Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: multicenter, prospective study
Effectiveness of rapid SARS-CoV-2 genome sequencing in supporting infection control for hospital-onset COVID-19 infection: multicenter, prospective study
Background: Viral sequencing of SARS-CoV-2 has been used for outbreak investigation, but there is limited evidence supporting routine use for infection prevention and control (IPC) within hospital settings.
Methods: We conducted a prospective non-randomised trial of sequencing at 14 acute UK hospital trusts. Sites each had a 4-week baseline data-collection period, followed by intervention periods comprising 8 weeks of 'rapid' (<48h) and 4 weeks of 'longer-turnaround' (5-10 day) sequencing using a sequence reporting tool (SRT). Data were collected on all hospital onset COVID-19 infections (HOCIs; detected ≥48h from admission). The impact of the sequencing intervention on IPC knowledge and actions, and on incidence of probable/definite hospital-acquired infections (HAIs) was evaluated.
Results: A total of 2170 HOCI cases were recorded from October 2020-April 2021, corresponding to a period of extreme strain on the health service, with sequence reports returned for 650/1320 (49.2%) during intervention phases. We did not detect a statistically significant change in weekly incidence of HAIs in longer-turnaround (incidence rate ratio 1.60, 95%CI 0.85-3.01; P=0.14) or rapid (0.85, 0.48-1.50; P=0.54) intervention phases compared to baseline phase. However, IPC practice was changed in 7.8% and 7.4% of all HOCI cases in rapid and longer-turnaround phases, respectively, and 17.2% and 11.6% of cases where the report was returned. In a 'per-protocol' sensitivity analysis there was an impact on IPC actions in 20.7% of HOCI cases when the SRT report was returned within 5 days. Capacity to respond effectively to insights from sequencing was breached in most sites by the volume of cases and limited resources.
Conclusion: While we did not demonstrate a direct impact of sequencing on the incidence of nosocomial transmission, our results suggest that sequencing can inform IPC response to HOCIs, particularly when returned within 5 days.
Funding: COG-UK is supported by funding from the Medical Research Council (MRC) part of UK Research & Innovation (UKRI), the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR) [grant code: MC_PC_19027], and Genome Research Limited, operating as the Wellcome Sanger Institute.Clinical trial number: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT04405934.
COVID-19, epidemiology, global health, healthcare-associated infection, hospital-acquired infection, human, infection control, infection prevention, infectious disease, microbiology, molecular epidemiology, viral genomics
Stirrup, Oliver
ae9630c0-36c0-4a35-93c1-19bbe3c9ef85
Blackstone, James
c2d01b3d-0227-47f3-a384-5d250124cf47
Mapp, Fiona
bb6e3fef-fc51-4b9d-8708-13635f6f9860
MacNeil, Alyson
0fe8d37c-3414-4f57-bf98-8f85f5eac07c
Panca, Monica
9d56e984-1b81-4ed7-b9e1-2518ed59836b
Holmes, Alison
c5420a59-f403-44a8-8611-aaf430fa9d4c
Machin, Nicholas
10819d76-ab73-49ca-b07e-15d668c76001
Shin, Gee Yen
d8394a15-47ef-41cf-ab91-6d95f3313bd6
Mahungu, Tabitha
317f36a9-c0c9-4e8d-a25f-8fe2cbc7083f
Saeed, Kordo
87cb67e5-71e8-4759-bf23-2ea00ebd8b39
Saluja, Tranprit
1c9a4f8e-f8b5-4020-95ac-b59822960759
Taha, Yusri
e7fc4688-2881-4f0a-915b-9657a5e288f3
Mahida, Nikunj
512ab4af-1f99-4194-aeb1-cb1302fdb680
Pope, Cassie
b517127d-860e-4955-b697-d798b62a6f72
Chawla, Anu
f2d0f719-54dd-4967-b9f2-173d99e38dfe
Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa
5d3e06c8-1bdd-4806-9415-05e87596bb23
Tamuri, Asif
63eb6585-6ba9-4368-8b4f-72cc7cff349b
Williams, Rachel
e9860b51-16e6-42a8-8f23-6b82d67b7771
Darby, Alistair
77def91d-dc09-4ab3-a4a6-52ee975e23b6
Robertson, David L
f04306d0-d549-4526-8d8a-df8be028df45
Flaviani, Flavia
66c2f883-e748-41b7-9630-d410974e88a3
Nastouli, Eleni
b8132b4b-e26f-4f25-8975-134b7a53f6d7
Robson, Samuel
b6217f51-904b-448b-8595-ca36a81d1dc8
Smith, Darren
3a26c950-1d6f-44a5-b082-3ce42a88276c
Laing, Kenneth
92a674ef-96d4-40f1-af00-8ca65cc11fbc
Monahan, Irene
e902051c-1d59-4abf-835f-cd09969fbebd
Kele, Beatrix
6f7c5553-c3f9-489a-a057-2537626cda01
Haldenby, Sam
c7b29872-fcd8-4a94-adc0-299712f1635c
George, Ryan
656a6460-c945-43ff-9b7b-181b742bd449
Bashton, Matthew
c1e21a20-2296-441d-8a39-4c01c7f54fba
Witney, Adam A
c1fea432-9123-4105-8bbb-9fea0119805e
Byott, Matthew
ee1e6747-a927-4526-a76d-3a708b622de5
Coll, Francesc
ed372c09-3aa7-4394-b1af-9e7ee9922ff8
Chapman, Michael
0bccef1f-ef20-408b-9c23-5f30e7ef3377
Peacock, Sharon J
23cf95d2-0dac-48d0-a5c8-199114942afa
Hughes, Joseph
4b9677ab-7b4b-49d5-8719-928c0ee9eca0
Nebbia, Gaia
3265d964-9d7b-4424-b698-c30a35175c00
Partridge, David G
332ee4e9-7731-4dbe-b420-42c82feb2276
Parker, Matthew
424f3565-ea3c-4b54-851f-f744f033a60e
Price, James Richard
539f9af1-d9d9-4028-90a8-19ab7056dab9
Peters, Christine
f776cb2c-f921-4bfa-941f-5cc844c9cbb5
Roy, Sunando
78300d81-5f00-4509-94ec-4b4025c505b9
Snell, Luke B
2cd1a0a9-475e-4240-bc2c-aacd0e0cd749
de Silva, Thushan I
6b5b0a5a-31bb-4f59-a920-df219fdfe320
Thomson, Emma
56756701-c8db-4b95-a453-910601c1f096
Flowers, Paul
552c5fd7-75dc-479f-b2e3-d66bbaad4b3f
Copas, Andrew
10c9d680-f510-4969-ab9a-9e2a61568cb8
Breuer, Judith
f2762443-c570-4da1-af7c-56ee30b0bb78
COG‐UK HOCI Investigators
13 September 2022
Stirrup, Oliver
ae9630c0-36c0-4a35-93c1-19bbe3c9ef85
Blackstone, James
c2d01b3d-0227-47f3-a384-5d250124cf47
Mapp, Fiona
bb6e3fef-fc51-4b9d-8708-13635f6f9860
MacNeil, Alyson
0fe8d37c-3414-4f57-bf98-8f85f5eac07c
Panca, Monica
9d56e984-1b81-4ed7-b9e1-2518ed59836b
Holmes, Alison
c5420a59-f403-44a8-8611-aaf430fa9d4c
Machin, Nicholas
10819d76-ab73-49ca-b07e-15d668c76001
Shin, Gee Yen
d8394a15-47ef-41cf-ab91-6d95f3313bd6
Mahungu, Tabitha
317f36a9-c0c9-4e8d-a25f-8fe2cbc7083f
Saeed, Kordo
87cb67e5-71e8-4759-bf23-2ea00ebd8b39
Saluja, Tranprit
1c9a4f8e-f8b5-4020-95ac-b59822960759
Taha, Yusri
e7fc4688-2881-4f0a-915b-9657a5e288f3
Mahida, Nikunj
512ab4af-1f99-4194-aeb1-cb1302fdb680
Pope, Cassie
b517127d-860e-4955-b697-d798b62a6f72
Chawla, Anu
f2d0f719-54dd-4967-b9f2-173d99e38dfe
Cutino-Moguel, Maria-Teresa
5d3e06c8-1bdd-4806-9415-05e87596bb23
Tamuri, Asif
63eb6585-6ba9-4368-8b4f-72cc7cff349b
Williams, Rachel
e9860b51-16e6-42a8-8f23-6b82d67b7771
Darby, Alistair
77def91d-dc09-4ab3-a4a6-52ee975e23b6
Robertson, David L
f04306d0-d549-4526-8d8a-df8be028df45
Flaviani, Flavia
66c2f883-e748-41b7-9630-d410974e88a3
Nastouli, Eleni
b8132b4b-e26f-4f25-8975-134b7a53f6d7
Robson, Samuel
b6217f51-904b-448b-8595-ca36a81d1dc8
Smith, Darren
3a26c950-1d6f-44a5-b082-3ce42a88276c
Laing, Kenneth
92a674ef-96d4-40f1-af00-8ca65cc11fbc
Monahan, Irene
e902051c-1d59-4abf-835f-cd09969fbebd
Kele, Beatrix
6f7c5553-c3f9-489a-a057-2537626cda01
Haldenby, Sam
c7b29872-fcd8-4a94-adc0-299712f1635c
George, Ryan
656a6460-c945-43ff-9b7b-181b742bd449
Bashton, Matthew
c1e21a20-2296-441d-8a39-4c01c7f54fba
Witney, Adam A
c1fea432-9123-4105-8bbb-9fea0119805e
Byott, Matthew
ee1e6747-a927-4526-a76d-3a708b622de5
Coll, Francesc
ed372c09-3aa7-4394-b1af-9e7ee9922ff8
Chapman, Michael
0bccef1f-ef20-408b-9c23-5f30e7ef3377
Peacock, Sharon J
23cf95d2-0dac-48d0-a5c8-199114942afa
Hughes, Joseph
4b9677ab-7b4b-49d5-8719-928c0ee9eca0
Nebbia, Gaia
3265d964-9d7b-4424-b698-c30a35175c00
Partridge, David G
332ee4e9-7731-4dbe-b420-42c82feb2276
Parker, Matthew
424f3565-ea3c-4b54-851f-f744f033a60e
Price, James Richard
539f9af1-d9d9-4028-90a8-19ab7056dab9
Peters, Christine
f776cb2c-f921-4bfa-941f-5cc844c9cbb5
Roy, Sunando
78300d81-5f00-4509-94ec-4b4025c505b9
Snell, Luke B
2cd1a0a9-475e-4240-bc2c-aacd0e0cd749
de Silva, Thushan I
6b5b0a5a-31bb-4f59-a920-df219fdfe320
Thomson, Emma
56756701-c8db-4b95-a453-910601c1f096
Flowers, Paul
552c5fd7-75dc-479f-b2e3-d66bbaad4b3f
Copas, Andrew
10c9d680-f510-4969-ab9a-9e2a61568cb8
Breuer, Judith
f2762443-c570-4da1-af7c-56ee30b0bb78