The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Potential value of a rapid syndromic multiplex PCR for the diagnosis of native and prosthetic joint infections: a real-world evidence study

Potential value of a rapid syndromic multiplex PCR for the diagnosis of native and prosthetic joint infections: a real-world evidence study
Potential value of a rapid syndromic multiplex PCR for the diagnosis of native and prosthetic joint infections: a real-world evidence study

Introduction: the BIOFIRE Joint Infection (JI) Panel is a diagnostic tool that uses multiplex-PCR testing to detect microorganisms in synovial fluid specimens from patients suspected of having septic arthritis (SA) on native joints or prosthetic joint infections (PJIs).

Methods: a study was conducted across 34 clinical sites in 19 European and Middle Eastern countries from March 2021 to June 2022 to assess the effectiveness of the BIOFIRE JI Panel.

Results: a total of 1527 samples were collected from patients suspected of SA or PJI, with an overall agreement of 88.4% and 85% respectively between the JI Panel and synovial fluid cultures (SFCs). The JI Panel detected more positive samples and microorganisms than SFC, with a notable difference on Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus species, Enterococcus faecalis, Kingella kingae, Neisseria gonorrhoeae, and anaerobic bacteria. The study found that the BIOFIRE JI Panel has a high utility in the real-world clinical setting for suspected SA and PJI, providing diagnostic results in approximately 1h. The user experience was positive, implying a potential benefit of rapidity of results' turnover in optimising patient management strategies.

Conclusion: the study suggests that the BIOFIRE JI Panel could potentially optimise patient management and antimicrobial therapy, thus highlighting its importance in the clinical setting.

2206-3552
87-97
Pascual, Stéphanie
29840dba-abb7-412b-948d-3ed177686c82
Noble, Brooklyn
545198cf-fcc0-4ccf-9a0e-46b55ba91021
Ahmad-Saeed, Nusreen
e71dce99-ff6a-4b66-8630-0b21f2c7ff21
Aldridge, Catherine
45f9024a-4f93-41bf-8136-94632e894290
Ambretti, Simone
db3b45f3-5ec1-4d86-93ea-8444f883ed58
Amit, Sharon
32874b57-8de7-4b1d-b182-923840c7b03c
Annett, Rachel
2713f665-b2fd-4e67-9420-a1a2abaf273d
O'Shea, Shaan Ashk
9a3b1fb6-b9c7-4c8b-96d7-ba638ebd5ce0
Barbui, Anna Maria
d19f0430-7936-4555-bb62-0c4e7190a130
Barlow, Gavin
f1f1d57d-6265-4ee2-b9c3-a72ccb6f4e61
Barrett, Lucinda
652689e7-6802-4923-a75f-f6fac571626f
Berth, Mario
0a0ea165-12c7-44ab-8928-d8b273f8682f
Bondi, Alessandro
49a56a2e-fbe8-4f35-962a-2e898314e9b5
Boran, Nicola
bfc29f97-a9f3-4b4b-b578-d2993c4d6699
Boyd, Sara E.
de338bfd-55a0-4c3b-99eb-44702750cab7
Chaves, Catarina
94423f0a-9795-4cb2-b30d-1a9c4856f4d9
Clauss, Martin
e0713626-770d-45c5-aaf6-3d16ed27ec6a
Davies, Peter
281e2afe-8fc1-4242-875c-df6c4db17375
Dianzo-Delgado, Ileana T.
0b84b0f8-fda3-42bf-a528-5d7915f2a7ca
Esteban, Jaime
fe74e0c1-8909-427e-b91e-677f6ceb07a2
Fuchs, Stefan
0af67383-bd2e-4a05-bf4a-a6345a840545
Friis-Hansen, Lennart
117285a7-2d98-43e5-bc46-b06cea349268
Goldenberger, Daniel
d56ca5d6-166c-42b6-9c26-99bbabe09052
Golle, Andrej
970e76de-df53-432b-9d02-eb6b06775654
Groonroos, Juha O.
53811500-b972-4d71-a0b3-0429401dc189
Hoffmann, Ines
7ecd38a1-0f77-43ab-bb05-5b925b5deb0e
Hoffmann, Tomer
ab60b88b-a1dd-4370-9559-e999ad556bea
Hughes, Harriet
e168b3d1-b6a1-4659-a774-f190b170dca4
Ivanova, Marina
8ca81fb3-a212-4659-9633-39c4a71bb1ce
Jezek, Peter
c26a2ead-5255-45df-9343-b75c8481ab19
Jones, Gwennan
1454eab1-20a9-40aa-a982-30ff0c9088bd
Ceren Karahan, Zeynep
dd868d51-f051-4bea-87c6-445d087e6311
Lass-Flörl, Cornelia
1a0c2e11-596c-48bf-8355-84f03ba63cf0
Laurent, Frédéric
9f1cb952-5fd0-4ded-b998-aa4ae571beb6
Leach, Laura
83171f78-d637-40e1-b6d9-ba022cfca50c
Horsbøll Pedersen, Matilde Lee
aa0eb3c1-c5ae-4fb0-9a72-1997689e5f35
Loiez, Caroline
27a8ca9d-5e8e-4205-8952-500a2e8280ab
Lynch, Maureen
92138cd9-a6bd-45dc-a475-3c20c6ad1b9b
Maloney, Robert J.
0991530c-1c9f-44ff-9a91-f2458a096305
Marsh, Martin
be174282-b466-4ed2-992c-1a140e1d6474
Milburn, Olivia
6be82569-b8f3-4d9b-9b25-7751d03a92f7
Mitchell, Shanine
b11cd319-9fce-4800-af4a-e8e6f9bace92
Moore, Luke S.P.
6645b537-50ac-4189-b270-55301bce3d64
Moffat, Lynn
46623b24-698c-4bbd-8f8f-7587694e89a8
Murdjeva, Marianna
e7f1d63e-62c4-46a8-a154-6ea5dcde7dc4
Murphy, Michael E.
f19846bf-82f8-45ff-8364-aef4604c7f13
Nayar, Deepa
c63f51c7-a852-4145-894d-d646cac3c3f6
Nigrisoli, Giacomo
e5ab0874-a024-4c21-997b-c0efb5037e83
O'Sullivan, Fionnuala
6f7a26b8-6d2e-4024-aa7f-8d2cdd89f26c
Saeed, Kordo
87cb67e5-71e8-4759-bf23-2ea00ebd8b39
et al.
Pascual, Stéphanie
29840dba-abb7-412b-948d-3ed177686c82
Noble, Brooklyn
545198cf-fcc0-4ccf-9a0e-46b55ba91021
Ahmad-Saeed, Nusreen
e71dce99-ff6a-4b66-8630-0b21f2c7ff21
Aldridge, Catherine
45f9024a-4f93-41bf-8136-94632e894290
Ambretti, Simone
db3b45f3-5ec1-4d86-93ea-8444f883ed58
Amit, Sharon
32874b57-8de7-4b1d-b182-923840c7b03c
Annett, Rachel
2713f665-b2fd-4e67-9420-a1a2abaf273d
O'Shea, Shaan Ashk
9a3b1fb6-b9c7-4c8b-96d7-ba638ebd5ce0
Barbui, Anna Maria
d19f0430-7936-4555-bb62-0c4e7190a130
Barlow, Gavin
f1f1d57d-6265-4ee2-b9c3-a72ccb6f4e61
Barrett, Lucinda
652689e7-6802-4923-a75f-f6fac571626f
Berth, Mario
0a0ea165-12c7-44ab-8928-d8b273f8682f
Bondi, Alessandro
49a56a2e-fbe8-4f35-962a-2e898314e9b5
Boran, Nicola
bfc29f97-a9f3-4b4b-b578-d2993c4d6699
Boyd, Sara E.
de338bfd-55a0-4c3b-99eb-44702750cab7
Chaves, Catarina
94423f0a-9795-4cb2-b30d-1a9c4856f4d9
Clauss, Martin
e0713626-770d-45c5-aaf6-3d16ed27ec6a
Davies, Peter
281e2afe-8fc1-4242-875c-df6c4db17375
Dianzo-Delgado, Ileana T.
0b84b0f8-fda3-42bf-a528-5d7915f2a7ca
Esteban, Jaime
fe74e0c1-8909-427e-b91e-677f6ceb07a2
Fuchs, Stefan
0af67383-bd2e-4a05-bf4a-a6345a840545
Friis-Hansen, Lennart
117285a7-2d98-43e5-bc46-b06cea349268
Goldenberger, Daniel
d56ca5d6-166c-42b6-9c26-99bbabe09052
Golle, Andrej
970e76de-df53-432b-9d02-eb6b06775654
Groonroos, Juha O.
53811500-b972-4d71-a0b3-0429401dc189
Hoffmann, Ines
7ecd38a1-0f77-43ab-bb05-5b925b5deb0e
Hoffmann, Tomer
ab60b88b-a1dd-4370-9559-e999ad556bea
Hughes, Harriet
e168b3d1-b6a1-4659-a774-f190b170dca4
Ivanova, Marina
8ca81fb3-a212-4659-9633-39c4a71bb1ce
Jezek, Peter
c26a2ead-5255-45df-9343-b75c8481ab19
Jones, Gwennan
1454eab1-20a9-40aa-a982-30ff0c9088bd
Ceren Karahan, Zeynep
dd868d51-f051-4bea-87c6-445d087e6311
Lass-Flörl, Cornelia
1a0c2e11-596c-48bf-8355-84f03ba63cf0
Laurent, Frédéric
9f1cb952-5fd0-4ded-b998-aa4ae571beb6
Leach, Laura
83171f78-d637-40e1-b6d9-ba022cfca50c
Horsbøll Pedersen, Matilde Lee
aa0eb3c1-c5ae-4fb0-9a72-1997689e5f35
Loiez, Caroline
27a8ca9d-5e8e-4205-8952-500a2e8280ab
Lynch, Maureen
92138cd9-a6bd-45dc-a475-3c20c6ad1b9b
Maloney, Robert J.
0991530c-1c9f-44ff-9a91-f2458a096305
Marsh, Martin
be174282-b466-4ed2-992c-1a140e1d6474
Milburn, Olivia
6be82569-b8f3-4d9b-9b25-7751d03a92f7
Mitchell, Shanine
b11cd319-9fce-4800-af4a-e8e6f9bace92
Moore, Luke S.P.
6645b537-50ac-4189-b270-55301bce3d64
Moffat, Lynn
46623b24-698c-4bbd-8f8f-7587694e89a8
Murdjeva, Marianna
e7f1d63e-62c4-46a8-a154-6ea5dcde7dc4
Murphy, Michael E.
f19846bf-82f8-45ff-8364-aef4604c7f13
Nayar, Deepa
c63f51c7-a852-4145-894d-d646cac3c3f6
Nigrisoli, Giacomo
e5ab0874-a024-4c21-997b-c0efb5037e83
O'Sullivan, Fionnuala
6f7a26b8-6d2e-4024-aa7f-8d2cdd89f26c
Saeed, Kordo
87cb67e5-71e8-4759-bf23-2ea00ebd8b39

Pascual, Stéphanie, Noble, Brooklyn and Ahmad-Saeed, Nusreen , et al. (2024) Potential value of a rapid syndromic multiplex PCR for the diagnosis of native and prosthetic joint infections: a real-world evidence study. Journal of Bone and Joint Infection, 9 (1), 87-97. (doi:10.5194/jbji-9-87-2024).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Introduction: the BIOFIRE Joint Infection (JI) Panel is a diagnostic tool that uses multiplex-PCR testing to detect microorganisms in synovial fluid specimens from patients suspected of having septic arthritis (SA) on native joints or prosthetic joint infections (PJIs).

Methods: a study was conducted across 34 clinical sites in 19 European and Middle Eastern countries from March 2021 to June 2022 to assess the effectiveness of the BIOFIRE JI Panel.

Results: a total of 1527 samples were collected from patients suspected of SA or PJI, with an overall agreement of 88.4% and 85% respectively between the JI Panel and synovial fluid cultures (SFCs). The JI Panel detected more positive samples and microorganisms than SFC, with a notable difference on Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus species, Enterococcus faecalis, Kingella kingae, Neisseria gonorrhoeae, and anaerobic bacteria. The study found that the BIOFIRE JI Panel has a high utility in the real-world clinical setting for suspected SA and PJI, providing diagnostic results in approximately 1h. The user experience was positive, implying a potential benefit of rapidity of results' turnover in optimising patient management strategies.

Conclusion: the study suggests that the BIOFIRE JI Panel could potentially optimise patient management and antimicrobial therapy, thus highlighting its importance in the clinical setting.

Text
jbji-9-87-2024 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (1MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 1 December 2023
Published date: 28 February 2024
Additional Information: Copyright: © 2024 Stéphanie Pascual et al.

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 488802
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/488802
ISSN: 2206-3552
PURE UUID: 3ead1df7-0a7b-4b3d-94e4-04c1b52d21ae
ORCID for Kordo Saeed: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-0123-0302

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 05 Apr 2024 16:44
Last modified: 08 May 2024 01:56

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Stéphanie Pascual
Author: Brooklyn Noble
Author: Nusreen Ahmad-Saeed
Author: Catherine Aldridge
Author: Simone Ambretti
Author: Sharon Amit
Author: Rachel Annett
Author: Shaan Ashk O'Shea
Author: Anna Maria Barbui
Author: Gavin Barlow
Author: Lucinda Barrett
Author: Mario Berth
Author: Alessandro Bondi
Author: Nicola Boran
Author: Sara E. Boyd
Author: Catarina Chaves
Author: Martin Clauss
Author: Peter Davies
Author: Ileana T. Dianzo-Delgado
Author: Jaime Esteban
Author: Stefan Fuchs
Author: Lennart Friis-Hansen
Author: Daniel Goldenberger
Author: Andrej Golle
Author: Juha O. Groonroos
Author: Ines Hoffmann
Author: Tomer Hoffmann
Author: Harriet Hughes
Author: Marina Ivanova
Author: Peter Jezek
Author: Gwennan Jones
Author: Zeynep Ceren Karahan
Author: Cornelia Lass-Flörl
Author: Frédéric Laurent
Author: Laura Leach
Author: Matilde Lee Horsbøll Pedersen
Author: Caroline Loiez
Author: Maureen Lynch
Author: Robert J. Maloney
Author: Martin Marsh
Author: Olivia Milburn
Author: Shanine Mitchell
Author: Luke S.P. Moore
Author: Lynn Moffat
Author: Marianna Murdjeva
Author: Michael E. Murphy
Author: Deepa Nayar
Author: Giacomo Nigrisoli
Author: Fionnuala O'Sullivan
Author: Kordo Saeed ORCID iD
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×