Whole genome sequencing for the diagnosis of neurological repeat expansion disorders in the UK: a retrospective diagnostic accuracy and prospective clinical validation study
Whole genome sequencing for the diagnosis of neurological repeat expansion disorders in the UK: a retrospective diagnostic accuracy and prospective clinical validation study
Background: repeat expansion disorders affect about 1 in 3000 individuals and are clinically heterogeneous diseases caused by expansions of short tandem DNA repeats. Genetic testing is often locus-specific, resulting in underdiagnosis of people who have atypical clinical presentations, especially in paediatric patients without a previous positive family history. Whole genome sequencing is increasingly used as a first-line test for other rare genetic disorders, and we aimed to assess its performance in the diagnosis of patients with neurological repeat expansion disorders.
Methods: we retrospectively assessed the diagnostic accuracy of whole genome sequencing to detect the most common repeat expansion loci associated with neurological outcomes (AR, ATN1, ATXN1, ATXN2, ATXN3, ATXN7, C9orf72, CACNA1A, DMPK, FMR1, FXN, HTT, and TBP) using samples obtained within the National Health Service in England from patients who were suspected of having neurological disorders; previous PCR test results were used as the reference standard. The clinical accuracy of whole genome sequencing to detect repeat expansions was prospectively examined in previously genetically tested and undiagnosed patients recruited in 2013–17 to the 100 000 Genomes Project in the UK, who were suspected of having a genetic neurological disorder (familial or early-onset forms of ataxia, neuropathy, spastic paraplegia, dementia, motor neuron disease, parkinsonian movement disorders, intellectual disability, or neuromuscular disorders). If a repeat expansion call was made using whole genome sequencing, PCR was used to confirm the result.
Findings: the diagnostic accuracy of whole genome sequencing to detect repeat expansions was evaluated against 793 PCR tests previously performed within the NHS from 404 patients. Whole genome sequencing correctly classified 215 of 221 expanded alleles and 1316 of 1321 non-expanded alleles, showing 97·3% sensitivity (95% CI 94·2–99·0) and 99·6% specificity (99·1–99·9) across the 13 disease-associated loci when compared with PCR test results. In samples from 11 631 patients in the 100 000 Genomes Project, whole genome sequencing identified 81 repeat expansions, which were also tested by PCR: 68 were confirmed as repeat expansions in the full pathogenic range, 11 were non-pathogenic intermediate expansions or premutations, and two were non-expanded repeats (16% false discovery rate). Interpretation: In our study, whole genome sequencing for the detection of repeat expansions showed high sensitivity and specificity, and it led to identification of neurological repeat expansion disorders in previously undiagnosed patients. These findings support implementation of whole genome sequencing in clinical laboratories for diagnosis of patients who have a neurological presentation consistent with a repeat expansion disorder. Funding: Medical Research Council, Department of Health and Social Care, National Health Service England, National Institute for Health Research, and Illumina.
234-245
Ibañez, Kristina
1a0e5b87-290d-4611-b8e9-cb4777d46022
Polke, James
c8152539-6225-4f96-954e-a036001a7956
Hagelstrom, R Tanner
b736007b-ab9f-4e1b-bdd4-34f011b269d4
Dolzhenko, Egor
97e442c5-5704-4f62-953c-17b7f29c41ab
Pasko, Dorota
64200766-2e03-43aa-a0f7-fb6e28f03e93
Thomas, Ellen Rachel Amy
8d6bf669-1c29-4558-8899-0976bd3534af
Daugherty, Louise C
396036cd-b6cc-4259-a7b1-a5c6b8dcf4f4
Kasperaviciute, Dalia
aa5a5cbe-8e46-4f57-94a2-0763eb504b07
Smith, Katherine R
e664f862-2631-40a4-b994-e7ef4e488312
Deans, Zandra C
c0246abe-844c-4a2f-b668-2f31f73c2c52
Hill, Sue
5c2aafea-5e01-47b5-88df-5f3acd94109e
Fowler, Tom
03a661df-122d-4617-8167-ca57c4062697
Scott, Richard H
19488755-f941-45d3-985b-dc0ab1e647d2
Hardy, John
7d6a3558-4b3a-4c69-953f-3f8a7d162dca
Chinnery, Patrick F
87789d1a-5265-4815-9f11-194ed9b4ad94
Houlden, Henry
b4cd8392-164c-4d35-8933-690a804ebb18
Rendon, Augusto
35e857eb-2076-4333-ba18-774366383320
Caulfield, Mark J
a13960ad-3f25-453e-a127-2913a935d73a
Eberle, Michael A
bbd86de7-da8b-46a1-b739-942992ab06fb
Taft, Ryan J
9945ca3f-a67f-43d2-992d-9d1a34e5404a
Tucci, Arianna
0115c333-64ef-4264-8cf2-9690e64646e6
Ambrose, John C.
bb4c6caa-2a38-4cb9-9a45-f386e23ddf33
Arumugam, Prabhu
91b24ee5-5dc1-4bbc-888c-fc5d2292bb09
Bleda, Marta
9c54656c-0117-4596-b452-07d41b776e94
Boardman-pretty, Freya
b928cc82-f967-4ba2-a6f3-105090e3099c
Boissiere, Jeanne M.
30236fd3-5ad3-47d6-9762-c51ba213182a
Boustred, Christopher R.
b6bd0260-df39-4bc2-942a-d8012f2e36d9
Craig, Clare E.h.
9265ae08-1108-4efc-9541-ac20c572769e
De Burca, Anna
0d921774-009a-43e1-a895-1a8d9594da00
Devereau, Andrew
c9b0681b-4160-45ab-af48-e4a52d93d979
Elgar, Greg
bbc4b75f-bf92-464e-ad2e-ff8c4c68ddf9
Foulger, Rebecca E.
ab5bb433-6518-4b1d-88d7-6279305e5765
Furió-tarí, Pedro
6e03b29d-94df-437f-9299-ea2ab228385c
Hackett, Joanne
72dd386b-378f-46e4-bee7-93d1946066c4
Halai, Dina
c7a228e8-f48e-4f6d-88b7-d7f376ada393
Hamblin, Angela
869c19be-0ec1-49b9-84ef-1d504f9e9643
Henderson, Shirley
c0b1898d-0f51-41f6-885a-0b7fb32822bf
Holman, James
c6c2fe8b-3973-42a7-9ec1-af8bd6162078
Hubbard, Tim J.p.
8a138795-6590-4999-bd50-fc3640efbded
Jackson, Rob
bcfe3587-04a4-4b46-bfd7-40660be78eb2
Jones, Louise J.
a6a6c58f-c843-42c7-8832-7c970959610c
Kayikci, Melis
c6e727a9-c4a1-4b94-86ac-6a428f8037b5
Lahnstein, Lea
a53d67b7-527d-49f5-bb96-cd82b0ede391
Lawson, Kay
2966a0d3-7880-46a5-911a-e0afdc72dba3
Leigh, Sarah E.a.
5dde1a74-37da-4a2d-a2d2-c01fcbb69096
Leong, Ivonne U.s.
7bb55fb9-9b4a-4eb5-8f57-b6ece4591a46
Lopez, Javier F.
86605b42-d718-4405-bed7-6e39124a2fb8
Maleady-crowe, Fiona
34c6f05f-364f-4611-8091-1bd48eeba3bc
Mason, Joanne
48823d29-62ae-4289-9758-88e0b2bc75a7
Mueller, Michael
8d83f393-377c-4684-a20e-4c35ea5d6d89
Murugaesu, Nirupa
9a87953f-293f-4ac2-8f93-bfbae1d1682f
Odhams, Chris A.
c4cc6d1d-e859-4e9c-8011-c2f5057393df
Perez-gil, Daniel
0d9bc613-dafe-4caf-9a76-526af72de7f4
Polychronopoulos, Dimitris
f5a5c3f1-7c43-4e3d-a894-9b864c1ba041
Pullinger, John
abbec6db-4987-4e0b-b5ed-8c761311306d
Rahim, Tahrima
cd0548e1-e677-40d8-9492-13ff8f5a0d57
Riesgo-ferreiro, Pablo
74426295-4ea9-400c-aa1f-b0dbc7f8731c
Rogers, Tim
c798f5bc-8820-4d71-91f2-c22966c0647d
Ryten, Mina
99212861-9f03-479b-9478-09dc6dd168d9
Savage, Kevin
b024d903-39ab-4c11-9352-1641a38a3af5
Sawant, Kushmita
ea9bec2a-5065-48d4-ad87-92da64b0b593
Siddiq, Afshan
d21875ef-1bff-48db-b0c3-aac8badd9cf6
Sieghart, Alexander
464815ec-25b2-4343-b484-00043e30ce02
Smedley, Damian
e10e5b38-5efb-4b50-ae2b-8e7bb9fd2916
Sosinsky, Alona
7b95221b-1dca-4cb4-85cf-f4be2052e217
Spooner, William
628a876c-39a8-4f58-a80f-1ddfd7c08798
Stevens, Helen E.
ecf51b50-36f9-4915-9a93-27d09f6a72e2
Stuckey, Alexander
aa5e1785-fa3e-428c-8883-eb4f6d3f554f
Sultana, Razvan
49400774-e17e-4547-9e89-72ed05285999
Thompson, Simon R.
bb9b871b-b0d9-434c-bd9c-d04e0b62c73d
Tregidgo, Carolyn
66fa5f47-61f7-4474-b384-db6285bc8646
Walsh, Emma
8b9bc675-048d-46fc-ba1b-5b95d127a99c
Watters, Sarah A.
99cf1005-b3a8-40c0-aa9b-2c6be77b12ff
Welland, Matthew J.
a09cdb70-b7a3-43cd-a3a5-b0e86c37d9df
Williams, Eleanor
52f03ad5-98e8-427a-b7f8-968e20769cd5
Witkowska, Katarzyna
6fee5679-7c65-4fdd-b860-78d563dfca63
Wood, Suzanne M.
76e19852-5703-42a0-b554-05aad0527cba
Zarowiecki, Magdalena
0890c6b4-e07a-4952-af54-462ce1a490cf
Temple, Karen
d63e7c66-9fb0-46c8-855d-ee2607e6c226
1 March 2022
Ibañez, Kristina
1a0e5b87-290d-4611-b8e9-cb4777d46022
Polke, James
c8152539-6225-4f96-954e-a036001a7956
Hagelstrom, R Tanner
b736007b-ab9f-4e1b-bdd4-34f011b269d4
Dolzhenko, Egor
97e442c5-5704-4f62-953c-17b7f29c41ab
Pasko, Dorota
64200766-2e03-43aa-a0f7-fb6e28f03e93
Thomas, Ellen Rachel Amy
8d6bf669-1c29-4558-8899-0976bd3534af
Daugherty, Louise C
396036cd-b6cc-4259-a7b1-a5c6b8dcf4f4
Kasperaviciute, Dalia
aa5a5cbe-8e46-4f57-94a2-0763eb504b07
Smith, Katherine R
e664f862-2631-40a4-b994-e7ef4e488312
Deans, Zandra C
c0246abe-844c-4a2f-b668-2f31f73c2c52
Hill, Sue
5c2aafea-5e01-47b5-88df-5f3acd94109e
Fowler, Tom
03a661df-122d-4617-8167-ca57c4062697
Scott, Richard H
19488755-f941-45d3-985b-dc0ab1e647d2
Hardy, John
7d6a3558-4b3a-4c69-953f-3f8a7d162dca
Chinnery, Patrick F
87789d1a-5265-4815-9f11-194ed9b4ad94
Houlden, Henry
b4cd8392-164c-4d35-8933-690a804ebb18
Rendon, Augusto
35e857eb-2076-4333-ba18-774366383320
Caulfield, Mark J
a13960ad-3f25-453e-a127-2913a935d73a
Eberle, Michael A
bbd86de7-da8b-46a1-b739-942992ab06fb
Taft, Ryan J
9945ca3f-a67f-43d2-992d-9d1a34e5404a
Tucci, Arianna
0115c333-64ef-4264-8cf2-9690e64646e6
Ambrose, John C.
bb4c6caa-2a38-4cb9-9a45-f386e23ddf33
Arumugam, Prabhu
91b24ee5-5dc1-4bbc-888c-fc5d2292bb09
Bleda, Marta
9c54656c-0117-4596-b452-07d41b776e94
Boardman-pretty, Freya
b928cc82-f967-4ba2-a6f3-105090e3099c
Boissiere, Jeanne M.
30236fd3-5ad3-47d6-9762-c51ba213182a
Boustred, Christopher R.
b6bd0260-df39-4bc2-942a-d8012f2e36d9
Craig, Clare E.h.
9265ae08-1108-4efc-9541-ac20c572769e
De Burca, Anna
0d921774-009a-43e1-a895-1a8d9594da00
Devereau, Andrew
c9b0681b-4160-45ab-af48-e4a52d93d979
Elgar, Greg
bbc4b75f-bf92-464e-ad2e-ff8c4c68ddf9
Foulger, Rebecca E.
ab5bb433-6518-4b1d-88d7-6279305e5765
Furió-tarí, Pedro
6e03b29d-94df-437f-9299-ea2ab228385c
Hackett, Joanne
72dd386b-378f-46e4-bee7-93d1946066c4
Halai, Dina
c7a228e8-f48e-4f6d-88b7-d7f376ada393
Hamblin, Angela
869c19be-0ec1-49b9-84ef-1d504f9e9643
Henderson, Shirley
c0b1898d-0f51-41f6-885a-0b7fb32822bf
Holman, James
c6c2fe8b-3973-42a7-9ec1-af8bd6162078
Hubbard, Tim J.p.
8a138795-6590-4999-bd50-fc3640efbded
Jackson, Rob
bcfe3587-04a4-4b46-bfd7-40660be78eb2
Jones, Louise J.
a6a6c58f-c843-42c7-8832-7c970959610c
Kayikci, Melis
c6e727a9-c4a1-4b94-86ac-6a428f8037b5
Lahnstein, Lea
a53d67b7-527d-49f5-bb96-cd82b0ede391
Lawson, Kay
2966a0d3-7880-46a5-911a-e0afdc72dba3
Leigh, Sarah E.a.
5dde1a74-37da-4a2d-a2d2-c01fcbb69096
Leong, Ivonne U.s.
7bb55fb9-9b4a-4eb5-8f57-b6ece4591a46
Lopez, Javier F.
86605b42-d718-4405-bed7-6e39124a2fb8
Maleady-crowe, Fiona
34c6f05f-364f-4611-8091-1bd48eeba3bc
Mason, Joanne
48823d29-62ae-4289-9758-88e0b2bc75a7
Mueller, Michael
8d83f393-377c-4684-a20e-4c35ea5d6d89
Murugaesu, Nirupa
9a87953f-293f-4ac2-8f93-bfbae1d1682f
Odhams, Chris A.
c4cc6d1d-e859-4e9c-8011-c2f5057393df
Perez-gil, Daniel
0d9bc613-dafe-4caf-9a76-526af72de7f4
Polychronopoulos, Dimitris
f5a5c3f1-7c43-4e3d-a894-9b864c1ba041
Pullinger, John
abbec6db-4987-4e0b-b5ed-8c761311306d
Rahim, Tahrima
cd0548e1-e677-40d8-9492-13ff8f5a0d57
Riesgo-ferreiro, Pablo
74426295-4ea9-400c-aa1f-b0dbc7f8731c
Rogers, Tim
c798f5bc-8820-4d71-91f2-c22966c0647d
Ryten, Mina
99212861-9f03-479b-9478-09dc6dd168d9
Savage, Kevin
b024d903-39ab-4c11-9352-1641a38a3af5
Sawant, Kushmita
ea9bec2a-5065-48d4-ad87-92da64b0b593
Siddiq, Afshan
d21875ef-1bff-48db-b0c3-aac8badd9cf6
Sieghart, Alexander
464815ec-25b2-4343-b484-00043e30ce02
Smedley, Damian
e10e5b38-5efb-4b50-ae2b-8e7bb9fd2916
Sosinsky, Alona
7b95221b-1dca-4cb4-85cf-f4be2052e217
Spooner, William
628a876c-39a8-4f58-a80f-1ddfd7c08798
Stevens, Helen E.
ecf51b50-36f9-4915-9a93-27d09f6a72e2
Stuckey, Alexander
aa5e1785-fa3e-428c-8883-eb4f6d3f554f
Sultana, Razvan
49400774-e17e-4547-9e89-72ed05285999
Thompson, Simon R.
bb9b871b-b0d9-434c-bd9c-d04e0b62c73d
Tregidgo, Carolyn
66fa5f47-61f7-4474-b384-db6285bc8646
Walsh, Emma
8b9bc675-048d-46fc-ba1b-5b95d127a99c
Watters, Sarah A.
99cf1005-b3a8-40c0-aa9b-2c6be77b12ff
Welland, Matthew J.
a09cdb70-b7a3-43cd-a3a5-b0e86c37d9df
Williams, Eleanor
52f03ad5-98e8-427a-b7f8-968e20769cd5
Witkowska, Katarzyna
6fee5679-7c65-4fdd-b860-78d563dfca63
Wood, Suzanne M.
76e19852-5703-42a0-b554-05aad0527cba
Zarowiecki, Magdalena
0890c6b4-e07a-4952-af54-462ce1a490cf
Temple, Karen
d63e7c66-9fb0-46c8-855d-ee2607e6c226