The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Buzz-saw noise prediction for axisymmetric and drooped turbofan intakes

Buzz-saw noise prediction for axisymmetric and drooped turbofan intakes
Buzz-saw noise prediction for axisymmetric and drooped turbofan intakes
As the aerospace industry grows and the number of aircraft movements increases, the noise impact of air travel is under scrutiny in the media and subject to increasingly stringent regulatory requirements. High-bypass ratio turbofan engines used on modern commercial airliners feature a large diameter fan to produce a significant proportion of the overall thrust. During the departure phase, the fan is a major contributor to overall aircraft noise. At high engine speeds used during take-off and climb, the velocity of the fan blade tip relative to the incoming flow can reach supersonic speeds, generating a system of shock waves that propagate through the intake and radiate to the forward arc as noise. The propagation of the pressure field generated by a transonic fan is inherently complex. The shocks produced at the leading edge of the fan blade tips differ from blade to blade due to variation in the manufactured blade geometry and the ‘untwist’ of each blade under load. The shock pattern then becomes increasingly irregular as it travels through the intake through a highly nonlinear propagation process. In addition, the pressure field is attenuated by an acoustic liner fitted to the intake wall and modified through interaction with the distorted intake flow. At the end of the intake, the irregular shock pattern is comprised of tones at harmonics of the blade passing frequency and the shaft rotation frequency. This noise type is known colloquially as ‘buzz-saw noise’ due to it’s similarity to the noise produced by a circular saw. Models which accurately predict the noise produced by an engine are essential for the development of future engine technologies. Existing numerical and analytic models can individually capture a subset of the physical effects associated with buzz-saw noise. These methods include the classical analytic models of linear duct acoustics, semi-analytic models for nonlinear propagation in simplified ducts, linear Computational AeroAcoustics (CAA) and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). While each of these methods has their merits, no single model can capture the nonlinear propagation, liner attenuation, interaction with a distorted flow field and radiation to the far-field. A final factor with considerable impact on a model’s prediction performance is the way a boundary layer is represented when modelling liner absorption. In many analytic and computational models, the boundary layer is modelled by an infinitely thin vortex sheet. This can result in an over-prediction of the liner attenuation for upstream noise propagation. In reality, a finite thickness boundary layer refracts the upstream propagating wave away from the liner, reducing the level of attenuation. In this work, a method for improving attenuation predictions is developed, by defining an ‘effective impedance’ which is informed by eigenmode solutions of the Pridmore-Brown equation in a duct with a finite-thickness boundary layer. The key aim of this PhD thesis is to develop fast and accurate buzz-saw noise prediction models which include all of the aforementioned physical features. The methods are ultimately intended to be applicable to three-dimensional intake geometries with distorted mean flow fields. To achieve the key aim, two coupled prediction models are developed and validated, initially against test data from an axisymmetric static rig intake. These methods incorporate a source prediction from RANS CFD (HYDRA) model with a linear CAA prediction (ActranTM) for the propagation and radiation. The difference in the two methods is the method by which nonlinear effects are captured; one method employs a one-dimensional nonlinear model (FDNS) to apply a nonlinear correction to the CAA predicted levels, while the other captures the nonlinear effect from the CFD within the source description provided to the CAA model. Both methods provide very realistic results in comparison to the rig intake data. Near the end of this thesis, the most appropriate of the two coupling methods is selected and extended to produce a prediction of buzz-saw noise in a realistic ‘drooped’ rig intake. The model couples a prediction from a large-scale unsteady RANS prediction to a three-dimensional CAA model of the intake, to include all effects of nonlinear propagation, liner attenuation with consideration of a finite thickness boundary layer, flow distortion and radiation to the far-field.
University of Southampton
James, Alexander, Owain
4ddf1891-0348-4b0f-859a-db2ef33bb0cd
James, Alexander, Owain
4ddf1891-0348-4b0f-859a-db2ef33bb0cd
Sugimoto, Rie
cb8c880d-0be0-4efe-9990-c79faa8804f0

James, Alexander, Owain (2022) Buzz-saw noise prediction for axisymmetric and drooped turbofan intakes. University of Southampton, Doctoral Thesis, 211pp.

Record type: Thesis (Doctoral)

Abstract

As the aerospace industry grows and the number of aircraft movements increases, the noise impact of air travel is under scrutiny in the media and subject to increasingly stringent regulatory requirements. High-bypass ratio turbofan engines used on modern commercial airliners feature a large diameter fan to produce a significant proportion of the overall thrust. During the departure phase, the fan is a major contributor to overall aircraft noise. At high engine speeds used during take-off and climb, the velocity of the fan blade tip relative to the incoming flow can reach supersonic speeds, generating a system of shock waves that propagate through the intake and radiate to the forward arc as noise. The propagation of the pressure field generated by a transonic fan is inherently complex. The shocks produced at the leading edge of the fan blade tips differ from blade to blade due to variation in the manufactured blade geometry and the ‘untwist’ of each blade under load. The shock pattern then becomes increasingly irregular as it travels through the intake through a highly nonlinear propagation process. In addition, the pressure field is attenuated by an acoustic liner fitted to the intake wall and modified through interaction with the distorted intake flow. At the end of the intake, the irregular shock pattern is comprised of tones at harmonics of the blade passing frequency and the shaft rotation frequency. This noise type is known colloquially as ‘buzz-saw noise’ due to it’s similarity to the noise produced by a circular saw. Models which accurately predict the noise produced by an engine are essential for the development of future engine technologies. Existing numerical and analytic models can individually capture a subset of the physical effects associated with buzz-saw noise. These methods include the classical analytic models of linear duct acoustics, semi-analytic models for nonlinear propagation in simplified ducts, linear Computational AeroAcoustics (CAA) and Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD). While each of these methods has their merits, no single model can capture the nonlinear propagation, liner attenuation, interaction with a distorted flow field and radiation to the far-field. A final factor with considerable impact on a model’s prediction performance is the way a boundary layer is represented when modelling liner absorption. In many analytic and computational models, the boundary layer is modelled by an infinitely thin vortex sheet. This can result in an over-prediction of the liner attenuation for upstream noise propagation. In reality, a finite thickness boundary layer refracts the upstream propagating wave away from the liner, reducing the level of attenuation. In this work, a method for improving attenuation predictions is developed, by defining an ‘effective impedance’ which is informed by eigenmode solutions of the Pridmore-Brown equation in a duct with a finite-thickness boundary layer. The key aim of this PhD thesis is to develop fast and accurate buzz-saw noise prediction models which include all of the aforementioned physical features. The methods are ultimately intended to be applicable to three-dimensional intake geometries with distorted mean flow fields. To achieve the key aim, two coupled prediction models are developed and validated, initially against test data from an axisymmetric static rig intake. These methods incorporate a source prediction from RANS CFD (HYDRA) model with a linear CAA prediction (ActranTM) for the propagation and radiation. The difference in the two methods is the method by which nonlinear effects are captured; one method employs a one-dimensional nonlinear model (FDNS) to apply a nonlinear correction to the CAA predicted levels, while the other captures the nonlinear effect from the CFD within the source description provided to the CAA model. Both methods provide very realistic results in comparison to the rig intake data. Near the end of this thesis, the most appropriate of the two coupling methods is selected and extended to produce a prediction of buzz-saw noise in a realistic ‘drooped’ rig intake. The model couples a prediction from a large-scale unsteady RANS prediction to a three-dimensional CAA model of the intake, to include all effects of nonlinear propagation, liner attenuation with consideration of a finite thickness boundary layer, flow distortion and radiation to the far-field.

Text
Final thesis - Version of Record
Available under License University of Southampton Thesis Licence.
Download (20MB)
Text
Permission to deposit thesis - Alexander James
Restricted to Repository staff only

More information

Submitted date: December 2020
Published date: June 2022

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 467322
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/467322
PURE UUID: b9b81ed6-d992-463e-bbb9-2d38fde065d2
ORCID for Rie Sugimoto: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-2426-2382

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 06 Jul 2022 16:30
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 02:58

Export record

Contributors

Author: Alexander, Owain James
Thesis advisor: Rie Sugimoto ORCID iD

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×