The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Evolution in European and Israeli school curricula – a comparative analysis

Evolution in European and Israeli school curricula – a comparative analysis
Evolution in European and Israeli school curricula – a comparative analysis

The contribution of school curricula to public understanding and acceptance of evolution is still mostly unknown, due to the scarcity of studies that compare the learning goals present in different curricula. To overcome this lack of data we analysed 19 school curricula (18 European and one from Israel) to study the differences regarding the inclusion of learning goals targeting evolution understanding. We performed a quantitative content analysis using the Framework for the Assessment of school Curricula on the presence of Evolutionary concepts (FACE). For each country/region we analysed what this educational system considered the minimum evolution education a citizen should get. Our results reveal that: (i) the curricula include less than half of the learning goals considered important for scientific literacy in evolution; (ii) the most frequent learning goals address basic knowledge of evolution; (iii) learning goals related with the processes that drive evolution are often not included or rarely mentioned; (iv) evolution is most often not linked to its applications in everyday life. These results highlight the need to rethink evolution education across Europe.

Evolution learning goals, biology education, education policy
0950-0693
1623-1649
Mavrikaki, Evangelia
57ce7e02-8bb3-47fc-8184-099c9420ffef
Realdon, Giulia
2d15f12c-379d-4b37-b2b2-37abd8b5e6e5
Aivelo, Tuomas
97fc07b3-450c-41af-8f98-2133d28aa73c
Bajrami, Ani
b59f9c39-5a10-481d-af7e-422ef4fb24f8
Dilek bakanay, Çiçek
0615438f-eea7-48dc-bb4a-1ffcea95d8c8
Beniermann, Anna
0f7190e2-e547-4a9c-8f2a-9523733d6ca2
Blagojević, Jelena
2c410490-61ac-4685-b660-27df80552ba7
Butkeviciene, Egle
8cdddb2f-1dd8-46f0-9cd0-c4070d478be2
Cavadas, Bento
f08c17e9-2f3a-4fc5-abea-0fd59c468aa6
Cossu, Costantina
1336d08e-b70e-4aec-8fb6-4d74a203ef1d
Cvetković, Dragana
c3967107-0af1-4dc1-8984-614c60d1a9d7
Drobniak, Szymon M.
138f0f94-b44d-4ece-b9db-c5efac084fd6
Özgür durmuş, Zelal
b963f7e1-a7f0-47a0-85cb-9d43616d706d
Marta dvořáková, Radka
1b5cda70-6785-4a8e-9bd8-73b607615949
Eens, Marcel
0fead501-e01e-40f8-a651-c8d9491369b0
Eret, Esra
24866454-f097-4c18-948b-5aa9f0220200
Eroglu, Seckin
88c070a0-331d-4d11-abdd-fca66e7e5e8d
Anna gazda, Małgorzata
f741f04c-4e23-45a0-93b8-e30dd4352d04
Georgiou, Martha
c3d0944a-a8f3-46cd-a601-7e8a2bde7df0
Gostling, Neil J.
4840aa40-cb6c-4112-a0b9-694a869523fc
Gregorčič, Tanja
1957588b-f9e8-4d17-9069-61e868fde39a
Janštová, Vanda
d1f011b8-eaaa-4f0a-b8d7-9f5735a184e5
Jenkins, Tania
e87f3aa2-b522-481a-a255-91c150faa918
Kervinen, Anttoni
7fb6fbba-9d57-4259-a05a-47ad272ca8d8
Korfiatis, Konstantinos
fc142be8-7e66-45c3-95fb-3426e80f2b46
Kuschmierz, Paul
d1e7c331-a3e5-4a75-8345-5783d21f23db
Lendvai, Ádám Z.
9d94a2c5-8e85-434d-bedd-691210125957
De lima, Joelyn
28cf71e6-ca28-42d1-a039-88464aadce87
Miri, Fundime
60c1e12f-4ccd-4d2b-a9c9-47297e5ccb28
Nogueira, Teresa
755653cb-a92d-467f-8957-dbf62868ddb1
Panayides, Andreas
8da5fe55-eb57-40c6-8fd1-6b7b1b6b1a15
Paolucci, Sylvia
8dadcc28-59d4-4089-ae56-005a7cdf355c
Papadopoulou, Penelope
bc340b58-cdce-432e-ad03-20dd2e717dba
Pessoa, Patrícia
3f3364be-c00e-4565-9345-135fc2bce13d
Pinxten, Rianne
36a956df-6408-4643-a4ad-b0d5f7b32ec3
Rios rocha, Joana
427b53b1-0e7b-4f3c-a11a-f54a1f728fa2
Fernández sánchez, Andrea
98c1d67b-dc68-46bc-ab11-f20b83d59a1a
Siani, Merav
2bf74b0b-c2e5-495d-a2ff-0fa0eff829ca
Sokoli, Elvisa
81e0eb0f-11df-4d7b-996f-1939b6daab0b
Sousa, Bruno
fc52d8fa-c194-4d8e-a459-97505765ec6c
Stasinakis, Panagiotis K.
6bb51cd2-fe7a-45b9-91a2-dabf5052893e
Torkar, Gregor
2103bf1c-ea6a-4bc7-97c1-f39e482506b5
Valackiene, Asta
ed153f20-2a61-438c-85d1-8f4533135b87
Varga, Máté
75622e38-a565-476f-9b29-4e3d07c5aa5d
Vázquez ben, Lucía
4fd3a925-1d28-4c49-87d4-28b99b20d101
Yarden, Anat
d5d6a44f-00f1-45c4-b1f1-5a2db0f676ef
Sá-Pinto, Xana
6547091c-4a3a-49ce-b2b9-fac25d3e0568
et al.
Mavrikaki, Evangelia
57ce7e02-8bb3-47fc-8184-099c9420ffef
Realdon, Giulia
2d15f12c-379d-4b37-b2b2-37abd8b5e6e5
Aivelo, Tuomas
97fc07b3-450c-41af-8f98-2133d28aa73c
Bajrami, Ani
b59f9c39-5a10-481d-af7e-422ef4fb24f8
Dilek bakanay, Çiçek
0615438f-eea7-48dc-bb4a-1ffcea95d8c8
Beniermann, Anna
0f7190e2-e547-4a9c-8f2a-9523733d6ca2
Blagojević, Jelena
2c410490-61ac-4685-b660-27df80552ba7
Butkeviciene, Egle
8cdddb2f-1dd8-46f0-9cd0-c4070d478be2
Cavadas, Bento
f08c17e9-2f3a-4fc5-abea-0fd59c468aa6
Cossu, Costantina
1336d08e-b70e-4aec-8fb6-4d74a203ef1d
Cvetković, Dragana
c3967107-0af1-4dc1-8984-614c60d1a9d7
Drobniak, Szymon M.
138f0f94-b44d-4ece-b9db-c5efac084fd6
Özgür durmuş, Zelal
b963f7e1-a7f0-47a0-85cb-9d43616d706d
Marta dvořáková, Radka
1b5cda70-6785-4a8e-9bd8-73b607615949
Eens, Marcel
0fead501-e01e-40f8-a651-c8d9491369b0
Eret, Esra
24866454-f097-4c18-948b-5aa9f0220200
Eroglu, Seckin
88c070a0-331d-4d11-abdd-fca66e7e5e8d
Anna gazda, Małgorzata
f741f04c-4e23-45a0-93b8-e30dd4352d04
Georgiou, Martha
c3d0944a-a8f3-46cd-a601-7e8a2bde7df0
Gostling, Neil J.
4840aa40-cb6c-4112-a0b9-694a869523fc
Gregorčič, Tanja
1957588b-f9e8-4d17-9069-61e868fde39a
Janštová, Vanda
d1f011b8-eaaa-4f0a-b8d7-9f5735a184e5
Jenkins, Tania
e87f3aa2-b522-481a-a255-91c150faa918
Kervinen, Anttoni
7fb6fbba-9d57-4259-a05a-47ad272ca8d8
Korfiatis, Konstantinos
fc142be8-7e66-45c3-95fb-3426e80f2b46
Kuschmierz, Paul
d1e7c331-a3e5-4a75-8345-5783d21f23db
Lendvai, Ádám Z.
9d94a2c5-8e85-434d-bedd-691210125957
De lima, Joelyn
28cf71e6-ca28-42d1-a039-88464aadce87
Miri, Fundime
60c1e12f-4ccd-4d2b-a9c9-47297e5ccb28
Nogueira, Teresa
755653cb-a92d-467f-8957-dbf62868ddb1
Panayides, Andreas
8da5fe55-eb57-40c6-8fd1-6b7b1b6b1a15
Paolucci, Sylvia
8dadcc28-59d4-4089-ae56-005a7cdf355c
Papadopoulou, Penelope
bc340b58-cdce-432e-ad03-20dd2e717dba
Pessoa, Patrícia
3f3364be-c00e-4565-9345-135fc2bce13d
Pinxten, Rianne
36a956df-6408-4643-a4ad-b0d5f7b32ec3
Rios rocha, Joana
427b53b1-0e7b-4f3c-a11a-f54a1f728fa2
Fernández sánchez, Andrea
98c1d67b-dc68-46bc-ab11-f20b83d59a1a
Siani, Merav
2bf74b0b-c2e5-495d-a2ff-0fa0eff829ca
Sokoli, Elvisa
81e0eb0f-11df-4d7b-996f-1939b6daab0b
Sousa, Bruno
fc52d8fa-c194-4d8e-a459-97505765ec6c
Stasinakis, Panagiotis K.
6bb51cd2-fe7a-45b9-91a2-dabf5052893e
Torkar, Gregor
2103bf1c-ea6a-4bc7-97c1-f39e482506b5
Valackiene, Asta
ed153f20-2a61-438c-85d1-8f4533135b87
Varga, Máté
75622e38-a565-476f-9b29-4e3d07c5aa5d
Vázquez ben, Lucía
4fd3a925-1d28-4c49-87d4-28b99b20d101
Yarden, Anat
d5d6a44f-00f1-45c4-b1f1-5a2db0f676ef
Sá-Pinto, Xana
6547091c-4a3a-49ce-b2b9-fac25d3e0568

Mavrikaki, Evangelia, Realdon, Giulia and Aivelo, Tuomas , et al. (2024) Evolution in European and Israeli school curricula – a comparative analysis. International Journal of Science Education, 46 (15), 1623-1649. (doi:10.1080/09500693.2023.2293090).

Record type: Article

Abstract

The contribution of school curricula to public understanding and acceptance of evolution is still mostly unknown, due to the scarcity of studies that compare the learning goals present in different curricula. To overcome this lack of data we analysed 19 school curricula (18 European and one from Israel) to study the differences regarding the inclusion of learning goals targeting evolution understanding. We performed a quantitative content analysis using the Framework for the Assessment of school Curricula on the presence of Evolutionary concepts (FACE). For each country/region we analysed what this educational system considered the minimum evolution education a citizen should get. Our results reveal that: (i) the curricula include less than half of the learning goals considered important for scientific literacy in evolution; (ii) the most frequent learning goals address basic knowledge of evolution; (iii) learning goals related with the processes that drive evolution are often not included or rarely mentioned; (iv) evolution is most often not linked to its applications in everyday life. These results highlight the need to rethink evolution education across Europe.

Text
EUROSCITIZEN_CURRICULUM PAPER_main_document_with full author details - Accepted Manuscript
Restricted to Repository staff only until 19 July 2025.
Request a copy

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 6 December 2023
e-pub ahead of print date: 19 January 2024
Published date: 19 January 2024
Additional Information: Publisher Copyright: © 2024 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
Keywords: Evolution learning goals, biology education, education policy

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 488977
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/488977
ISSN: 0950-0693
PURE UUID: f119b675-e731-4f3a-9503-6c56edce7b63
ORCID for Neil J. Gostling: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-5960-7769

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 10 Apr 2024 16:36
Last modified: 13 Nov 2024 02:45

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Evangelia Mavrikaki
Author: Giulia Realdon
Author: Tuomas Aivelo
Author: Ani Bajrami
Author: Çiçek Dilek bakanay
Author: Anna Beniermann
Author: Jelena Blagojević
Author: Egle Butkeviciene
Author: Bento Cavadas
Author: Costantina Cossu
Author: Dragana Cvetković
Author: Szymon M. Drobniak
Author: Zelal Özgür durmuş
Author: Radka Marta dvořáková
Author: Marcel Eens
Author: Esra Eret
Author: Seckin Eroglu
Author: Małgorzata Anna gazda
Author: Martha Georgiou
Author: Tanja Gregorčič
Author: Vanda Janštová
Author: Tania Jenkins
Author: Anttoni Kervinen
Author: Konstantinos Korfiatis
Author: Paul Kuschmierz
Author: Ádám Z. Lendvai
Author: Joelyn De lima
Author: Fundime Miri
Author: Teresa Nogueira
Author: Andreas Panayides
Author: Sylvia Paolucci
Author: Penelope Papadopoulou
Author: Patrícia Pessoa
Author: Rianne Pinxten
Author: Joana Rios rocha
Author: Andrea Fernández sánchez
Author: Merav Siani
Author: Elvisa Sokoli
Author: Bruno Sousa
Author: Panagiotis K. Stasinakis
Author: Gregor Torkar
Author: Asta Valackiene
Author: Máté Varga
Author: Lucía Vázquez ben
Author: Anat Yarden
Author: Xana Sá-Pinto
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×