Delphi study to define core clinical outcomes for inclusion in a complex regional pain syndrome international research registry and data bank
Delphi study to define core clinical outcomes for inclusion in a complex regional pain syndrome international research registry and data bank
Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) clinical trials have historically captured a diverse range of outcomes. A minimum set of CRPS patient-reported outcomes has been agreed for inclusion in a future CRPS international clinical research registry and data bank. This study aimed to identify a complementary set of core clinical outcomes. Clinicians and researchers from the international CRPS community informed the content of a 2-round electronic Delphi study. Participation was invited from members of the International Association for the Study of Pain CRPS Special Interest Group and the International Research Consortium for CRPS. In round 1, participants rated the relevance of 59 clinical outcomes in relation to the question “What is the clinical presentation and course of CRPS, and what factors influence it?” (1 = not relevant and 9 = highly relevant). In round 2, participants rerated each outcome in the light of the round 1 median scores. The criterion for consensus was median score ≥7, agreed by 75% of respondents. The core study team considered the feasibility of data collection of each identified outcome in agreeing final selections. Sixty respondents completed both survey rounds, with responses broadly consistent across professions. Nine outcomes met the consensus criterion. Final outcomes recommended for inclusion in the core clinical set were record of medications, presence of posttraumatic stress disorder, extent of allodynia, and skin temperature difference between limbs. Study findings provide robust recommendations for core clinical outcome data fields in the future CPRS international clinical research registry. Alongside patient-reported outcomes, these data will enable a better understanding of CRPS.
543-554
Llewellyn, Alison
55a5ade7-c203-4ec7-95b9-6caee14b1127
Buckle, Lisa
1cd3e1f5-c033-46d5-8980-0f412bad7707
Grieve, Sharon
7e6c6d5f-df44-4327-86d7-bc31c9c157cc
Birklein, Frank
6518e819-57d8-4f2d-8f56-74d870a382d2
Brunner, Florian
c4d73c4d-96cd-4a45-859c-bb6eac4ffd7d
Goebel, Andreas
ddfb56e1-3689-40d7-84a2-d8c391677051
Harden, R. Norman
abafc80b-694b-4164-8a8c-2f499a22825a
Bruehl, Stephen
8537bbda-e517-4a52-9bc7-adff77ffc850
Vaughan-spickers, Nicole
d4bc6005-6bea-4fa6-8b4d-fb211a4bb0dc
Connett, Robyn
c72e4bb9-bf33-42fa-b4f9-7884f1ea8471
Mccabe, Candida
ccb8a891-0053-424e-be0a-a0dfc93f2160
1 March 2023
Llewellyn, Alison
55a5ade7-c203-4ec7-95b9-6caee14b1127
Buckle, Lisa
1cd3e1f5-c033-46d5-8980-0f412bad7707
Grieve, Sharon
7e6c6d5f-df44-4327-86d7-bc31c9c157cc
Birklein, Frank
6518e819-57d8-4f2d-8f56-74d870a382d2
Brunner, Florian
c4d73c4d-96cd-4a45-859c-bb6eac4ffd7d
Goebel, Andreas
ddfb56e1-3689-40d7-84a2-d8c391677051
Harden, R. Norman
abafc80b-694b-4164-8a8c-2f499a22825a
Bruehl, Stephen
8537bbda-e517-4a52-9bc7-adff77ffc850
Vaughan-spickers, Nicole
d4bc6005-6bea-4fa6-8b4d-fb211a4bb0dc
Connett, Robyn
c72e4bb9-bf33-42fa-b4f9-7884f1ea8471
Mccabe, Candida
ccb8a891-0053-424e-be0a-a0dfc93f2160
Llewellyn, Alison, Buckle, Lisa, Grieve, Sharon, Birklein, Frank, Brunner, Florian, Goebel, Andreas, Harden, R. Norman, Bruehl, Stephen, Vaughan-spickers, Nicole, Connett, Robyn and Mccabe, Candida
(2023)
Delphi study to define core clinical outcomes for inclusion in a complex regional pain syndrome international research registry and data bank.
Pain, 164 (3), .
(doi:10.1097/j.pain.0000000000002729).
Abstract
Complex regional pain syndrome (CRPS) clinical trials have historically captured a diverse range of outcomes. A minimum set of CRPS patient-reported outcomes has been agreed for inclusion in a future CRPS international clinical research registry and data bank. This study aimed to identify a complementary set of core clinical outcomes. Clinicians and researchers from the international CRPS community informed the content of a 2-round electronic Delphi study. Participation was invited from members of the International Association for the Study of Pain CRPS Special Interest Group and the International Research Consortium for CRPS. In round 1, participants rated the relevance of 59 clinical outcomes in relation to the question “What is the clinical presentation and course of CRPS, and what factors influence it?” (1 = not relevant and 9 = highly relevant). In round 2, participants rerated each outcome in the light of the round 1 median scores. The criterion for consensus was median score ≥7, agreed by 75% of respondents. The core study team considered the feasibility of data collection of each identified outcome in agreeing final selections. Sixty respondents completed both survey rounds, with responses broadly consistent across professions. Nine outcomes met the consensus criterion. Final outcomes recommended for inclusion in the core clinical set were record of medications, presence of posttraumatic stress disorder, extent of allodynia, and skin temperature difference between limbs. Study findings provide robust recommendations for core clinical outcome data fields in the future CPRS international clinical research registry. Alongside patient-reported outcomes, these data will enable a better understanding of CRPS.
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
e-pub ahead of print date: 4 July 2022
Published date: 1 March 2023
Additional Information:
Funding Information:
R. N. Harden and S. Bruehl currently sit on the Board of Directors of the Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome Association (RSDSA). C. McCabe has previously received grants from the RSDSA. F. Birklein is supported by the BGW, Mainz. All other authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest. A. Llewellyn is a recipient of a National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) funding award. The views expressed in this article are those of the authors and not necessarily those of the NIHR or the Department of Health and Social Care. Acknowledgements
Funding Information:
The authors acknowledge and thank those organisations who have supported this work, without their contributions this work would not have been possible. In particular, the authors thank the Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy Syndrome Association for funding this work and the International Research Consortium for CRPS and the International Association for the Study of Pain CRPS Special Interest Group for disseminating the study invitation to their respective memberships. The authors also thank all respondents who participated in the e-Delphi survey.
Publisher Copyright:
© 2023 Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. All rights reserved.
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 477214
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/477214
ISSN: 0304-3959
PURE UUID: bd1d8d85-33ee-41c5-bdf1-78fd94a0b7ce
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 01 Jun 2023 16:44
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 01:21
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Alison Llewellyn
Author:
Lisa Buckle
Author:
Sharon Grieve
Author:
Frank Birklein
Author:
Florian Brunner
Author:
Andreas Goebel
Author:
R. Norman Harden
Author:
Stephen Bruehl
Author:
Nicole Vaughan-spickers
Author:
Robyn Connett
Author:
Candida Mccabe
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics