The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization
The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization
Background: The shift from solitary to social behavior is one of the major evolutionary transitions. Primitively eusocial bumblebees are uniquely placed to illuminate the evolution of highly eusocial insect societies. Bumblebees are also invaluable natural and agricultural pollinators, and there is widespread concern over recent population declines in some species. High-quality genomic data will inform key aspects of bumblebee biology, including susceptibility to implicated population viability threats.
Results: We report the high quality draft genome sequences of Bombus terrestris and Bombus impatiens, two ecologically dominant bumblebees and widely utilized study species. Comparing these new genomes to those of the highly eusocial honeybee Apis mellifera and other Hymenoptera, we identify deeply conserved similarities, as well as novelties key to the biology of these organisms. Some honeybee genome features thought to underpin advanced eusociality are also present in bumblebees, indicating an earlier evolution in the bee lineage. Xenobiotic detoxification and immune genes are similarly depauperate in bumblebees and honeybees, and multiple categories of genes linked to social organization, including development and behavior, show high conservation. Key differences identified include a bias in bumblebee chemoreception towards gustation from olfaction, and striking differences in microRNAs, potentially responsible for gene regulation underlying social and other traits.
Conclusions: These two bumblebee genomes provide a foundation for post-genomic research on these key pollinators and insect societies. Overall, gene repertoires suggest that the route to advanced eusociality in bees was mediated by many small changes in many genes and processes, and not by notable expansion or depauperation.
Sadd, Ben M
4ce5579c-8533-409b-89d8-98e3c07239b4
Barribeau, Seth M
f877a501-5bb6-4704-9de7-28b7a3cf8361
Bloch, Guy
3115081f-d50c-46c2-80c8-7b1bb8a965f6
De Graaf, Dirk C
9dfb95c2-22f2-41f6-9580-f772be0ce36e
Dearden, Peter
ea2a0df1-5cb7-4101-93c8-5bc7b3898d33
Elsik, Christine G
20912fb0-b8e9-4288-a993-da851f8cf69b
Gadau, Jürgen
77fcef92-0260-4b86-8526-f4c8e992e278
Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis Jp
7d236433-3e53-492b-8572-8f65fd766897
Hasselmann, Martin
ec52f0cc-82e5-491b-ac9c-5ba84766bf0c
Lozier, Jeffrey D
459651d6-49dc-40f9-b81d-d3517bd64598
Robertson, Hugh M
152c4c05-1f27-43e4-a296-1fd21374056b
Smagghe, Guy
dd96063a-ac19-45b2-8ed2-6b402cb22ce0
Stolle, Eckart
a58f29fe-8b4a-4d4c-86b7-5654e3909b86
Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias
531352c0-f7d8-45e1-9011-bfb0bad6cf8a
Waterhouse, Robert M
263e4726-529a-461b-896c-118845b278ff
Bornberg-bauer, Erich
59bf0725-91ac-4a09-b492-b6ce238b8e0a
Klasberg, Steffen
2cf73a21-7007-40ec-bd7c-3e72704d48c6
Bennett, Anna K
6a8d7e9d-7d77-4ea8-8421-31869be96936
Câmara, Francisco
0ff79889-81b7-4e96-8865-2b17f04420c0
Guigó, Roderic
5ae54aaa-f40b-4a41-ab99-cfdf010cdd66
Hoff, Katharina
041ceb9c-883c-448e-93f3-dcd124e200c3
Mariotti, Marco
488cb871-6db9-4a77-96d1-350600a589ed
Munoz-torres, Monica
7eaed64b-d1fc-4ce3-af50-25735079f361
Murphy, Terence
2ed50910-9b35-43a2-b311-89a4ce2297e3
Santesmasses, Didac
c9cb52b7-aa8c-4382-bb5c-1937cf8c19d8
Amdam, Gro V
6e5d2775-64ca-4926-9dbc-37b6f0ecf4de
Beckers, Matthew
17c0a087-12aa-4f08-b371-dbac3acae82a
Beye, Martin
c8af0659-0354-4012-b633-e93b2f3ff29e
Biewer, Matthias
99e486a5-8b40-49c9-9492-8b615ec2a99e
Bitondi, Márcia Mg
a71f31b4-5faf-4214-8a61-38b1f4c186ea
Blaxter, Mark L
5f03450c-455a-448d-97cc-ea096ba0c57e
Bourke, Andrew Fg
b1d6e49d-33f3-4c28-874d-4f4f40edc1ef
Brown, Mark Jf
e948d727-2341-4c1c-a385-b3d5963dd703
Buechel, Severine D
41cc38f6-5736-475a-8673-b879f2d07906
Cameron, Rossanah
6bedf1f5-8b20-4271-825a-a0f036b404d8
Cappelle, Kaat
24f8eb88-1b2f-4480-9494-418642e07853
Carolan, James C
c3b9dbd5-de64-498c-af0e-2c747df05275
Christiaens, Olivier
325fcc8d-70c1-434c-8065-fc084ecbf131
Ciborowski, Kate L
7a3a2207-67b6-469b-b399-84eed35bac4e
Clarke, David F
c6db207f-cdf9-48c0-a0ca-2bbf29e374c0
Colgan, Thomas J
ecfbe74f-4794-46cf-87fa-601ba2568025
Collins, David H
24bcac30-862c-4005-af0d-31a3f7093a6c
Cridge, Andrew G
82d132c8-6621-4151-a55b-12e454d20aca
Dalmay, Tamas
c224e5fb-99c1-45f0-ba79-c1c2675d3742
Dreier, Stephanie
7d2753d3-63a6-4d41-9e56-41de1c9b80c3
Du Plessis, Louis
b73c550f-9e6a-44af-b09a-c863c45efb8e
Duncan, Elizabeth
e35aea74-200a-431d-a721-c0955017e185
Erler, Silvio
05efe494-6c08-4988-a3f1-976e352a07ec
Evans, Jay
22ab579d-8897-481d-9377-fcd6a27cf9dc
Lockett, Gabrielle A
4d92a28c-f54c-431b-81f6-e82ad9057d7a
1 December 2015
Sadd, Ben M
4ce5579c-8533-409b-89d8-98e3c07239b4
Barribeau, Seth M
f877a501-5bb6-4704-9de7-28b7a3cf8361
Bloch, Guy
3115081f-d50c-46c2-80c8-7b1bb8a965f6
De Graaf, Dirk C
9dfb95c2-22f2-41f6-9580-f772be0ce36e
Dearden, Peter
ea2a0df1-5cb7-4101-93c8-5bc7b3898d33
Elsik, Christine G
20912fb0-b8e9-4288-a993-da851f8cf69b
Gadau, Jürgen
77fcef92-0260-4b86-8526-f4c8e992e278
Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis Jp
7d236433-3e53-492b-8572-8f65fd766897
Hasselmann, Martin
ec52f0cc-82e5-491b-ac9c-5ba84766bf0c
Lozier, Jeffrey D
459651d6-49dc-40f9-b81d-d3517bd64598
Robertson, Hugh M
152c4c05-1f27-43e4-a296-1fd21374056b
Smagghe, Guy
dd96063a-ac19-45b2-8ed2-6b402cb22ce0
Stolle, Eckart
a58f29fe-8b4a-4d4c-86b7-5654e3909b86
Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias
531352c0-f7d8-45e1-9011-bfb0bad6cf8a
Waterhouse, Robert M
263e4726-529a-461b-896c-118845b278ff
Bornberg-bauer, Erich
59bf0725-91ac-4a09-b492-b6ce238b8e0a
Klasberg, Steffen
2cf73a21-7007-40ec-bd7c-3e72704d48c6
Bennett, Anna K
6a8d7e9d-7d77-4ea8-8421-31869be96936
Câmara, Francisco
0ff79889-81b7-4e96-8865-2b17f04420c0
Guigó, Roderic
5ae54aaa-f40b-4a41-ab99-cfdf010cdd66
Hoff, Katharina
041ceb9c-883c-448e-93f3-dcd124e200c3
Mariotti, Marco
488cb871-6db9-4a77-96d1-350600a589ed
Munoz-torres, Monica
7eaed64b-d1fc-4ce3-af50-25735079f361
Murphy, Terence
2ed50910-9b35-43a2-b311-89a4ce2297e3
Santesmasses, Didac
c9cb52b7-aa8c-4382-bb5c-1937cf8c19d8
Amdam, Gro V
6e5d2775-64ca-4926-9dbc-37b6f0ecf4de
Beckers, Matthew
17c0a087-12aa-4f08-b371-dbac3acae82a
Beye, Martin
c8af0659-0354-4012-b633-e93b2f3ff29e
Biewer, Matthias
99e486a5-8b40-49c9-9492-8b615ec2a99e
Bitondi, Márcia Mg
a71f31b4-5faf-4214-8a61-38b1f4c186ea
Blaxter, Mark L
5f03450c-455a-448d-97cc-ea096ba0c57e
Bourke, Andrew Fg
b1d6e49d-33f3-4c28-874d-4f4f40edc1ef
Brown, Mark Jf
e948d727-2341-4c1c-a385-b3d5963dd703
Buechel, Severine D
41cc38f6-5736-475a-8673-b879f2d07906
Cameron, Rossanah
6bedf1f5-8b20-4271-825a-a0f036b404d8
Cappelle, Kaat
24f8eb88-1b2f-4480-9494-418642e07853
Carolan, James C
c3b9dbd5-de64-498c-af0e-2c747df05275
Christiaens, Olivier
325fcc8d-70c1-434c-8065-fc084ecbf131
Ciborowski, Kate L
7a3a2207-67b6-469b-b399-84eed35bac4e
Clarke, David F
c6db207f-cdf9-48c0-a0ca-2bbf29e374c0
Colgan, Thomas J
ecfbe74f-4794-46cf-87fa-601ba2568025
Collins, David H
24bcac30-862c-4005-af0d-31a3f7093a6c
Cridge, Andrew G
82d132c8-6621-4151-a55b-12e454d20aca
Dalmay, Tamas
c224e5fb-99c1-45f0-ba79-c1c2675d3742
Dreier, Stephanie
7d2753d3-63a6-4d41-9e56-41de1c9b80c3
Du Plessis, Louis
b73c550f-9e6a-44af-b09a-c863c45efb8e
Duncan, Elizabeth
e35aea74-200a-431d-a721-c0955017e185
Erler, Silvio
05efe494-6c08-4988-a3f1-976e352a07ec
Evans, Jay
22ab579d-8897-481d-9377-fcd6a27cf9dc
Lockett, Gabrielle A
4d92a28c-f54c-431b-81f6-e82ad9057d7a