The Practicalities of Managing and Mapping Potentially Polluting Shipwrecks in the UK: Legal, Social and Ethical Considerations
The Practicalities of Managing and Mapping Potentially Polluting Shipwrecks in the UK: Legal, Social and Ethical Considerations
The issue of potentially polluting wrecks is relatively unstudied in the UK despite the potential threat presented by hundreds of shipwrecks in UK waters that contain oil, chemicals and other hazardous materials. As these wrecks degrade they will inevitably release their cargoes and fuel stores into the marine environment.
While there have been studies elsewhere that examine the risk from polluting shipwrecks, the limited work that has been undertaken on this topic in the UK is restricted to a number of government commissioned reports. These have attempted to quantify and risk assess the shipwrecks that pose a pollution threat in UK waters in order to inform ongoing management of these shipwrecks. However, there remain significant uncertainties about the nature of the threat from polluting shipwrecks in the UK. The existing studies also fail to take into account social and political influences that affect wreck management.
This research therefore critically examines the state of research and the current management of polluting shipwrecks in the UK. It does this through examination of the legal requirements to remediate wrecks and to determine who is responsible for managing these shipwrecks. It presents a critical analysis of the existing risk assessments, wreck databases and the data that underpins them to reveal the high level of uncertainty in existing studies. Finally it demonstrates that through spatial assessment of open source socio-economic datasets we can determine with more certainty the potential consequences of wreck pollution and its impacts on the UK.
The results of this research highlight issues relating to data availability and reliability which limits our ability to adequately risk assess and make decisions to pro-actively manage these wrecks. This research provides an alternative method for prioritising mitigation measures based on the spatial analysis of the socio-economic impact of wreck pollution rather than through traditional risk assessment. This allows us to examine these wrecks in a new manner and to make decisions despite high levels of uncertainty. It also allows for greater stakeholder engagement and integration into the management process. Ultimately this research presents the first holistic assessment of the management of potentially polluting wrecks in the UK.
University of Southampton
Moore, Camilla, Isobelle Clodagh
66ead5b6-a417-409d-8a2a-a6f332f450aa
2021
Moore, Camilla, Isobelle Clodagh
66ead5b6-a417-409d-8a2a-a6f332f450aa
Sturt, Fraser
442e14e1-136f-4159-bd8e-b002bf6b95f6
Dix, Justin
efbb0b6e-7dfd-47e1-ae96-92412bd45628
Tsimplis, Michael N
df6dd749-cda4-46ec-983c-bf022d737031
Moore, Camilla, Isobelle Clodagh
(2021)
The Practicalities of Managing and Mapping Potentially Polluting Shipwrecks in the UK: Legal, Social and Ethical Considerations.
University of Southampton, Doctoral Thesis, 371pp.
Record type:
Thesis
(Doctoral)
Abstract
The issue of potentially polluting wrecks is relatively unstudied in the UK despite the potential threat presented by hundreds of shipwrecks in UK waters that contain oil, chemicals and other hazardous materials. As these wrecks degrade they will inevitably release their cargoes and fuel stores into the marine environment.
While there have been studies elsewhere that examine the risk from polluting shipwrecks, the limited work that has been undertaken on this topic in the UK is restricted to a number of government commissioned reports. These have attempted to quantify and risk assess the shipwrecks that pose a pollution threat in UK waters in order to inform ongoing management of these shipwrecks. However, there remain significant uncertainties about the nature of the threat from polluting shipwrecks in the UK. The existing studies also fail to take into account social and political influences that affect wreck management.
This research therefore critically examines the state of research and the current management of polluting shipwrecks in the UK. It does this through examination of the legal requirements to remediate wrecks and to determine who is responsible for managing these shipwrecks. It presents a critical analysis of the existing risk assessments, wreck databases and the data that underpins them to reveal the high level of uncertainty in existing studies. Finally it demonstrates that through spatial assessment of open source socio-economic datasets we can determine with more certainty the potential consequences of wreck pollution and its impacts on the UK.
The results of this research highlight issues relating to data availability and reliability which limits our ability to adequately risk assess and make decisions to pro-actively manage these wrecks. This research provides an alternative method for prioritising mitigation measures based on the spatial analysis of the socio-economic impact of wreck pollution rather than through traditional risk assessment. This allows us to examine these wrecks in a new manner and to make decisions despite high levels of uncertainty. It also allows for greater stakeholder engagement and integration into the management process. Ultimately this research presents the first holistic assessment of the management of potentially polluting wrecks in the UK.
Text
PhD Thesis_Camilla Moore
- Version of Record
Text
Permission to Deposit Thesis_Camilla Moore
Restricted to Repository staff only
More information
Published date: 2021
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 451733
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/451733
PURE UUID: a66679d5-d151-4075-a681-d33c557470c9
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 22 Oct 2021 16:31
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 03:05
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Camilla, Isobelle Clodagh Moore
Thesis advisor:
Michael N Tsimplis
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics