD
Author: Adrian Rogers
Author: Guy Scadding
Author: Sarah Stoneham
Author: Darryl Thomson
Author: Heidi Urwin
Author: Carina Venter
Author: Michael Walker
Author: Rachel Ward
Author: Ross A R Yarham
Author: Maggie Young
Author: John O'Brien

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×