The accuracy and precision of small-sized modern wood samples analyzed at the Chronos 14Carbon-Cycle Facility
The accuracy and precision of small-sized modern wood samples analyzed at the Chronos 14Carbon-Cycle Facility
Tree-ring series offer considerable potential for the development of environment-sensitive proxy records. However, with traditional increment cores, only small amounts of wood are often available from annual tree-ring sequences. For this reason, it is important to understand the reliability (and reproducibility) of radiocarbon measurements obtained from small-sized samples. Here we report the F14C results from the Chronos 14Carbon-Cycle Facility of modern tropical Australian tree samples over a range of four graphite target sizes from the same rings. Our study shows that similar precision can be obtained from full-sized, half-sized, as well as small-sized graphite targets using standard pretreatment and analysis procedures. However, with a decline in sample size, there was an increase seen in the associated variance of the ages and the smallest target weights started showing a systematic bias. Wiggle-matching accuracy tests, comparing the Southern Hemisphere post-bomb atmospheric calibration curve to the different sample weight sequences, were all significant except for the 200 gC graphite targets. Our results indicate that samples smaller than 350 gC have limited accuracy and precision. Overall, reliable measurements of F14C sequences from tree-ring records across a range of sample sizes, with best results found using graphitized samples >350 gC.
environmental change, FC, MIni CArbon DAting System (MICADAS), small sample size, tree rings, (FC)-C-14
561-571
Haines, Heather A.
0b5e1c15-6478-4a59-b960-4fa836ca1077
Hiscock, William T.
57d2eb7d-bf3d-4423-95c5-8ca254b4a513
Palmer, Jonathan G.
6b327a39-f234-4cdc-ae73-0c48340f05b3
Turney, Chris S.M.
5149b57c-77c2-4375-97a2-a4f00aa74d97
Thomas, Zoë A.
4b512d3a-3478-4270-9fdd-61256aa640d3
Cadd, Haidee
76201167-1262-4904-a8d7-d7551fbb1d43
Vohra, Juee
3ab852d5-baf8-4161-bfe3-302767cdee2b
Marjo, Christopher E.
6ab38661-cb2d-4a78-a102-cf2d9e29cd43
21 April 2023
Haines, Heather A.
0b5e1c15-6478-4a59-b960-4fa836ca1077
Hiscock, William T.
57d2eb7d-bf3d-4423-95c5-8ca254b4a513
Palmer, Jonathan G.
6b327a39-f234-4cdc-ae73-0c48340f05b3
Turney, Chris S.M.
5149b57c-77c2-4375-97a2-a4f00aa74d97
Thomas, Zoë A.
4b512d3a-3478-4270-9fdd-61256aa640d3
Cadd, Haidee
76201167-1262-4904-a8d7-d7551fbb1d43
Vohra, Juee
3ab852d5-baf8-4161-bfe3-302767cdee2b
Marjo, Christopher E.
6ab38661-cb2d-4a78-a102-cf2d9e29cd43
Haines, Heather A., Hiscock, William T., Palmer, Jonathan G., Turney, Chris S.M., Thomas, Zoë A., Cadd, Haidee, Vohra, Juee and Marjo, Christopher E.
(2023)
The accuracy and precision of small-sized modern wood samples analyzed at the Chronos 14Carbon-Cycle Facility.
Radiocarbon, 65 (2), .
(doi:10.1017/RDC.2023.4).
Abstract
Tree-ring series offer considerable potential for the development of environment-sensitive proxy records. However, with traditional increment cores, only small amounts of wood are often available from annual tree-ring sequences. For this reason, it is important to understand the reliability (and reproducibility) of radiocarbon measurements obtained from small-sized samples. Here we report the F14C results from the Chronos 14Carbon-Cycle Facility of modern tropical Australian tree samples over a range of four graphite target sizes from the same rings. Our study shows that similar precision can be obtained from full-sized, half-sized, as well as small-sized graphite targets using standard pretreatment and analysis procedures. However, with a decline in sample size, there was an increase seen in the associated variance of the ages and the smallest target weights started showing a systematic bias. Wiggle-matching accuracy tests, comparing the Southern Hemisphere post-bomb atmospheric calibration curve to the different sample weight sequences, were all significant except for the 200 gC graphite targets. Our results indicate that samples smaller than 350 gC have limited accuracy and precision. Overall, reliable measurements of F14C sequences from tree-ring records across a range of sample sizes, with best results found using graphitized samples >350 gC.
Text
Haines et al. 2023 the-accuracy-and-precision-of-small-sized-modern-wood-samples-analyzed-at-the-chronos-14carbon-cycle-facility
Restricted to Repository staff only
Request a copy
More information
e-pub ahead of print date: 21 April 2023
Published date: 21 April 2023
Keywords:
environmental change, FC, MIni CArbon DAting System (MICADAS), small sample size, tree rings, (FC)-C-14
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 481790
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/481790
ISSN: 0033-8222
PURE UUID: dbbd2aa5-9992-423b-9e24-2d11a5e15f92
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 07 Sep 2023 16:42
Last modified: 06 Jun 2024 02:16
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Heather A. Haines
Author:
William T. Hiscock
Author:
Jonathan G. Palmer
Author:
Chris S.M. Turney
Author:
Zoë A. Thomas
Author:
Haidee Cadd
Author:
Juee Vohra
Author:
Christopher E. Marjo
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics