PaCTS 1.0: a crowdsourced reporting standard for paleoclimate data
PaCTS 1.0: a crowdsourced reporting standard for paleoclimate data
The progress of science is tied to the standardization of measurements, instruments, and data. This is especially true in the Big Data age, where analyzing large data volumes critically hinges on the data being standardized. Accordingly, the lack of community-sanctioned data standards in paleoclimatology has largely precluded the benefits of Big Data advances in the field. Building upon recent efforts to standardize the format and terminology of paleoclimate data, this article describes the Paleoclimate Community reporTing Standard (PaCTS), a crowdsourced reporting standard for such data. PaCTS captures which information should be included when reporting paleoclimate data, with the goal of maximizing the reuse value of paleoclimate data sets, particularly for synthesis work and comparison to climate model simulations. Initiated by the LinkedEarth project, the process to elicit a reporting standard involved an international workshop in 2016, various forms of digital community engagement over the next few years, and grassroots working groups. Participants in this process identified important properties across paleoclimate archives, in addition to the reporting of uncertainties and chronologies; they also identified archive-specific properties and distinguished reporting standards for new versus legacy data sets. This work shows that at least 135 respondents overwhelmingly support a drastic increase in the amount of metadata accompanying paleoclimate data sets. Since such goals are at odds with present practices, we discuss a transparent path toward implementing or revising these recommendations in the near future, using both bottom-up and top-down approaches.
best practices, data, FAIR, paleoceanography, paleoclimate, standards
1570-1596
Khider, D.
e49b6dfc-2a43-43a6-a154-f3198c560065
Emile-Geay, Julien
8a4c2485-9dc4-487e-bcca-19972c9fab69
McKay, N. P.
efb7a775-a002-4840-a165-092b9eabd560
Gil, Y.
db85654f-6250-4666-8c77-64c4afea8d85
Garijo, D.
0efae87c-6602-4ee2-b46a-ae4537b4acb6
Ratnakar, V.
75fc2ef1-82d2-4f43-8308-d004d53641cc
Alonso-Garcia, M.
7899abf2-8d23-4ffd-94af-e89cc73f154f
Bertrand, S.
f5511086-7bad-47d1-9ece-1ac7c8fed071
Bothe, O.
bfd97eda-f35e-4117-9e43-9f62496b31b9
Brewer, P.
228885ca-95cf-4bbd-acbc-fe9b39a75004
Bunn, A.
5fc8660b-bd6e-4721-b7ce-ceb6bbe044a8
Chevalier, M.
4a59ec8f-660b-4335-9731-fde016d55f33
Comas-Bru, L.
83bd7ffb-b9e3-46ad-9962-7df39e8801d3
Csank, A.
2389881c-096c-4c39-87bd-7b14be5a9549
Dassié, E.
17fa5421-4b29-42c4-9a11-3f39c9df93f1
DeLong, K.
db2d170b-5303-458a-9783-3841e696ce34
Felis, T.
dc2d083e-4a76-4980-a427-131d2bd5e00f
Francus, P.
46e6adff-29d8-4461-8444-485e92df4d9b
Frappier, A.
9beb7f09-37ad-4fc5-ba7d-a5dcc21bf401
Gray, W.
9def902d-d4f0-4826-ace4-32c8369af4f9
Goring, S.
4d9b9b6f-0134-4b90-954a-c27e4bd57b57
Jonkers, L.
3ade20ae-7ed4-40c9-8bc1-4d03386f68eb
Kahle, M.
41de5821-2f93-4cc2-97ac-fb575aaac112
Kaufman, D.
0845f8ab-ee9f-467c-8cfd-2171989538bf
Kehrwald, N. M.
5e4ead06-8796-430a-9709-6b571803b4f4
Martrat, B.
2fe759c9-6ad3-4bcc-a28c-1d14794a8466
McGregor, H.
7fe03a9a-c87f-4eb2-889c-3d08d330177f
Richey, J.
20d3a4b4-0b01-4d98-8315-951ede890eb0
Schmittner, A.
ca519d9f-ba98-4bd8-9d78-f4cadc3da69d
Scroxton, N.
1fc0087e-7222-4d51-979c-78dbc5b07d7f
Sutherland, E.
53786572-b679-4147-903f-f442e79112f2
Thirumalai, K.
097c5afe-4dcc-4b7c-8276-05d5a7e119db
Allen, Kathryn
89184bac-d72b-4540-a171-23d69b197b6e
Arnaud, F.
796056b8-1c4a-4712-a6c6-c58563545935
Axford, Yarrow
57d964d8-424f-40ef-a5f8-77fbf5bfe916
Barrows, T.
10517b62-ebd7-4c3f-bebe-1b29424a6911
Bazin, L.
dc8eff48-7621-483d-bb5f-236532ef6fd6
Pilaar Birch, S. E.
f7368846-ed8c-4f31-b4ed-30d66faaab90
Bradley, E.
68c529c9-fa8c-4c75-82f0-f0bffe58c2b6
Bregy, J.
5b65c77e-04b6-481e-b995-550ac3d9be3f
Capron, E.
799eac6c-efeb-4c66-a4db-ef73da50fedf
Cartapanis, O.
bffe2df1-3a77-4fd3-b34a-c8dc60e1b07b
Chiang, H. W.
f07f4681-d1f9-4c7f-b1b7-621c6a203c7b
Cobb, K. M.
4f416cb9-c8a0-42a4-b439-ee3ea66822a0
Debret, M.
b4b6e80f-412b-437b-8ebe-bbd4136db327
Dommain, R.
2d966b9a-caa5-4316-b060-fcb2acdad0e7
Du, J.
d83f6402-9ca1-4055-8ece-d58f71a6e394
Dyez, K.
7957e0c9-41e6-4176-bc51-dc0e60f4d47d
Emerick, S.
a90371ad-b25b-424d-a71d-cda7b436e0a6
Erb, M. P.
31079ad6-2719-4198-acd2-935b01919585
Falster, G.
70edd22f-d25d-4d26-975c-311bd38b45a5
Finsinger, W.
fb19f9a1-53dc-441f-acd3-369dc22eff4e
Fortier, D.
f0eb6be4-a5c3-43c0-a0b1-918af524a651
Gauthier, Nicolas
da7439ce-d607-4f87-9c54-30997d6388ad
George, S.
fd62ffdc-7e02-4a60-8a3c-5995e504674b
Grimm, E.
9ab6810e-16be-4858-87eb-a67e6a47ac2b
Hertzberg, J.
c8a4c8c5-401b-4f28-a943-5fb3227cfd9e
Hibbert, F.
d94edad0-4751-45cb-b441-909c7bbdddb8
Hillman, A.
1b235c5d-b9c3-46b9-a597-fc87a8509fbe
Hobbs, W.
860ac634-1b45-4105-8f9f-de007d741b86
Huber, M.
f86c1008-e7d4-4b48-bfcf-347951cfdde4
Hughes, A. L.C.
2528e362-975c-4af5-a3d1-e04dacaa8909
Jaccard, S.
2ca25b07-e88d-442b-b655-c05fd1f1f79b
Ruan, J.
2876da05-8988-4d0c-9725-e02f683e7fa8
Kienast, M.
cfe16655-ef5b-4ca7-b7c5-44068906f8cb
Konecky, B.
e8d8d52c-c042-4b0b-afac-0074d4ae8271
Le Roux, G.
cb0abeda-2079-433a-a90b-900e9d99c6e1
Lyubchich, V.
8dcbc47f-44c3-42ec-a634-28edad58db47
Novello, V. F.
907999d1-e06c-4ada-9f72-ab7aa25bb328
Olaka, L.
1450a93d-884a-4d36-9afa-dc260f9f4845
Partin, J. W.
38bffa7f-ce5f-4193-8897-f52796cfaa45
Pearce, C.
c83b6228-0b64-4f5a-a8ad-e5cd33a11de3
Phipps, S. J.
e758b744-d223-43af-8234-156c31a58f82
Pignol, C.
bc058a9b-e133-4d5c-8598-0683bc98dee9
Piotrowska, N.
84dabb87-76d8-4db8-82fe-a51d94bf4b19
Poli, M. S.
2fd5728b-94dc-47df-8fea-3565616259c9
Prokopenko, A.
bba549b5-6714-4c2e-a06c-805d20c0e737
Schwanck, F.
29af30a0-9cee-468b-9b3b-64e1a0507183
Stepanek, C.
f9594fb4-9950-4608-86c4-3662a6527a2b
Swann, G. E.A.
b4d954da-8ae0-49e8-b777-babfdb4344cc
Telford, R.
8a08fadf-e777-47f9-bdf6-6a3e4fdb6c49
Thomas, E.
d33060cf-0782-498e-9b96-f04119158973
Thomas, Z.
4b512d3a-3478-4270-9fdd-61256aa640d3
Truebe, S.
912ce42b-35b7-4d78-8d5a-9f0ae2fc3567
von Gunten, L.
1369e3f7-e552-431b-bf0e-0a8ab348e6d8
Waite, A.
01666e1d-ef61-4f3a-938f-722c5b7fdef9
Weitzel, N.
65e3e176-7d29-4f27-9eb9-4b62ab6ca0d4
Wilhelm, B.
f5c77f5c-7795-414e-afd1-6af825348dc3
Williams, J.
26231e2d-d4ce-4b24-a85f-ba3ca4405a06
Williams, J. J.
44d8e691-bcea-4e97-95e8-e923c605d185
Winstrup, M.
3df6caea-5f31-41db-9a97-ab9fea0003c9
Zhao, N.
8ba6d30b-7668-4a25-960d-8cadd1a677e3
Zhou, Y.
9e51dac1-ed2c-4d5c-a7cb-7995e7cf6fea
23 November 2019
Khider, D.
e49b6dfc-2a43-43a6-a154-f3198c560065
Emile-Geay, Julien
8a4c2485-9dc4-487e-bcca-19972c9fab69
McKay, N. P.
efb7a775-a002-4840-a165-092b9eabd560
Gil, Y.
db85654f-6250-4666-8c77-64c4afea8d85
Garijo, D.
0efae87c-6602-4ee2-b46a-ae4537b4acb6
Ratnakar, V.
75fc2ef1-82d2-4f43-8308-d004d53641cc
Alonso-Garcia, M.
7899abf2-8d23-4ffd-94af-e89cc73f154f
Bertrand, S.
f5511086-7bad-47d1-9ece-1ac7c8fed071
Bothe, O.
bfd97eda-f35e-4117-9e43-9f62496b31b9
Brewer, P.
228885ca-95cf-4bbd-acbc-fe9b39a75004
Bunn, A.
5fc8660b-bd6e-4721-b7ce-ceb6bbe044a8
Chevalier, M.
4a59ec8f-660b-4335-9731-fde016d55f33
Comas-Bru, L.
83bd7ffb-b9e3-46ad-9962-7df39e8801d3
Csank, A.
2389881c-096c-4c39-87bd-7b14be5a9549
Dassié, E.
17fa5421-4b29-42c4-9a11-3f39c9df93f1
DeLong, K.
db2d170b-5303-458a-9783-3841e696ce34
Felis, T.
dc2d083e-4a76-4980-a427-131d2bd5e00f
Francus, P.
46e6adff-29d8-4461-8444-485e92df4d9b
Frappier, A.
9beb7f09-37ad-4fc5-ba7d-a5dcc21bf401
Gray, W.
9def902d-d4f0-4826-ace4-32c8369af4f9
Goring, S.
4d9b9b6f-0134-4b90-954a-c27e4bd57b57
Jonkers, L.
3ade20ae-7ed4-40c9-8bc1-4d03386f68eb
Kahle, M.
41de5821-2f93-4cc2-97ac-fb575aaac112
Kaufman, D.
0845f8ab-ee9f-467c-8cfd-2171989538bf
Kehrwald, N. M.
5e4ead06-8796-430a-9709-6b571803b4f4
Martrat, B.
2fe759c9-6ad3-4bcc-a28c-1d14794a8466
McGregor, H.
7fe03a9a-c87f-4eb2-889c-3d08d330177f
Richey, J.
20d3a4b4-0b01-4d98-8315-951ede890eb0
Schmittner, A.
ca519d9f-ba98-4bd8-9d78-f4cadc3da69d
Scroxton, N.
1fc0087e-7222-4d51-979c-78dbc5b07d7f
Sutherland, E.
53786572-b679-4147-903f-f442e79112f2
Thirumalai, K.
097c5afe-4dcc-4b7c-8276-05d5a7e119db
Allen, Kathryn
89184bac-d72b-4540-a171-23d69b197b6e
Arnaud, F.
796056b8-1c4a-4712-a6c6-c58563545935
Axford, Yarrow
57d964d8-424f-40ef-a5f8-77fbf5bfe916
Barrows, T.
10517b62-ebd7-4c3f-bebe-1b29424a6911
Bazin, L.
dc8eff48-7621-483d-bb5f-236532ef6fd6
Pilaar Birch, S. E.
f7368846-ed8c-4f31-b4ed-30d66faaab90
Bradley, E.
68c529c9-fa8c-4c75-82f0-f0bffe58c2b6
Bregy, J.
5b65c77e-04b6-481e-b995-550ac3d9be3f
Capron, E.
799eac6c-efeb-4c66-a4db-ef73da50fedf
Cartapanis, O.
bffe2df1-3a77-4fd3-b34a-c8dc60e1b07b
Chiang, H. W.
f07f4681-d1f9-4c7f-b1b7-621c6a203c7b
Cobb, K. M.
4f416cb9-c8a0-42a4-b439-ee3ea66822a0
Debret, M.
b4b6e80f-412b-437b-8ebe-bbd4136db327
Dommain, R.
2d966b9a-caa5-4316-b060-fcb2acdad0e7
Du, J.
d83f6402-9ca1-4055-8ece-d58f71a6e394
Dyez, K.
7957e0c9-41e6-4176-bc51-dc0e60f4d47d
Emerick, S.
a90371ad-b25b-424d-a71d-cda7b436e0a6
Erb, M. P.
31079ad6-2719-4198-acd2-935b01919585
Falster, G.
70edd22f-d25d-4d26-975c-311bd38b45a5
Finsinger, W.
fb19f9a1-53dc-441f-acd3-369dc22eff4e
Fortier, D.
f0eb6be4-a5c3-43c0-a0b1-918af524a651
Gauthier, Nicolas
da7439ce-d607-4f87-9c54-30997d6388ad
George, S.
fd62ffdc-7e02-4a60-8a3c-5995e504674b
Grimm, E.
9ab6810e-16be-4858-87eb-a67e6a47ac2b
Hertzberg, J.
c8a4c8c5-401b-4f28-a943-5fb3227cfd9e
Hibbert, F.
d94edad0-4751-45cb-b441-909c7bbdddb8
Hillman, A.
1b235c5d-b9c3-46b9-a597-fc87a8509fbe
Hobbs, W.
860ac634-1b45-4105-8f9f-de007d741b86
Huber, M.
f86c1008-e7d4-4b48-bfcf-347951cfdde4
Hughes, A. L.C.
2528e362-975c-4af5-a3d1-e04dacaa8909
Jaccard, S.
2ca25b07-e88d-442b-b655-c05fd1f1f79b
Ruan, J.
2876da05-8988-4d0c-9725-e02f683e7fa8
Kienast, M.
cfe16655-ef5b-4ca7-b7c5-44068906f8cb
Konecky, B.
e8d8d52c-c042-4b0b-afac-0074d4ae8271
Le Roux, G.
cb0abeda-2079-433a-a90b-900e9d99c6e1
Lyubchich, V.
8dcbc47f-44c3-42ec-a634-28edad58db47
Novello, V. F.
907999d1-e06c-4ada-9f72-ab7aa25bb328
Olaka, L.
1450a93d-884a-4d36-9afa-dc260f9f4845
Partin, J. W.
38bffa7f-ce5f-4193-8897-f52796cfaa45
Pearce, C.
c83b6228-0b64-4f5a-a8ad-e5cd33a11de3
Phipps, S. J.
e758b744-d223-43af-8234-156c31a58f82
Pignol, C.
bc058a9b-e133-4d5c-8598-0683bc98dee9
Piotrowska, N.
84dabb87-76d8-4db8-82fe-a51d94bf4b19
Poli, M. S.
2fd5728b-94dc-47df-8fea-3565616259c9
Prokopenko, A.
bba549b5-6714-4c2e-a06c-805d20c0e737
Schwanck, F.
29af30a0-9cee-468b-9b3b-64e1a0507183
Stepanek, C.
f9594fb4-9950-4608-86c4-3662a6527a2b
Swann, G. E.A.
b4d954da-8ae0-49e8-b777-babfdb4344cc
Telford, R.
8a08fadf-e777-47f9-bdf6-6a3e4fdb6c49
Thomas, E.
d33060cf-0782-498e-9b96-f04119158973
Thomas, Z.
4b512d3a-3478-4270-9fdd-61256aa640d3
Truebe, S.
912ce42b-35b7-4d78-8d5a-9f0ae2fc3567
von Gunten, L.
1369e3f7-e552-431b-bf0e-0a8ab348e6d8
Waite, A.
01666e1d-ef61-4f3a-938f-722c5b7fdef9
Weitzel, N.
65e3e176-7d29-4f27-9eb9-4b62ab6ca0d4
Wilhelm, B.
f5c77f5c-7795-414e-afd1-6af825348dc3
Williams, J.
26231e2d-d4ce-4b24-a85f-ba3ca4405a06
Williams, J. J.
44d8e691-bcea-4e97-95e8-e923c605d185
Winstrup, M.
3df6caea-5f31-41db-9a97-ab9fea0003c9
Zhao, N.
8ba6d30b-7668-4a25-960d-8cadd1a677e3
Zhou, Y.
9e51dac1-ed2c-4d5c-a7cb-7995e7cf6fea