Postmodernism's use and abuse of Nietzsche
Postmodernism's use and abuse of Nietzsche
Postmodern readings of Nietzsche typically misunderstand his various attacks on dogmatic philosophy as paving the way for acceptance of a self, a world, characterized by fundamental disunity. In contrast I suggest that Nietzsche's attack on essentialist dogmatic metaphysics is less a gesture at philosophical reform than a call to engage in a purposive self creation under a unifying will, a will that the possesses the strength to reinterpret history as a pathway to "the problem that we are". Nietzsche agrees with the postmoderns that unity is not a pre-given. Where he parts from them is in their complete rejection of unity as a goal. On the descriptive side, Nietzsche and the post-moderns agree that the received notion of the unified Cartesian subject is a myth, however on the prescriptive side, while the postmoderns celebrate the death of the subject Nietzsche rejects this valorization of disunity as a form of Nihilism and prescribes the creation of a genuine unified subjectivity to those few capable and hence worthy of such a goal. To this extent the postmoderns are nearer Nietzsche's idea of the Last Man than his idea of the Overman.
nietzsche, postmodernism, unity, foucault, self
337-360
Gemes, Ken
f087c5ea-9397-4dc3-96a0-a4889cfb840e
March 2001
Gemes, Ken
f087c5ea-9397-4dc3-96a0-a4889cfb840e
Abstract
Postmodern readings of Nietzsche typically misunderstand his various attacks on dogmatic philosophy as paving the way for acceptance of a self, a world, characterized by fundamental disunity. In contrast I suggest that Nietzsche's attack on essentialist dogmatic metaphysics is less a gesture at philosophical reform than a call to engage in a purposive self creation under a unifying will, a will that the possesses the strength to reinterpret history as a pathway to "the problem that we are". Nietzsche agrees with the postmoderns that unity is not a pre-given. Where he parts from them is in their complete rejection of unity as a goal. On the descriptive side, Nietzsche and the post-moderns agree that the received notion of the unified Cartesian subject is a myth, however on the prescriptive side, while the postmoderns celebrate the death of the subject Nietzsche rejects this valorization of disunity as a form of Nihilism and prescribes the creation of a genuine unified subjectivity to those few capable and hence worthy of such a goal. To this extent the postmoderns are nearer Nietzsche's idea of the Last Man than his idea of the Overman.
Text
Postmodernism's_Use_and_Absue_of_Nietzsche_April_05.doc
- Other
More information
Published date: March 2001
Keywords:
nietzsche, postmodernism, unity, foucault, self
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 48466
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/48466
ISSN: 0031-8205
PURE UUID: 4acf3975-c286-4433-83b4-1e9e4e3e43bb
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 27 Sep 2007
Last modified: 15 Mar 2024 09:46
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Ken Gemes
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics