The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The role of non-English-language science in informing national biodiversity assessments

The role of non-English-language science in informing national biodiversity assessments
The role of non-English-language science in informing national biodiversity assessments

Consulting the best available evidence is key to successful conservation decision-making. While much scientific evidence on conservation continues to be published in non-English languages, a poor understanding of how non-English-language science contributes to conservation decision-making is causing global assessments and studies to practically ignore non-English-language literature. By investigating the use of scientific literature in biodiversity assessment reports across 37 countries/territories, we have uncovered the established role of non-English-language literature as a major source of information locally. On average, non-English-language literature constituted 65% of the references cited, and these were recognized as relevant knowledge sources by 75% of report authors. This means that by ignoring non-English-language science, international assessments may overlook important information on local and/or regional biodiversity. Furthermore, a quarter of the authors acknowledged the struggles of understanding English-language literature. This points to the need to aid the use of English-language literature in domestic decision-making, for example, by providing non-English-language abstracts or improving and/or implementing machine translation. (This abstract is also avaialble in 21 other languages in Supplementary Data 4).

2398-9629
845-854
Amano, Tatsuya
e7c187c3-c64d-4798-886e-14527301e162
Berdejo-Espinola, Violeta
67a0129e-ff14-4746-9cf0-81b6b0ac7331
Akasaka, Munemitsu
fd0a09e5-8b94-4b71-be77-1caf34cf81b8
de Andrade Junior, Milton A.U.
2654feee-d13c-49fa-9c12-55ee0ed96249
Blaise, Ndayizeye
9415c044-aa1d-4ae1-9337-9d84a1761d21
Checco, Julia
edbd84d4-b04e-4e06-9ea4-84de400d26f9
Çilingir, F. Gözde
18118b13-f75b-4d93-8279-cfadfa6fa48d
Citegetse, Geoffroy
6d56edbd-33ce-4d85-9722-008e634f16e1
Corella Tor, Marina
1aefd744-c386-4c7b-86d3-adbfbe0f5660
Drobniak, Szymon M.
138f0f94-b44d-4ece-b9db-c5efac084fd6
Giakoumi, Sylvaine
02ed284a-5c1f-4887-a71e-1ddc4b04ba04
Golivets, Marina
8c974ba9-0144-4f4d-a055-4f785a5c8188
Ion, Mihaela C.
e48535f4-72f8-46c9-a4ba-9326dd267db3
Jara-Díaz, Javiera P.
6be9a38e-4134-4b1b-aab3-8db683585941
Katayose, Ryosuke
f8e4bb6a-8774-4feb-8d04-cb8247ec36ee
Lasmana, Felicia P.S.
7066445e-b815-48fb-aad4-6ef66f5b6707
Lin, Hsien Yung
37ef976d-b21a-4112-8534-21bd64780976
Lopez, Erick
bf2a82ff-af67-4f51-9f78-7ea71ddbc3e1
Mikula, Peter
5e08e848-cca4-43c3-875a-46031c0e939f
Morales-Barquero, Lucia
094e220f-8ea4-4faa-a76c-fd09e3d6175f
Mupepele, Anne Christine
18861d41-1287-4c07-b968-6b23aefcc716
Narváez-Gómez, Juan P.
cf8da330-2293-4a81-a7ca-18ff0fecf1de
Nguyen, Thi Hieu
50464540-2387-4da8-852f-f0137356ba69
Lisboa, Sá Nogueira
4389363a-8a4a-4e5b-bc16-e435c286a385
Nuñez, Martin A.
c3f20913-7674-4e99-9525-c5230b288374
Pavón-Jordán, Diego
b291f4d7-1280-43fe-b948-937ad4702766
Pottier, Patrice
aa7b7bb4-1d74-489f-b76b-6fe7e173e33b
Prescott, Graham W.
24f3e5ae-1a69-4aa6-b1cf-dae439927bbb
Samad, Farah
bd638d33-1a1c-45e2-b141-e6ced8880d29
Šćiban, Marko
654a9a6d-4c7a-45b3-86cd-48ed64b93e9d
Seo, Hae Min
2f66dd19-c03a-4bef-b465-0a9b656bc2ef
Shinoda, Yushin
f0e10946-21d8-4d68-ac56-0a145255d2cd
Vajna, Flóra
9f349c22-7bb3-4ecf-97b5-f1e6aa7b5080
Vozykova, Svetlana
e03a3207-372d-4dd8-a14a-922b5ab6e305
Walsh, Jessica C.
d5bb1403-6878-4b09-bf7c-5b68f4e0dc8f
Wee, Alison K.S.
38bdbc0b-24c9-4757-af22-df108355cbbb
Xiao, Hui
c70e695a-d56c-418b-a744-b1a0a594b41d
Zamora-Gutierrez, Veronica
17a6b9d9-3346-4df6-9438-026b7342e28a
Amano, Tatsuya
e7c187c3-c64d-4798-886e-14527301e162
Berdejo-Espinola, Violeta
67a0129e-ff14-4746-9cf0-81b6b0ac7331
Akasaka, Munemitsu
fd0a09e5-8b94-4b71-be77-1caf34cf81b8
de Andrade Junior, Milton A.U.
2654feee-d13c-49fa-9c12-55ee0ed96249
Blaise, Ndayizeye
9415c044-aa1d-4ae1-9337-9d84a1761d21
Checco, Julia
edbd84d4-b04e-4e06-9ea4-84de400d26f9
Çilingir, F. Gözde
18118b13-f75b-4d93-8279-cfadfa6fa48d
Citegetse, Geoffroy
6d56edbd-33ce-4d85-9722-008e634f16e1
Corella Tor, Marina
1aefd744-c386-4c7b-86d3-adbfbe0f5660
Drobniak, Szymon M.
138f0f94-b44d-4ece-b9db-c5efac084fd6
Giakoumi, Sylvaine
02ed284a-5c1f-4887-a71e-1ddc4b04ba04
Golivets, Marina
8c974ba9-0144-4f4d-a055-4f785a5c8188
Ion, Mihaela C.
e48535f4-72f8-46c9-a4ba-9326dd267db3
Jara-Díaz, Javiera P.
6be9a38e-4134-4b1b-aab3-8db683585941
Katayose, Ryosuke
f8e4bb6a-8774-4feb-8d04-cb8247ec36ee
Lasmana, Felicia P.S.
7066445e-b815-48fb-aad4-6ef66f5b6707
Lin, Hsien Yung
37ef976d-b21a-4112-8534-21bd64780976
Lopez, Erick
bf2a82ff-af67-4f51-9f78-7ea71ddbc3e1
Mikula, Peter
5e08e848-cca4-43c3-875a-46031c0e939f
Morales-Barquero, Lucia
094e220f-8ea4-4faa-a76c-fd09e3d6175f
Mupepele, Anne Christine
18861d41-1287-4c07-b968-6b23aefcc716
Narváez-Gómez, Juan P.
cf8da330-2293-4a81-a7ca-18ff0fecf1de
Nguyen, Thi Hieu
50464540-2387-4da8-852f-f0137356ba69
Lisboa, Sá Nogueira
4389363a-8a4a-4e5b-bc16-e435c286a385
Nuñez, Martin A.
c3f20913-7674-4e99-9525-c5230b288374
Pavón-Jordán, Diego
b291f4d7-1280-43fe-b948-937ad4702766
Pottier, Patrice
aa7b7bb4-1d74-489f-b76b-6fe7e173e33b
Prescott, Graham W.
24f3e5ae-1a69-4aa6-b1cf-dae439927bbb
Samad, Farah
bd638d33-1a1c-45e2-b141-e6ced8880d29
Šćiban, Marko
654a9a6d-4c7a-45b3-86cd-48ed64b93e9d
Seo, Hae Min
2f66dd19-c03a-4bef-b465-0a9b656bc2ef
Shinoda, Yushin
f0e10946-21d8-4d68-ac56-0a145255d2cd
Vajna, Flóra
9f349c22-7bb3-4ecf-97b5-f1e6aa7b5080
Vozykova, Svetlana
e03a3207-372d-4dd8-a14a-922b5ab6e305
Walsh, Jessica C.
d5bb1403-6878-4b09-bf7c-5b68f4e0dc8f
Wee, Alison K.S.
38bdbc0b-24c9-4757-af22-df108355cbbb
Xiao, Hui
c70e695a-d56c-418b-a744-b1a0a594b41d
Zamora-Gutierrez, Veronica
17a6b9d9-3346-4df6-9438-026b7342e28a

Amano, Tatsuya, Berdejo-Espinola, Violeta, Akasaka, Munemitsu, de Andrade Junior, Milton A.U., Blaise, Ndayizeye, Checco, Julia, Çilingir, F. Gözde, Citegetse, Geoffroy, Corella Tor, Marina, Drobniak, Szymon M., Giakoumi, Sylvaine, Golivets, Marina, Ion, Mihaela C., Jara-Díaz, Javiera P., Katayose, Ryosuke, Lasmana, Felicia P.S., Lin, Hsien Yung, Lopez, Erick, Mikula, Peter, Morales-Barquero, Lucia, Mupepele, Anne Christine, Narváez-Gómez, Juan P., Nguyen, Thi Hieu, Lisboa, Sá Nogueira, Nuñez, Martin A., Pavón-Jordán, Diego, Pottier, Patrice, Prescott, Graham W., Samad, Farah, Šćiban, Marko, Seo, Hae Min, Shinoda, Yushin, Vajna, Flóra, Vozykova, Svetlana, Walsh, Jessica C., Wee, Alison K.S., Xiao, Hui and Zamora-Gutierrez, Veronica (2023) The role of non-English-language science in informing national biodiversity assessments. Nature Sustainability, 6 (7), 845-854. (doi:10.1038/s41893-023-01087-8).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Consulting the best available evidence is key to successful conservation decision-making. While much scientific evidence on conservation continues to be published in non-English languages, a poor understanding of how non-English-language science contributes to conservation decision-making is causing global assessments and studies to practically ignore non-English-language literature. By investigating the use of scientific literature in biodiversity assessment reports across 37 countries/territories, we have uncovered the established role of non-English-language literature as a major source of information locally. On average, non-English-language literature constituted 65% of the references cited, and these were recognized as relevant knowledge sources by 75% of report authors. This means that by ignoring non-English-language science, international assessments may overlook important information on local and/or regional biodiversity. Furthermore, a quarter of the authors acknowledged the struggles of understanding English-language literature. This points to the need to aid the use of English-language literature in domestic decision-making, for example, by providing non-English-language abstracts or improving and/or implementing machine translation. (This abstract is also avaialble in 21 other languages in Supplementary Data 4).

This record has no associated files available for download.

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 13 February 2023
e-pub ahead of print date: 16 March 2023
Published date: July 2023
Additional Information: Funding Information: We thank all authors and editors of the reports who participated in our survey, V. V. Natykanets for his help in data collection and M. Amano for all her support. This work was funded by an Australian Research Council Future Fellowship (FT180100354), University of Queensland strategic funding (T.A.), an Australian Research Council DECRA Fellowship (DE180100202, S.M.D.), Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior - Brazil (CAPES, Finance Code 001, J.P.N.-G.) and the Swiss National Science Foundation (G.W.P.).

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 487254
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/487254
ISSN: 2398-9629
PURE UUID: 7ede5abd-d0d5-4196-a298-83715a93cf51
ORCID for Veronica Zamora-Gutierrez: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-0661-5180

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 16 Feb 2024 15:31
Last modified: 18 Mar 2024 04:18

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Tatsuya Amano
Author: Violeta Berdejo-Espinola
Author: Munemitsu Akasaka
Author: Milton A.U. de Andrade Junior
Author: Ndayizeye Blaise
Author: Julia Checco
Author: F. Gözde Çilingir
Author: Geoffroy Citegetse
Author: Marina Corella Tor
Author: Szymon M. Drobniak
Author: Sylvaine Giakoumi
Author: Marina Golivets
Author: Mihaela C. Ion
Author: Javiera P. Jara-Díaz
Author: Ryosuke Katayose
Author: Felicia P.S. Lasmana
Author: Hsien Yung Lin
Author: Erick Lopez
Author: Peter Mikula
Author: Lucia Morales-Barquero
Author: Anne Christine Mupepele
Author: Juan P. Narváez-Gómez
Author: Thi Hieu Nguyen
Author: Sá Nogueira Lisboa
Author: Martin A. Nuñez
Author: Diego Pavón-Jordán
Author: Patrice Pottier
Author: Graham W. Prescott
Author: Farah Samad
Author: Marko Šćiban
Author: Hae Min Seo
Author: Yushin Shinoda
Author: Flóra Vajna
Author: Svetlana Vozykova
Author: Jessica C. Walsh
Author: Alison K.S. Wee
Author: Hui Xiao
Author: Veronica Zamora-Gutierrez ORCID iD

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×