Limited environmental and yield benefits of intercropping practices in smallholder fields: evidence from multi-source data

Abstract

Context: To ensure food security in sub-Saharan Africa, it is necessary to improve crop yields while minimizing environmental impacts. Intercropping has been demonstrated to deliver such outcomes, but their performance in smallholder fields has received limited attention therefore insufficient to capture the complexity of real-world crop fields run by smallholder farmers. Objective: This study examines the benefits and management of intercropping practices in real smallholder fields in Malawi. Methods: We collected field data on intercrop types, the number of intercropped species and maize yield in intercropped maize fields. Field data was then combined with geospatial and household survey data to investigate the yield benefits, agricultural inputs, and factors related to intercropping choices. We used Pearson correlation and Tukey's test to test the statistical significance in the difference between intercropped fields and monoculture fields. Results: We found that more intercrops were planted in fields with smaller sizes, drier conditions, and higher soil erosion levels, with adoption rates increasing from 75 % in 2010 to 84 % in 2020. In addition, our field data shows that intercropping is associated with reduced primary maize yield (2.7 t/ha) compared to pure maize yield (3.8 t/ha). Conversely, satellite data demonstrates an improvement in overall field yield in intercropped fields. Meanwhile, intercropped fields require higher labor inputs (11 h more per season) and increased weeding times than monocultures, however agrochemical inputs (fertilizers and pesticides) do not necessarily decrease in intercropped fields compared to monocultures. Conclusions: Our results suggest that while smallholder farmers in Malawi adopt intercropping to improve land use efficiency, drought resilience, and soil fertility, they are not realizing the full benefits observed in experimental trials. Implications: More evidence on the benefits and best practices of intercropping in smallholder fields is necessary in order to better understand this practice as an option for sustainable intensification.

More information

Identifiers

ORCID for Jadunandan Dash: orcid.org/0000-0002-5444-2109

Catalogue record

Export record

Altmetrics