The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Reporting the whole story: analysis of the ‘out-of-scope’ questions from the James Lind Alliance Teenage and Young Adult Cancer Priority Setting Partnership Survey

Reporting the whole story: analysis of the ‘out-of-scope’ questions from the James Lind Alliance Teenage and Young Adult Cancer Priority Setting Partnership Survey
Reporting the whole story: analysis of the ‘out-of-scope’ questions from the James Lind Alliance Teenage and Young Adult Cancer Priority Setting Partnership Survey

Objective: we conducted a UK-wide survey to identify the top 10 research questions for young people's cancer. We conducted secondary analysis of questions submitted, which were ‘out-of-scope’ of the original survey aim. We sought to disseminate these questions, to inform practice, policy and the development of potential interventions to support young people with cancer. Design: James Lind Alliance Priority Setting Partnership. 

Participants: young people aged 13-24 with a current/previous cancer diagnosis, their families/friends/partners and professionals who work with this population. Methods: Eight hundred and fifty-five potential research questions were submitted, and 326 were classified as ‘out-of-scope’. These questions, along with 49 ‘free-text’ comments, were analysed using thematic analysis. 

Results: the 375 out-of-scope questions and comments were submitted by: 68 young people, 81 family members/partners/friends and 42 professionals. Ten overarching themes were identified: diagnostic experience; communication; coordination of care; information needs and lack of information; service provision; long-term effects and aftercare support; family support; financial impact; end-of life care; and research methods and current research. 

Conclusions: the need to tailor services, information and communication is a striking thread evidenced across the ‘out-of-scope’ questions. Gaps in information highlight implications for practice in revisiting information needs throughout the cancer trajectory. We must advocate for specialist care for young people and promote the research priorities and these findings to funding bodies, charities, young people and health and social care policymakers, in order to generate an evidence base to inform effective interventions across the cancer trajectory and improve outcomes. 

Patient/public contributions: patients and carers were equal stakeholders throughout.

cancer, information, James Lind Alliance, support, teenage, young adult
1369-6513
1593-1606
Gibson, Faith
b537d483-3f20-4f15-a9b8-880758746728
Fern, Lorna A.
22366d52-db1b-4eda-8c35-6f1991e35d8e
Phillips, Bob
11d4e5d1-e11f-4e9c-a9f2-8107e0f3e59d
Gravestock, Helen
7bfd276c-426c-4195-a570-88ff46aa62f0
Malik, Sonia
591f57bf-6a23-440d-b6b4-5f2419b968c4
Callaghan, Amy
62e99e46-fcb4-4f77-b4fb-c2def945acdc
Dyker, Karen
5e17a631-3d76-4322-95d1-4bdefcd33010
Groszmann, Mike
f02e0ae6-dc82-403c-9c0d-97e4acaec9dd
Hamrang, Leila
c066292a-62b2-4e21-a507-1391fdb5f5ee
Hough, Rachael
f098c75d-4163-41c5-830a-a790e0cfaba5
McGeachy, Demi
7ef94f86-e3e3-4698-ae67-784b2de215af
Morgan, Sue
8e4169ad-6cfd-4c75-80f5-3489a0ac4304
Smith, Sam
df3f0c0f-e8d2-4b8b-b9b8-0d5b1178d2ea
Upadhyaya, Sheela
f45d08a7-198f-408a-88d3-075912d38266
Veitch, Helen
9e7845ce-da4e-4061-8360-0fb538c8b914
Williamson, Max
964b7433-7e27-4f24-9184-793204fb7509
Whelan, Jeremy
4bf4a3ce-4f83-4927-a3dd-8007110e9cf9
Aldiss, Susie
1731ec9b-2fbb-4cbb-929c-a2eaadf0243b
Gibson, Faith
b537d483-3f20-4f15-a9b8-880758746728
Fern, Lorna A.
22366d52-db1b-4eda-8c35-6f1991e35d8e
Phillips, Bob
11d4e5d1-e11f-4e9c-a9f2-8107e0f3e59d
Gravestock, Helen
7bfd276c-426c-4195-a570-88ff46aa62f0
Malik, Sonia
591f57bf-6a23-440d-b6b4-5f2419b968c4
Callaghan, Amy
62e99e46-fcb4-4f77-b4fb-c2def945acdc
Dyker, Karen
5e17a631-3d76-4322-95d1-4bdefcd33010
Groszmann, Mike
f02e0ae6-dc82-403c-9c0d-97e4acaec9dd
Hamrang, Leila
c066292a-62b2-4e21-a507-1391fdb5f5ee
Hough, Rachael
f098c75d-4163-41c5-830a-a790e0cfaba5
McGeachy, Demi
7ef94f86-e3e3-4698-ae67-784b2de215af
Morgan, Sue
8e4169ad-6cfd-4c75-80f5-3489a0ac4304
Smith, Sam
df3f0c0f-e8d2-4b8b-b9b8-0d5b1178d2ea
Upadhyaya, Sheela
f45d08a7-198f-408a-88d3-075912d38266
Veitch, Helen
9e7845ce-da4e-4061-8360-0fb538c8b914
Williamson, Max
964b7433-7e27-4f24-9184-793204fb7509
Whelan, Jeremy
4bf4a3ce-4f83-4927-a3dd-8007110e9cf9
Aldiss, Susie
1731ec9b-2fbb-4cbb-929c-a2eaadf0243b

Gibson, Faith, Fern, Lorna A., Phillips, Bob, Gravestock, Helen, Malik, Sonia, Callaghan, Amy, Dyker, Karen, Groszmann, Mike, Hamrang, Leila, Hough, Rachael, McGeachy, Demi, Morgan, Sue, Smith, Sam, Upadhyaya, Sheela, Veitch, Helen, Williamson, Max, Whelan, Jeremy and Aldiss, Susie (2021) Reporting the whole story: analysis of the ‘out-of-scope’ questions from the James Lind Alliance Teenage and Young Adult Cancer Priority Setting Partnership Survey. Health Expectations, 24 (5), 1593-1606. (doi:10.1111/hex.13276).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Objective: we conducted a UK-wide survey to identify the top 10 research questions for young people's cancer. We conducted secondary analysis of questions submitted, which were ‘out-of-scope’ of the original survey aim. We sought to disseminate these questions, to inform practice, policy and the development of potential interventions to support young people with cancer. Design: James Lind Alliance Priority Setting Partnership. 

Participants: young people aged 13-24 with a current/previous cancer diagnosis, their families/friends/partners and professionals who work with this population. Methods: Eight hundred and fifty-five potential research questions were submitted, and 326 were classified as ‘out-of-scope’. These questions, along with 49 ‘free-text’ comments, were analysed using thematic analysis. 

Results: the 375 out-of-scope questions and comments were submitted by: 68 young people, 81 family members/partners/friends and 42 professionals. Ten overarching themes were identified: diagnostic experience; communication; coordination of care; information needs and lack of information; service provision; long-term effects and aftercare support; family support; financial impact; end-of life care; and research methods and current research. 

Conclusions: the need to tailor services, information and communication is a striking thread evidenced across the ‘out-of-scope’ questions. Gaps in information highlight implications for practice in revisiting information needs throughout the cancer trajectory. We must advocate for specialist care for young people and promote the research priorities and these findings to funding bodies, charities, young people and health and social care policymakers, in order to generate an evidence base to inform effective interventions across the cancer trajectory and improve outcomes. 

Patient/public contributions: patients and carers were equal stakeholders throughout.

Text
Health Expectations - 2021 - Gibson - Reporting the whole story Analysis of the out‐of‐scope questions from the James - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (284kB)

More information

e-pub ahead of print date: 10 July 2021
Published date: October 2021
Additional Information: Funding Information: This work was supported by Teenage Cancer Trust, Young Lives vs Cancer and Children with Cancer UK. Lorna Fern is funded by Teenage Cancer Trust. Faith Gibson receives some support from the NIHR Great Ormond Street Hospital Biomedical Research Centre Publisher Copyright: © 2021 The Authors. Health Expectations published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd. Copyright: Copyright 2021 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
Keywords: cancer, information, James Lind Alliance, support, teenage, young adult

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 453445
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/453445
ISSN: 1369-6513
PURE UUID: 04cd2d44-320e-4185-9692-309e169a86bc

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 17 Jan 2022 17:44
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 12:48

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Faith Gibson
Author: Lorna A. Fern
Author: Bob Phillips
Author: Helen Gravestock
Author: Sonia Malik
Author: Amy Callaghan
Author: Karen Dyker
Author: Mike Groszmann
Author: Leila Hamrang
Author: Rachael Hough
Author: Demi McGeachy
Author: Sue Morgan
Author: Sam Smith
Author: Sheela Upadhyaya
Author: Helen Veitch
Author: Max Williamson
Author: Jeremy Whelan
Author: Susie Aldiss

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×