Is there a 'bipolar iceberg' in UK primary care psychological therapy services?
Is there a 'bipolar iceberg' in UK primary care psychological therapy services?
Background: Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) is a primary care therapy service commissioned by England’s National Health Service (NHS) for people with unipolar depression and anxiety-related disorders. Its scope does not extend to ‘severe mental illness’, including bipolar disorders (BD), but evidence suggests there is a high BD prevalence in ostensibly unipolar major depressive disorder (uMDD) samples. This study aimed to indicate the prevalence and characteristics of people with BD in a naturalistic cohort of IAPT patients.
Methods: 371 participants were assessed before initiating therapy. Participants were categorised by indicated diagnoses: BD type-I (BD-I) or type-II (BD-II) as defined using a DSM diagnostic interview, bipolar spectrum (BSp, not meeting diagnostic criteria but exceeding BD screening thresholds), lifetime uMDD or other. Information about psychiatric history and co-morbidities was examined, along with symptoms before and after therapy.
Results: 10% of participants were grouped as having BD-I, 20% BD-II, 40% BSp, 25% uMDD and 5% other. BD and uMDD participants had similar demographic characteristics, but patients meeting criteria for BD-I/BD-II had more complex psychiatric presentations. All three ‘bipolar’ groups had particularly high rates of anxiety disorders. IAPT therapy receipt was comparable between groups, as was therapy response (F9,704=1.113, p=0.351).
Conclusions: notwithstanding the possibility that bipolar diathesis was overestimated, findings illustrate a high prevalence of BD in groups of people notionally with uMDD or anxiety. As well as improving the detection of BD, further substantive investigation is required to establish whether individuals affected by BD should be eligible for primary care psychological intervention.
Bipolar disorders, bipolar spectrum, major depression, primary care, psychological therapy
Strawbridge, Rebecca
63badd46-dc5c-4f27-96aa-20f8f5f4e051
Alexander, Laith
450aef31-1d90-4abd-9bd1-4c2b7471264c
Richardson, Thomas
f8d84122-b061-4322-a594-5ef2eb5cad0d
Young, Allan
d16d60ae-7238-44e9-823b-fb592e54b3ce
Cleare, Anthony
bba8b40e-2ff6-4ad2-8e6a-bc963d794624
3 August 2022
Strawbridge, Rebecca
63badd46-dc5c-4f27-96aa-20f8f5f4e051
Alexander, Laith
450aef31-1d90-4abd-9bd1-4c2b7471264c
Richardson, Thomas
f8d84122-b061-4322-a594-5ef2eb5cad0d
Young, Allan
d16d60ae-7238-44e9-823b-fb592e54b3ce
Cleare, Anthony
bba8b40e-2ff6-4ad2-8e6a-bc963d794624
Strawbridge, Rebecca, Alexander, Laith, Richardson, Thomas, Young, Allan and Cleare, Anthony
(2022)
Is there a 'bipolar iceberg' in UK primary care psychological therapy services?
Psychological Medicine.
(doi:10.1017/S0033291722002343).
Abstract
Background: Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) is a primary care therapy service commissioned by England’s National Health Service (NHS) for people with unipolar depression and anxiety-related disorders. Its scope does not extend to ‘severe mental illness’, including bipolar disorders (BD), but evidence suggests there is a high BD prevalence in ostensibly unipolar major depressive disorder (uMDD) samples. This study aimed to indicate the prevalence and characteristics of people with BD in a naturalistic cohort of IAPT patients.
Methods: 371 participants were assessed before initiating therapy. Participants were categorised by indicated diagnoses: BD type-I (BD-I) or type-II (BD-II) as defined using a DSM diagnostic interview, bipolar spectrum (BSp, not meeting diagnostic criteria but exceeding BD screening thresholds), lifetime uMDD or other. Information about psychiatric history and co-morbidities was examined, along with symptoms before and after therapy.
Results: 10% of participants were grouped as having BD-I, 20% BD-II, 40% BSp, 25% uMDD and 5% other. BD and uMDD participants had similar demographic characteristics, but patients meeting criteria for BD-I/BD-II had more complex psychiatric presentations. All three ‘bipolar’ groups had particularly high rates of anxiety disorders. IAPT therapy receipt was comparable between groups, as was therapy response (F9,704=1.113, p=0.351).
Conclusions: notwithstanding the possibility that bipolar diathesis was overestimated, findings illustrate a high prevalence of BD in groups of people notionally with uMDD or anxiety. As well as improving the detection of BD, further substantive investigation is required to establish whether individuals affected by BD should be eligible for primary care psychological intervention.
Text
is-there-a-bipolar-iceberg-in-uk-primary-care-psychological-therapy-services
- Version of Record
Text
Iceberg paper submitted
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 5 July 2022
e-pub ahead of print date: 3 August 2022
Published date: 3 August 2022
Keywords:
Bipolar disorders, bipolar spectrum, major depression, primary care, psychological therapy
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 468515
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/468515
ISSN: 0033-2917
PURE UUID: 0e4dd56c-fe11-4689-a0c9-ccb58f559fdb
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 17 Aug 2022 16:30
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 04:02
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Rebecca Strawbridge
Author:
Laith Alexander
Author:
Allan Young
Author:
Anthony Cleare
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics