The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

First step towards a consensus strategy for multi-locus diagnostic testing of imprinting disorders

First step towards a consensus strategy for multi-locus diagnostic testing of imprinting disorders
First step towards a consensus strategy for multi-locus diagnostic testing of imprinting disorders
Background: imprinting disorders, which affect growth, development, metabolism and neoplasia risk, are caused by genetic or epigenetic changes to genes that are expressed from only one parental allele. Disease may result from changes in coding sequences, copy number changes, uniparental disomy or imprinting defects. Some imprinting disorders are clinically heterogeneous, some are associated with more than one imprinted locus, and some patients have alterations affecting multiple loci. Most imprinting disorders are diagnosed by stepwise analysis of gene dosage and methylation of single loci, but some laboratories assay a panel of loci associated with different imprinting disorders. We looked into the experience of several laboratories using single-locus and/or multi-locus diagnostic testing to explore how different testing strategies affect diagnostic outcomes and whether multi-locus testing has the potential to increase the diagnostic efficiency or reveal unforeseen diagnoses. Results: we collected data from 11 laboratories in seven countries, involving 16,364 individuals and eight imprinting disorders. Among the 4721 individuals tested for the growth restriction disorder Silver–Russell syndrome, 731 had changes on chromosomes 7 and 11 classically associated with the disorder, but 115 had unexpected diagnoses that involved atypical molecular changes, imprinted loci on chromosomes other than 7 or 11 or multi-locus imprinting disorder. In a similar way, the molecular changes detected in Beckwith–Wiedemann syndrome and other imprinting disorders depended on the testing strategies employed by the different laboratories. Conclusions: based on our findings, we discuss how multi-locus testing might optimise diagnosis for patients with classical and less familiar clinical imprinting disorders. Additionally, our compiled data reflect the daily life experiences of diagnostic laboratories, with a lower diagnostic yield than in clinically well-characterised cohorts, and illustrate the need for systematising clinical and molecular data.
Genetic testing, Imprinting disorders, Multi-locus imprinting disorder, Multi-locus testing, Overlapping phenotypes, Unexpected molecular diagnosis
1868-7075
Mackay, Deborah
588a653e-9785-4a00-be71-4e547850ee4a
Bliek, Jet
71a7b9b1-a591-491d-832a-9b670ef05195
Kagami, Masayo
d64be3de-4119-4c21-aa3a-2e97541356cc
Tenorio-castano, Jair
dad21a19-3056-42a8-886e-838371f18639
Pereda, Arrate
4d699104-2546-4282-b8d7-2140deb8918b
Brioude, Frédéric
eb192db3-3f71-40ac-bf63-c64a8d04bc1c
Netchine, Irène
8f1b8436-aa93-4722-be70-fb70351bf078
Papingi, Dzhoy
1d71e570-4b34-4e30-9abd-718207314ff0
De Franco, Elisa
8095fa27-0cd3-47c9-add4-037182ed1af2
Lever, Margaret
4d112693-a8b5-46d9-8759-29e3677f31d6
Sillibourne, Julie
01057b20-1618-48f3-8ec5-3681ed85d5eb
Lombardi, Paola
372aa188-e6c1-4e20-9ebe-934640656bcc
Gaston, Véronique
50059862-5184-4391-9c54-3cb945dfa249
Tauber, Maithé
3146a2fe-8f69-4bf6-a788-6a262b7d8dd4
Diene, Gwenaelle
a5771c98-f34c-4c66-a58f-78119a0fd26b
Bieth, Eric
f3a5d831-31e4-46a9-8694-df0090e3c92d
Fernandez, Luis
f22dd87e-596c-4c8b-a997-ad16713c8896
Nevado, Julian
13728b40-53dc-4c52-a3f7-d8f93a199aeb
Tümer, Zeynep
75c1d336-a336-4ceb-a19a-e20e1eeae033
Riccio, Andrea
0ac5879d-b47d-4c9f-beaf-ba15c0794954
Maher, Eamonn R.
0ffc76f0-a381-4cc0-ba2b-7f5df847e161
Beygo, Jasmin
7d5384e5-392a-456b-a8f8-858dd6259da2
Tannorella, Pierpaola
d39e1aaa-787d-4657-abe7-4d272b947c34
Russo, Silvia
c58120ef-376c-49f9-be98-0b72bd45d525
De Nanclares, Guiomar Perez
4f5fb1c5-879f-4db8-a9cd-8987d8f3d120
Temple, I. Karen
d63e7c66-9fb0-46c8-855d-ee2607e6c226
Ogata, Tsutomu
5d95197e-a8b1-4e2d-9409-b17821268394
Lapunzina, Pablo
a42660d7-e5ed-42a4-a896-df7ee512d13d
Eggermann, Thomas
f65876e2-0250-48e9-be6c-40abd9b43a6f
et al.
Mackay, Deborah
588a653e-9785-4a00-be71-4e547850ee4a
Bliek, Jet
71a7b9b1-a591-491d-832a-9b670ef05195
Kagami, Masayo
d64be3de-4119-4c21-aa3a-2e97541356cc
Tenorio-castano, Jair
dad21a19-3056-42a8-886e-838371f18639
Pereda, Arrate
4d699104-2546-4282-b8d7-2140deb8918b
Brioude, Frédéric
eb192db3-3f71-40ac-bf63-c64a8d04bc1c
Netchine, Irène
8f1b8436-aa93-4722-be70-fb70351bf078
Papingi, Dzhoy
1d71e570-4b34-4e30-9abd-718207314ff0
De Franco, Elisa
8095fa27-0cd3-47c9-add4-037182ed1af2
Lever, Margaret
4d112693-a8b5-46d9-8759-29e3677f31d6
Sillibourne, Julie
01057b20-1618-48f3-8ec5-3681ed85d5eb
Lombardi, Paola
372aa188-e6c1-4e20-9ebe-934640656bcc
Gaston, Véronique
50059862-5184-4391-9c54-3cb945dfa249
Tauber, Maithé
3146a2fe-8f69-4bf6-a788-6a262b7d8dd4
Diene, Gwenaelle
a5771c98-f34c-4c66-a58f-78119a0fd26b
Bieth, Eric
f3a5d831-31e4-46a9-8694-df0090e3c92d
Fernandez, Luis
f22dd87e-596c-4c8b-a997-ad16713c8896
Nevado, Julian
13728b40-53dc-4c52-a3f7-d8f93a199aeb
Tümer, Zeynep
75c1d336-a336-4ceb-a19a-e20e1eeae033
Riccio, Andrea
0ac5879d-b47d-4c9f-beaf-ba15c0794954
Maher, Eamonn R.
0ffc76f0-a381-4cc0-ba2b-7f5df847e161
Beygo, Jasmin
7d5384e5-392a-456b-a8f8-858dd6259da2
Tannorella, Pierpaola
d39e1aaa-787d-4657-abe7-4d272b947c34
Russo, Silvia
c58120ef-376c-49f9-be98-0b72bd45d525
De Nanclares, Guiomar Perez
4f5fb1c5-879f-4db8-a9cd-8987d8f3d120
Temple, I. Karen
d63e7c66-9fb0-46c8-855d-ee2607e6c226
Ogata, Tsutomu
5d95197e-a8b1-4e2d-9409-b17821268394
Lapunzina, Pablo
a42660d7-e5ed-42a4-a896-df7ee512d13d
Eggermann, Thomas
f65876e2-0250-48e9-be6c-40abd9b43a6f

Mackay, Deborah, Bliek, Jet, Kagami, Masayo and Temple, I. Karen , et al. (2022) First step towards a consensus strategy for multi-locus diagnostic testing of imprinting disorders. Clinical Epigenetics, 14 (1), [143]. (doi:10.1186/s13148-022-01358-9).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Background: imprinting disorders, which affect growth, development, metabolism and neoplasia risk, are caused by genetic or epigenetic changes to genes that are expressed from only one parental allele. Disease may result from changes in coding sequences, copy number changes, uniparental disomy or imprinting defects. Some imprinting disorders are clinically heterogeneous, some are associated with more than one imprinted locus, and some patients have alterations affecting multiple loci. Most imprinting disorders are diagnosed by stepwise analysis of gene dosage and methylation of single loci, but some laboratories assay a panel of loci associated with different imprinting disorders. We looked into the experience of several laboratories using single-locus and/or multi-locus diagnostic testing to explore how different testing strategies affect diagnostic outcomes and whether multi-locus testing has the potential to increase the diagnostic efficiency or reveal unforeseen diagnoses. Results: we collected data from 11 laboratories in seven countries, involving 16,364 individuals and eight imprinting disorders. Among the 4721 individuals tested for the growth restriction disorder Silver–Russell syndrome, 731 had changes on chromosomes 7 and 11 classically associated with the disorder, but 115 had unexpected diagnoses that involved atypical molecular changes, imprinted loci on chromosomes other than 7 or 11 or multi-locus imprinting disorder. In a similar way, the molecular changes detected in Beckwith–Wiedemann syndrome and other imprinting disorders depended on the testing strategies employed by the different laboratories. Conclusions: based on our findings, we discuss how multi-locus testing might optimise diagnosis for patients with classical and less familiar clinical imprinting disorders. Additionally, our compiled data reflect the daily life experiences of diagnostic laboratories, with a lower diagnostic yield than in clinically well-characterised cohorts, and illustrate the need for systematising clinical and molecular data.

Text
s13148-022-01358-9 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (1MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 17 October 2022
Published date: 7 November 2022
Additional Information: Funding Information: Open Access funding enabled and organized by Projekt DEAL. The authors are supported by the following grants: Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (to TE: EG 115/13-1). Instituto de Salud Carlos III (ISCIIII) of the Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (Spain) (to GPdN and AP: PI20/00950), co-financed by the European Regional Development Fund. 2019 research unit grant from ESPE (to GdPN). Instituto de Salud Carlos III of the Ministry of Economy and Competitiveness (Spain) (to PL: grants # FIS 20/01053, IMPACT project 20/IMP00009). Italian Ministry of Health RC 08C724, 08C502 (to SR and PT). Wellcome Trust (WT098395/Z/12/Z, to EdF). IKT is supported in part by the Southampton NIHR Biomedical Research Centre, UK (2017-2022, IS-BRC-1215-20004). ERM thanks the NIHR Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre for research support. The University of Cambridge has received salary support for ERM from the NHS in the East of England through the Clinical Academic Reserve. The views expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NHS or Department of Health (ERM and IKT). EDF is a Diabetes UK RD Lawrence Fellow (19/005971). MK and TO are funded by the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development (AMED) (20ek0109373h0003, 22ek0109587). Publisher Copyright: © 2022, The Author(s).
Keywords: Genetic testing, Imprinting disorders, Multi-locus imprinting disorder, Multi-locus testing, Overlapping phenotypes, Unexpected molecular diagnosis

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 472604
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/472604
ISSN: 1868-7075
PURE UUID: 865046d7-8667-4388-99e7-2fd7e51c653d
ORCID for Deborah Mackay: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-3088-4401
ORCID for I. Karen Temple: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-6045-1781

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 09 Dec 2022 17:42
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 02:48

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Deborah Mackay ORCID iD
Author: Jet Bliek
Author: Masayo Kagami
Author: Jair Tenorio-castano
Author: Arrate Pereda
Author: Frédéric Brioude
Author: Irène Netchine
Author: Dzhoy Papingi
Author: Elisa De Franco
Author: Margaret Lever
Author: Julie Sillibourne
Author: Paola Lombardi
Author: Véronique Gaston
Author: Maithé Tauber
Author: Gwenaelle Diene
Author: Eric Bieth
Author: Luis Fernandez
Author: Julian Nevado
Author: Zeynep Tümer
Author: Andrea Riccio
Author: Eamonn R. Maher
Author: Jasmin Beygo
Author: Pierpaola Tannorella
Author: Silvia Russo
Author: Guiomar Perez De Nanclares
Author: I. Karen Temple ORCID iD
Author: Tsutomu Ogata
Author: Pablo Lapunzina
Author: Thomas Eggermann
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×