The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program results: type Ia Supernova brightness correlates with host galaxy dust

The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program results: type Ia Supernova brightness correlates with host galaxy dust
The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program results: type Ia Supernova brightness correlates with host galaxy dust
Cosmological analyses with type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) often assume a single empirical relation between colour and luminosity (β) and do not account for varying host-galaxy dust properties. However, from studies of dust in large samples of galaxies, it is known that dust attenuation can vary significantly. Here, we take advantage of state-of-the-art modelling of galaxy properties to characterize dust parameters (dust attenuation AV, and a parameter describing the dust law slope RV) for 1100 Dark Energy Survey (DES) SN host galaxies. Utilizing optical and infrared data of the hosts alone, we find three key aspects of host dust that impact SN cosmology: (1) there exists a large range (∼1–6) of host RV; (2) high-stellar mass hosts have RV on average ∼0.7 lower than that of low-mass hosts; (3) for a subsample of 81 spectroscopically classified SNe there is a significant (>3σ) correlation between the Hubble diagram residuals of red SNe Ia and the host RV that when corrected for reduces scatter by ∼13 per cent∼13 per cent and the significance of the ‘mass step’ to ∼1σ. These represent independent confirmations of recent predictions based on dust that attempted to explain the puzzling ‘mass step’ and intrinsic scatter (σint) in SN Ia analyses.
astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA
1365-2966
1985–2004
Meldorf, Cole
3cca9e19-a8c0-4d01-b86b-6ca55f25cbe2
Palmese, Antonella
8b71d0c5-06d9-4633-b796-865cd492aae5
Brout, Dillon
3c80bd11-51f5-4d3a-b0f1-02b3f0389e7d
Chen, Rebecca
06aa7502-ca5d-4ae0-9f34-5afc3fcec15c
Scolnic, Daniel
354fb11f-024e-4bcc-9192-dd9b3e61adf0
Kelsey, Lisa
e468815b-9246-4e0f-a6d5-b037765590e4
Galbany, Lluís
53211706-78b6-4666-b078-e19b0273a513
Hartley, Will
83ee157c-84cb-4a84-a59f-f623aaf364b4
Davis, Tamara
c578ca32-c9d2-4f21-8fbb-84bc741c1cd7
Drlica-Wagner, Alex
c3437869-8575-4c08-b7f4-ce0771fd0db6
Vincenzi, Maria
a15a3563-56f2-4692-b192-36b745e67d0b
Annis, James
2c3e39f4-a2a3-411d-952a-c254b45707b5
Dixon, Mitchell
7edf01fa-ce4b-411b-b01f-3a7c19f2200f
Graur, Or
02c2ee78-2e37-4304-8dcf-d5bbb56536fc
Kim, Alex
6a8ff299-4d14-47da-8016-3c6b957fc920
Lidman, Christopher
1c2af5d6-f6a9-418d-a3db-d64fc630f77b
Möller, Anais
90240402-7f83-45db-8eae-d6085024b031
Nugent, Peter
f98e37c2-aa8f-455b-8eb9-5b350046a2e0
Rose, Benjamin
98cc9230-85ba-4e10-8461-0bf205046c87
Smith, Mathew
8bdc74e1-a37b-434d-ae75-82763109bf7a
Allam, Sahar
7b660f87-7928-4d0d-a70b-d216ebae7abe
Diehl, H. Thomas
e9d80b5a-51f2-447a-a8eb-0e90cb3ed8ce
Tucker, Douglas
56c3322c-8787-4097-86c5-6b32a5421aa3
Asorey, Jacobo
c15770ed-d448-4e4e-b4f1-834b1ecbd981
Calcino, Josh
348b8430-c4c0-4540-b55f-4891565b8d3d
Carollo, Daniela
ba0d39dc-bf78-4cd9-b545-db7e31b2467c
Glazebrook, Karl
a0f7c538-1e8c-4ea8-9f49-a5ab0eb353f4
Lewis, Geraint
03eec181-f335-4eec-9be9-ec03e611f19b
Taylor, Georgina
676f33d8-e407-4c9d-a8f1-89563de95ba2
Tucker, Brad E.
6f4db462-bdb8-4c2e-891b-3d00c0be0c56
Aguena, Michel
6adbfd8d-6b07-47a1-9380-97434d73fb8e
Andrade-Oliveira, Felipe
4bd08020-ec95-4380-a556-66d5b439753e
Bacon, David
e3465208-c360-4d45-b8c9-7ace451a7d43
Bertin, Emmanuel
3434204a-f930-40e1-9e4d-21b0df6d58ec
Bocquet, Sebastian
9bc911fd-76df-41a4-be99-8ba15b0591b3
Brooks, David
2b1c5a0f-d701-4dc7-97bc-e774a020762c
Burke, David
aa60811e-c486-433f-aace-cf30dc3b45b6
Carretero, Jorge
8ed8b4af-5b18-4854-bb6c-d8ce8d386c00
Kind, Matias Carrasco
e2affdb5-0f85-4471-8a13-f32d81e9b35b
Castander, Francisco Javier
fed824f5-b672-4d58-92cf-d2f4e090e721
Costanzi, Matteo
f5d41c1b-6f89-46a9-9278-81039f112b5a
Costa, Luiz da
adf9d5ad-0433-4d95-a99f-eaf193e9d090
Desai, Shantanu
b991e8e7-d64f-4d08-ac5a-564372822a46
Doel, Peter
0f9d3420-e532-44ac-b687-b9051e0cb596
Everett, Spencer
e0dc953b-4278-486c-b05a-74fe19c1ef25
Ferrero, Ismael
67c5547a-e919-4b14-981f-0a90d9589640
Friedel, Douglas
8c16c152-f211-4925-b8cf-e7d6984e223e
Frieman, Josh
e1bdde5c-9577-4826-a1a1-ba3ebb65095c
Garcia-Bellido, Juan
2dd20b70-bb01-47b7-bd4e-11f5e0dcdfe0
Gatti, Marco
9030e965-b5a6-4a0a-ba19-775d9337e852
Gruen, Daniel
ccb6c63f-0287-4a68-a43b-39e57e3005e6
Gschwend, Julia
145943bc-e79c-4be2-aae5-d6ad10c72d9f
Gutierrez, Gaston
9351e95b-09fd-4557-b2e8-0e755a8e6473
Hinton, Samuel
9e2f00d6-7026-4491-a28e-17d5880f65d1
Hollowood, Devon L.
0148abc6-4e30-4746-8b32-c7fe1ba285f7
Honscheid, Klaus
88cd08db-e75b-4c0f-9910-ac56504cb8a0
James, David
6607bafb-c9f0-413c-9d41-a8366fbd61a5
Kuehn, Kyler
8a2596e9-ba5b-47f1-8874-7015fce5a8a9
March, Marisa
52a1e735-e7d8-4872-ba8a-5455716a307e
Marshall, Jennifer
4c26b5c7-399e-40d9-a492-16b4d79e255c
Menanteau, Felipe
1bc0c994-18ac-40d4-9418-88566097f1b7
Miquel, Ramon
0fea613a-4365-4a72-a4e4-5ace87b031f5
Morgan, Robert
c7652169-29e0-462c-a519-a199b3a9a8c6
Paz-Chinchon, Francisco
f94426af-d95b-47dc-be27-86eb4e57271f
Pereira, Maria Elidaiana da Silva
bd3d3ea0-8db5-4c56-a8d4-e59d29fe6fac
Sanchez, Eusebio
74a62676-ee80-43b0-b504-8a5c389b6545
Scarpine, Vic
83f16cff-1be1-4bf1-90a1-9a065a4ccc83
Sevilla, Ignacio
2bb4f8c2-27f5-4b7e-a2ea-3d01f24baf0a
Suchyta, Eric
ad4d6b19-7675-4b01-9583-9bdc22f8cb8d
Tarle, Gregory
b99b5456-2e33-4a01-a86f-4f2418ffbede
Varga, Tamas Norbert
2f288ec4-3d23-436d-bba9-b0e1aca38ceb
Meldorf, Cole
3cca9e19-a8c0-4d01-b86b-6ca55f25cbe2
Palmese, Antonella
8b71d0c5-06d9-4633-b796-865cd492aae5
Brout, Dillon
3c80bd11-51f5-4d3a-b0f1-02b3f0389e7d
Chen, Rebecca
06aa7502-ca5d-4ae0-9f34-5afc3fcec15c
Scolnic, Daniel
354fb11f-024e-4bcc-9192-dd9b3e61adf0
Kelsey, Lisa
e468815b-9246-4e0f-a6d5-b037765590e4
Galbany, Lluís
53211706-78b6-4666-b078-e19b0273a513
Hartley, Will
83ee157c-84cb-4a84-a59f-f623aaf364b4
Davis, Tamara
c578ca32-c9d2-4f21-8fbb-84bc741c1cd7
Drlica-Wagner, Alex
c3437869-8575-4c08-b7f4-ce0771fd0db6
Vincenzi, Maria
a15a3563-56f2-4692-b192-36b745e67d0b
Annis, James
2c3e39f4-a2a3-411d-952a-c254b45707b5
Dixon, Mitchell
7edf01fa-ce4b-411b-b01f-3a7c19f2200f
Graur, Or
02c2ee78-2e37-4304-8dcf-d5bbb56536fc
Kim, Alex
6a8ff299-4d14-47da-8016-3c6b957fc920
Lidman, Christopher
1c2af5d6-f6a9-418d-a3db-d64fc630f77b
Möller, Anais
90240402-7f83-45db-8eae-d6085024b031
Nugent, Peter
f98e37c2-aa8f-455b-8eb9-5b350046a2e0
Rose, Benjamin
98cc9230-85ba-4e10-8461-0bf205046c87
Smith, Mathew
8bdc74e1-a37b-434d-ae75-82763109bf7a
Allam, Sahar
7b660f87-7928-4d0d-a70b-d216ebae7abe
Diehl, H. Thomas
e9d80b5a-51f2-447a-a8eb-0e90cb3ed8ce
Tucker, Douglas
56c3322c-8787-4097-86c5-6b32a5421aa3
Asorey, Jacobo
c15770ed-d448-4e4e-b4f1-834b1ecbd981
Calcino, Josh
348b8430-c4c0-4540-b55f-4891565b8d3d
Carollo, Daniela
ba0d39dc-bf78-4cd9-b545-db7e31b2467c
Glazebrook, Karl
a0f7c538-1e8c-4ea8-9f49-a5ab0eb353f4
Lewis, Geraint
03eec181-f335-4eec-9be9-ec03e611f19b
Taylor, Georgina
676f33d8-e407-4c9d-a8f1-89563de95ba2
Tucker, Brad E.
6f4db462-bdb8-4c2e-891b-3d00c0be0c56
Aguena, Michel
6adbfd8d-6b07-47a1-9380-97434d73fb8e
Andrade-Oliveira, Felipe
4bd08020-ec95-4380-a556-66d5b439753e
Bacon, David
e3465208-c360-4d45-b8c9-7ace451a7d43
Bertin, Emmanuel
3434204a-f930-40e1-9e4d-21b0df6d58ec
Bocquet, Sebastian
9bc911fd-76df-41a4-be99-8ba15b0591b3
Brooks, David
2b1c5a0f-d701-4dc7-97bc-e774a020762c
Burke, David
aa60811e-c486-433f-aace-cf30dc3b45b6
Carretero, Jorge
8ed8b4af-5b18-4854-bb6c-d8ce8d386c00
Kind, Matias Carrasco
e2affdb5-0f85-4471-8a13-f32d81e9b35b
Castander, Francisco Javier
fed824f5-b672-4d58-92cf-d2f4e090e721
Costanzi, Matteo
f5d41c1b-6f89-46a9-9278-81039f112b5a
Costa, Luiz da
adf9d5ad-0433-4d95-a99f-eaf193e9d090
Desai, Shantanu
b991e8e7-d64f-4d08-ac5a-564372822a46
Doel, Peter
0f9d3420-e532-44ac-b687-b9051e0cb596
Everett, Spencer
e0dc953b-4278-486c-b05a-74fe19c1ef25
Ferrero, Ismael
67c5547a-e919-4b14-981f-0a90d9589640
Friedel, Douglas
8c16c152-f211-4925-b8cf-e7d6984e223e
Frieman, Josh
e1bdde5c-9577-4826-a1a1-ba3ebb65095c
Garcia-Bellido, Juan
2dd20b70-bb01-47b7-bd4e-11f5e0dcdfe0
Gatti, Marco
9030e965-b5a6-4a0a-ba19-775d9337e852
Gruen, Daniel
ccb6c63f-0287-4a68-a43b-39e57e3005e6
Gschwend, Julia
145943bc-e79c-4be2-aae5-d6ad10c72d9f
Gutierrez, Gaston
9351e95b-09fd-4557-b2e8-0e755a8e6473
Hinton, Samuel
9e2f00d6-7026-4491-a28e-17d5880f65d1
Hollowood, Devon L.
0148abc6-4e30-4746-8b32-c7fe1ba285f7
Honscheid, Klaus
88cd08db-e75b-4c0f-9910-ac56504cb8a0
James, David
6607bafb-c9f0-413c-9d41-a8366fbd61a5
Kuehn, Kyler
8a2596e9-ba5b-47f1-8874-7015fce5a8a9
March, Marisa
52a1e735-e7d8-4872-ba8a-5455716a307e
Marshall, Jennifer
4c26b5c7-399e-40d9-a492-16b4d79e255c
Menanteau, Felipe
1bc0c994-18ac-40d4-9418-88566097f1b7
Miquel, Ramon
0fea613a-4365-4a72-a4e4-5ace87b031f5
Morgan, Robert
c7652169-29e0-462c-a519-a199b3a9a8c6
Paz-Chinchon, Francisco
f94426af-d95b-47dc-be27-86eb4e57271f
Pereira, Maria Elidaiana da Silva
bd3d3ea0-8db5-4c56-a8d4-e59d29fe6fac
Sanchez, Eusebio
74a62676-ee80-43b0-b504-8a5c389b6545
Scarpine, Vic
83f16cff-1be1-4bf1-90a1-9a065a4ccc83
Sevilla, Ignacio
2bb4f8c2-27f5-4b7e-a2ea-3d01f24baf0a
Suchyta, Eric
ad4d6b19-7675-4b01-9583-9bdc22f8cb8d
Tarle, Gregory
b99b5456-2e33-4a01-a86f-4f2418ffbede
Varga, Tamas Norbert
2f288ec4-3d23-436d-bba9-b0e1aca38ceb

Meldorf, Cole, Palmese, Antonella, Brout, Dillon, Chen, Rebecca, Scolnic, Daniel, Kelsey, Lisa, Galbany, Lluís, Hartley, Will, Davis, Tamara, Drlica-Wagner, Alex, Vincenzi, Maria, Annis, James, Dixon, Mitchell, Graur, Or, Kim, Alex, Lidman, Christopher, Möller, Anais, Nugent, Peter, Rose, Benjamin, Smith, Mathew, Allam, Sahar, Diehl, H. Thomas, Tucker, Douglas, Asorey, Jacobo, Calcino, Josh, Carollo, Daniela, Glazebrook, Karl, Lewis, Geraint, Taylor, Georgina, Tucker, Brad E., Aguena, Michel, Andrade-Oliveira, Felipe, Bacon, David, Bertin, Emmanuel, Bocquet, Sebastian, Brooks, David, Burke, David, Carretero, Jorge, Kind, Matias Carrasco, Castander, Francisco Javier, Costanzi, Matteo, Costa, Luiz da, Desai, Shantanu, Doel, Peter, Everett, Spencer, Ferrero, Ismael, Friedel, Douglas, Frieman, Josh, Garcia-Bellido, Juan, Gatti, Marco, Gruen, Daniel, Gschwend, Julia, Gutierrez, Gaston, Hinton, Samuel, Hollowood, Devon L., Honscheid, Klaus, James, David, Kuehn, Kyler, March, Marisa, Marshall, Jennifer, Menanteau, Felipe, Miquel, Ramon, Morgan, Robert, Paz-Chinchon, Francisco, Pereira, Maria Elidaiana da Silva, Sanchez, Eusebio, Scarpine, Vic, Sevilla, Ignacio, Suchyta, Eric, Tarle, Gregory and Varga, Tamas Norbert (2022) The Dark Energy Survey Supernova Program results: type Ia Supernova brightness correlates with host galaxy dust. Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 518 (2), 1985–2004. (doi:10.1093/mnras/stac3056).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Cosmological analyses with type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) often assume a single empirical relation between colour and luminosity (β) and do not account for varying host-galaxy dust properties. However, from studies of dust in large samples of galaxies, it is known that dust attenuation can vary significantly. Here, we take advantage of state-of-the-art modelling of galaxy properties to characterize dust parameters (dust attenuation AV, and a parameter describing the dust law slope RV) for 1100 Dark Energy Survey (DES) SN host galaxies. Utilizing optical and infrared data of the hosts alone, we find three key aspects of host dust that impact SN cosmology: (1) there exists a large range (∼1–6) of host RV; (2) high-stellar mass hosts have RV on average ∼0.7 lower than that of low-mass hosts; (3) for a subsample of 81 spectroscopically classified SNe there is a significant (>3σ) correlation between the Hubble diagram residuals of red SNe Ia and the host RV that when corrected for reduces scatter by ∼13 per cent∼13 per cent and the significance of the ‘mass step’ to ∼1σ. These represent independent confirmations of recent predictions based on dust that attempted to explain the puzzling ‘mass step’ and intrinsic scatter (σint) in SN Ia analyses.

Text
2206.06928v1 - Author's Original
Available under License Other.
Download (3MB)
Text
stac3056 - Version of Record
Available under License Other.
Download (3MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 18 October 2022
e-pub ahead of print date: 26 October 2022
Keywords: astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 482852
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/482852
ISSN: 1365-2966
PURE UUID: 9880c3b1-fe7f-47b2-8e1b-9904f13b7bcf
ORCID for Mathew Smith: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-3321-1432

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 13 Oct 2023 16:49
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 03:36

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Cole Meldorf
Author: Antonella Palmese
Author: Dillon Brout
Author: Rebecca Chen
Author: Daniel Scolnic
Author: Lisa Kelsey
Author: Lluís Galbany
Author: Will Hartley
Author: Tamara Davis
Author: Alex Drlica-Wagner
Author: Maria Vincenzi
Author: James Annis
Author: Mitchell Dixon
Author: Or Graur
Author: Alex Kim
Author: Christopher Lidman
Author: Anais Möller
Author: Peter Nugent
Author: Benjamin Rose
Author: Mathew Smith ORCID iD
Author: Sahar Allam
Author: H. Thomas Diehl
Author: Douglas Tucker
Author: Jacobo Asorey
Author: Josh Calcino
Author: Daniela Carollo
Author: Karl Glazebrook
Author: Geraint Lewis
Author: Georgina Taylor
Author: Brad E. Tucker
Author: Michel Aguena
Author: Felipe Andrade-Oliveira
Author: David Bacon
Author: Emmanuel Bertin
Author: Sebastian Bocquet
Author: David Brooks
Author: David Burke
Author: Jorge Carretero
Author: Matias Carrasco Kind
Author: Francisco Javier Castander
Author: Matteo Costanzi
Author: Luiz da Costa
Author: Shantanu Desai
Author: Peter Doel
Author: Spencer Everett
Author: Ismael Ferrero
Author: Douglas Friedel
Author: Josh Frieman
Author: Juan Garcia-Bellido
Author: Marco Gatti
Author: Daniel Gruen
Author: Julia Gschwend
Author: Gaston Gutierrez
Author: Samuel Hinton
Author: Devon L. Hollowood
Author: Klaus Honscheid
Author: David James
Author: Kyler Kuehn
Author: Marisa March
Author: Jennifer Marshall
Author: Felipe Menanteau
Author: Ramon Miquel
Author: Robert Morgan
Author: Francisco Paz-Chinchon
Author: Maria Elidaiana da Silva Pereira
Author: Eusebio Sanchez
Author: Vic Scarpine
Author: Ignacio Sevilla
Author: Eric Suchyta
Author: Gregory Tarle
Author: Tamas Norbert Varga

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×