The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Agricultural systems regulate plant and insect (beetle) diversity and induce ecosystem novelty

Agricultural systems regulate plant and insect (beetle) diversity and induce ecosystem novelty
Agricultural systems regulate plant and insect (beetle) diversity and induce ecosystem novelty

Land-use change plays an important role in shaping plant and insect diversity over long time timescales. Great Britain provides an ideal case study to investigate patterns of long-term vegetation and insect diversity change owing to the existence of spatially and temporally extensive environmental archives (lake sediments, peatlands, and archaeological sites) and a long history of landscape transformation through agrarian change. The trends identified in past environmental datasets allow the impacts of land-use change on plant and insect diversity trends to be investigated alongside exploration of the emergence of ecological novelty. Using fossil pollen, insect (beetle), archaeodemographic, archaeobotanical and modern landscape datasets covering Britain, similarities are identified between insect diversity and pollen sample evenness indicating that vegetation heterogeneity influences insect diversity. Changing land use captured by archaeobotanical data is significantly correlated with pollen diversity demonstrating the role of human activity in shaping past diversity trends with shifts towards ecosystem novelty identified in the form of non-analogue pollen taxa assemblages (unique species combinations). Modern landscapes with higher agricultural suitability are less likely to have pollen analogues beyond the last 1000 years, whilst those in areas less suited to agriculture and on more variable topography are more likely to have analogues older than 1000 years. This signifies the role of agriculture in the creation of novel ecosystems. Ecological assemblages characteristic of earlier periods of the Holocene may persist in areas less affected by agriculture. The last 200 years has witnessed major shifts in novelty in a low number of pollen sites suggesting that novel ecosystems emerged over a longer time period resulting from the cumulative impacts of land-use change.

beetles, biodiversity, disturbance, insects, land-use, palaeoecology, pollen
2213-3054
Woodbridge, Jessie
ac1ab941-9e61-484d-b14c-d497cb7d2678
Fyfe, Ralph
0efffd2b-297e-4867-a585-e7ad6c4468db
Smith, David
385fb364-d85b-4e94-b8bd-40d5e379eb59
de Varielles, Anne
4e4ebf40-2b4f-43e9-83b4-bfdb7ec13f85
Pelling, Ruth
884251fa-bce3-4709-9ff6-7140f2520607
Grant, Michael
56dae074-d54a-4da8-858a-2bf364a5a550
Batchelor, Robert
c2f1c1ff-ec4c-4acb-8268-39fd42c1955f
Scaife, Robert
f6525225-e2d2-4c2e-9450-cca17817cf37
Greig, James
233412ed-4139-4321-ac40-837bd8dd31ae
Dark, Petra
704ea27f-196f-47dd-8f96-e0031d4f1f82
Druce, Denise
29285a1e-bd89-41d9-ace0-7cce8c2c92e1
Garbett, Geoff
725d30e2-f576-436c-99af-49b1a41de109
Parker, Adrian
882e8697-e465-42e8-b13e-7538d3a4d870
Hill, Tom
4db0c57e-732d-4135-9c20-4b448a056d6e
Schofield, James Edward
ee07e19c-4ef3-47d6-8d76-fb1317744a8b
Simmonds, Mike
c83a001d-4b9c-46ec-934e-ecc4127c0f52
Chambers, F.M.
0c6d908d-22c3-4079-9a2e-0ddd2c11c26c
Barnett, Catherine
b4efc8bd-4f79-4ecd-9a5f-3864cc91daf0
Waller, M.P.
462f8c8e-6a30-47f4-a267-242737860465
Woodbridge, Jessie
ac1ab941-9e61-484d-b14c-d497cb7d2678
Fyfe, Ralph
0efffd2b-297e-4867-a585-e7ad6c4468db
Smith, David
385fb364-d85b-4e94-b8bd-40d5e379eb59
de Varielles, Anne
4e4ebf40-2b4f-43e9-83b4-bfdb7ec13f85
Pelling, Ruth
884251fa-bce3-4709-9ff6-7140f2520607
Grant, Michael
56dae074-d54a-4da8-858a-2bf364a5a550
Batchelor, Robert
c2f1c1ff-ec4c-4acb-8268-39fd42c1955f
Scaife, Robert
f6525225-e2d2-4c2e-9450-cca17817cf37
Greig, James
233412ed-4139-4321-ac40-837bd8dd31ae
Dark, Petra
704ea27f-196f-47dd-8f96-e0031d4f1f82
Druce, Denise
29285a1e-bd89-41d9-ace0-7cce8c2c92e1
Garbett, Geoff
725d30e2-f576-436c-99af-49b1a41de109
Parker, Adrian
882e8697-e465-42e8-b13e-7538d3a4d870
Hill, Tom
4db0c57e-732d-4135-9c20-4b448a056d6e
Schofield, James Edward
ee07e19c-4ef3-47d6-8d76-fb1317744a8b
Simmonds, Mike
c83a001d-4b9c-46ec-934e-ecc4127c0f52
Chambers, F.M.
0c6d908d-22c3-4079-9a2e-0ddd2c11c26c
Barnett, Catherine
b4efc8bd-4f79-4ecd-9a5f-3864cc91daf0
Waller, M.P.
462f8c8e-6a30-47f4-a267-242737860465

Woodbridge, Jessie, Fyfe, Ralph, Smith, David, de Varielles, Anne, Pelling, Ruth, Grant, Michael, Batchelor, Robert, Scaife, Robert, Greig, James, Dark, Petra, Druce, Denise, Garbett, Geoff, Parker, Adrian, Hill, Tom, Schofield, James Edward, Simmonds, Mike, Chambers, F.M., Barnett, Catherine and Waller, M.P. (2023) Agricultural systems regulate plant and insect (beetle) diversity and induce ecosystem novelty. Anthropocene, 41, [100369]. (doi:10.1016/j.ancene.2023.100369).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Land-use change plays an important role in shaping plant and insect diversity over long time timescales. Great Britain provides an ideal case study to investigate patterns of long-term vegetation and insect diversity change owing to the existence of spatially and temporally extensive environmental archives (lake sediments, peatlands, and archaeological sites) and a long history of landscape transformation through agrarian change. The trends identified in past environmental datasets allow the impacts of land-use change on plant and insect diversity trends to be investigated alongside exploration of the emergence of ecological novelty. Using fossil pollen, insect (beetle), archaeodemographic, archaeobotanical and modern landscape datasets covering Britain, similarities are identified between insect diversity and pollen sample evenness indicating that vegetation heterogeneity influences insect diversity. Changing land use captured by archaeobotanical data is significantly correlated with pollen diversity demonstrating the role of human activity in shaping past diversity trends with shifts towards ecosystem novelty identified in the form of non-analogue pollen taxa assemblages (unique species combinations). Modern landscapes with higher agricultural suitability are less likely to have pollen analogues beyond the last 1000 years, whilst those in areas less suited to agriculture and on more variable topography are more likely to have analogues older than 1000 years. This signifies the role of agriculture in the creation of novel ecosystems. Ecological assemblages characteristic of earlier periods of the Holocene may persist in areas less affected by agriculture. The last 200 years has witnessed major shifts in novelty in a low number of pollen sites suggesting that novel ecosystems emerged over a longer time period resulting from the cumulative impacts of land-use change.

Text
Woodbridge et al PEARL - Accepted Manuscript
Restricted to Repository staff only until 8 February 2025.
Request a copy
Text
Woodbridge et al 2023 Anthro online first - Proof
Restricted to Repository staff only
Request a copy
Spreadsheet
Supplementary Information 1 - Proof
Restricted to Repository staff only
Request a copy

More information

Submitted date: 4 April 2022
Accepted/In Press date: 8 February 2023
e-pub ahead of print date: 11 February 2023
Published date: 11 February 2023
Additional Information: Funding Information: The research was funded by the Leverhulme Trust (award number RPG-2018-357 ) and supported by the Universities of Plymouth and Birmingham and Historic England . This work would not have been possible without open access contributions to the European Pollen Database (database manager: Michelle Leydet) and all data contributors (see Supplementary Information 1: data contributor names), (BPOL: Michael Grant) archaeobotanical databases (ABCD, ADAPT and EUROEVOL), the fossil insect database BugsCEP (Phil Buckland), contributions from palynologists, and contributors to open-access repositories of archaeological material. We are also grateful to Philipp Sommer for helpful advice regarding the use of Straditize software.
Keywords: beetles, biodiversity, disturbance, insects, land-use, palaeoecology, pollen

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 477125
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/477125
ISSN: 2213-3054
PURE UUID: b1ca9a62-d650-43b6-8e23-d886ce21927f
ORCID for Michael Grant: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-4766-6913

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 30 May 2023 16:31
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 03:34

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Jessie Woodbridge
Author: Ralph Fyfe
Author: David Smith
Author: Anne de Varielles
Author: Ruth Pelling
Author: Michael Grant ORCID iD
Author: Robert Batchelor
Author: Robert Scaife
Author: James Greig
Author: Petra Dark
Author: Denise Druce
Author: Geoff Garbett
Author: Adrian Parker
Author: Tom Hill
Author: James Edward Schofield
Author: Mike Simmonds
Author: F.M. Chambers
Author: Catherine Barnett
Author: M.P. Waller

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×