WAO consensus on DEfinition of Food Allergy SEverity (DEFASE)
WAO consensus on DEfinition of Food Allergy SEverity (DEFASE)
BACKGROUND: While several scoring systems for the severity of anaphylactic reactions have been developed, there is a lack of consensus on definition and categorisation of severity of food allergy disease as a whole.
AIM: To develop an international consensus on the severity of food allergy (DEfinition of Food Allergy Severity, DEFASE) scoring system, to be used globally.
METHODS PHASE 1: We conducted a mixed-method systematic review (SR) of 11 databases for published and unpublished literature on severity of food allergy management and set up a panel of international experts.
PHASE 2: Based on our findings in Phase 1, we drafted statements for a two-round modified electronic Delphi (e-Delphi) survey. A purposefully selected multidisciplinary international expert panel on food allergy (n = 60) was identified and sent a structured questionnaire, including a set of statements on different domains of food allergy severity related to symptoms, health-related quality of life, and economic impact. Participants were asked to score their agreement on each statement on a 5-point Likert scale ranging from "strongly agree" to "strongly disagree". Median scores and percentage agreements were calculated. Consensus was defined a priori as being achieved if 70% or more of panel members rated a statement as "strongly agree" to "agree" after the second round. Based on feedback, 2 additional online voting rounds were conducted.
RESULTS: We received responses from 92% of Delphi panel members in round 1 and 85% in round 2. Consensus was achieved on the overall score and in all of the 5 specific key domains as essential components of the DEFASE score.
CONCLUSIONS: The DEFASE score is the first comprehensive grading of food allergy severity that considers not only the severity of a single reaction, but the whole disease spectrum. An international consensus has been achieved regarding a scoring system for food allergy disease. It offers an evaluation grid, which may help to rate the severity of food allergy. Phase 3 will involve validating the scoring system in research settings, and implementing it in clinical practice.
Consensus, Definition, Food allergy, Severity, e-Delphi study
Arasi, Stefania
ae1cb6ec-1484-4fc9-aac6-3a18aeae18e4
Nurmatov, Ulugbek
4919c95c-0855-4352-9414-17181fbeb1cd
Dunn-Galvin, Audrey
df33ae04-bb19-4024-83ed-25c3e3a676e0
Roberts, Graham
ea00db4e-84e7-4b39-8273-9b71dbd7e2f3
Turner, Paul J
22cee218-a226-4300-aad1-b9a77ca65915
Shinder, Sayantani B
4dde8f62-d827-4641-8046-55732e535341
Gupta, Ruchi
112ba5bd-7b57-49ee-a784-9387489e3df1
Eigenmann, Philippe
3e63730f-7e33-412f-9e2d-64d607922647
Nowak-Wegrzyn, Anna
661bfdbf-32de-4421-9c1b-277c7b62861b
Ansotegui, Ignacio J
414b20b6-c4d0-4801-bbe1-b12f67a97ede
Rivas, Montserrat Fernandez
e98af60e-7ac4-431c-b0c1-18fa9fefa594
Petrou, Stavros
5ee930f5-99db-4fb8-b401-95584cff0e20
Tanno, Luciana K
e601cbc5-cd59-45db-aa11-df6f37218bb3
Vazquez-Ortiz, Marta
890eb8f6-2903-44dd-b494-36af021f7708
Vickery, Brian
124b08b1-ca00-4a34-bcc0-3bd1b4288384
Wong, Gary
76551efa-3264-4f85-a436-5107e0b2432f
Alvaro-Lozano, Montserrat
a5a23120-bb01-4177-a478-a15783a85bef
Asaria, Miqdad
d556044d-c9fb-4235-92ee-b3f799a3f026
Begin, Philippe
19cdfb13-be1e-407b-9c0d-c6eca19b7ccc
Bozzola, Martin
01314643-5e03-4d50-b43c-2fdb3fc40ca5
Boyle, Robert
5e72dbea-6d1d-4745-906f-0a912d6498f6
Brough, Helen
ad550b22-eed8-4a61-9703-bd16aea45873
Cardona, Victoria
a0844f96-a8d4-454e-bbb4-93aedef5d737
Chinthrajah, R Sharon
d3bbf255-70c4-42aa-8273-fada1886b50a
Cianferoni, Antonella
93c5d15e-d960-4b22-ac71-4728ef4215c3
Deschildre, Antoine
0b3562a0-65e1-4e75-aba4-469371cd2c93
Fleischer, David
085e52de-faaa-41a9-8eba-47ff70f8a99d
Gazzani, Flavio
7cffc807-5ab0-460d-9d24-e49e961a2fe3
Gerdts, Jennifer
c09c6388-36e4-448d-8031-88b38b837759
Giannetti, Marilena
00bb0706-1388-43ef-8705-ce652f8b4048
Greenhawt, Matthew
b360033f-d839-45c6-bafd-133cd5b9f71b
Guzmán, Maria Antonieta
2dfa245c-64bc-4c02-8cbb-221d3477bfe6
Hossny, Elham
4c0dd72f-34ef-418b-9a13-33cc5f0424bc
Kauppi, Paula
8dc5aeaa-36ee-4936-b77e-7944d271c03e
Jones, Carla
25959da6-5dee-4225-b7e7-ad534bf54ac0
Lucidi, Francesco
1d1d1174-21cf-4d9f-aaa3-09ba67ed6713
Monge Ortega, Olga Patricia
86d5cb4c-de88-4780-929a-1854767ffdb5
Munblit, Daniel
caebf4a0-0825-43df-b797-a9d5ca7a475f
Muraro, Antonella
c554bef5-502b-4540-a6f0-a3f7c37f0075
Pajno, Giovanni
dc6da1c6-fdc3-46c7-aaed-0a34d4e393a1
Podestà, Marcia
cef318a4-31b0-42ad-b8ab-475091d6748d
Rodriguez Del Rio, Pablo
3b947412-a3bd-4b20-8b77-b37818a3dc83
Said, Maria
c705e507-e797-4650-b736-ea1ea3568c2c
Santos, Alexandra
80ed4c69-36eb-47cc-9637-b41ba926631c
Shaker, Marcus
1c12952a-3c3e-4f3e-a394-06f9207bd0d2
Szajewska, Hania
84cfc816-e146-4417-930d-df9ec827f52b
Venter, Carina
b865c2a4-7789-46c9-b6ef-c032c4fda66a
Warren, Cristopher
b281d5f4-871a-4c1b-a249-f855aacfdf09
Winders, Tonya
2400e57c-b375-4363-94ad-e7f666ed5aee
Ebisawa, Motohiro
874c6f29-2460-4d70-b0d0-5054b5ba0f71
Fiocchi, Alessandro
84f49387-5e31-4760-93d2-65b552d43c57
March 2023
Arasi, Stefania
ae1cb6ec-1484-4fc9-aac6-3a18aeae18e4
Nurmatov, Ulugbek
4919c95c-0855-4352-9414-17181fbeb1cd
Dunn-Galvin, Audrey
df33ae04-bb19-4024-83ed-25c3e3a676e0
Roberts, Graham
ea00db4e-84e7-4b39-8273-9b71dbd7e2f3
Turner, Paul J
22cee218-a226-4300-aad1-b9a77ca65915
Shinder, Sayantani B
4dde8f62-d827-4641-8046-55732e535341
Gupta, Ruchi
112ba5bd-7b57-49ee-a784-9387489e3df1
Eigenmann, Philippe
3e63730f-7e33-412f-9e2d-64d607922647
Nowak-Wegrzyn, Anna
661bfdbf-32de-4421-9c1b-277c7b62861b
Ansotegui, Ignacio J
414b20b6-c4d0-4801-bbe1-b12f67a97ede
Rivas, Montserrat Fernandez
e98af60e-7ac4-431c-b0c1-18fa9fefa594
Petrou, Stavros
5ee930f5-99db-4fb8-b401-95584cff0e20
Tanno, Luciana K
e601cbc5-cd59-45db-aa11-df6f37218bb3
Vazquez-Ortiz, Marta
890eb8f6-2903-44dd-b494-36af021f7708
Vickery, Brian
124b08b1-ca00-4a34-bcc0-3bd1b4288384
Wong, Gary
76551efa-3264-4f85-a436-5107e0b2432f
Alvaro-Lozano, Montserrat
a5a23120-bb01-4177-a478-a15783a85bef
Asaria, Miqdad
d556044d-c9fb-4235-92ee-b3f799a3f026
Begin, Philippe
19cdfb13-be1e-407b-9c0d-c6eca19b7ccc
Bozzola, Martin
01314643-5e03-4d50-b43c-2fdb3fc40ca5
Boyle, Robert
5e72dbea-6d1d-4745-906f-0a912d6498f6
Brough, Helen
ad550b22-eed8-4a61-9703-bd16aea45873
Cardona, Victoria
a0844f96-a8d4-454e-bbb4-93aedef5d737
Chinthrajah, R Sharon
d3bbf255-70c4-42aa-8273-fada1886b50a
Cianferoni, Antonella
93c5d15e-d960-4b22-ac71-4728ef4215c3
Deschildre, Antoine
0b3562a0-65e1-4e75-aba4-469371cd2c93
Fleischer, David
085e52de-faaa-41a9-8eba-47ff70f8a99d
Gazzani, Flavio
7cffc807-5ab0-460d-9d24-e49e961a2fe3
Gerdts, Jennifer
c09c6388-36e4-448d-8031-88b38b837759
Giannetti, Marilena
00bb0706-1388-43ef-8705-ce652f8b4048
Greenhawt, Matthew
b360033f-d839-45c6-bafd-133cd5b9f71b
Guzmán, Maria Antonieta
2dfa245c-64bc-4c02-8cbb-221d3477bfe6
Hossny, Elham
4c0dd72f-34ef-418b-9a13-33cc5f0424bc
Kauppi, Paula
8dc5aeaa-36ee-4936-b77e-7944d271c03e
Jones, Carla
25959da6-5dee-4225-b7e7-ad534bf54ac0
Lucidi, Francesco
1d1d1174-21cf-4d9f-aaa3-09ba67ed6713
Monge Ortega, Olga Patricia
86d5cb4c-de88-4780-929a-1854767ffdb5
Munblit, Daniel
caebf4a0-0825-43df-b797-a9d5ca7a475f
Muraro, Antonella
c554bef5-502b-4540-a6f0-a3f7c37f0075
Pajno, Giovanni
dc6da1c6-fdc3-46c7-aaed-0a34d4e393a1
Podestà, Marcia
cef318a4-31b0-42ad-b8ab-475091d6748d
Rodriguez Del Rio, Pablo
3b947412-a3bd-4b20-8b77-b37818a3dc83
Said, Maria
c705e507-e797-4650-b736-ea1ea3568c2c
Santos, Alexandra
80ed4c69-36eb-47cc-9637-b41ba926631c
Shaker, Marcus
1c12952a-3c3e-4f3e-a394-06f9207bd0d2
Szajewska, Hania
84cfc816-e146-4417-930d-df9ec827f52b
Venter, Carina
b865c2a4-7789-46c9-b6ef-c032c4fda66a
Warren, Cristopher
b281d5f4-871a-4c1b-a249-f855aacfdf09
Winders, Tonya
2400e57c-b375-4363-94ad-e7f666ed5aee
Ebisawa, Motohiro
874c6f29-2460-4d70-b0d0-5054b5ba0f71
Fiocchi, Alessandro
84f49387-5e31-4760-93d2-65b552d43c57