Teaching about newspapers : what determines what is taught when teachers teach about newspapers, and how theories of texts, contexts and readers might contribute to a broader, more coherent approach
Teaching about newspapers : what determines what is taught when teachers teach about newspapers, and how theories of texts, contexts and readers might contribute to a broader, more coherent approach
This thesis argues that teaching about newspapers is problematic. Problems arise out of the range of publications currently sold as newspapers, the diversity of text types to be found within each newspaper, and the lack of consensus amongst the English teaching community as to the value in and purpose of studying newspapers. The thesis concentrates specifically on the 14 to 16 age group, that is, those pupils who are studying within United Kingdom schools at Key Stage 4, and for whom study of the media, within the National Curriculum for English, is mandatory.
The thesis begins by exploring the constraints on and opportunities for teaching about newspapers in the English curriculum. The curriculum is defined by the government agency, the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, and mediated by the General Certificate of Secondary Education English examination syllabuses and examination papers arising from them. The thesis moves on to examine published educational research for an overview of what is known about current practice with regard to teaching about the media, about news and about newspapers.
Empirical evidence on the current situation is then offered. Through interviews with teachers in eleven schools and observation of eleven Media lessons, it explores the curricular, institutional and interpersonal contexts in which teachers of English currently operate. This research also considers how teachers' own views about the media and about Media Education might helpfully be described within three Media/English paradigms.
Arguing that the resulting newspaper curriculum is too narrow, the thesis discusses how a broader curriculum might be possible. Chapter 4 explores issues of craft knowledge in teaching and considers the circumstances that might be necessary for curricular change to take place. Chapter 5 moves the discussion from what is taught and what determines what is taught to a consideration of what textual and socio-cultural theories (in particular, Critical Discourse Analysis) might be brought to bear in attempting to broaden our understanding of how newspapers function.
University of Southampton
Hicks, Alun John
05e04671-4402-4425-b8b4-8a297183b130
2001
Hicks, Alun John
05e04671-4402-4425-b8b4-8a297183b130
Hicks, Alun John
(2001)
Teaching about newspapers : what determines what is taught when teachers teach about newspapers, and how theories of texts, contexts and readers might contribute to a broader, more coherent approach.
University of Southampton, Doctoral Thesis.
Record type:
Thesis
(Doctoral)
Abstract
This thesis argues that teaching about newspapers is problematic. Problems arise out of the range of publications currently sold as newspapers, the diversity of text types to be found within each newspaper, and the lack of consensus amongst the English teaching community as to the value in and purpose of studying newspapers. The thesis concentrates specifically on the 14 to 16 age group, that is, those pupils who are studying within United Kingdom schools at Key Stage 4, and for whom study of the media, within the National Curriculum for English, is mandatory.
The thesis begins by exploring the constraints on and opportunities for teaching about newspapers in the English curriculum. The curriculum is defined by the government agency, the Qualifications and Curriculum Authority, and mediated by the General Certificate of Secondary Education English examination syllabuses and examination papers arising from them. The thesis moves on to examine published educational research for an overview of what is known about current practice with regard to teaching about the media, about news and about newspapers.
Empirical evidence on the current situation is then offered. Through interviews with teachers in eleven schools and observation of eleven Media lessons, it explores the curricular, institutional and interpersonal contexts in which teachers of English currently operate. This research also considers how teachers' own views about the media and about Media Education might helpfully be described within three Media/English paradigms.
Arguing that the resulting newspaper curriculum is too narrow, the thesis discusses how a broader curriculum might be possible. Chapter 4 explores issues of craft knowledge in teaching and considers the circumstances that might be necessary for curricular change to take place. Chapter 5 moves the discussion from what is taught and what determines what is taught to a consideration of what textual and socio-cultural theories (in particular, Critical Discourse Analysis) might be brought to bear in attempting to broaden our understanding of how newspapers function.
Text
811185.pdf
- Version of Record
More information
Published date: 2001
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 464457
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/464457
PURE UUID: 3f572dee-3a0b-482a-a8d1-3f04406a02a8
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 04 Jul 2022 23:39
Last modified: 16 Mar 2024 19:31
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Alun John Hicks
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics