Which outcomes should always be measured in intervention studies for improving work participation for people with a health problem?: an international multistakeholder Delphi study to develop a core outcome set for Work participation (COS for Work)
Which outcomes should always be measured in intervention studies for improving work participation for people with a health problem?: an international multistakeholder Delphi study to develop a core outcome set for Work participation (COS for Work)
 
  Objective: synthesising evidence of the effects of interventions to improve work participation among people with health problems is currently difficult due to heterogeneity in outcome measurements. A core outcome set for work participation is needed.
Study design and setting: following the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials methodology, we used a five-step approach to reach international multistakeholder consensus on a core outcome set for work participation. Five subgroups of stakeholders took part in two rounds of discussions and completed two Delphi voting rounds on 26 outcomes. A consensus of ≥80% determined core outcomes and 50%-80% consensus was required for candidate outcomes.
Results: fifty-eight stakeholders took part in the Delphi rounds. Core outcomes were: 'any type of employment including self-employment', 'proportion of workers that return to work after being absent because of illness' and 'time to return to work'. Ten candidate outcomes were proposed, among others: 'sustainable employment', 'work productivity' and 'workers' perception of return to work'.
Conclusion: as a minimum, all studies evaluating the impact of interventions on work participation should include one employment outcome and two return to work outcomes if workers are on sick leave prior to the intervention.
consensus, delphi technique, Endpoint Determination, humans, outcome assessment, health care, research design, treatment outcome, occupational & industrial medicine, rehabilitation medicine, statistics & research methods, public health
  
  
  
    
      Ravinskaya, Margarita
      
        802fb413-6cbc-4c89-bcb5-525ad0c7e1a4
      
     
  
    
      Verbeek, Jos H.
      
        2357db5b-9248-4751-a12f-c8b674a74b45
      
     
  
    
      Langendam, Miranda
      
        fe60e990-e2b9-49cd-882a-17796f007c59
      
     
  
    
      Madan, Ira
      
        c6fd0de4-6d73-47eb-9e97-79a2941c8767
      
     
  
    
      Verstappen, Suzanne M.M.
      
        34d9aaa3-c50d-4a7f-8d81-b3d61e66f393
      
     
  
    
      Kunz, Regina
      
        b8c137ea-b551-447f-9109-3fa57dbcd28a
      
     
  
    
      Hulshof, Carel T.J.
      
        6d8f9647-e27d-4191-8576-07f0e26ef1f5
      
     
  
    
      Hoving, Jan L.
      
        f7317d31-6990-4c59-8837-fa5341a05917
      
     
  
    
      Walker-Bone, Karen
      
        ad7d1336-ed2c-4f39-ade5-da84eb412109
      
     
  
  
   
  
    
  
  
    
    
  
    
    
  
    
      15 February 2023
    
    
  
  
    
      Ravinskaya, Margarita
      
        802fb413-6cbc-4c89-bcb5-525ad0c7e1a4
      
     
  
    
      Verbeek, Jos H.
      
        2357db5b-9248-4751-a12f-c8b674a74b45
      
     
  
    
      Langendam, Miranda
      
        fe60e990-e2b9-49cd-882a-17796f007c59
      
     
  
    
      Madan, Ira
      
        c6fd0de4-6d73-47eb-9e97-79a2941c8767
      
     
  
    
      Verstappen, Suzanne M.M.
      
        34d9aaa3-c50d-4a7f-8d81-b3d61e66f393
      
     
  
    
      Kunz, Regina
      
        b8c137ea-b551-447f-9109-3fa57dbcd28a
      
     
  
    
      Hulshof, Carel T.J.
      
        6d8f9647-e27d-4191-8576-07f0e26ef1f5
      
     
  
    
      Hoving, Jan L.
      
        f7317d31-6990-4c59-8837-fa5341a05917
      
     
  
    
      Walker-Bone, Karen
      
        ad7d1336-ed2c-4f39-ade5-da84eb412109
      
     
  
       
    
 
  
    
      
  
  
  
  
  
  
    Walker-Bone, Karen
  
, 
  
  
    Delphi participants
  
  
  
  
   
    (2023)
  
  
    
    Which outcomes should always be measured in intervention studies for improving work participation for people with a health problem?: an international multistakeholder Delphi study to develop a core outcome set for Work participation (COS for Work).
  
  
  
  
    BMJ Open, 13 (2), [e069174].
  
   (doi:10.1136/bmjopen-2022-069174). 
  
  
   
  
  
  
  
  
   
  
    
    
      
        
          Abstract
          Objective: synthesising evidence of the effects of interventions to improve work participation among people with health problems is currently difficult due to heterogeneity in outcome measurements. A core outcome set for work participation is needed.
Study design and setting: following the Core Outcome Measures in Effectiveness Trials methodology, we used a five-step approach to reach international multistakeholder consensus on a core outcome set for work participation. Five subgroups of stakeholders took part in two rounds of discussions and completed two Delphi voting rounds on 26 outcomes. A consensus of ≥80% determined core outcomes and 50%-80% consensus was required for candidate outcomes.
Results: fifty-eight stakeholders took part in the Delphi rounds. Core outcomes were: 'any type of employment including self-employment', 'proportion of workers that return to work after being absent because of illness' and 'time to return to work'. Ten candidate outcomes were proposed, among others: 'sustainable employment', 'work productivity' and 'workers' perception of return to work'.
Conclusion: as a minimum, all studies evaluating the impact of interventions on work participation should include one employment outcome and two return to work outcomes if workers are on sick leave prior to the intervention.
         
      
      
        
          
            
  
    Text
 e069174.full
     - Version of Record
   
  
  
    
  
 
          
            
          
            
           
            
           
        
        
       
    
   
  
  
  More information
  
    
      Accepted/In Press date: 2 February 2023
 
    
      e-pub ahead of print date: 15 February 2023
 
    
      Published date: 15 February 2023
 
    
  
  
    
  
    
     
        Additional Information:
        Funding Information:
This research received no specific grant from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors. SV is supported by Versus Arthritis (grant numbers 20385, 20380) and the NIHR Manchester Biomedical Research Centre.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 BMJ Publishing Group. All rights reserved.
      
    
  
    
  
    
  
    
  
    
     
        Keywords:
        consensus, delphi technique, Endpoint Determination, humans, outcome assessment, health care, research design, treatment outcome, occupational & industrial medicine, rehabilitation medicine, statistics & research methods, public health
      
    
  
    
  
    
  
  
  
    
  
  
        Identifiers
        Local EPrints ID: 477142
        URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/477142
        
          
        
        
        
          ISSN: 2044-6055
        
        
          PURE UUID: 54e2e333-58c4-48ca-b38a-90b2af047dfb
        
  
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
        
    
        
          
            
              
            
          
        
    
  
  Catalogue record
  Date deposited: 30 May 2023 16:38
  Last modified: 06 Jun 2024 01:38
  Export record
  
  
   Altmetrics
   
   
  
 
 
  
    
    
      Contributors
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Margarita Ravinskaya
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Jos H. Verbeek
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Miranda Langendam
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Ira Madan
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Suzanne M.M. Verstappen
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Regina Kunz
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Carel T.J. Hulshof
            
          
        
      
          
          Author:
          
            
            
              Jan L. Hoving
            
          
        
      
        
      
      
          
          Corporate Author: Delphi participants
        
      
      
    
  
   
  
    Download statistics
    
      Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
      
      View more statistics