The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Therapeutic options for CTLA-4 insufficiency

Therapeutic options for CTLA-4 insufficiency
Therapeutic options for CTLA-4 insufficiency

BACKGROUND: Heterozygous germline mutations in cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated antigen-4 (CTLA4) impair the immunomodulatory function of regulatory T cells. Affected individuals are prone to life-threatening autoimmune and lymphoproliferative complications. A number of therapeutic options are currently being used with variable effectiveness.

OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to characterize the responsiveness of patients with CTLA-4 insufficiency to specific therapies and provide recommendations for the diagnostic workup and therapy at an organ-specific level.

METHODS: Clinical features, laboratory findings, and response to treatment were reviewed retrospectively in an international cohort of 173 carriers of CTLA4 mutation. Patients were followed between 2014 and 2020 for a total of 2624 months from diagnosis. Clinical manifestations were grouped on the basis of organ-specific involvement. Medication use and response were recorded and evaluated.

RESULTS: Among the 173 CTLA4 mutation carriers, 123 (71%) had been treated for immune complications. Abatacept, rituximab, sirolimus, and corticosteroids ameliorated disease severity, especially in cases of cytopenias and lymphocytic organ infiltration of the gut, lungs, and central nervous system. Immunoglobulin replacement was effective in prevention of infection. Only 4 of 16 patients (25%) with cytopenia who underwent splenectomy had a sustained clinical response. Cure was achieved with stem cell transplantation in 13 of 18 patients (72%). As a result of the aforementioned methods, organ-specific treatment pathways were developed.

CONCLUSION: Systemic immunosuppressants and abatacept may provide partial control but require ongoing administration. Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation offers a possible cure for patients with CTLA-4 insufficiency.

CTLA-4, HSCT, LRBA, abatacept, common variable immunodeficiency, diagnosis, primary immunodeficiency, rituximab, sirolimus, treatment
0091-6749
Egg, David
e1e98776-c21c-4d5a-9271-23229a564cdb
Rump, Ina Caroline
f7f7651f-6ace-44c1-a51b-36f3758e1afa
Mitsuiki, Noriko
11fb82d3-0067-4540-bff5-c40e9b57d969
Rojas-Restrepo, Jessica
d8e945a3-e477-47a7-a3d9-834406e2b114
Maccari, Maria-Elena
fc1a56fc-d00d-42db-bb3f-5b3bb0239ac4
Schwab, Charlotte
fed72734-1b59-49a0-a9db-61d88e23560e
Gabrysch, Annemarie
b2b8352c-c36c-4534-b3b7-69cf6c4bc72f
Warnatz, Klaus
080f4e56-7e34-40f4-a218-c3a39b3a1d8d
Goldacker, Sigune
d0acc04f-662d-4aaa-bc0b-c4fa04feb05b
Patiño, Virginia
7ef87a31-9525-4927-86fb-928d86c46144
Wolff, Daniel
8be5c2ad-5a34-4e5c-924c-b4a599278a80
Okada, Satoshi
57a0b283-ddc4-41f6-8bcf-1d5f92ee4249
Hayakawa, Seiichi
e39b3fee-d077-49e2-866c-36cceaa5d25c
Shikama, Yoshiaki
7033f96a-7320-4500-b590-c7e40dfd0a27
Kanda, Kenji
d5c1123b-0477-4ceb-9951-e534044222e5
Imai, Kohsuke
a909d73f-7c80-49c9-8f85-47b534e1312a
Sotomatsu, Manabu
96a5c0f6-ac64-44de-80e9-0abd5b4e81d8
Kuwashima, Makoto
a09ab35d-0e94-4f7f-a146-b8703298b7e9
Kamiya, Takahiro
84f129ec-50b3-4143-a939-f26b6a0b076d
Morio, Tomohiro
3919ac2f-8ad0-40a5-bd41-7a11daef6ebe
Matsumoto, Kazuaki
2979aa2a-6e0c-4fa0-924d-18a50405af4c
Mori, Takeshi
8e62dbef-d1a6-4b3e-b011-4660e464a963
Yoshimoto, Yuri
02d8e9ec-80d1-4646-9034-352015c21400
Dybedal, Ingunn
4e79fcdf-4b7f-4617-b65e-9ba746bd8793
Kanariou, Maria
bc0daa17-6c4c-4abf-acbf-a92a4e09787e
Kucuk, Zeynep Yesim
353b2c02-3b30-40d5-a499-c35c71dc5a04
Chapdelaine, Hugo
5d1b47d9-972c-4398-9419-1e790d1e1e4a
Petruzelkova, Lenka
0a232ae4-17e3-4894-aacb-6733dd6f1568
Lorenz, Hanns-Martin
6be96676-8343-48e1-b2c1-b5abdbde9e72
Sullivan, Kathleen E
c7ebf537-fd99-4c92-9f59-b6c028793951
Heimall, Jennifer
ca84eda8-6340-4fa8-866d-2ebaec77f93a
Moutschen, Michel
e80775ff-bbcc-450d-a60a-31ad5e448ae5
Litzman, Jiri
0c383a9f-6fca-432c-86b1-1a63e0a326f8
Recher, Mike
09112232-0e12-4b6b-aa4d-e962169fc34c
Albert, Michael H
337e38ca-a0db-4820-8dbe-ed187646abfc
Hauck, Fabian
44ec07bb-dd1d-4c9c-b2da-60743cf7700c
Seneviratne, Suranjith
5ed30936-442d-41de-8666-a837005fab84
Pachlopnik Schmid, Jana
e49beb5d-aefb-465d-83dd-d9f0c05d8150
Kolios, Antonios
1b84496e-388d-4b92-b21c-a4f61833438f
Unglik, Gary
05a356a3-5ba0-4d1f-a2cb-7f528da01d75
Klemann, Christian
02eee389-5bec-4119-900d-1d0339a33ac5
Snapper, Scott
effdd39d-7835-410a-974e-868b711d6d54
Giulino-Roth, Lisa
9041aa89-4f6e-4203-aca7-38c2bf2dec5d
Svaton, Michael
6629d3ea-90c4-460b-b966-4176d6c8fb85
Platt, Craig D
fc07e2bd-2d9c-44c8-b4c7-d1355743f5f2
Hambleton, Sophie
284eae35-615f-4eae-adde-0f0419893c1e
Neth, Olaf
3a88236a-b4dc-4397-93de-0273610909ad
Gosse, Geraldine
6e6cb2c5-5578-4ec2-9850-afae7a681dd3
Reinsch, Steffen
d0bb50d3-390b-4598-8bb5-cd550abc8096
Holzinger, Dirk
4862fce2-6193-45ee-928c-270fb7f9ca51
Kim, Yae-Jean
2afce08b-3eb9-4266-836a-c89efe8f184b
Bakhtiar, Shahrzad
2bec77c0-b717-461f-85cc-e8025ccda206
Atschekzei, Faranaz
afb8466c-1fa6-4340-8c44-e145c6304589
Schmidt, Reinhold
76d98ff9-9234-4893-bdd1-e69e1d60ffc8
Sogkas, Georgios
24788d28-932e-45d6-a2fb-dfa73a4ecb88
Chandrakasan, Shanmuganathan
cd927405-4bb3-4933-89f6-205bacd30bfe
Rae, William
8746e0ae-b868-4356-9c89-fe78600cf427
Derfalvi, Beata
e46972d9-c58f-4246-8981-07c802fc0e4b
Marquart, Hanne Vibeke
349f1c62-5c34-41c1-ab5d-827d991c0894
Ozen, Ahmet
e9774987-9325-4220-807e-de484a2a18fd
Kiykim, Ayca
88c2bbde-4e97-483d-8848-5214ae9c3594
Karakoc-Aydiner, Elif
4bf056e3-2cf1-4a20-ac92-e19e5e176443
Králíčková, Pavlína
dabef455-5d0b-44d8-afa3-42d905a11c27
de Bree, Godelieve
fc245428-4f94-4af4-a7a8-0ebb34feedab
Kiritsi, Dimitra
fc15ccc9-9e33-44b8-8ba3-e8fd1754d516
Seidel, Markus G
caf675dd-ea3a-44f7-925a-a5df522f62e5
Kobbe, Robin
a9f6424e-d975-4521-9876-d8b56c0feb2f
Dantzer, Jennifer
4c1d8b8f-6f0f-4bde-afbb-4a42821cdb91
Alsina, Laia
c27491d9-2294-4b23-8b9f-42272b133561
Armangue, Thais
b1695209-3dd6-466e-82cf-53b7d19699e8
Lougaris, Vassilios
9eeba3ee-e566-4fec-8e36-9c8e60a7f858
Agyeman, Philipp
e1aea909-c728-40ad-b7cf-9486a40f7f4a
Nyström, Sofia
823e0177-a5c6-4224-9f5e-19db0e1c51db
Buchbinder, David
798325d3-f93b-44f9-8455-7d81f6c0a72a
Arkwright, Peter D
6c3ba71b-c1ea-4679-a28a-ef288c4764aa
Grimbacher, Bodo
76c5b722-dc7b-4df1-abd8-238f3f3652ae
Egg, David
e1e98776-c21c-4d5a-9271-23229a564cdb
Rump, Ina Caroline
f7f7651f-6ace-44c1-a51b-36f3758e1afa
Mitsuiki, Noriko
11fb82d3-0067-4540-bff5-c40e9b57d969
Rojas-Restrepo, Jessica
d8e945a3-e477-47a7-a3d9-834406e2b114
Maccari, Maria-Elena
fc1a56fc-d00d-42db-bb3f-5b3bb0239ac4
Schwab, Charlotte
fed72734-1b59-49a0-a9db-61d88e23560e
Gabrysch, Annemarie
b2b8352c-c36c-4534-b3b7-69cf6c4bc72f
Warnatz, Klaus
080f4e56-7e34-40f4-a218-c3a39b3a1d8d
Goldacker, Sigune
d0acc04f-662d-4aaa-bc0b-c4fa04feb05b
Patiño, Virginia
7ef87a31-9525-4927-86fb-928d86c46144
Wolff, Daniel
8be5c2ad-5a34-4e5c-924c-b4a599278a80
Okada, Satoshi
57a0b283-ddc4-41f6-8bcf-1d5f92ee4249
Hayakawa, Seiichi
e39b3fee-d077-49e2-866c-36cceaa5d25c
Shikama, Yoshiaki
7033f96a-7320-4500-b590-c7e40dfd0a27
Kanda, Kenji
d5c1123b-0477-4ceb-9951-e534044222e5
Imai, Kohsuke
a909d73f-7c80-49c9-8f85-47b534e1312a
Sotomatsu, Manabu
96a5c0f6-ac64-44de-80e9-0abd5b4e81d8
Kuwashima, Makoto
a09ab35d-0e94-4f7f-a146-b8703298b7e9
Kamiya, Takahiro
84f129ec-50b3-4143-a939-f26b6a0b076d
Morio, Tomohiro
3919ac2f-8ad0-40a5-bd41-7a11daef6ebe
Matsumoto, Kazuaki
2979aa2a-6e0c-4fa0-924d-18a50405af4c
Mori, Takeshi
8e62dbef-d1a6-4b3e-b011-4660e464a963
Yoshimoto, Yuri
02d8e9ec-80d1-4646-9034-352015c21400
Dybedal, Ingunn
4e79fcdf-4b7f-4617-b65e-9ba746bd8793
Kanariou, Maria
bc0daa17-6c4c-4abf-acbf-a92a4e09787e
Kucuk, Zeynep Yesim
353b2c02-3b30-40d5-a499-c35c71dc5a04
Chapdelaine, Hugo
5d1b47d9-972c-4398-9419-1e790d1e1e4a
Petruzelkova, Lenka
0a232ae4-17e3-4894-aacb-6733dd6f1568
Lorenz, Hanns-Martin
6be96676-8343-48e1-b2c1-b5abdbde9e72
Sullivan, Kathleen E
c7ebf537-fd99-4c92-9f59-b6c028793951
Heimall, Jennifer
ca84eda8-6340-4fa8-866d-2ebaec77f93a
Moutschen, Michel
e80775ff-bbcc-450d-a60a-31ad5e448ae5
Litzman, Jiri
0c383a9f-6fca-432c-86b1-1a63e0a326f8
Recher, Mike
09112232-0e12-4b6b-aa4d-e962169fc34c
Albert, Michael H
337e38ca-a0db-4820-8dbe-ed187646abfc
Hauck, Fabian
44ec07bb-dd1d-4c9c-b2da-60743cf7700c
Seneviratne, Suranjith
5ed30936-442d-41de-8666-a837005fab84
Pachlopnik Schmid, Jana
e49beb5d-aefb-465d-83dd-d9f0c05d8150
Kolios, Antonios
1b84496e-388d-4b92-b21c-a4f61833438f
Unglik, Gary
05a356a3-5ba0-4d1f-a2cb-7f528da01d75
Klemann, Christian
02eee389-5bec-4119-900d-1d0339a33ac5
Snapper, Scott
effdd39d-7835-410a-974e-868b711d6d54
Giulino-Roth, Lisa
9041aa89-4f6e-4203-aca7-38c2bf2dec5d
Svaton, Michael
6629d3ea-90c4-460b-b966-4176d6c8fb85
Platt, Craig D
fc07e2bd-2d9c-44c8-b4c7-d1355743f5f2
Hambleton, Sophie
284eae35-615f-4eae-adde-0f0419893c1e
Neth, Olaf
3a88236a-b4dc-4397-93de-0273610909ad
Gosse, Geraldine
6e6cb2c5-5578-4ec2-9850-afae7a681dd3
Reinsch, Steffen
d0bb50d3-390b-4598-8bb5-cd550abc8096
Holzinger, Dirk
4862fce2-6193-45ee-928c-270fb7f9ca51
Kim, Yae-Jean
2afce08b-3eb9-4266-836a-c89efe8f184b
Bakhtiar, Shahrzad
2bec77c0-b717-461f-85cc-e8025ccda206
Atschekzei, Faranaz
afb8466c-1fa6-4340-8c44-e145c6304589
Schmidt, Reinhold
76d98ff9-9234-4893-bdd1-e69e1d60ffc8
Sogkas, Georgios
24788d28-932e-45d6-a2fb-dfa73a4ecb88
Chandrakasan, Shanmuganathan
cd927405-4bb3-4933-89f6-205bacd30bfe
Rae, William
8746e0ae-b868-4356-9c89-fe78600cf427
Derfalvi, Beata
e46972d9-c58f-4246-8981-07c802fc0e4b
Marquart, Hanne Vibeke
349f1c62-5c34-41c1-ab5d-827d991c0894
Ozen, Ahmet
e9774987-9325-4220-807e-de484a2a18fd
Kiykim, Ayca
88c2bbde-4e97-483d-8848-5214ae9c3594
Karakoc-Aydiner, Elif
4bf056e3-2cf1-4a20-ac92-e19e5e176443
Králíčková, Pavlína
dabef455-5d0b-44d8-afa3-42d905a11c27
de Bree, Godelieve
fc245428-4f94-4af4-a7a8-0ebb34feedab
Kiritsi, Dimitra
fc15ccc9-9e33-44b8-8ba3-e8fd1754d516
Seidel, Markus G
caf675dd-ea3a-44f7-925a-a5df522f62e5
Kobbe, Robin
a9f6424e-d975-4521-9876-d8b56c0feb2f
Dantzer, Jennifer
4c1d8b8f-6f0f-4bde-afbb-4a42821cdb91
Alsina, Laia
c27491d9-2294-4b23-8b9f-42272b133561
Armangue, Thais
b1695209-3dd6-466e-82cf-53b7d19699e8
Lougaris, Vassilios
9eeba3ee-e566-4fec-8e36-9c8e60a7f858
Agyeman, Philipp
e1aea909-c728-40ad-b7cf-9486a40f7f4a
Nyström, Sofia
823e0177-a5c6-4224-9f5e-19db0e1c51db
Buchbinder, David
798325d3-f93b-44f9-8455-7d81f6c0a72a
Arkwright, Peter D
6c3ba71b-c1ea-4679-a28a-ef288c4764aa
Grimbacher, Bodo
76c5b722-dc7b-4df1-abd8-238f3f3652ae

Egg, David, Rump, Ina Caroline, Mitsuiki, Noriko, Rojas-Restrepo, Jessica, Maccari, Maria-Elena, Schwab, Charlotte, Gabrysch, Annemarie, Warnatz, Klaus, Goldacker, Sigune, Patiño, Virginia, Wolff, Daniel, Okada, Satoshi, Hayakawa, Seiichi, Shikama, Yoshiaki, Kanda, Kenji, Imai, Kohsuke, Sotomatsu, Manabu, Kuwashima, Makoto, Kamiya, Takahiro, Morio, Tomohiro, Matsumoto, Kazuaki, Mori, Takeshi, Yoshimoto, Yuri, Dybedal, Ingunn, Kanariou, Maria, Kucuk, Zeynep Yesim, Chapdelaine, Hugo, Petruzelkova, Lenka, Lorenz, Hanns-Martin, Sullivan, Kathleen E, Heimall, Jennifer, Moutschen, Michel, Litzman, Jiri, Recher, Mike, Albert, Michael H, Hauck, Fabian, Seneviratne, Suranjith, Pachlopnik Schmid, Jana, Kolios, Antonios, Unglik, Gary, Klemann, Christian, Snapper, Scott, Giulino-Roth, Lisa, Svaton, Michael, Platt, Craig D, Hambleton, Sophie, Neth, Olaf, Gosse, Geraldine, Reinsch, Steffen, Holzinger, Dirk, Kim, Yae-Jean, Bakhtiar, Shahrzad, Atschekzei, Faranaz, Schmidt, Reinhold, Sogkas, Georgios, Chandrakasan, Shanmuganathan, Rae, William, Derfalvi, Beata, Marquart, Hanne Vibeke, Ozen, Ahmet, Kiykim, Ayca, Karakoc-Aydiner, Elif, Králíčková, Pavlína, de Bree, Godelieve, Kiritsi, Dimitra, Seidel, Markus G, Kobbe, Robin, Dantzer, Jennifer, Alsina, Laia, Armangue, Thais, Lougaris, Vassilios, Agyeman, Philipp, Nyström, Sofia, Buchbinder, David, Arkwright, Peter D and Grimbacher, Bodo (2021) Therapeutic options for CTLA-4 insufficiency. Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology. (doi:10.1016/j.jaci.2021.04.039).

Record type: Article

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Heterozygous germline mutations in cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated antigen-4 (CTLA4) impair the immunomodulatory function of regulatory T cells. Affected individuals are prone to life-threatening autoimmune and lymphoproliferative complications. A number of therapeutic options are currently being used with variable effectiveness.

OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to characterize the responsiveness of patients with CTLA-4 insufficiency to specific therapies and provide recommendations for the diagnostic workup and therapy at an organ-specific level.

METHODS: Clinical features, laboratory findings, and response to treatment were reviewed retrospectively in an international cohort of 173 carriers of CTLA4 mutation. Patients were followed between 2014 and 2020 for a total of 2624 months from diagnosis. Clinical manifestations were grouped on the basis of organ-specific involvement. Medication use and response were recorded and evaluated.

RESULTS: Among the 173 CTLA4 mutation carriers, 123 (71%) had been treated for immune complications. Abatacept, rituximab, sirolimus, and corticosteroids ameliorated disease severity, especially in cases of cytopenias and lymphocytic organ infiltration of the gut, lungs, and central nervous system. Immunoglobulin replacement was effective in prevention of infection. Only 4 of 16 patients (25%) with cytopenia who underwent splenectomy had a sustained clinical response. Cure was achieved with stem cell transplantation in 13 of 18 patients (72%). As a result of the aforementioned methods, organ-specific treatment pathways were developed.

CONCLUSION: Systemic immunosuppressants and abatacept may provide partial control but require ongoing administration. Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation offers a possible cure for patients with CTLA-4 insufficiency.

Text
1-s2.0-S0091674921008915-main - Proof
Restricted to Repository staff only

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 23 April 2021
e-pub ahead of print date: 7 June 2021
Keywords: CTLA-4, HSCT, LRBA, abatacept, common variable immunodeficiency, diagnosis, primary immunodeficiency, rituximab, sirolimus, treatment

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 452798
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/452798
ISSN: 0091-6749
PURE UUID: 37edd8c3-6edd-487a-9aa3-a108cd11e594

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 20 Dec 2021 17:51
Last modified: 10 May 2024 17:00

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: David Egg
Author: Ina Caroline Rump
Author: Noriko Mitsuiki
Author: Jessica Rojas-Restrepo
Author: Maria-Elena Maccari
Author: Charlotte Schwab
Author: Annemarie Gabrysch
Author: Klaus Warnatz
Author: Sigune Goldacker
Author: Virginia Patiño
Author: Daniel Wolff
Author: Satoshi Okada
Author: Seiichi Hayakawa
Author: Yoshiaki Shikama
Author: Kenji Kanda
Author: Kohsuke Imai
Author: Manabu Sotomatsu
Author: Makoto Kuwashima
Author: Takahiro Kamiya
Author: Tomohiro Morio
Author: Kazuaki Matsumoto
Author: Takeshi Mori
Author: Yuri Yoshimoto
Author: Ingunn Dybedal
Author: Maria Kanariou
Author: Zeynep Yesim Kucuk
Author: Hugo Chapdelaine
Author: Lenka Petruzelkova
Author: Hanns-Martin Lorenz
Author: Kathleen E Sullivan
Author: Jennifer Heimall
Author: Michel Moutschen
Author: Jiri Litzman
Author: Mike Recher
Author: Michael H Albert
Author: Fabian Hauck
Author: Suranjith Seneviratne
Author: Jana Pachlopnik Schmid
Author: Antonios Kolios
Author: Gary Unglik
Author: Christian Klemann
Author: Scott Snapper
Author: Lisa Giulino-Roth
Author: Michael Svaton
Author: Craig D Platt
Author: Sophie Hambleton
Author: Olaf Neth
Author: Geraldine Gosse
Author: Steffen Reinsch
Author: Dirk Holzinger
Author: Yae-Jean Kim
Author: Shahrzad Bakhtiar
Author: Faranaz Atschekzei
Author: Reinhold Schmidt
Author: Georgios Sogkas
Author: Shanmuganathan Chandrakasan
Author: William Rae
Author: Beata Derfalvi
Author: Hanne Vibeke Marquart
Author: Ahmet Ozen
Author: Ayca Kiykim
Author: Elif Karakoc-Aydiner
Author: Pavlína Králíčková
Author: Godelieve de Bree
Author: Dimitra Kiritsi
Author: Markus G Seidel
Author: Robin Kobbe
Author: Jennifer Dantzer
Author: Laia Alsina
Author: Thais Armangue
Author: Vassilios Lougaris
Author: Philipp Agyeman
Author: Sofia Nyström
Author: David Buchbinder
Author: Peter D Arkwright
Author: Bodo Grimbacher

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×