The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Time for revival of bone biopsy with histomorphometric analysis in chronic kidney disease (CKD): moving from skepticism to pragmatism.

Time for revival of bone biopsy with histomorphometric analysis in chronic kidney disease (CKD): moving from skepticism to pragmatism.
Time for revival of bone biopsy with histomorphometric analysis in chronic kidney disease (CKD): moving from skepticism to pragmatism.

Bone Biopsy (BB) with histomorphometric analysis still represents the gold standard for the diagnosis and classification of different forms of renal osteodystrophy. Bone biopsy is the only technique able to provide comprehensive information on all bone parameters, measuring static and dynamic parameters of turnover, cortical and trabecular microarchitecture, and mineralization defects. In nephrological practice, bone biopsy yields relevant indications to support therapeutic choices in CKD, heavily impacting the management and prognosis of uremic patients. Unfortunately, the use of bone biopsy has decreased; a lack of expertise in performing and interpreting, perceived procedure invasiveness and pain, and reimbursement issues have all contributed to this decline. Nevertheless, both bone biomarkers and instrumental images cannot be considered reliable surrogates for histological findings, being insufficiently accurate to properly evaluate underlying mineral and bone disorders. This is a multidisciplinary position paper from the Nephrology and Osteoporosis Italian Scientific Societies with the purpose of restating the role of bone biopsy in CKD patient management and of providing strong solutions to allow diffusion of this technique in Italy, but potentially also in other countries. The Italian approach through the optimization and standardization of bone biopsy procedure, the construction of the Italian Hub and Spoke network, and a request for adjustment and national homogenization of reimbursement to the Italian Health Ministry has led the way to implement bone biopsy and to improve CKD patient management and prognosis.

CKD-MBD, bone biopsy, chronic kidney disease, fractures, osteoporosis, renal osteodystrophy
2072-6643
Fusaro, Maria
983d9f7c-bd89-4367-bc35-39b5259367d3
Re Sarto, Giulia Vanessa
5e998dc2-a45e-45ce-9bc7-305aa424f786
Gallieni, Maurizio
f023f4cc-07ae-4fca-9735-f9a9f261e41e
Cosmai, Laura
febb1a4c-da83-4980-bc14-b18d6ca91e43
Messa, Pieregiorgio
8de37ead-fb75-4123-804e-de85ad13bab2
Rossini, Maurizio
8edfffaa-db68-48c5-8c8d-180ec75e35b3
Chiodini, Iacopo
dc3a9875-e1aa-4e21-a08f-01e331a3eb26
Plebani, Mario
748a0f7b-ca3c-49c8-96a8-e339562d2a9e
Evenepoel, Pieter
20c46a65-fce6-444f-aa2d-c30120ed5e1d
Harvey, Nicholas
ce487fb4-d360-4aac-9d17-9466d6cba145
Ferrari, S.
aa19a7ab-b6a7-4abb-a38c-7e972084fa42
Cannata-Andía, Jorge B
b9314500-f7e6-4e5f-9f81-0977fea91652
Trombetti, Andrea
dc9047ef-75af-408c-861c-1ecd80120832
Brandi, Maria Luisa
b42820a8-1622-4a0d-8f9b-3f53f2e90180
Ketteler, Markus
bda423e3-a298-4101-9247-952da4bb8d5d
Nickolas, Thomas L.
928065d5-47bb-4cf7-8084-8d33fccde988
Cunningham, John
343fb89e-5c58-48c4-b1a5-a1e491797d91
Salam, Syazrah
4f911b1b-b3df-45dc-b1de-68bca210ae58
Rocca, Carlo Della
2c3bb948-94dd-44ea-a29d-7c1915c0bb6e
Scarpa, Aldo
01018ec1-a965-42e1-91b8-326f7babaacf
Minisola, Salvatore
bb6a66ba-66be-46fc-8721-c33848a4b073
Malberti, Fabio
9dd644ec-ef4f-4cb1-8d26-96441279f34e
Cetani, Filomena
38c3ffa6-f4e7-4955-bb57-cef0afd2761a
Cozzolino, Mario
8fae637b-aafd-482d-afb1-783517a62b47
Mazzaferro, Sandro
c6584be6-6836-443f-adc2-bbbc97655f7b
Morrone, Luigi
76358dff-c05b-4f00-82c5-b0b170771ce9
Tripepi, Giovanni
5e5ea5bf-9052-443b-a6c1-fd9033160077
Zaninotto, Martina
73f7ba5e-66bb-4d43-850d-a0af31e417de
Mereu, Maria Cristina
74f27398-f5d6-433f-8752-a15a0d66ba82
Ravera, Maura
e99269cb-b395-4414-8477-c298fa398738
Cianciolo, Giuseppe
ab4a8321-83f9-4fcb-80ae-0a45f53abff9
La Manna, Gaetano
4bade75f-1581-4530-9b4e-bf859db77a45
Aghi, Andrea
06936e75-865c-4bf5-a6af-1759b35cc15a
Giannini, Sandro
bd886084-213f-450e-ac93-3cb7a5f71997
Dalle Carbonare, Luca
805c02db-c72a-49fd-9774-2675850fe789
Fusaro, Maria
983d9f7c-bd89-4367-bc35-39b5259367d3
Re Sarto, Giulia Vanessa
5e998dc2-a45e-45ce-9bc7-305aa424f786
Gallieni, Maurizio
f023f4cc-07ae-4fca-9735-f9a9f261e41e
Cosmai, Laura
febb1a4c-da83-4980-bc14-b18d6ca91e43
Messa, Pieregiorgio
8de37ead-fb75-4123-804e-de85ad13bab2
Rossini, Maurizio
8edfffaa-db68-48c5-8c8d-180ec75e35b3
Chiodini, Iacopo
dc3a9875-e1aa-4e21-a08f-01e331a3eb26
Plebani, Mario
748a0f7b-ca3c-49c8-96a8-e339562d2a9e
Evenepoel, Pieter
20c46a65-fce6-444f-aa2d-c30120ed5e1d
Harvey, Nicholas
ce487fb4-d360-4aac-9d17-9466d6cba145
Ferrari, S.
aa19a7ab-b6a7-4abb-a38c-7e972084fa42
Cannata-Andía, Jorge B
b9314500-f7e6-4e5f-9f81-0977fea91652
Trombetti, Andrea
dc9047ef-75af-408c-861c-1ecd80120832
Brandi, Maria Luisa
b42820a8-1622-4a0d-8f9b-3f53f2e90180
Ketteler, Markus
bda423e3-a298-4101-9247-952da4bb8d5d
Nickolas, Thomas L.
928065d5-47bb-4cf7-8084-8d33fccde988
Cunningham, John
343fb89e-5c58-48c4-b1a5-a1e491797d91
Salam, Syazrah
4f911b1b-b3df-45dc-b1de-68bca210ae58
Rocca, Carlo Della
2c3bb948-94dd-44ea-a29d-7c1915c0bb6e
Scarpa, Aldo
01018ec1-a965-42e1-91b8-326f7babaacf
Minisola, Salvatore
bb6a66ba-66be-46fc-8721-c33848a4b073
Malberti, Fabio
9dd644ec-ef4f-4cb1-8d26-96441279f34e
Cetani, Filomena
38c3ffa6-f4e7-4955-bb57-cef0afd2761a
Cozzolino, Mario
8fae637b-aafd-482d-afb1-783517a62b47
Mazzaferro, Sandro
c6584be6-6836-443f-adc2-bbbc97655f7b
Morrone, Luigi
76358dff-c05b-4f00-82c5-b0b170771ce9
Tripepi, Giovanni
5e5ea5bf-9052-443b-a6c1-fd9033160077
Zaninotto, Martina
73f7ba5e-66bb-4d43-850d-a0af31e417de
Mereu, Maria Cristina
74f27398-f5d6-433f-8752-a15a0d66ba82
Ravera, Maura
e99269cb-b395-4414-8477-c298fa398738
Cianciolo, Giuseppe
ab4a8321-83f9-4fcb-80ae-0a45f53abff9
La Manna, Gaetano
4bade75f-1581-4530-9b4e-bf859db77a45
Aghi, Andrea
06936e75-865c-4bf5-a6af-1759b35cc15a
Giannini, Sandro
bd886084-213f-450e-ac93-3cb7a5f71997
Dalle Carbonare, Luca
805c02db-c72a-49fd-9774-2675850fe789

Fusaro, Maria, Re Sarto, Giulia Vanessa, Gallieni, Maurizio, Cosmai, Laura, Messa, Pieregiorgio, Rossini, Maurizio, Chiodini, Iacopo, Plebani, Mario, Evenepoel, Pieter, Harvey, Nicholas, Ferrari, S., Cannata-Andía, Jorge B, Trombetti, Andrea, Brandi, Maria Luisa, Ketteler, Markus, Nickolas, Thomas L., Cunningham, John, Salam, Syazrah, Rocca, Carlo Della, Scarpa, Aldo, Minisola, Salvatore, Malberti, Fabio, Cetani, Filomena, Cozzolino, Mario, Mazzaferro, Sandro, Morrone, Luigi, Tripepi, Giovanni, Zaninotto, Martina, Mereu, Maria Cristina, Ravera, Maura, Cianciolo, Giuseppe, La Manna, Gaetano, Aghi, Andrea, Giannini, Sandro and Dalle Carbonare, Luca (2022) Time for revival of bone biopsy with histomorphometric analysis in chronic kidney disease (CKD): moving from skepticism to pragmatism. Nutrients, 14 (9), [1742]. (doi:10.3390/nu14091742).

Record type: Review

Abstract

Bone Biopsy (BB) with histomorphometric analysis still represents the gold standard for the diagnosis and classification of different forms of renal osteodystrophy. Bone biopsy is the only technique able to provide comprehensive information on all bone parameters, measuring static and dynamic parameters of turnover, cortical and trabecular microarchitecture, and mineralization defects. In nephrological practice, bone biopsy yields relevant indications to support therapeutic choices in CKD, heavily impacting the management and prognosis of uremic patients. Unfortunately, the use of bone biopsy has decreased; a lack of expertise in performing and interpreting, perceived procedure invasiveness and pain, and reimbursement issues have all contributed to this decline. Nevertheless, both bone biomarkers and instrumental images cannot be considered reliable surrogates for histological findings, being insufficiently accurate to properly evaluate underlying mineral and bone disorders. This is a multidisciplinary position paper from the Nephrology and Osteoporosis Italian Scientific Societies with the purpose of restating the role of bone biopsy in CKD patient management and of providing strong solutions to allow diffusion of this technique in Italy, but potentially also in other countries. The Italian approach through the optimization and standardization of bone biopsy procedure, the construction of the Italian Hub and Spoke network, and a request for adjustment and national homogenization of reimbursement to the Italian Health Ministry has led the way to implement bone biopsy and to improve CKD patient management and prognosis.

Text
Fusaro et al BBmanuscriptRevised 21april2022Nutrients copia - Accepted Manuscript
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (1MB)
Text
nutrients-14-01742-v3 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (1MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 14 April 2022
Published date: 1 May 2022
Additional Information: Publisher Copyright: © 2022 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. Copyright: Copyright 2022 Elsevier B.V., All rights reserved.
Keywords: CKD-MBD, bone biopsy, chronic kidney disease, fractures, osteoporosis, renal osteodystrophy

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 457302
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/457302
ISSN: 2072-6643
PURE UUID: 467054d2-b941-4c41-89d7-08cfbe406cd4
ORCID for Nicholas Harvey: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-8194-2512

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 31 May 2022 16:39
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 02:58

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Maria Fusaro
Author: Giulia Vanessa Re Sarto
Author: Maurizio Gallieni
Author: Laura Cosmai
Author: Pieregiorgio Messa
Author: Maurizio Rossini
Author: Iacopo Chiodini
Author: Mario Plebani
Author: Pieter Evenepoel
Author: Nicholas Harvey ORCID iD
Author: S. Ferrari
Author: Jorge B Cannata-Andía
Author: Andrea Trombetti
Author: Maria Luisa Brandi
Author: Markus Ketteler
Author: Thomas L. Nickolas
Author: John Cunningham
Author: Syazrah Salam
Author: Carlo Della Rocca
Author: Aldo Scarpa
Author: Salvatore Minisola
Author: Fabio Malberti
Author: Filomena Cetani
Author: Mario Cozzolino
Author: Sandro Mazzaferro
Author: Luigi Morrone
Author: Giovanni Tripepi
Author: Martina Zaninotto
Author: Maria Cristina Mereu
Author: Maura Ravera
Author: Giuseppe Cianciolo
Author: Gaetano La Manna
Author: Andrea Aghi
Author: Sandro Giannini
Author: Luca Dalle Carbonare

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×