The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS)

The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS)
The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS)

Objective: To develop and update evidence-based and consensus-based guidelines on laparoscopic and robotic pancreatic surgery. Summary Background Data: Minimally invasive pancreatic surgery (MIPS), including laparoscopic and robotic surgery, is complex and technically demanding. Minimizing the risk for patients requires stringent, evidence-based guidelines. Since the International Miami Guidelines on MIPS in 2019, new developments and key publications have been reported, necessitating an update. Methods: Evidence-based guidelines on 22 topics in 8 domains were proposed: terminology, indications, patients, procedures, surgical techniques and instrumentation, assessment tools, implementation and training, and artificial intelligence. The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS, September 2022) used the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) methodology to assess the evidence and develop guideline recommendations, the Delphi method to establish consensus on the recommendations among the Expert Committee, and the AGREE II-GRS tool for guideline quality assessment and external validation by a Validation Committee. Results: Overall, 27 European experts, 6 international experts, 22 international Validation Committee members, 11 Jury Committee members, 18 Research Committee members, and 121 registered attendees of the 2-day meeting were involved in the development and validation of the guidelines. In total, 98 recommendations were developed, including 33 on laparoscopic, 34 on robotic, and 31 on general MIPS, covering 22 topics in 8 domains. Out of 98 recommendations, 97 reached at least 80% consensus among the experts and congress attendees, and all recommendations were externally validated by the Validation Committee. Conclusions: The EGUMIPS evidence-based guidelines on laparoscopic and robotic MIPS can be applied in current clinical practice to provide guidance to patients, surgeons, policy-makers, and medical societies.

guidelines, pancreas, surgry, evidence-based guidelines, robotic pancreatic surgery, laparoscopic pancreatic surgery, minimally invasive pancreatic surgery
0003-4932
45-57
Abu Hilal, Mohammad
eadffdfb-f2f4-4f77-84f6-573015ce7a50
van Ramshorst, Tess M.E.
e2469565-684f-4751-8e26-ae2175125b1e
Boggi, Ugo
134fd957-620c-48b2-8b08-f2051fb2a953
Dokmak, Safi
632b4bb2-e6aa-4acd-88c1-d764da95e3a1
Edwin, Bjørn
b04994d3-928a-49ad-8bdf-183c7e7a08d2
Keck, Tobias
8a68ba34-6169-413c-96d0-a920d9ebecc5
Khatkov, Igor
69336d3e-0232-4ffa-80e9-c9310146c128
Ahmad, Jawad
2378fd75-73a9-4589-b88c-1bcbd91d24a5
Al Saati, Hani
44ef292e-b727-45e2-a4da-6b0835b71613
Alseidi, Adnan
56ccae5a-69f6-424b-8921-0f73bfff0d60
Azagra, Juan S.
d3e7dc96-be67-4100-be1b-074bcf55552b
Björnsson, Bergthor
fe8fcaf2-bd24-497c-b00a-62f7fc34c2e4
Can, Fatih M.
2f0eef05-b2b6-4346-8fcf-f06500008272
D'Hondt, Mathieu
c0a0e77a-094e-4173-a571-453cb3a1e1d9
Efanov, Mikhail
ceefe17f-20c9-4add-837c-0d9a3edca254
Alvarez, Francisco Espin
4860f961-b530-453b-b943-1570b64f61ba
Esposito, Alessandro
a248c941-ccba-431c-a3c4-668c85f6dbb9
Ferrari, Giovanni
29ec9621-a8dd-4737-aef4-e01612afd32f
Koerkamp, Bas Groot
6ef2d5db-d7ac-45ce-9dd9-7e07a63f60dc
Gumbs, Andrew A.
1f3f87b3-2f19-4be8-8018-5e776aa63aed
Hogg, Melissa E.
012fb9c0-2756-4ad3-afbf-f8c1752014d9
Huscher, Cristiano G.S.
84f4fdd3-9ef6-4dd5-b0c6-e2ceaea2cb32
Ielpo, Benedetto
e7699c60-2945-45fb-ae80-4006b3d6c23f
Ivanecz, Arpad
fbba88bd-c888-4e58-bcd8-12b244850b52
Jang, Jin-Young
7a86406c-ead4-4c5b-9148-8a22edfa524c
Liu, Rong
c30d45dd-68bc-4410-9e9a-7dc5598eb89e
Luyer, Misha D.P.
69cc95aa-3906-4330-ad02-0fe495b4389f
Menon, Krishna
d07aeb0b-4e37-4f9a-b23c-55d5d35fa535
Nakamura, Masafumi
92ee1512-d41f-43b0-87bb-4585b7d7a625
Piardi, Tullio
5518ebca-5692-434e-8e84-941c683d3ef1
Saint-Marc, Olivier
f5f1ef5c-9c84-4c0e-8b30-359eb5cdf95c
White, Steve
5cbbd8df-d8af-404c-be75-cfd419db1b34
Yoon, Yoo-Seok
933c33f2-944f-45fb-97fa-9533f12980ac
Zerbi, Alessandro
8ffae682-e51d-4584-9e62-1d33012b97f8
Bassi, Claudio
247ade4b-d6a6-4816-ade1-292031a4ec92
Berrevoet, Frederik
e545a28b-7399-4d20-b6e2-599ae383b08e
Chan, Carlos
36837523-8a11-4d05-a575-18ba76939ab1
Coimbra, Felipe J.
f2c04ca8-d1a4-43db-ab8f-689f70ab48dd
Conlon, Kevin C.P.
061283a5-0d97-4133-90de-73549225306d
Cook, Andrew
ab9c7bb3-974a-4db9-b3c2-9942988005d5
Dervenis, Christos
8a2669fc-fe08-4830-b418-8cc29f13dcc2
Falconi, Massimo
b9496ba2-e76d-455e-8cb6-56fd6d74dd4d
Ferrari, Clarissa
8aab3a17-4448-435b-9c60-264f8a6fad19
Frigerio, Isabella
bf1a6ead-4ae3-4a8a-9f3b-9940e697db39
Fusai, Giuseppe K.
2f44d5cb-579d-4543-bf7b-66d4fa2e25bb
De Oliveira, Michelle L
f13ab829-9509-4670-82a7-cbde031abfc9
Pinna, Antonio D.
ddd66053-1d2b-42a5-939d-f0090a15c33a
Primrose, John
d85f3b28-24c6-475f-955b-ec457a3f9185
Sauvanet, Alain
525bbc50-f1c3-4cbb-b53b-7ec636e93f9a
Smadi, Sameer
dea572d9-f2ae-4f22-9ec9-6a172f951ab7
et al.
Abu Hilal, Mohammad
eadffdfb-f2f4-4f77-84f6-573015ce7a50
van Ramshorst, Tess M.E.
e2469565-684f-4751-8e26-ae2175125b1e
Boggi, Ugo
134fd957-620c-48b2-8b08-f2051fb2a953
Dokmak, Safi
632b4bb2-e6aa-4acd-88c1-d764da95e3a1
Edwin, Bjørn
b04994d3-928a-49ad-8bdf-183c7e7a08d2
Keck, Tobias
8a68ba34-6169-413c-96d0-a920d9ebecc5
Khatkov, Igor
69336d3e-0232-4ffa-80e9-c9310146c128
Ahmad, Jawad
2378fd75-73a9-4589-b88c-1bcbd91d24a5
Al Saati, Hani
44ef292e-b727-45e2-a4da-6b0835b71613
Alseidi, Adnan
56ccae5a-69f6-424b-8921-0f73bfff0d60
Azagra, Juan S.
d3e7dc96-be67-4100-be1b-074bcf55552b
Björnsson, Bergthor
fe8fcaf2-bd24-497c-b00a-62f7fc34c2e4
Can, Fatih M.
2f0eef05-b2b6-4346-8fcf-f06500008272
D'Hondt, Mathieu
c0a0e77a-094e-4173-a571-453cb3a1e1d9
Efanov, Mikhail
ceefe17f-20c9-4add-837c-0d9a3edca254
Alvarez, Francisco Espin
4860f961-b530-453b-b943-1570b64f61ba
Esposito, Alessandro
a248c941-ccba-431c-a3c4-668c85f6dbb9
Ferrari, Giovanni
29ec9621-a8dd-4737-aef4-e01612afd32f
Koerkamp, Bas Groot
6ef2d5db-d7ac-45ce-9dd9-7e07a63f60dc
Gumbs, Andrew A.
1f3f87b3-2f19-4be8-8018-5e776aa63aed
Hogg, Melissa E.
012fb9c0-2756-4ad3-afbf-f8c1752014d9
Huscher, Cristiano G.S.
84f4fdd3-9ef6-4dd5-b0c6-e2ceaea2cb32
Ielpo, Benedetto
e7699c60-2945-45fb-ae80-4006b3d6c23f
Ivanecz, Arpad
fbba88bd-c888-4e58-bcd8-12b244850b52
Jang, Jin-Young
7a86406c-ead4-4c5b-9148-8a22edfa524c
Liu, Rong
c30d45dd-68bc-4410-9e9a-7dc5598eb89e
Luyer, Misha D.P.
69cc95aa-3906-4330-ad02-0fe495b4389f
Menon, Krishna
d07aeb0b-4e37-4f9a-b23c-55d5d35fa535
Nakamura, Masafumi
92ee1512-d41f-43b0-87bb-4585b7d7a625
Piardi, Tullio
5518ebca-5692-434e-8e84-941c683d3ef1
Saint-Marc, Olivier
f5f1ef5c-9c84-4c0e-8b30-359eb5cdf95c
White, Steve
5cbbd8df-d8af-404c-be75-cfd419db1b34
Yoon, Yoo-Seok
933c33f2-944f-45fb-97fa-9533f12980ac
Zerbi, Alessandro
8ffae682-e51d-4584-9e62-1d33012b97f8
Bassi, Claudio
247ade4b-d6a6-4816-ade1-292031a4ec92
Berrevoet, Frederik
e545a28b-7399-4d20-b6e2-599ae383b08e
Chan, Carlos
36837523-8a11-4d05-a575-18ba76939ab1
Coimbra, Felipe J.
f2c04ca8-d1a4-43db-ab8f-689f70ab48dd
Conlon, Kevin C.P.
061283a5-0d97-4133-90de-73549225306d
Cook, Andrew
ab9c7bb3-974a-4db9-b3c2-9942988005d5
Dervenis, Christos
8a2669fc-fe08-4830-b418-8cc29f13dcc2
Falconi, Massimo
b9496ba2-e76d-455e-8cb6-56fd6d74dd4d
Ferrari, Clarissa
8aab3a17-4448-435b-9c60-264f8a6fad19
Frigerio, Isabella
bf1a6ead-4ae3-4a8a-9f3b-9940e697db39
Fusai, Giuseppe K.
2f44d5cb-579d-4543-bf7b-66d4fa2e25bb
De Oliveira, Michelle L
f13ab829-9509-4670-82a7-cbde031abfc9
Pinna, Antonio D.
ddd66053-1d2b-42a5-939d-f0090a15c33a
Primrose, John
d85f3b28-24c6-475f-955b-ec457a3f9185
Sauvanet, Alain
525bbc50-f1c3-4cbb-b53b-7ec636e93f9a
Smadi, Sameer
dea572d9-f2ae-4f22-9ec9-6a172f951ab7

Abu Hilal, Mohammad, van Ramshorst, Tess M.E. and Boggi, Ugo , et al. (2024) The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS). Annals of Surgery, 279 (1), 45-57. (doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000006006).

Record type: Review

Abstract

Objective: To develop and update evidence-based and consensus-based guidelines on laparoscopic and robotic pancreatic surgery. Summary Background Data: Minimally invasive pancreatic surgery (MIPS), including laparoscopic and robotic surgery, is complex and technically demanding. Minimizing the risk for patients requires stringent, evidence-based guidelines. Since the International Miami Guidelines on MIPS in 2019, new developments and key publications have been reported, necessitating an update. Methods: Evidence-based guidelines on 22 topics in 8 domains were proposed: terminology, indications, patients, procedures, surgical techniques and instrumentation, assessment tools, implementation and training, and artificial intelligence. The Brescia Internationally Validated European Guidelines on Minimally Invasive Pancreatic Surgery (EGUMIPS, September 2022) used the Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network (SIGN) methodology to assess the evidence and develop guideline recommendations, the Delphi method to establish consensus on the recommendations among the Expert Committee, and the AGREE II-GRS tool for guideline quality assessment and external validation by a Validation Committee. Results: Overall, 27 European experts, 6 international experts, 22 international Validation Committee members, 11 Jury Committee members, 18 Research Committee members, and 121 registered attendees of the 2-day meeting were involved in the development and validation of the guidelines. In total, 98 recommendations were developed, including 33 on laparoscopic, 34 on robotic, and 31 on general MIPS, covering 22 topics in 8 domains. Out of 98 recommendations, 97 reached at least 80% consensus among the experts and congress attendees, and all recommendations were externally validated by the Validation Committee. Conclusions: The EGUMIPS evidence-based guidelines on laparoscopic and robotic MIPS can be applied in current clinical practice to provide guidance to patients, surgeons, policy-makers, and medical societies.

Text
The_Brescia_Internationally_Validated_European.554 - Accepted Manuscript
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (650kB)

More information

e-pub ahead of print date: 14 July 2023
Published date: 1 January 2024
Additional Information: Publisher Copyright: © 2024 Lippincott Williams and Wilkins. All rights reserved.
Keywords: guidelines, pancreas, surgry, evidence-based guidelines, robotic pancreatic surgery, laparoscopic pancreatic surgery, minimally invasive pancreatic surgery

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 479531
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/479531
ISSN: 0003-4932
PURE UUID: bc86e57f-6372-4fc3-8248-88759b97bf40
ORCID for Andrew Cook: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-6680-439X
ORCID for John Primrose: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-2069-7605

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 26 Jul 2023 05:11
Last modified: 13 Apr 2024 01:40

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Mohammad Abu Hilal
Author: Tess M.E. van Ramshorst
Author: Ugo Boggi
Author: Safi Dokmak
Author: Bjørn Edwin
Author: Tobias Keck
Author: Igor Khatkov
Author: Jawad Ahmad
Author: Hani Al Saati
Author: Adnan Alseidi
Author: Juan S. Azagra
Author: Bergthor Björnsson
Author: Fatih M. Can
Author: Mathieu D'Hondt
Author: Mikhail Efanov
Author: Francisco Espin Alvarez
Author: Alessandro Esposito
Author: Giovanni Ferrari
Author: Bas Groot Koerkamp
Author: Andrew A. Gumbs
Author: Melissa E. Hogg
Author: Cristiano G.S. Huscher
Author: Benedetto Ielpo
Author: Arpad Ivanecz
Author: Jin-Young Jang
Author: Rong Liu
Author: Misha D.P. Luyer
Author: Krishna Menon
Author: Masafumi Nakamura
Author: Tullio Piardi
Author: Olivier Saint-Marc
Author: Steve White
Author: Yoo-Seok Yoon
Author: Alessandro Zerbi
Author: Claudio Bassi
Author: Frederik Berrevoet
Author: Carlos Chan
Author: Felipe J. Coimbra
Author: Kevin C.P. Conlon
Author: Andrew Cook ORCID iD
Author: Christos Dervenis
Author: Massimo Falconi
Author: Clarissa Ferrari
Author: Isabella Frigerio
Author: Giuseppe K. Fusai
Author: Michelle L De Oliveira
Author: Antonio D. Pinna
Author: John Primrose ORCID iD
Author: Alain Sauvanet
Author: Sameer Smadi
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×