The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Does an extensive diagnostic workup for upfront resectable pancreatic cancer result in a delay which affects survival? Results from an international multicentre study

Does an extensive diagnostic workup for upfront resectable pancreatic cancer result in a delay which affects survival? Results from an international multicentre study
Does an extensive diagnostic workup for upfront resectable pancreatic cancer result in a delay which affects survival? Results from an international multicentre study

Backgrounds/aims: pancreatoduodenectomy (PD) is recommended in fit patients with a carcinoma (PDAC) of the pancreatic head, and a delayed resection may affect survival. This study aimed to correlate the time from staging to PD with long-term survival, and study the impact of preoperative investigations (if any) on the timing of surgery.

Methods: data were extracted from the Recurrence After Whipple's (RAW) study, a multicentre retrospective study of PD outcomes. Only PDAC patients who underwent an upfront resection were included. Patients who received neoadjuvant chemo-/radiotherapy were excluded. Group A (PD within 28 days of most recent preoperative computed tomography [CT]) was compared to group B (> 28 days).

Results: a total of 595 patents were included. Compared to group A (median CT-PD time: 12.5 days, interquartile range: 6-21), group B (49 days, 39-64.5) had similar one-year survival (73% vs. 75%, p = 0.6), five-year survival (23% vs. 21%, p = 0.6) and median time-todeath (17 vs. 18 months, p = 0.8). Staging laparoscopy (43 vs. 29.5 days, p = 0.009) and preoperative biliary stenting (39 vs. 20 days, p < 0.001) were associated with a delay to PD, but magnetic resonance imaging (32 vs. 32 days, p = 0.5), positron emission tomography (40 vs. 31 days, p > 0.99) and endoscopic ultrasonography (28 vs. 32 days, p > 0.99) were not.

Conclusions: although a treatment delay may give rise to patient anxiety, our findings would suggest this does not correlate with worse survival. A delay may be necessary to obtain further information and minimize the number of PD patients diagnosed with early disease recurrence.

Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, Magnetic resonance imaging, Pancreatic ductal carcinoma, Pancreaticoduodenectomy, X-ray computed tomography
2508-5859
403-414
Russell, Thomas B.
aa38ef73-d1cb-4634-8bff-10293799eb3e
Labib, Peter L.
baaaf73b-71b2-497e-be55-a3a14f2cda83
Denson, Jemimah
9692e5c2-547b-468d-bf61-5248ab1c720e
Ausania, Fabio
4bdee26f-efe8-485f-a24e-e335ddc73e49
Pando, Elizabeth
a99d3d9a-807e-4bda-881c-f4a908c7d991
Roberts, Keith J.
a74b19fc-0509-435a-9292-e213931cf734
Kausar, Ambareen
efa1f2b3-42c5-4190-a84e-59417bdd4a11
Mavroeidis, Vasileios K.
7e1d9bd5-4239-4091-9cdc-7871e8e57b72
Marangoni, Gabriele
b876a178-8129-4455-adcf-1f8b04428c2a
Thomasset, Sarah C.
b26051a1-0715-4b20-8b02-eb5a27e7a63c
Frampton, Adam E.
d5cf9723-91a0-43f2-9ad2-cfd669eefcb5
Lykoudis, Pavlos
bc705761-0eca-4ad3-bc38-359f13760d41
Maglione, Manuel
a996a90b-4a3b-42d6-b24d-4c9daad8f1bd
Alhaboob, Nassir
625d17d8-953d-460f-a827-5109de3191ad
Bari, Hassaan
5d9062e2-e0b3-43b7-bf28-46a5a7e7ea33
Smith, Andrew M.
4b35f002-67f4-4d5e-9ca8-5b2a8ef79da6
Spalding, Duncan
df47f2b3-5b70-465b-a43a-4d6cc5b5e35a
Srinivasan, Parthi
400175cf-a18b-4725-bdc6-6e15868b82c0
Davidson, Brian R.
ad35b9bb-d75b-4414-8eb9-d73b77313ed6
Bhogal, Ricky H.
0e670132-dbd5-49ae-99ec-8c4985d7febb
Croagh, Daniel
38094310-91f6-4939-b2bb-f9742df56dea
Rajagopalan, Ashray
bf9a914b-0579-471b-9cd6-3a9f7d61ea05
Dominguez, Ismael
f08b0ece-043b-416a-9d87-a9cff47c0eb4
Thakkar, Rohan
81b74d0d-0a17-40f4-99b6-f54fe237aef1
Gomez, Dhanny
7330d00c-af63-46f7-8797-c7e0ac57ca2c
Silva, Michael A.
6ddfe6d5-9fe9-4729-a0e0-e8cb79af6b7d
Lapolla, Pierfrancesco
90d8864e-3b8f-4fd5-94c6-119828c6750f
Mingoli, Andrea
5c3a7f75-05b3-4674-bf0d-a34b51601164
Porcu, Alberto
91af0f20-480d-47be-bd85-a48801ee020b
Perra, Teresa
df58db2f-8c6e-4f50-92f4-4e74496396e0
Shah, Nehal S.
d31d2103-06c5-42b0-b743-d9f8cccf30da
Hamady, Zaed Z.R.
545a1c81-276e-4341-a420-aa10aa5d8ca8
Al-Sarrieh, Bilal
058e55cf-9996-46e0-a923-cdd55d2f0a77
Serrablo, Alejandro
8647c43c-eb2a-4cdb-9312-4ad66e267848
Aroori, Somaiah
842a95b8-42fb-462d-85a7-faeefd6ecea0
RAW Study Collaborators
Russell, Thomas B.
aa38ef73-d1cb-4634-8bff-10293799eb3e
Labib, Peter L.
baaaf73b-71b2-497e-be55-a3a14f2cda83
Denson, Jemimah
9692e5c2-547b-468d-bf61-5248ab1c720e
Ausania, Fabio
4bdee26f-efe8-485f-a24e-e335ddc73e49
Pando, Elizabeth
a99d3d9a-807e-4bda-881c-f4a908c7d991
Roberts, Keith J.
a74b19fc-0509-435a-9292-e213931cf734
Kausar, Ambareen
efa1f2b3-42c5-4190-a84e-59417bdd4a11
Mavroeidis, Vasileios K.
7e1d9bd5-4239-4091-9cdc-7871e8e57b72
Marangoni, Gabriele
b876a178-8129-4455-adcf-1f8b04428c2a
Thomasset, Sarah C.
b26051a1-0715-4b20-8b02-eb5a27e7a63c
Frampton, Adam E.
d5cf9723-91a0-43f2-9ad2-cfd669eefcb5
Lykoudis, Pavlos
bc705761-0eca-4ad3-bc38-359f13760d41
Maglione, Manuel
a996a90b-4a3b-42d6-b24d-4c9daad8f1bd
Alhaboob, Nassir
625d17d8-953d-460f-a827-5109de3191ad
Bari, Hassaan
5d9062e2-e0b3-43b7-bf28-46a5a7e7ea33
Smith, Andrew M.
4b35f002-67f4-4d5e-9ca8-5b2a8ef79da6
Spalding, Duncan
df47f2b3-5b70-465b-a43a-4d6cc5b5e35a
Srinivasan, Parthi
400175cf-a18b-4725-bdc6-6e15868b82c0
Davidson, Brian R.
ad35b9bb-d75b-4414-8eb9-d73b77313ed6
Bhogal, Ricky H.
0e670132-dbd5-49ae-99ec-8c4985d7febb
Croagh, Daniel
38094310-91f6-4939-b2bb-f9742df56dea
Rajagopalan, Ashray
bf9a914b-0579-471b-9cd6-3a9f7d61ea05
Dominguez, Ismael
f08b0ece-043b-416a-9d87-a9cff47c0eb4
Thakkar, Rohan
81b74d0d-0a17-40f4-99b6-f54fe237aef1
Gomez, Dhanny
7330d00c-af63-46f7-8797-c7e0ac57ca2c
Silva, Michael A.
6ddfe6d5-9fe9-4729-a0e0-e8cb79af6b7d
Lapolla, Pierfrancesco
90d8864e-3b8f-4fd5-94c6-119828c6750f
Mingoli, Andrea
5c3a7f75-05b3-4674-bf0d-a34b51601164
Porcu, Alberto
91af0f20-480d-47be-bd85-a48801ee020b
Perra, Teresa
df58db2f-8c6e-4f50-92f4-4e74496396e0
Shah, Nehal S.
d31d2103-06c5-42b0-b743-d9f8cccf30da
Hamady, Zaed Z.R.
545a1c81-276e-4341-a420-aa10aa5d8ca8
Al-Sarrieh, Bilal
058e55cf-9996-46e0-a923-cdd55d2f0a77
Serrablo, Alejandro
8647c43c-eb2a-4cdb-9312-4ad66e267848
Aroori, Somaiah
842a95b8-42fb-462d-85a7-faeefd6ecea0

RAW Study Collaborators (2023) Does an extensive diagnostic workup for upfront resectable pancreatic cancer result in a delay which affects survival? Results from an international multicentre study. Annals of hepato-biliary-pancreatic surgery, 27 (4), 403-414. (doi:10.14701/ahbps.23-042).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Backgrounds/aims: pancreatoduodenectomy (PD) is recommended in fit patients with a carcinoma (PDAC) of the pancreatic head, and a delayed resection may affect survival. This study aimed to correlate the time from staging to PD with long-term survival, and study the impact of preoperative investigations (if any) on the timing of surgery.

Methods: data were extracted from the Recurrence After Whipple's (RAW) study, a multicentre retrospective study of PD outcomes. Only PDAC patients who underwent an upfront resection were included. Patients who received neoadjuvant chemo-/radiotherapy were excluded. Group A (PD within 28 days of most recent preoperative computed tomography [CT]) was compared to group B (> 28 days).

Results: a total of 595 patents were included. Compared to group A (median CT-PD time: 12.5 days, interquartile range: 6-21), group B (49 days, 39-64.5) had similar one-year survival (73% vs. 75%, p = 0.6), five-year survival (23% vs. 21%, p = 0.6) and median time-todeath (17 vs. 18 months, p = 0.8). Staging laparoscopy (43 vs. 29.5 days, p = 0.009) and preoperative biliary stenting (39 vs. 20 days, p < 0.001) were associated with a delay to PD, but magnetic resonance imaging (32 vs. 32 days, p = 0.5), positron emission tomography (40 vs. 31 days, p > 0.99) and endoscopic ultrasonography (28 vs. 32 days, p > 0.99) were not.

Conclusions: although a treatment delay may give rise to patient anxiety, our findings would suggest this does not correlate with worse survival. A delay may be necessary to obtain further information and minimize the number of PD patients diagnosed with early disease recurrence.

Text
ahbps-27-4-403 - Version of Record
Download (852kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 6 June 2023
Published date: November 2023
Additional Information: Funding Information: 280423; REC reference: 20/NW/0397). The study was also supported by the collaborating centers’ research and development departments and adhered to the standards laid down in the Declaration of Helsinki (revised 2013). Publisher Copyright: © The Korean Association of Hepato-Biliary-Pancreatic Surgery.
Keywords: Endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, Magnetic resonance imaging, Pancreatic ductal carcinoma, Pancreaticoduodenectomy, X-ray computed tomography

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 485382
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/485382
ISSN: 2508-5859
PURE UUID: 8fa2271a-ce20-4ef6-989a-08253711bef5
ORCID for Zaed Z.R. Hamady: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-4591-5226

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 05 Dec 2023 17:41
Last modified: 18 Mar 2024 04:05

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Thomas B. Russell
Author: Peter L. Labib
Author: Jemimah Denson
Author: Fabio Ausania
Author: Elizabeth Pando
Author: Keith J. Roberts
Author: Ambareen Kausar
Author: Vasileios K. Mavroeidis
Author: Gabriele Marangoni
Author: Sarah C. Thomasset
Author: Adam E. Frampton
Author: Pavlos Lykoudis
Author: Manuel Maglione
Author: Nassir Alhaboob
Author: Hassaan Bari
Author: Andrew M. Smith
Author: Duncan Spalding
Author: Parthi Srinivasan
Author: Brian R. Davidson
Author: Ricky H. Bhogal
Author: Daniel Croagh
Author: Ashray Rajagopalan
Author: Ismael Dominguez
Author: Rohan Thakkar
Author: Dhanny Gomez
Author: Michael A. Silva
Author: Pierfrancesco Lapolla
Author: Andrea Mingoli
Author: Alberto Porcu
Author: Teresa Perra
Author: Nehal S. Shah
Author: Zaed Z.R. Hamady ORCID iD
Author: Bilal Al-Sarrieh
Author: Alejandro Serrablo
Author: Somaiah Aroori
Corporate Author: RAW Study Collaborators

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×