‘Wellbeing’ and the production of disability in the university: erasure, effacement and institutional exceptionalism
‘Wellbeing’ and the production of disability in the university: erasure, effacement and institutional exceptionalism
This article uses ‘wellbeing’ as deployed within UK higher education as a starting point for examining the relationship between disability and the university. We explore various strands of scholarship that seek to critique wellbeing, universities, and/or connections between disability and these institutions. Work on ‘wellbeing’ identifies the harmful logics underpinning its political appropriation, but erases disability by declining to consider it as political experience. Critiques of the university efface disability by considering disablement only insofar as it affects the non-disabled, and reify ‘intellect’ as neutral entity and sole true purview of higher education. Work on the political economy of disability exposes crucial connections between disability and capitalism, and the role of economic and political institutions in upholding them, but relies on a distinction between worker and surplus that cannot reckon with institutional complexity. Finally, scholarship that directly confronts the university as disabling institution accounts for complexity, but hinges on an ultimately utopian vision of the university as an exceptional, salvageable space, neglecting key mechanisms by which it continues to marginalise disabled people. We suggest that reaching a fuller understanding of the university as producing disability must involve moving away from this exceptionalism and toward dialogue with critiques of other institutions.
ableism, disability, exclusion, higher education, university, wellbeing, Wellbeing
Orchard, Vivienne
887b56d5-eda6-4583-ba2e-709de2ccff3a
Jones, Eleanor K.
42bcb412-95ca-4acb-b80a-2b9b471e0c7f
19 March 2024
Orchard, Vivienne
887b56d5-eda6-4583-ba2e-709de2ccff3a
Jones, Eleanor K.
42bcb412-95ca-4acb-b80a-2b9b471e0c7f
Orchard, Vivienne and Jones, Eleanor K.
(2024)
‘Wellbeing’ and the production of disability in the university: erasure, effacement and institutional exceptionalism.
Power and Education.
(doi:10.1177/17577438241239840).
Abstract
This article uses ‘wellbeing’ as deployed within UK higher education as a starting point for examining the relationship between disability and the university. We explore various strands of scholarship that seek to critique wellbeing, universities, and/or connections between disability and these institutions. Work on ‘wellbeing’ identifies the harmful logics underpinning its political appropriation, but erases disability by declining to consider it as political experience. Critiques of the university efface disability by considering disablement only insofar as it affects the non-disabled, and reify ‘intellect’ as neutral entity and sole true purview of higher education. Work on the political economy of disability exposes crucial connections between disability and capitalism, and the role of economic and political institutions in upholding them, but relies on a distinction between worker and surplus that cannot reckon with institutional complexity. Finally, scholarship that directly confronts the university as disabling institution accounts for complexity, but hinges on an ultimately utopian vision of the university as an exceptional, salvageable space, neglecting key mechanisms by which it continues to marginalise disabled people. We suggest that reaching a fuller understanding of the university as producing disability must involve moving away from this exceptionalism and toward dialogue with critiques of other institutions.
Text
Wellbeing ACCEPTED MS
- Accepted Manuscript
Text
orchard-jones-2024-wellbeing-and-the-production-of-disability-in-the-university-erasure-effacement-and-institutional
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 4 February 2024
e-pub ahead of print date: 19 March 2024
Published date: 19 March 2024
Additional Information:
Publisher Copyright:
© The Author(s) 2024.
Keywords:
ableism, disability, exclusion, higher education, university, wellbeing, Wellbeing
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 487941
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/487941
ISSN: 1757-7438
PURE UUID: aa60b96d-827e-4c39-822c-671973d7fd7a
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 11 Mar 2024 17:38
Last modified: 02 May 2024 01:37
Export record
Altmetrics
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics