Chirality: a key parameter in chemical probes
Chirality: a key parameter in chemical probes
Many small molecule bioactive and marketed drugs are chiral. They are often synthesised from commercially available chiral building blocks. However, chirality is sometimes incorrectly assigned by manufacturers with consequences for the end user ranging from: experimental irreproducibility, wasted time on synthesising the wrong product and reanalysis, to the added cost of purchasing the precursor and resynthesis of the correct stereoisomer. Further on, this could lead to loss of reputation, loss of funding, to safety and ethical concerns due to potential in vivo administration of the wrong form of a drug. It is our firm belief that more stringent control of chirality be provided by the supplier and, if needed, requested by the end user, to minimise the potential issues mentioned above. Certification of chirality would bring much needed confidence in chemical structure assignment and could be provided by a variety of techniques, from polarimetry, chiral HPLC, using known chiral standards, vibrational circular dichroism, and x-ray crystallography. A few case studies of our brushes with wrong chirality assignment are shown as well as some examples of what we believe to be good practice.
716-721
McGown, Andrew
5809e935-f2bc-4222-8757-f8a07296bcb1
Nafie, Jordan
59e81e45-ddbc-424a-939d-1c8f24db82b9
Otayfah, Mohammed
51ffcae3-7652-4ebd-ad7a-60daae18340a
Hassell-Hart, Storm
cb87c9ec-7c5c-4ba5-8893-1348694eb4bd
Tizzard, Graham J.
8474c0fa-40df-43a6-a662-7f3c4722dbf2
Coles, Simon J.
3116f58b-c30c-48cf-bdd5-397d1c1fecf8
Banks, Rebecca
79174933-9e48-4df0-8b1c-e6ee79e0fa74
Marsh, Graham P.
937b77a4-3d88-43b7-9845-20ffb1804c62
Maple, Hannah J.
d25a19da-d87e-472f-b08f-ddc49354cd05
Kostakis, George E.
dd72c724-c82e-4891-aa68-ccdb42cc6cb8
Proietti Silvestri, Ilaria
0baa7cce-0aaa-4017-891a-60b5999845ae
Colbon, Paul
1592a6a5-16f5-46bb-91e1-411b815375e6
Spencer, John
a3cf55cd-a4c7-4af6-b16c-96c8fb8c4cf4
4 October 2023
McGown, Andrew
5809e935-f2bc-4222-8757-f8a07296bcb1
Nafie, Jordan
59e81e45-ddbc-424a-939d-1c8f24db82b9
Otayfah, Mohammed
51ffcae3-7652-4ebd-ad7a-60daae18340a
Hassell-Hart, Storm
cb87c9ec-7c5c-4ba5-8893-1348694eb4bd
Tizzard, Graham J.
8474c0fa-40df-43a6-a662-7f3c4722dbf2
Coles, Simon J.
3116f58b-c30c-48cf-bdd5-397d1c1fecf8
Banks, Rebecca
79174933-9e48-4df0-8b1c-e6ee79e0fa74
Marsh, Graham P.
937b77a4-3d88-43b7-9845-20ffb1804c62
Maple, Hannah J.
d25a19da-d87e-472f-b08f-ddc49354cd05
Kostakis, George E.
dd72c724-c82e-4891-aa68-ccdb42cc6cb8
Proietti Silvestri, Ilaria
0baa7cce-0aaa-4017-891a-60b5999845ae
Colbon, Paul
1592a6a5-16f5-46bb-91e1-411b815375e6
Spencer, John
a3cf55cd-a4c7-4af6-b16c-96c8fb8c4cf4
McGown, Andrew, Nafie, Jordan, Otayfah, Mohammed, Hassell-Hart, Storm, Tizzard, Graham J., Coles, Simon J., Banks, Rebecca, Marsh, Graham P., Maple, Hannah J., Kostakis, George E., Proietti Silvestri, Ilaria, Colbon, Paul and Spencer, John
(2023)
Chirality: a key parameter in chemical probes.
RSC Chemical Biology, 4 (10), .
(doi:10.1039/d3cb00082f).
Abstract
Many small molecule bioactive and marketed drugs are chiral. They are often synthesised from commercially available chiral building blocks. However, chirality is sometimes incorrectly assigned by manufacturers with consequences for the end user ranging from: experimental irreproducibility, wasted time on synthesising the wrong product and reanalysis, to the added cost of purchasing the precursor and resynthesis of the correct stereoisomer. Further on, this could lead to loss of reputation, loss of funding, to safety and ethical concerns due to potential in vivo administration of the wrong form of a drug. It is our firm belief that more stringent control of chirality be provided by the supplier and, if needed, requested by the end user, to minimise the potential issues mentioned above. Certification of chirality would bring much needed confidence in chemical structure assignment and could be provided by a variety of techniques, from polarimetry, chiral HPLC, using known chiral standards, vibrational circular dichroism, and x-ray crystallography. A few case studies of our brushes with wrong chirality assignment are shown as well as some examples of what we believe to be good practice.
Text
d3cb00082f
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 1 August 2023
e-pub ahead of print date: 8 August 2023
Published date: 4 October 2023
Additional Information:
Funding Information:
M. O. thanks University of Jazan, Jazan, Saudi Arabia for financial support for a PhD studentship. J. S., A. M., and G. E. K. are grateful to the University of Sussex for HEIF Business Collaboration & Commercialisation 2023 funding. J. S. and S. H. H. would like to thank EPSRC for funding (EP/P026990/1). We thank the reviewers and Drs Brett Stevenson (Sygnature) and Klaus Rumpel (Boehringer-Ingelheim) for stimulating comments.
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 483729
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/483729
ISSN: 2633-0679
PURE UUID: a095b7e8-4d45-47e8-9235-0a915eaf5d68
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 03 Nov 2023 18:01
Last modified: 18 Mar 2024 02:54
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Andrew McGown
Author:
Jordan Nafie
Author:
Mohammed Otayfah
Author:
Storm Hassell-Hart
Author:
Rebecca Banks
Author:
Graham P. Marsh
Author:
Hannah J. Maple
Author:
George E. Kostakis
Author:
Ilaria Proietti Silvestri
Author:
Paul Colbon
Author:
John Spencer
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics